Compact vs Manager & Waiter
-
Hi all
I've been carrying a keychain Manager which is really handy, and when not in work adding a Waiter to the pocket. Between them they do: small package knife, medium food knife, decent bottle and can opener, corkscrew, file, scissors, pen, tweezers, etc. I'm really happy with that mix of tools (bizarrely, I do use the pen) and it's very similar to what comes with the Compact that I ordered as a present for a friend.
How do people see the pros and cons of carrying two cheap, small SAKs vs a single (slightly) larger one? Tempted to switch?
-
It comes down to personal preference. I would carry the Compact, because i prefer the 91mm over the smaller ones. I also prefer to carry one tool, instead of two. Whatever suits your needs

And welcome to MTo, JK!
-
While I’m of the opinion that the Compact is the king of the 91mm line, if I’m carrying my keys (with a Classic on the ring) I’ll often drop a Waiter in my pocket instead.
It’s a very light, very capable combination.
-
I prefer the Explorer Plus and Manager combo. The Manager provides the micro phillips driver, and those screws hold the whole world together.

-
@SirVicaLot said:
It comes down to personal preference. I would carry the Compact, because i prefer the 91mm over the smaller ones. I also prefer to carry one tool, instead of two. Whatever suits your needs
And welcome to MTo, JK!
I would go with the Compact, for the 91mm scissors.
-
@powernoodle said:
I prefer the Explorer Plus and Manager combo. The Manager provides the micro phillips driver, and those screws hold the whole world together.
Excellent set up!

-
I'm a Tinker guy. Sometimes with a small one hander in the opposite pocket.
Rich -
Another Manager user/carrier. Mine has rode on my keys for a very long time now. No change in the near or distant future regardless of what I carry. It plays back up or primary depending on what I need at that moment. I posted a while back on how hard I used it and at that moment didn't care if it broke. It survived and the value of it increased significantly.
IMO the Manager or any 58mm carried is a wonderful companion to any larger SAK. I was super happy to get a second Manager for backup because I am not afraid to push my primary hard.
Pair up my friend

-
The Compact has a lot of functionality for a 2 layer SAK. And the functionality of the Manager/Waiter combo and the Compact are almost identical. Price wise, they are almost identical too, $47 for the combo, $44 for the Compact (based on MSRP on the US Vic website).
There are some minor differences: with the combo you get the addition of a small blade, a better nail file, the small screwdrivers, and IMHO a better pen (ergonomics of holding it). With the Compact you have bigger scissors and the hook.
You mention that at work you just have the Manager. Is there a work place prohibition on the larger SAK? That would necessitate keeping the Manager. Of course you already own the Manager, and I suspect that you will keep that on your keys even if you get yourself the Compact, so it really boils down to: do I want to swap out the Waiter with a Compact?
-
Thanks all!
I think I wouldn't swap the waiter for a compact and I slightly prefer the 84mm knife so I'll stick to it. Nice to fiddle about with the Compact before handing it away, though. I think if you only had one SAK it would be great to travel with.
TBH, the Waiter is quite underrated: it's all you need if you go from b&b to b&b or between camping sites in Western Europe. It's sort of civilization in a knife.
After lurking some time it's nice to see the love for the Manager too. Since I got it I use it a lot. More than I've ever used larger knives or SAKs. I live in the UK so we have limitations on what to carry - no large blades and no fixed or locking blades (which is common to most of Europe). I do take a puukko out on occasion but strictly to go into the wild and back.
-
Smiller: just checked Victorinox site here and you are right, the Compact is cheaper than Manager + Waiter. However, most retailers seem to discount Manager, and especially Waiter, more than Compact. I paid about the same for either alternative.
-
I think I wouldn't swap the waiter for a compact and I slightly prefer the 84mm knife so I'll stick to it. Nice to fiddle about with the Compact before handing it away, though. I think if you only had one SAK it would be great to travel with.
**TBH, the Waiter is quite underrated: it's all you need if you go from b&b to b&b or between camping sites in Western Europe. It's sort of civilization in a knife. **
After lurking some time it's nice to see the love for the Manager too. Since I got it I use it a lot. More than I've ever used larger knives or SAKs. I live in the UK so we have limitations on what to carry - no large blades and no fixed or locking blades (which is common to most of Europe). I do take a puukko out on occasion but strictly to go into the wild and back.
That sounds like a job for the Tourist!
-
@ElevenBlade said:
That sounds like a job for the Tourist!
I've become a big fan of the Tourist. It's not much thicker or heavier than the Waiter and you gain so much more: the small blade, all the benefits of the full opener layer, and awl. I pair mine with a Rambler on my keyring. For me, it makes a potent urban or minimalist combination.
Buy used and save some dollars!
-
@Sawl Goodman said:

I've become a big fan of the Tourist. It's not much thicker or heavier than the Waiter and you gain so much more: the small blade, all the benefits of the full opener layer, and awl. I pair mine with a Rambler on my keyring. For me, it makes a potent urban or minimalist combination.
Buy used and save some dollars!
I like having the awl and I miss it when I carry the Compact. Nice to have a pointed, edged implement to use when you wanna muck up your blade.
-
I lean the other way: I prefer the combo tool to open bottles and cans over the full layer. The full layer is better only for screws.
-
@Robert669 said:
I like having the awl and I miss it when I carry the Compact. Nice to have a pointed, edged implement to use when you wanna muck up your blade.Same here - its one of the things that makes me flip back to the Soldier ... I'll carry the Compact until I miss the awl... then carry the Soldier until I miss the combo tool. :ahhh
@JK said:
I lean the other way: I prefer the combo tool to open bottles and cans over the full layer. The full layer is better only for screws.I prefer the combo tool to open bottles, without question.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login