What is your Multitool of choice when hiking, backpacking, tramping, camping?
-
^^^^ Yep gotta agree SR.
For true backpacking you must minimise weight- And possibly **do not **even take everything you think you might need - ***Just take the absolute essentials *** and compromise!
The MT.o/Boy Scouts motto of "Be Prepared" is replaced my "Minimal Carry"
For instance I find local rocks are pretty good for hammering in tent pegs !! :D
And as Ihave said before - In decades of climbing, hiking and backpacking I have never really needed pliers! - And possibly **do not **even take everything you think you might need - ***Just take the absolute essentials *** and compromise!
-
@Huntsman said:
For true backpacking you must minimise weight- And possibly do not even take everything you think you might need - Just take the absolute essentials and compromise!
For instance I find local rocks are pretty good for hammering in tent pegs !! :D
The Mohave hammer has done its fair share my camps. Pliers can be truly useful, but needed? That is a personal decision. What is your definition of "need"? A once at home weighs a pound on the trail. The more you own, the more you are owned. One of the measures of a individual is how well they make do with what is at hand.
- And possibly do not even take everything you think you might need - Just take the absolute essentials and compromise!
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I've been looking at the Leatherman Signal... just for fun.I think I'm in the minority here, but I think that the LM Signal would be a good tool for the outdoors, as a supplement.
Hear me out here...
Just about every one of us carries two tools, and according to my calculations, about half of us carry a plier based MT.
If I'm going to bring a plier based MT out to the woods with me, it's going to spend most of the time in my pack.
But since its there, who not relegate my saw to that tool, and keep the same SAK that I carry in town with me in my pocket out to the woods (instead of switching to a 111mm Trekker)?
Personally, I use the saw on one of my 7 or 8 layer SAKs most often and that stays in my pack most of the time anyway - thats also where I have the extra tools I dont anticipate needing much. The Signal adds a serrated blade (of questionable use, I understand), and pliers (which I understand I dont need). Regardless, I may as well keep a Signal in my pack. It almost makes more sense than carrying two different SAKs - theres almost less redundancy.
As for the gimmicks, they don't bother me since I heard what a LM engineer's thought process was. Far too often, we expect things from gadgets that they weren't designed to do. He admits that they chose a ferro rod that was softer so that it could throw a better spark for that one time it was needed in an emergency. The only time it's going to be used is when I am in dire straits and I have misplaced my actual ferro rod. By that time, its no fault of Leatherman if I am going to survive or not, and I'll be glad to have something to try to use. The whistle adds a splash of color to the tool, if it attracts attention, in an emergency that's good too. The pommel is good enough to tap in tent stakes or do whatever it is that I would bother to retrieve it from my pack. It's certainly better than what I was going to use otherwise, isn't it?
Contrarily, I own the Signal and was rather disappointed at it.
With the same price, folks could have gotten a collection of 'better' tools for real 'outdoor survival'.
LM Signal is 120usd on Amazon, meanwhile you could have gotten all these gears on Amazon:
Storm whistle 2usd
Bayite 4 Inch Survival Ferrocerium w/ striker 15usd
LM Sidekick 60usd
All weather blanket 20usd
Sawyer Mini 20usd
Rock (free for hammering)Budget aside, I was a little disappointed in how LM advertise it as a 'outdoor survival' tool(I think they might have changed it now) and while those whom are well versed in survival skill probably have the skill to make do with it (or already have their full set of gears which they can rely on), there always will be some poor souls actually will buy into this false pretense and think it is a 'legit' kit to help them survive.
And as Ethan Becker once pointed out in a video, pommel on knives are not meant to hammer with, but hammer on; same thing apply to the pommel 'hammer' here on Signal, try using this to hammer something like a tent stake, one miss, and you will have a bloody hand to deal with. And the worst part, the pommel literally interfere with normal usage for half the tools on the chassis.
I did a pretty through test a while back, comparing all the LM/Vic/Gerber/SOG mid and large size tools in a youtube video, and IIRC, the Signal has one of the worst ergo in the entire industry, and the saw result was poor because of that.
Don't get me wrong, I love LM offerings(though I am a SAK fan), but this is one of the weaker link.
-
@Scorpion Regent said:
The Mohave hammer has done its fair share my camps. Pliers can be truly useful, but needed? That is a personal decision. What is your definition of "need"? A once at home weighs a pound on the trail. The more you own, the more you are owned. One of the measures of a individual is how well they make do with what is at hand.:(. Times were sure simpler when I had but one maybe 2 choices. Its no wonder I survived ( said with sarcasm ) ;).
-
@Aloha said:
:(. Times were sure simpler when I had but one maybe 2 choices. Its no wonder I survived ( said with sarcasm ) ;).Ah the good old days -
I remember choosing between a Gerber somethingorother, vs a Leatherman ST or PST. I chose the LM ST, the only one with locks.... and what a cumbersome locking mechanism it was! I did my fair share of camping with it - lifting hot pans with the pliers... just because.
If I had to choose my first MT in this day and age... :ahhh
-
Big beasts, Surge, Core. Something with lots of stuff, including pliers.
Also, I had to look up what 'tramping' was.

