Rust issue, not only leatherman
-
i need to try out a swisstool :D
-
I have an engraved Spirit S that J-Sews put a pocket clip on. It's an awesome tool but it's also pretty special to me. I must admit I've considered getting a LM Kick with a pocket clip to carry when I'm going somewhere that I might lose my Spirit.
-
Hi,
I have 263 Leatherman tools, pruners, knives & lights. After I use them, I wipe them down with a silicone cloth. Guess what - no rust. If you have rust on your tools (of any brand), perhaps it speaks to inadequate care on your part?
Time to stop beating a dead donkey.
Cheers - Joe
-
Do you have a pic of your collection?
-
I don't know about you guys, but the Swiss dominance around here is getting old.
Why does it bother you that more people prefer another brand? It's not that big of a deal. If you're happy with Leatherman tools then great but I prefer Vics and when someone new gets on here and asks for my preference then I'm gonna tell him.
I'm not saying that, it's just like just about every Swiss related thread talks about it's superiority! Which is perfectly fine, but a lot of claims are false.. Just like LM's rust. I don't have nearly as many LM's as Joe, but, I'm up there: and still no rust.. But yeah, LM doesn't have a mirror polish so a few specks of rust is inevitable. LM even says to wipe down your tool immediately after salsmurfer exposure. Oh wait, I think the Swisstool manual says the same thing.. If you follow those simple guidelines you won't get any rust! :)
-
Well I for one love these arguments on tools. I actually work in a very wet environment and any tool I carry rusts quickly including Sog, Vic, Wenger and LM. It dont bother me one bit and I usually give my tools a good cleaning when I get home and strip out the pockets.A little whipe down and maybe sometimes some fine steel wool and good to go.
But still I would love to see some steel guru figure out how to make H1 steel harder so tools can be manufactured from it.
-
I don't see rust as a problem.
-
it's just like just about every Swiss related thread talks about it's superiority! Which is perfectly fine, but a lot of claims are false..
Exactly which claims are "false"? Vics aren't immune to rust but obviously the experience of a lot of people on here point to the probability that Vics have a more rust resistant finish than Leathermans. And a lot of people on here prefer the Vic tools over the Leatherman tools. Are Vic tools higher quality than Leatherman tools? Is it a certifiable fact? I don't think that you can prove it scientifically but you have to at least listen to the majority opinion.
-
Multitools aren't meant to appeal to the masses really.. Everyone's needs are different thus everyone likes their own brand etc. Like I like tools with one hand opening knife blades so it's really only Leatherman's for me.
-

Everyone likes their own brand
-
I have 263 Leatherman tools, pruners, knives & lights. After I use them, I wipe them down with a silicone cloth. Guess what - no rust. If you have rust on your tools (of any brand), perhaps it speaks to inadequate care on your part?
Time to stop beating a dead donkey.
Cheers - Joe
And not least, how do you store them.. :D
/post/207770 -
It' not just a question of rust though, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do. Every LM I've had, from Micra's to Charges has needed to be inspected daily for rust, then cleaned and oiled, which is fine until your too tired or haven't got time to do it, but I have been happy to leave my Vic's dirty in the knowledge that it won't dothem any harm :)
But that's my opinion based on 18 years of pocket tool use, of nearly every major brand :)
-
@Micky d said:
It' not just a question of rust though, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do. Every LM I've had, from Micra's to Charges has needed to be inspected daily for rust, then cleaned and oiled, which is fine until your too tired or haven't got time to do it, but I have been happy to leave my Vic's dirty in the knowledge that it won't dothem any harm :)But that's my opinion based on 18 years of pocket tool use, of nearly every major brand :)
Oh come on, that's way too exaggerated. I also have a micra made in 1999 in my pocket that undergone the same trip and treatment as the wave and powerlock, and has zero speck of rust, simply because it has no rough unpolished surface.
I sense the vic fans getting defensive. :D
-
In the immortal words of Shakespeare, "What's in a name? That which we call a rose."

I can see which one is the rose.
-
@Micky d said:
It' not just a question of rust though, LM's require far more car and attention that Vic will ever do. Every LM I've had, from Micra's to Charges has needed to be inspected daily for rust, then cleaned and oiled, which is fine until your too tired or haven't got time to do it, but I have been happy to leave my Vic's dirty in the knowledge that it won't dothem any harm :)
But that's my opinion based on 18 years of pocket tool use, of nearly every major brand :)
Oh come on, that's way too exaggerated. I also have a micra made in 1999 in my pocket that undergone the same trip and treatment as the wave and powerlock, and has zero speck of rust, simply because it has no rough unpolished surface.
I sense the vic fans getting defensive. :D
Not at all, I recognise LM's for what they are :), but I really did find that my LM's rusted at an altogether unacceptable rate, partly that's down to my apparently Nurglite powers, and partly due to the fact that it was in my belt pouch whilst riding motorcycles, so while not exposed to direct water, it certainly collected some moisture :-\
And so I spent almost everyday having to wipe it down, and then wiping off the surface rust around the pivots and between the tools, whereas I had to saw several branches off of a sycamore tree today, and I've not even bothered to clean the saw blade, and probably won't get around to it till tommorow, but I know despite the sap (it's still very much alive) they'll be no corrosion :)
-
Seems like someone did a rust test a while back on here. Do i need to call Jamie and Adam, Grant, Kari, and Tory for a Mythbuster?
Mmmmmm Kari...... :D >:D
-
you know what, that actually sounds like a good idea, weve seen them using MT, at least i know id like to see them try that just for the sake of it :D
-
Anything I'd had from new of either brand hasn't rusted, but I've seen plenty of old neglected ones looking like cr*p. I don't put them through the kind of abuse that leaves them filthy or damp really o it's never been a big issue for me. Now I have a dedicated alox harvester for the allotment use, we shall see if that copes!
-
@Buzzbait said:
In the immortal words of Shakespeare, "What's in a name? That which we call a rose."I can see which one is the rose.
And which one works for a living, and which one is a shelf queen. A picture of one tool with rust the other without doesn't mean anything.
Funny all the vic fans just look directly over SOG mentioned, and the conclusion of it basically comes down to surface finish rather than brand/steel, and turned this into leatherman vs. vic.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



