Perceived need?
-
Need vs want is what drives high dollar advertising firms to do extensive market research on what will drive the next big sales push.
Need vs want is what drives the collector people because of that extensively researched market drive.
The gun collector, knife collector, car collector, and other accumulators all fall prey to artificially created markets if the new "you must have this " psychology that is designed to get you to buy what you don't really need, but are driven to want. Believe me, they know what they are doing. The gun companies and knife companies all pay a lot of money to have the experts come up with a program that will you something that won't really do anything any better than what you already have, but you feel you absolute need it. No mater if its a boutique brand pocket knife from GEC for a hundred bucks that won't cut the end of a pice of rope any better than a 17.95 Vic recruit, let alone deal with a loose screw on a door hinge, fix a dead Vespa motor scooter in the middle of nowhere, fix a trolling motor on a canoe in the middle of nowhere, open a can of chill in the boondocks, or just open a cold one after the job is done. Is a fancy wood handle worth a hundred bucks? GEC market research says so and they sell them. Thats market research and advertising for ya.
The American car companies used this kind of advertising to keep selling the same tired junk on the American public for 50 years. It wasn't until enough people saw their neighbors getting better service from VW's, Datsun's and Toyota that their sales went way down, but they kept on making junk. Even after a lot of people knew better, there was enough of the people around that wouldn't buy a foreign car, that they kept in business. They sold on image. The ego vs the id. Need vs want.
I look back on the stuff I bought in my younger days, and I cringe. Its like what the hell was I thinking. All those useless knives and guns that I had zero need of, but spent good money on. But I saw a movie or advertising and got hooked into the imagery. Never mind that I wasn't a commando taking an enemy beach, or the caped crusader defending Gotham. I only thank God I managed to get most my money back when I grew up and sold it all off.
What we need is a universe apart from what the manufacturers would have us think.
-
Perceived need is an interesting driver of economy. We all know about supply and demand, but there's an interesting and very different issue that comes up with availability and perceived need driving use.
An interesting example of this is the availability and utilization of mental healthcare in various parts of the world.
But about SAKs - I can think of some of the various stages of my life... different jobs, hobbies, places I've lived,,. where I had a perceived need of a specific tool or feature. Over the years I've had a perceived need for...
- pliers (resulting in the purchase of 4 MTs)
- oho knife (Wave, and countless folders)
- sheepfoot serrated blade (3 of those MTs)
- Ruler (4 MTs and a fish scaler ???)
- scissors (everything since 2002-ish?)
- saw (ahem..... :P)
While it's certainly part of the companies marketing strategy, it's also our fault... and it's part of the fun... and funnily enough, it can go either way.
I can stick to my I need a saw and scissors story, and go for a Huntsman, or need for a ruler and be stuck with a Swisschamp. Sometimes the perceived need limits your choices to something you wouldn't ordinarily carry due to size/weight.
On the other hand, my perceived need can be exclusionary, or in a negative space... minimalist, perhaps. I could have perceived that my need is to carry a SAK that is particularly light-weight.
As mentioned in my oft re-told but never quoted discourse on "Color as a Tool", besides the individual implements and layers on the SAK, compactness and indeed scale color is a tool of sorts, and I do factor that into my MT choices.
Ultimately, I could be entirely nihilist about the whole situation. 2 of my friends carry SAKs, most others carry folders, but a majority of people I know on a day to day basis don't carry anything. So do I really need to EDC anything at all? In actuality, I can get away without an EDC. But my perceived need is that I do.
We chase our tails for a hobby, don't we?
When I think about what I really need on a day to day basis (barring needing nothing), I can get by with a LM Micra, to be honest. For food prep I can find a plastic knife in the break room, or throw an Opinel in the lunch bag if I want to cut down on waste. The game of picking out the ideal SAK for myself is really just a game.
Over the last couple of months, I'm trying to disabuse myself of the notion that I need a saw. If you wait long enough, the feeling subsides.
-
I'm an office worker and have to dress fancy. My needs are simple: scissors, knife blade, nail tool. If I'm carrying something that doesn't have a nail tool, I'll just use the knife blade for that. So for me it's Voyageur, Compact, Yeoman, Super Cadet, etc.
The weekend comes and I switch to a Pioneer or something similarly robust, the scissors become optional, and a bottle opener/screwdriver becomes a must.
All of this means that I could really probably get along with two SAKs, but that's no fun.
