SAK STACK 30 days challenge 2020 for Swisschamp, Cybertool & Toolchest
-
Darn it, you guys are making it sound way to much fun. Let‘s see. Fieldmaster challenge in Feb, take a break in March, Swisschamp in April. I am in unless work gets in my way

SAK STACK 30 days Challenge in April 2020
- comis
- Sos24
- Zrxoa1
- Kraken
- BadMechanic
- Antti Lammi
- Ron Who
- Ivo
- Ulzhan
- Gath
- Rizio Il Ghiro
- ElevenBlade
- Pacu
- CraftsmanSAK
- Simon_Templar
- Max Stone
- SirVicaLot (work permitting)
-
Comis, looks as if your fridge magnets have a lot of power of attraction ;)
-
@comis said:
Simon, thank you for looking this up, S54 is already on the list, and since S28(Wenger Champ) is close relative to Tool Chest, and I will be accepting Victorinox Champion, it will only be natural for S28 to join too.
So now the STACK challenge do welcome owner of the following models to come and join us! :D
...
**Wenger/Delemont: **
Wenger Tool Chest family(Tool Chest plus, Matterhorn, Snap Shackle and SGT fix it)
Wenger/Delemont S54 and S28Damn, I don't have any of those. :( I hope some other participant does and will carry it throughout the challenge. If you change your mind on the 557, I solemny swear to only carry this one in April. But I understand that you consider it too "understacked" if the Swisschamp is the reference. Hm, maybe I will just carry the CT 29 instead

-
@SirVicaLot said:
Darn it, you guys are making it sound way to much fun. Let‘s see. Fieldmaster challenge in Feb, take a break in March, Swisschamp in April. I am in unless work gets in my way
SAK STACK 30 days Challenge in April 2020
- comis
- Sos24
- Zrxoa1
- Kraken
- BadMechanic
- Antti Lammi
- Ron Who
- Ivo
- Ulzhan
- Gath
- Rizio Il Ghiro
- ElevenBlade
- Pacu
- CraftsmanSAK
- Simon_Templar
- Max Stone
- SirVicaLot (work permitting)
SVL, great to have you!
I too hope the work schedule works out for you! -
@Simon_Templar said:
Comis, looks as if your fridge magnets have a lot of power of attraction ;)I don't know how strong it is, but I have been planning on that for a while and I for one would love to have something to remind me of this challenge.
@Simon_Templar said:
Damn, I don't have any of those. :( I hope some other participant does and will carry it throughout the challenge. If you change your mind on the 557, I solemny swear to only carry this one in April. But I understand that you consider it too "understacked" if the Swisschamp is the reference. Hm, maybe I will just carry the CT 29 instead
CT29 totally qualify per the badge rule, so you are set!
557 is significant in Wenger history since it features only Wenger originated tools, I too have one and would love to see it on list. But considering it at 5 layers, while I am only opening to Victorinox Champion 7 layers to accommodate, and if we stretch it to 5 layers, then literally dozen more models will be eligible and it will no longer be a "STACK" challenge.I know it may not make perfect sense why the much slimmer CT29 and CT34 could join, while some thicker layers couldn't, but since these are the original badge rules, I think we should still try to adhere to the rules without overusing the leeway.

-
@comis said:
I don't know how strong it is, but I have been planning on that for a while and I for one would love to have something to remind me of this challenge.I know it may not make perfect sense why the much slimmer CT29 and CT34 could join, while some thicker layers couldn't, but since these are the original badge rules, I think we should still try to adhere to the rules without overusing the leeway.

It will indeed be lovely to have such a memento on the fridge. It's really a very nice idea.
As to not admitting the 557, I understand your reasoning. As a matter of fact, I think the moderators should rather change the rules for this challenge so as to exclude the CT 29 and even the CT 34, which both seem like loopholes to me (even though I might use them myself now that they're here >:D). One could for example just make the Swisschamp the point of reference and allow any SAK that is as wide or wider. That would simply things a lot.
-
Is a interesting debate. 6-layer Expedition Lite is almost as wide as 8-layer SwissChamp. So just going by the number of layers won’t work.
Here are some quick measurements I took:
1st gen SC 31.8mm
New SC 32.3mm
CT29 21.0mm
CT34 28.3mm
CT41 33.0mm
CT Lite 33.6mm
Expedition Lite 30.5mm
XLT 43.1mm
XAVT 65mm
Evogrip S54 45.5mm
EvoWood S557 28mmThere’s nothing in the current 91mm wider than the CT34 other than those listed above. So I’d support dropping the CT29 but keeping the 34 if there was a review of the Stack rules...

Don’t have a Champion, but it must be around 28-29mm?
-
...that will sweep up the Handyman too...
-
Yes. The difference between Champion and Handyman is less than 1 mm.
-
I think 1” (scale to scale) is a good benchmark. These are all big SAKs...
-
...not always. Some 6 layers trump 7 layer SAKs because of chubby tools like pliers, LED, thicker scales, etc. 5 layer CT34 Cybertool is a hair wider than the Champion!
-
Hmmm....I think there are many ways to looks at this challenge rule, by width, by tool count, by lineage, by layers, etc...or any combination of those.
For now, I am still inclined to try to stick with the original rules of CT, Swisschamp and ToolChest variant, because that would be most fair to those whom have participated(or couldn't participate) in the past.But having said that, I was told there is a small leeway to give, if certain model is just 1 layer short(or 1-2 layers+) of Swisschamp(8 layers), and looking it up on SAKwiki, it will mean the 7 layers, which will include the CT41(which is already on list), and Champion C and Champion Plus(which both have direct lineage to Swisschamp, and same layers to CT41)
For Wenger/Delemont, it make sense to open upwards to 8-10 layers(Tool Chest is 7), because we do allow much, much bigger Swisschamp to join, all the way up to 15 layers.

@Max Stone said:
...not always. Some 6 layers trump 7 layer SAKs because of chubby tools like pliers, LED, thicker scales, etc. 5 layer CT34 Cybertool is a hair wider than the Champion!@ElevenBlade said:
When I had inquired previously about the Champion I was told it would qualify as it has 7 layers.I suppose its a layer issue...
The 1 inch discussion is interesting, but similar idea may keep opening doors for interpretation and soon it may become a fudge to explain. For example, Handyman, there supposed to have two versions, original vs modern, one is under 1 inch and the other is above 1 inch, is it fair to accepting one without the other?

One could argue why must there be a hard cut off at 1 inch and only accepting part of the 6 layers family? And if we start opening doors to some of the 6 layers from Victorinox line, why can't rest of the 6 layers from Victorinox and Wenger/Delemont join as well?(more than 20 in total) :ahhh
If we turn around and look at other challenges, remember we have a similar discussion earlier in the Minimal Challenge 2020? Folks were discussing the possibilities to include Soldiers into the Minimal challenge, eventually it was decided that it may be best to run them separately because it is difficult to accept Soldier into Minimal, while saying either yes or no to the 111mm Soldiers would feel awkward either way.
Anyhow, just for sake of discussion, this topic kinda reminded me our fellow member hiraethus discussing the concept of Wabi-sabi in Vidar's R&D thread. Sure, some of these challenge rules may or may not make perfect sense, but what matter most to me is our sense of camaraderie that we cultivated thru these challenges, and everything else to me could might as well be Wabi-sabi. ;)
-
*
I have the SAK STACK badge, but may be an unofficial participant.*
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


