Why lock blades?
-
Most thought-provoking post. If you look at multitool development, the first products had blades and tools that did not lock. And when doing the PST challenge in December, it was the lack of a lock on the Phillips driver that I missed the most (not on the blade), as I had it fold back a couple of times driving screws. But maybe there’s a common element between the modern folder and modern multitool; that they are both general purpose tools that have limitations. And regardless of how good the design is, it can never replace a tool specifically designed and optimized for a task, like a proper screwdriver or fixed blade.

-
I think I'll just join the choir?
Personally I never trust a lock, and make sure to never depend on it in any way. Basically I use folding knives as if the lock isn't there. If that lock then suddenly comes into use for whatever reason it has likely done something good and worked as an extra safety. With correct use locks are a good thing - but correct use is the key.
The flip side is that a seemingly reliable lock might allow and tempt user into wrong and dangerous practices. In that respect knife manufacturers whose marketing plays at trusting their locks might set their customers up for injury.
Sometimes I wonder if locks should be made with a bit of controlled give to them - like a fair warning to prevent bad habits.
-
@cbl51 said:
Any knife that folds is already broken. Any lock, just like any man made item can fail, and will in time if pushed hard. Maybe its time for the un-folding pocket knife to come about.Amen to that, I think what cb51 wrote about bring home the message--if forefathers could survive all those harsh conditions with slipjoints and 'fixed' blade reliably, modern buyers need to rethink what's their definition of 'hard use' and why is everyone paying premium for additional features. At the end of the day, lane drift alarm and self-barking never can replace safe driving. Knife lock can never replace knife safety knowledge.
-
Why? Because these knife companies need to keep in business. All of us have at home, far more knives than we practically need, but unless we keep buying there'll be no more knife companies.
The beast that is advanced stage capitalism has to come up with constant 'innovation' in order to stay alive and there's a real market out there for men, increasingly seperated from a 'hands on' lifestyle, to buy a knife or knives that makes them feel like they could survive some sort of crisis.
Truth is that a fixed blade and/or a folder will do pretty everything we need a blade for. But that doesn't feed the beast :D
-
A one handed opening blade requires a lock pretty much. OHO as a requirement is a function of the immediacy of the age rather than a necessity but I would assume that an entire societal mindset change, a reset, would be required to change this fact and the drive in is the opposite direction.
-
CBL51
I think I can say +1 pretty much all of your post, especially the knife and gun phobia. I’m a ‘60 vintage , and there was never any thought of knives in the way they are now. It was a part of the list of kit requirements when going away on camp as a Cadet, which was compulsory for 2 years in high school. Our school had a .22 small bore range and I took my.22 to school for Friday afternoon range practice on the school bus. Any new rifle I purchased later on (mid-late 70’s) I took home on the public transport (boxed up).
As far as folders are concerned I never new about lock blades till I was a teenager, in fact all my first knives were sheath knives, however I have had a folder fold on me and it was a slip joint ( yes I was using it as a screwdriver).I understand looking at the present with eyes from the past and wish some things weren’t the way they are too, though I can see the benefits in some improvements and think lock blades are a natural progression, especially after the introduction of the 110. I mostly use lock blade folders now. I do wish the general perception of knives was different.
Love the post
-
Lock blades feel safer and, I think , are safer.
Mrs Nix won't use anything else. The lock makes the knife feel more secure to her.
I had an early Spyderco lock fail once (twice actually) where I got a minor cut. So lock blades are not fool-proof; I'm proof of that.
But....I've also managed to cut myself multiple times with fixed blades and slipjoints. I'm a strong believer in the fixed blade knife. All subsequent 'improvements' have been gimmicks or compromising conveniences. However, I've also nicked, cut, and stabbed myself more with fixed blades than any other type of knife. For no apparent reason, the locking blade knife has been the type least injurious to me.
Bottom line, if you don't respect the blade....