-
Ultimately, I’m confident that nothing more than a Climber would be required to handle virtually everything I need on a day-to-day basis. The rest is just for fun.
-
@nate j said:
Ultimately, I’m confident that nothing more than a Climber would be required to handle virtually everything I need on a day-to-day basis. The rest is just for fun.I agree that the Climber has everything I need on a day to day basis - except for one thing.... the 2 layer form factor. I have a perceived need for two layers...
So I go with the Compact about half the time, and forgo the small blade. Meanwhile on my 7-8 layer SAKs, without a question, my most-used tool is the small blade.
-
Boy Scout motto always kicks in on this type of stuff...Be Prepared

-
Schwartz relates the ideas of psychologist Herbert A. Simon from the 1950s to the psychological stress that most consumers face today. He notes some important distinctions between, what Simon termed, maximizers and satisficers. A maximizer is like a perfectionist, someone who needs to be assured that their every purchase or decision was the best that could be made. The way a maximizer knows for certain is to consider all the alternatives they can imagine. This creates a psychologically daunting task, which can become even more daunting as the number of options increases. The alternative to maximizing is to be a satisficer. A satisficer has criteria and standards, but a satisficer is not worried about the possibility that there might be something better. Ultimately, Schwartz agrees with Simon's conclusion, that satisficing is, in fact, the maximizing strategy.
As the year wears on I am focused on satisficing. We'll see how this goes.
-
A funny thing perception is. It rarely matches reality.
Most of my SAKs have a woodsaw because that´s the tool I use most. But to be honest, the work truck has a chainsaw, a pole saw, and a few pruning saws. And there´s a folding saw in my pocket, one of several that I own. I´m over equipped. So why do I insist that my SAKs have a woodsaw? Why do I perceive the need?
-
A modified DofE which I named the Sheepsfoot Duke (I reshaped the rounded nose on the blade to a sheepsfoot), helped to give me clarity and free me from artificial needs. I went for a while carrying just that in my pocket, and my Gerber Dime on my keys. The purpose of this was go go intentionally less than what my perceived need had been telling me, and see just how frequently my pocket tools let me down, but they never did.
The only times that I was left wanting, was when I had a specific trip task or project, where I knew in advance that I would need more capability, but I'd carried an extra tool suited to those occasions anyway. Outside of those times, not only did that light carry do the trick, but I started finding more uses for those few tools, such as using the hook to carry shopping, using the fixed blade of the scissors as an awl, and using the tweezers as a small screwdriver.
Suddenly, I realised I no longer had a need for a full sized pliers based tool. The little pliers that had been useless in previous years, were now perfectly adequate. I didn't need a heavy duty Phillips either, as I only needed to nip up the occasional loose screw, well enough until I could get a proper driver. Unless I was attempting a specific task that I could get tooled up for, I never had to loosen a tight screw. I'd attempted to be underequipped... and failed.
This is when I decided to revisit the Deluxe Tinker and found it a perfect fit for daily carry. Sure, I've used pliers tools, and the CT41 occasionally since then, but I knew in advance that those tools would be handy before starting a task, be it fitting a new network card in the laptop, changing bathroom taps, setting up my neice's guitar, or whatever. I didn't have to work purely with what was in my pockets. Those days are behind me.
My perceived needs were based on me running a boatyard and engineering company, but I don't do those things anymore. The needs had accumulated, just as the tools had accumulated, from being in situations I couldn't fix, and increasing capabilities accordingly. However, once the real needs had gone, the perceived needs remained, and it took a while and some deliberate action to erase them. I have more clarity now, but then life is less hectic now, and I face different challenges. I don't have to be a walking solution to every problem that might arise anymore, but it can be hard to let go of.
As tool carriers, we often spend time bouncing between too much, and not enough. This can be complicated by changing needs. We also get off on the high of being able to fix something that most folks couldn't, because we had the means available. The more irregular the challenges we overcome that way, the greater our need to want to be able to overcome anything else that arises. Frozen locks, something wrapped round an axle, a machinery fix, some stranger's wheelchair or baby buggy, an electrical fault, something drops into a crack in the pavement, whatever it is, we want to be able to fix it there and then, and we'd look on it as a failure if we couldn't. Why? No bugger else would! Perceived need can be insightful, but it can also be a handicap. Taking time to separate perceived need from real need can be quite liberating.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
A modified DofE which I named the Sheepsfoot Duke (I reshaped the rounded nose on the blade to a sheepsfoot), helped to give me clarity and free me from artificial needs. I went for a while carrying just that in my pocket, and my Gerber Dime on my keys. The purpose of this was go go intentionally less than what my perceived need had been telling me, and see just how frequently my pocket tools let me down, but they never did.The only times that I was left wanting, was when I had a specific trip task or project, where I knew in advance that I would need more capability, but I'd carried an extra tool suited to those occasions anyway. Outside of those times, not only did that light carry do the trick, but I started finding more uses for those few tools, such as using the hook to carry shopping, using the fixed blade of the scissors as an awl, and using the tweezers as a small screwdriver.