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Big beasts, Surge, Core. Something with lots of stuff, including pliers.Also, I had to look up what 'tramping' was.

That was for YOUR benefit RP!

I'm not of the opinion that American English is the only variety. -
@ReamerPunch said:
Big beasts, Surge, Core. Something with lots of stuff, including pliers.Also, I had to look up what 'tramping' was.

So then, my question is... what do you use your MT of choice for when hiking, backpacking et cetera?
On my last trip:
blade to open a package of firewood that someone had purchased ::)
saw and blade to fashion a green stick into a cooking skewer
blade for food prep
can opener for tomatoes that went into the chili
spine of the saw on the ferro rodthats about it for me...
what about you?
-
Pliers come in handy for many things. I had to fix my shoe and I used the pliers to push a needle through the sole. Also cutting coat hangers to make s hooks, and tightening/untying my favorite knot, the friendship knot.
I also like the screwdrivers for scavenging spare parts off of furniture. Saws for making handles for things and file to finish them off. Serrated blade for opening my peanuts/trailmix.The funnest was using the pliers of the Core to remove the hook from this eel.
Spoiler:

-
Other....if you can count that little Victoronix nail clipper combo in my FAK.
Weight is the enemy, I'll leave the MT for somebody else in the group to carry, never used.
-
Mine is either my Victorinox Swisstool or Spirit which I carry everyday weather I am in the woods or not.
It never changes
-
Sure make things easy. -
@mashguy4077 said:
Mine is either my Victorinox Swisstool or Spirit which I carry everyday weather I am in the woods or not.
It never changes
The weather always changes :D
-
Thinking about the old adage "one is none, two is one, three is prepared", and also thinking about weight.
Is there anything else that we regularly carry backups for? Recently I did get a backup stove (because I wanted a different kind, and voila! I have a "backup").
Once I start looking at redundancy in the name of preparedness, I roll down the slippery slope because of added weight.
So then I wonder... do I really need the "right tool for the job"? Probably not. The hemostats in my FAK are mini pliers if I ever need one to repair gear. Each edged tool is a backup for the other, even if nothing is considered the "right tool". I don't carry a fixed blade, partly because It would obviate the need for my other tools, and mainly because a good bushcraft fixed blade is not that great of a multi-purpose tool. A good fixed blade for bushcraft is bad for food prep - it will split food rather than slice it. The corkscrew comes in handy for a lot of things, and I'm sure I can manage to use someting else in its stead... except for opening a cork. (yes, that happens to me in the woods). I'm not good at the can-opener on the cork trick.
So that leaves me to consider weight in my pack... and we all know mathematically speaking, every ounce counts. So with what combination of tools will I have the least weight? And with that question in mind, enter the Victorinox OHT vs Swisschamp dielemma...

-
Check this poll out ... > 350 votes, but not outdoor activity specific.
Interesting results.
Which multitool do you EDC? - StrawPoll
What is your opinion? Vote now: Leatherman Wave+, Leatherman Surge, Victorinox Swisstool X, Victorinox Spirit, Leatherman Skeletool, Leatherman Charge, SOG PowerAssist, Gerber Bear G
StrawPoll (strawpoll.com)
-
I've come to realize I've got to carry what feels right for me. I see the thru hikers load outs and the ultralight folks as well. Its about goals it seems. Their goal is ULTRA light and so they have a predetermined mindset to achieve that. We or I am looking at preparedness. With that goal in mind I try to balance practicality and need or perceived need. I have considered needs from past hikes mixed with a bit of want and a touch of I like this piece of gear.
If weight is the concern then you must carry the target weight. If preparedness is the goal then follow what makes sense to you. If you care to strike a balance of weight then you can decide the target weight and preparedness and off you go.
As if it was this easy

-
@Aloha said:
I've come to realize I've got to carry what feels right for me. We or I am looking at preparedness.True preparedness is having the skills to be able to do a lot with very little. Load out weight isn't just about speed and easy walking, it also is about practicality. The heavier your load the more calories you have to burn to carry it, which in turn means more food that you will have to carry. Factors like climatic extremes (cold weather gear or extra water), harsh terrain and high altitude will clarify priorities even faster.
In the end it really boils down to one simple concept, if it makes the trip easier bring it. -
looking at the numbers so far...
I find it interesting that the Leatherman Juice isnt more popular, and that it's being discontinued. I thought it filled an important need - a lightweight plier based MT which is more for quick repairs than hard work. I never got one because I already have plenty of things for camping... but if I had to pick one thing (and I was one of the un-initiated) I would strongly consider a Juice.
I think... as a group we tend to use tools just to use them... or we use what we intend to... rather than having something "just in case"
-
We love tools that for sure
. Like Dave Caterbury we go tool heavy. I've been looking back at what I've carried and the quality has increased however the quantity tends to remain the same. Pocket knife, MT, Fixed blade.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