-
Why lock blades?
Locking knives are great. I carry one in the form of the wave at work and tenacious at home. They offer the safety of a fixed blade when having to stab when required (opening sacks) with the convenience of a folder (pocket carry).
What’s not to like.
-
Great posts and great information! Even better memories as being able to carry a pocket knife in school and actually using it and never given a second look.
-
** The modern do-it-all lock blade that can deanimate enemy sentries or pry open a Russian tank hatch. Why?**
After getting my BK2 I wonder the same thing
. Could it be as simple as designers pushing the limits of a folder, as ElevenBlade says, innovation? Certianly our upbringings have a lot to do with how we see tools and the "need" or not of their development.I grew up in a much different environment. I grew up in an urban landscape with no hunters, little open space, and mother dominated homes. I was not privy to seeing pocket knives as tools. I remember movies like Westside Story where the switch blade as a weapon. I remember zip guns. No one hunted or went to target ranges. Early on I saw these not as tools and it wasn't until much later that I began to see my childhood influenced how I thought.
My inner-city childhood vs rural life couldn't have been more different. I spent a great deal of my early life cooking for a living so a "fixed blade" was my tool. Not much I cannot do with a chefs knife. I'm not sure if having a lock makes me less careful? Having recently really begun to appreciate the classic slip joint I find myself no less as careful as when I use a fixed. Downward pressure on the cutting edge always.
I wonder how many injuries have occurred simply from foolishness? Having been in the kitchens cooking and around knives I have seen some cuts happen. It usually rushing or a momentary loss of attention. With the tactical side of folders these days I wonder if the design itself pushes some to push these features?
-
@Aloha said:
** The modern do-it-all lock blade that can deanimate enemy sentries or pry open a Russian tank hatch. Why?**After getting my BK2 I wonder the same thing
. Could it be as simple as designers pushing the limits of a folder, as ElevenBlade says, innovation? Certianly our upbringings have a lot to do with how we see tools and the "need" or not of their development.I grew up in a much different environment. I grew up in an urban landscape with no hunters, little open space, and mother dominated homes. I was not privy to seeing pocket knives as tools. I remember movies like Westside Story where the switch blade as a weapon. I remember zip guns. No one hunted or went to target ranges. Early on I saw these not as tools and it wasn't until much later that I began to see my childhood influenced how I thought.
My inner-city childhood vs rural life couldn't have been more different. I spent a great deal of my early life cooking for a living so a "fixed blade" was my tool. Not much I cannot do with a chefs knife. I'm not sure if having a lock makes me less careful? Having recently really begun to appreciate the classic slip joint I find myself no less as careful as when I use a fixed. Downward pressure on the cutting edge always.
I wonder how many injuries have occurred simply from foolishness? Having been in the kitchens cooking and around knives I have seen some cuts happen. It usually rushing or a momentary loss of attention. With the tactical side of folders these days I wonder if the design itself pushes some to push these features?

I try to be mindful that our friends here on MTo are from all around the globe, even some using Google Translate to communicate, and we all have different upbringings, cultures, and laws. For that reason, I try to avoid being too specific, for fear of being unrelatable - but I think you hit the nail on the head in my world.
I had a similar upbringing... "mother-dominated homes" Yes. Exactly. Nobody's father took them hunting, except for the two guys whos dad taught all of us everything we learned in the Scouts.... Nobody's father fixed anything around the house - except for that one guy who was lucky because his "dad is a contractor". I told you about my grandfather... but I didn't tell you about my dad, who never once carried the 3-blade stockman he owned, and never needed to fix the gutter in the building we didn't actually own.
I also didn't mention the detail that where I live, chefs and line cooks have been arrested and jailed time and again for carrying a pocketknife with a visible pocket clip for work, - the one they carry to preserve their expensive German steel.
It's just a reality of life around here in the suburbs - where we do get to have guns and knives - but the guns aren't for harvesting food., the knives aren't for working the back yard.
Pay close attention to this very entertaining video, and tell me if you notice what's in the back of Jimmy's mind.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_HTQdCglXKITo circle back to the original question. I think I'll just bluntly answer what I've been skirting around... While it's certainly not the whole "why", it's representative.
Why lock blades?
To stab

-
Locking knives are great. I carry one in the form of the wave at work and tenacious at home. They offer the safety of a fixed blade when having to stab when required (opening sacks) with the convenience of a folder (pocket carry).
What’s not to like.
Whats not to like???
The simple statement that you make about how they offer the safety of a fixed blade tells me that you totally miss the whole point. They do NOT offer the safety of a fixe blade. That is an illusion put out by the knife manufacturers to sell their over hyped and over priced knives.
This is the third time I've seen a young man get very seriously injured by a "locked" knife. All three of them had one big thing in common; they all were amazed and even dumfounded that the knife folded on them when pushed. All the way to the hospital, John kept repeating to himself that he didn't understand what happened, the blade was locked. And John is soooo typical of the young men of his generation.
John grew up in a typical Southern California mega suburbia. His father was an engineer with lots of lab experience endnote an outdoorsman. He knows very little about knives, and bought what was a highly advertised knife, a ZT with tiger stripes on the blade. Tiger stripes????
Like most the guys ins generation, he never even handled a slip joint, and his sole knife experience was the one hand wonder lock blades. He never learned proper safe knife handling, and when I tried to gov him some fatherly advice, his reply was "That's okay, I'm not using one of those old fashioned knives that don't lock." He was convinced that he had the ultimate folding knife that would never fold on him because of the mighty lock. Now he has a partly disable right hand and is looking at an operation by. a hand speSmurfpillst to restore full use to this right index finger, which the stitches are now out, but it doesn't work much.
Theres a whole generation of guys that have b been taken in by the knife industry. The industry has created an artificial market to stimulate sales by pushing a BS product. A product that is an accident waiting to happen.
In the old days, a man carried a pocket that had a couple blades, and would fold up on him if he acted stupidly with it. if he needed a stronger blade, he'd use a fixed blade, as it is called now. Darn near every man had a small fixed blade. They were made by Case, Kabar, Western, Camillus, Buck, and others. They were not expensive as there was not much to them. A blade and a handle and a sheath to put them in. The could not fold up unless you actually snapped the blade off, and that took a real effort.
There is absolutely nothing that a lock blade can do that a fixed blade can't as well if not better and safer.
-
To circle back to the original question. I think I'll just bluntly answer what I've been skirting around... While it's certainly not the whole "why", it's representative.
Why lock blades?
To stab