Suddenly, I realised I no longer had a need for a full sized pliers based tool. The little pliers that had been useless in previous years, were now perfectly adequate. I didn't need a heavy duty Phillips either, as I only needed to nip up the occasional loose screw, well enough until I could get a proper driver. Unless I was attempting a specific task that I could get tooled up for, I never had to loosen a tight screw. I'd attempted to be underequipped... and failed.
This is when I decided to revisit the Deluxe Tinker and found it a perfect fit for daily carry. Sure, I've used pliers tools, and the CT41 occasionally since then, but I knew in advance that those tools would be handy before starting a task, be it fitting a new network card in the laptop, changing bathroom taps, setting up my neice's guitar, or whatever. I didn't have to work purely with what was in my pockets. Those days are behind me.
My perceived needs were based on me running a boatyard and engineering company, but I don't do those things anymore. The needs had accumulated, just as the tools had accumulated, from being in situations I couldn't fix, and increasing capabilities accordingly. However, once the real needs had gone, the perceived needs remained, and it took a while and some deliberate action to erase them. I have more clarity now, but then life is less hectic now, and I face different challenges. I don't have to be a walking solution to every problem that might arise anymore, but it can be hard to let go of.
As tool carriers, we often spend time bouncing between too much, and not enough. This can be complicated by changing needs. We also get off on the high of being able to fix something that most folks couldn't, because we had the means available. The more irregular the challenges we overcome that way, the greater our need to want to be able to overcome anything else that arises. Frozen locks, something wrapped round an axle, a machinery fix, some stranger's wheelchair or baby buggy, an electrical fault, something drops into a crack in the pavement, whatever it is, we want to be able to fix it there and then, and we'd look on it as a failure if we couldn't. Why? No bugger else would! Perceived need can be insightful, but it can also be a handicap. Taking time to separate perceived need from real need can be quite liberating.
Aimless, you're just discovering that needs in our life changes as we go through life and its stages. Now as an old fart and retired, what they call in the U.K. a pensioner, my needs have changed a bit from my working days in a machine shop. And those needs were different than when I was in the army. Life is lived in stages.
I always remember something my old man told me; "Remember who you are, and what you are, and where you are. " That saying would have saved me some major money if I had listened to him in my younger day. :o
My profession of SAK's and other knives went in a descending order as I got older. As I got more experienced in the game of life, my hardware got downsized by that experience and added insight form both failures and successes. Some emergencies along the way and the survival of them with what Had, re-enforced the lesson that you really don't need as much as you think. Being out in the woods in a snow storm with a young lady with a broken ankle and a Vic pioneer to make a stretcher with, was a lesson in how we don't really need a saw.
By downsizing, we do learn to use what tools we have in more ways than they are designed for. Like the can opener. It makes a great hook for taking a pot off the campfire, as well as a cotter pin puller from a trailer hitch. It makes a great staple puller and zipper hook when the pull tb comes off the ski jacket. When I was carrying a classic, I learned that the scissors handles can act like mini pliers to squeeze the ring on an earring that the better half had fall off. The SD tip of the classic can open a beer just fine by using the SD tip tp insert under the crimp and twist slightly and gently to bend the crown edge out a bit. Do this about a third of the way mourned the cp and it becomes loose enough o pop off with your thumb.
About 1995 or 96, my better half and her boss at work was instrumental at getting me into the classic as an EDC pocket knife. I had been on a downward trend curtesy of my old man and his Case peanut, but this was a big step down. After an "experiment" in which I just used the classic everyone a pocket knife job came up, I went cold turkey and walked out the door with just the classic one day. The earth kept on spinning on its axis, the sun stillest that day in the west, and I go home just fine. Then it became a habit and it was a metaphor for a lot of things in life that we tend to over-do it because we confuse needs from wants.
