Interesting double standard
-
If you copy something to make it better is an improve, if you copy something to make it cheaper is a ripoff

-
Another concept you have to bear in mind vis a vis intellectual property , is that of a " novel combination " . Mixing a cocktail no one has ever mixed before . At a guess , pliers with knives of harder material probably got started as surgical implements , spread into fishing ( a sport followed by lots of Docs ) , and spread outwards from there .
Chris
-
It will be interesting to see how the LM 154cm wire cutters hold up and compare to the Gerber carbide cutters. But I really wonder if there is anything truly new in multitools except variations of the same theme. Of course you (hopefully) get better materials and better functionality through better engineering. But really, is there anything really new under the sun here? Pliers and bolt cutters with replaceable cutters and even swappable heads have been around quite awhile so really LM and the rest of these guys are waaaay behind the curve in this design aspect.
Maybe it's not so much the multitool manufacturers copying each other, or innovating existing designs so much as they are taking their queues from standard tool makers.
In any case, I think there are double standards. Even though LM wasn't the first to come out with a plier based multitool they were probably the first to successfully market and sell them to a mass consumer base and open the door for other multitool manufacturers. So, in this regrad I think LM get's more latitude when it comes to their designs.
Mike
-
@Mike said:
It will be interesting to see how the LM 154cm wire cutters hold up and compare to the Gerber carbide cutters. But I really wonder if there is anything truly new in multitools except variations of the same theme. Of course you (hopefully) get better materials and better functionality through better engineering. **But really, is there anything really new under the sun here? ** Pliers and bolt cutters with replaceable cutters and even swappable heads have been around quite awhile so really LM and the rest of these guys are waaaay behind the curve in this design aspect.Maybe it's not so much the multitool manufacturers copying each other, or innovating existing designs so much as they are taking their queues from standard tool makers.
In any case, I think there are double standards. Even though LM wasn't the first to come out with a plier based multitool they were probably the first to successfully market and sell them to a mass consumer base and open the door for other multitool manufacturers. So, in this regrad I think LM get's more latitude when it comes to their designs.
Mike
Three words:
Wenger
Business
Tool.

-
Mike
[/quote]Three words:
Wenger
Business
Tool.

[/quote]i had never seen that tool before. makes me wish i was a secratary, oops i mean administrative assistant. :D
-
What about the Wenger Business Tool? Years ago I had seen staplers with a few extras on them. Not to the extent of Wenger, but with extras none the less. So, Wenger just added more extras. But, you could just as easily go the other way and say Wenger simply added a stapler to their existing line Swiss Army knives. Again, nothing too exciting and new here.
Now, the "exciting and new" is just my perspective. If you want to go gaga over a stapler with extras or a Swiss Army Knife with a stapler added, that's cool. If folks want to go gaga over replaceable wire cutters on the new LM, that's cool too. Don't get me wrong, they are all cool, but it's hard for me to get too overly excited about emptying my wallet even more for (in my opinion) modest changes.
Again, these are just my opinions and I'm not saying yours are wrong.
Mike
-
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I don't know if anyone has noticed this, but we have an interesting double standard- or at least it appears that way, but maybe there's more to it than is obvious?When I posted pics of the new (/topic/11095) everyone was excited to see the Gerber style wire cutters and think it's great to finally see it.
But, some time ago when Mikey posted the Gerber Crucial was berated for being a "Skeletool Knockoff."
Is it a double standard that makes it ok for Leatherman to "copy" Gerber, but not ok for Gerber to "copy" Leatherman?
Def
Double standards? Maybe. Narrow minded? Definitely.
As for the "copying" idea, how many people:
- Drive a Ford (Model T was first production car);
- Use a Hoover vacuum cleaner?
- etc.
I absolutely expect that tool manufacturers copy (and hopefully improve upon) innovative ideas. I don't know which car manufacturer came up with the idea of air bags for example, but I'm bloody glad that everyone else copied them.
-
@goodgirl said:
If you copy something to make it better is an improve, if you copy something to make it cheaper is a ripoff
If you really want to pursue it, does simply having a better end result give you a free license to take other people's design? How's that fundamentally more right than the latter?
-
That's it jz. It's not different and that's the whole point of the "double standard". As people have said, there are just so many ideas in this field. It's like someone patenting something obvious, then call everybody else who had the same idea "thieves" or "copycats". It doesn't make any sense. It's not the idea that counts so much as is the execution/implementation. Sure, give credit to the designer but don't discredit the engineers. ;) It's called evolution people.
-
i think what we have all missed in this debate is not so much what company copied whatever other company but that leatherman copied almost to a T the leatherman core. they look identical, there are no new tools, the blades do not have premium steel. so the cutters have 154cm, big deal, i have yet to break one of my leatherman cutters.i mean, name one thing that the 300 can do that the core cannot and for less than half the price.
-
As someone who is actually designing something(not a multitool) I can say I would hate for someone to use my idea, yet I have taken 2 other peoples ideas combined then with my own... Double standard indeed.
-
@nelly1974 said:
i think what we have all missed in this debate is not so much what company copied whatever other company but that leatherman copied almost to at the leatherman core. they look identical, there are no new tools, the blades do not have premium steel. so the cutters have 154cm, big deal, i have yet to break one of my leatherman cutters.i mean, name one thing that the 300 can do that the core cannot and for less than half the price.the wire cutters deform easily from cutting nails...
-
@nelly1974 said:
i mean,** name one thing that the 300 can do that the core cannot and for less than half the price.**The Core MSRP is $76.00
The Supertool 300 MSRP is $84.00
We do not yet know what the street price of the Supertool 300 will be 4 years after it is first released to compare to the Core's current price.
the wire cutters deform easily from cutting nails...
They're called "wire cutters" for a reason.
-
i think what we have all missed in this debate is not so much what company copied whatever other company but that leatherman copied almost to at the leatherman core. they look identical, there are no new tools, the blades do not have premium steel. so the cutters have 154cm, big deal, i have yet to break one of my leatherman cutters.i mean, name one thing that the 300 can do that the core cannot and for less than half the price.
the wire cutters deform easily from cutting nails...
I don't think any MT cutters were meant to be used on nails.
-
i think what we have all missed in this debate is not so much what company copied whatever other company but that leatherman copied almost to at the leatherman core. they look identical, there are no new tools, the blades do not have premium steel. so the cutters have 154cm, big deal, i have yet to break one of my leatherman cutters.i mean, name one thing that the 300 can do that the core cannot and for less than half the price.
the wire cutters deform easily from cutting nails...
I don't think any MT cutters were meant to be used on nails.
Wasn't there a video of tim leatherman in russia using a charge to cut nails?
-
i mean,** name one thing that the 300 can do that the core cannot and for less than half the price.**
The Core MSRP is $76.00
The Supertool 300 MSRP is $84.00
We do not yet know what the street price of the Supertool 300 will be 4 years after it is first released to compare to the Core's current price.
the wire cutters deform easily from cutting nails...
They're called "wire cutters" for a reason.
well, the hard wire notch is huge...and LM says that their wire cutters can cut 16-penny nails and stay sharp enough to cut paper, multiple times...
-
IMO, the ST300 will be around $68-75
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login