Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
Thanks for the responses, guys.
-
What is the general consensus regarding the serrated blade tip shape on the P4? ???
I understand LM designed it that way so the blade would be locked into the handles when the pliers are used, but does the chisel tip shape serve any practical purpose otherwise? I'm not really liking it. I'm on the fence about just grinding an angled sheep's foot profile on the end of the blade to make it more useful. The spring tension on the lock release seems to keep the blade in place enough by itself for me.
-

It came with the clip. In short supply here despite the high price. Minus the local VAT, I paid USD171 equivalent in shekels. But I prefer to inspect my multitools carefully, in hand, which I can do in an outdoors shop. And I don't get the wrong tool, or have shipping charges. Almost all the shops that carry multitools were out of the P4 already. They came in, and out they went. A lot of Moms and Dads give multitools to their kids when they are conscripted at age 18. Probably more to sons than daughters. I suspect the Free P4s are on green webbing belts already. Though I'd say that the Surge is best for a soldier, personally.
Anyway, I swore I would pass the Free P4 by. The magnetic attraction got to me. The bugger already took first blood. (Thumb healing nicely.) So I can say, it was shipped sharp!
I thought I would hate the awl, but I don't. I work mostly in pine, so I am ok there. Even the little file is better than the stories of of being Wingmanish or Sidekickian. Scissors: good enough! Better than the mini scissors on the Wave and the Charge. Saw: works well.
Lock-up: tight.
Won't replace my Surge in bushcrafting, but a decent bit of kit, with some tight engineering.
My very short-term commentary. A tidy little fidget spanner.
-
Nice

-
After using the Free P4 all week...

Still awkward to open tools from some positions, but ok, possible. Not as intuitively useable and fluid as claimed, but ok. I don't sit around flipping MTs, so I may take a while, but ok.
I do question the ruler, which for me is a good quick way to measure for bolts and other smaller fasteners, and small depths. The whole world uses the metric system, which is shortchanged in this design with a partial ruler, and a useless diagram indicating the wire stripper. The English or Imperial measures dominate, yet only 4 or 5% of the world uses them. At least they should have given equal clarity to the metric measures. Even countries other than the US, of British origin, use and understand metric measure and often make tools and supplies and mechanical and engineering plans in metric. And besides, many engineers, mechanics, tool-users and scientific and technical professions in the US do know the metric system. Sloppy Leatherman! World sales are an ever-growing percentage of your market. Even tiny Israel in far-off Asia has a Leatherman warranty centre and representative (of sorts). Perhaps few care for any tiny ruler, but I love the ability to measure small fasteners and shallow depths.
Too many flathead openers, which are too thin. I would have liked a beefier awl, and no can opener. I love the Victorinox can opener, but I use it as a mini-blade in small scale woodcraft. Very few cans need an opener anymore. And I almost never buy those. The file does work, but, for many It is too small. However, I would not give up the serrated knife. Most people so automatically say, "not a fan of serrated blades." I use it for boxes, card stock, rope and string, cloth etc. Keeps the straight blade sharp. A smaller serrated utility blade would have been ok, but with that chisel tip still. As with 99% of MT owners, I don't attend road accidents and have to extricate anyone from a jammed seat belt. If I prepared for contingencies beyond a reasonable point, I'd have to lug around a 40k rucksack, and never take off my aluminium headgear, or garlic necklace, in public.
Otherwise, I do like the P4. The grey belt sheath will get dirty quickly no doubt. Would have preferred black, but ok. Now is just to see how the tool wears over time, and to stay out of metal shops and ferrous particulate. Durability--only time and use will tell. Meanwhile LM moddies are no doubt gearing up to develop bit-driver adapters for the Free P4. I have bit-drivers on my Waves, my Surge, my Skeletools, and maybe others. I wanted a stand-alone with no extra parts to carry with the Free P4--so no bit-driver doesn't chafe me. I like the tight, minimalist sheath, aside from the grey colour.
Overall, a B+ tool. Subject to future elevation or demotion. Some great engineering--if the P4 proves durable.
-
I have been wondering about these. Good review. Looking forward to your future thoughts on this one.

-
Been bothering me all week. Something did not feel right about the hand-feel and balance of the Free P4. Especially compared to the Wave. The P4 in plier position is wanting to slip dow and out of my grip. Opening and closing the plier head feels insecure and awkward. The Wave feels balanced, and does not tend to slip. The Wave can be manipulated without losing position in my hand.
I could just squeeze harder when using the P4. An answer if sorts. It contrasts with the balanced hand-feel of the Wave. Perhaps I will get used to the differences, I don't know.
-
Vice one

-
@israelpiper said:
Been bothering me all week. Something did not feel right about the hand-feel and balance of the Free P4. Especially compared to the Wave. The P4 in plier position is wanting to slip dow and out of my grip. Opening and closing the plier head feels insecure and awkward. The Wave feels balanced, and does not tend to slip. The Wave can be manipulated without losing position in my hand.I could just squeeze harder when using the P4. An answer if sorts. It contrasts with the balanced hand-feel of the Wave. Perhaps I will get used to the differences, I don't know.

Handles are too long so the ends don’t rest in the back of the palm like the Wave without wanting to fall fwd, and too many hot spots at the ends. While I appreciate the technology put into Free, my P2 does not get carried.
-
@Philabuster said:
What is the general consensus regarding the serrated blade tip shape on the P4? ???I understand LM designed it that way so the blade would be locked into the handles when the pliers are used, but does the chisel tip shape serve any practical purpose otherwise? I'm not really liking it. I'm on the fence about just grinding an angled sheep's foot profile on the end of the blade to make it more useful. The spring tension on the lock release seems to keep the blade in place enough by itself for me.
Hi, You can punch through things like drywall with the chisel end serrated blade (even twist it like an awl through plywood) and then go in with the saw to continue cutting. The serrated blade and saw have almost the exact same profile.
One of my favorite things about the Free series is how quickly I can close the blades with one hand. I have 4 kids running around always wanting to help. It's nice to be able to put the blade away quickly.
-
Welcome to
tbateman 
-
My Free P2 is going back. Pliers binding https://youtu.be/NFsneeJLltc :'(
-
That is just smurfing

Especially for the price that they are
-
Glad to hear it's going back, Max. Customers should not be expected to have to correct these issues themselves.
-
There is a lot of problems out there with the pliers, I dont understand why Leatherman keeps sending out those tools all over the world:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