Thank you for the honesty.
A Victorinox SAK is a pocket knife. A Buck 301 stockman is a pocket knife.
Some knife that can be flicked open with one hand and blade locks, is a weapon. The modern knife industry is selling fantasy with the over hyped knives they sell to young men who don't know any better.
-
@cbl51 said:
Thank you for the honesty.A Victorinox SAK is a pocket knife. A Buck 301 stockman is a pocket knife.
Some knife that can be flicked open with one hand and blade locks, is a weapon. The modern knife industry is selling fantasy with the over hyped knives they sell to young men who don't know any better.
That's painting it with a pretty broad brush

Lockbacks with OHO have their place and uses, this is coming from someone who pretty much carries slipjoints only. I do use a modern OHO locker for a work knife as it is much safer for rough use.
-
@cbl51 said:
Whats not to like???The simple statement that you make about how they offer the safety of a fixed blade tells me that you totally miss the whole point. They do NOT offer the safety of a fixe blade. That is an illusion put out by the knife manufacturers to sell their over hyped and over priced knives.
This is the third time I've seen a young man get very seriously injured by a "locked" knife. All three of them had one big thing in common; they all were amazed and even dumfounded that the knife folded on them when pushed. All the way to the hospital, John kept repeating to himself that he didn't understand what happened, the blade was locked. And John is soooo typical of the young men of his generation.
John grew up in a typical Southern California mega suburbia. His father was an engineer with lots of lab experience endnote an outdoorsman. He knows very little about knives, and bought what was a highly advertised knife, a ZT with tiger stripes on the blade. Tiger stripes????
Like most the guys ins generation, he never even handled a slip joint, and his sole knife experience was the one hand wonder lock blades. He never learned proper safe knife handling, and when I tried to gov him some fatherly advice, his reply was "That's okay, I'm not using one of those old fashioned knives that don't lock." He was convinced that he had the ultimate folding knife that would never fold on him because of the mighty lock. Now he has a partly disable right hand and is looking at an operation by. a hand speSmurfpillst to restore full use to this right index finger, which the stitches are now out, but it doesn't work much.
Theres a whole generation of guys that have b been taken in by the knife industry. The industry has created an artificial market to stimulate sales by pushing a BS product. A product that is an accident waiting to happen.
In the old days, a man carried a pocket that had a couple blades, and would fold up on him if he acted stupidly with it. if he needed a stronger blade, he'd use a fixed blade, as it is called now. Darn near every man had a small fixed blade. They were made by Case, Kabar, Western, Camillus, Buck, and others. They were not expensive as there was not much to them. A blade and a handle and a sheath to put them in. The could not fold up unless you actually snapped the blade off, and that took a real effort.
There is absolutely nothing that a lock blade can do that a fixed blade can't as well if not better and safer.
cbl!It's an unfortunate aspect of our culture. A vast majority of us drive like our brakes won't fail. walk like the floor isn't slippery, cut like the lock won't collapse. And then we sue the manufacturer or owner.
In my less-foolish, not-yet-wiser years I only really ever use two locking knives: a Victorinox and a Camillus, not counting pliers based MTs. I open them carefully with two hands (assuming the back spring will overcome my strength, and I use them as if the lock will fail. Then, harkening back to the "snap or pinch closed" debate, I pinch them closed under the assumption that my fingers can slip into the slot of the handle.
As always, your posts are appreciated.

-
@SteveC said:
That's painting it with a pretty broad brush
Lockbacks with OHO have their place and uses, this is coming from someone who pretty much carries slipjoints only. I do use a modern OHO locker for a work knife as it is much safer for rough use.
Painting with a broad brush gets the job done faster.
I'm sorry but the elephant in the room should be addressed. I grew up watching and learning from men who just got back fighting a world war. They didn't feel the need for a locking blade knife, and they did the job of life very well. In fact, the only people who carried knives with locking blades in my youth were the punks. The Italian style switch blades and stilettos that were some kind of a badge of manhood. The modern one hand flipper is the modern switch blade for the wannabe James Dean's of our age.
Safer for rough use????
Is there anything that lock blade will do for you that a Buck 102, Esee Izula, Matini puuko, Mora fixed blade or any other trout and bird size sheath knife will do? Aside from fold up that is?
Come on, are you really going to say that a small fixed blade will not stand up to "rough" work better than any folding knife?
There comes a point where the tool become a weapon because of design.
-
Your posts have come off as bitter and angry.
Too bad.
-
You are obviously looking for a fight. I never said anything about a lockback being better suited than a fixed blade for rough use.
A modern lockblade it definitely more suited for rough use than a slippie. ;)
All knives are weapons if used as such, I'm done here .
-
as an aside - I like to have an awl on my EDC because I think its a safer method of stabbing into things, not just wood and leather, but cardboard, sacks, plastic, etc.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