These days I own just five SAK's that are my only pocket knives. All my 'other' pocket knives have been given away. Last year when we went to Key West again, I bought a new classic to mail to myself where we'd be staying, use and give away on the boring we flew out to come home. That tiny classic cut fishing line and squid bait out on the flats bone fishing, cut the little Key Limes for vodka tonics on the patio in the evenings, cut plastic tags off souvenir T-shirts and ball caps, cut off the top of a plastic suntan lotion bottle for the better half, and the tweezers pulled a sticker out of the granddaughters foot when she stepped on one of those spiky things that fall off the trees there. The shuttle bus driver that took us to the airport was very enthusiastically grateful when I handed to him at the airport.
Its too bad that I got this old before I figured it out, it was very very liberating to realize I didn't need half the junk I had accumulated over the years. Like a ball and chain had been removed from my leg.
The Chinese have a saying; " if you own too many possessions, the possessions end up owning you."
-
Aren't we maybe overanalyzing this?
I got a SAK as a kid (pretty sure it was a Huntsman), loved it, eventually lost it. When I was a student I got myself a Swisschamp because I could, and it served me well. Eventually lost that one too. Lived a few years without a SAK, got by just fine. Got sentimental in 2007, bought two 111mm SAKs and a Minichamp. Everything was fine. More than fine in fact: the only one of the three SAKs I regularly used was the Hercules, until I put the Minichamp on my keyring in 2015.
Last June, I suddenly got my very own "Rosebud" moment and had to get another Swisschamp. And consequently almost any other current 91mm SAK. Why? Dunno. Is there any perceived need that triggered this? Not really. I know for a fact I got by fine with just one SAK before, and even during the times I did not have any the world kept spinning. So I won't even pretend that what I did makes any sense. Just old fashioned lunacy or a midlife crisis of sorts. Who cares, really?
-
@cbl51 said:
Aimless, you're just discovering that needs in our life changes as we go through life and its stages. Now as an old fart and retired, what they call in the U.K. a pensioner, my needs have changed a bit from my working days in a machine shop. And those needs were different than when I was in the army. Life is lived in stages.Indeed! You're ahead of me though, Carl, in more ways than one.
There are days when a Classic is enough, and I have one on a neck lanyard that I wear occasionally, but I do still genuinely benefit from having that little bit more on days when I'm semi-functional. I use the pliers at least once a week on average, maybe a little more, and when I do, the plier tips get used, so fudging it with scissors wouldn't work. I do still occasionally have need of a fullsize plier tool, despite not working, and having a more sedate lifestyle.
The hook is very useful to me when shopping. A loop of cord hitched through the handles of the bags, stops the contents spilling in the boot of a taxi, and the hook on the back of a knife lets me lift them out of the boot and get them to the house in ease and comfort. I vape, and the awl is great for digging out the button in the battery when it gets jammed down.
I could pare down further, but there would be no gain. For me life is easier having that little extra, and after all, that's what carrying pocket tools is all about. There's a balance to be found, and at this stage in my life, the Deluxe Tinker provides that. The pliers based tools, or other tools, maybe come out of the drawer a couple of times a month, but only if I'm going somewhere or attempting something where I think they may be useful. Even though they may not be used daily, or even weekly, they are an option that I'd rather not be without.
-
@Ron Who said:
A funny thing perception is. It rarely matches reality.Most of my SAKs have a woodsaw because that´s the tool I use most. But to be honest, the work truck has a chainsaw, a pole saw, and a few pruning saws. And there´s a folding saw in my pocket, one of several that I own. I´m over equipped. So why do I insist that my SAKs have a woodsaw? Why do I perceive the need?
Great reads all around guys

Im in the same boat - I have an over-abundance of wood saws, mainly because I use that tool a lot in the woods, and I'm so darn impressed with that little fella (I dont own or need another saw).
I'm literally talking out loud to myself, trying to convince me that I don't need to replace my Huntsman, or that I don't need a Farmer X when it comes out.
My goal is to own fewer models - I'm less concerned that they are smaller models. In theory, I'm more likely to EDC just a Swisschamp than just a Classic, at this point in my life. I'm ok with that. The trouble is my perception that I need specific things - because I have used them several times - saw, in-line awl, tweezers and eyeglass screwdriver.
Aloha, thanks for the psychology herein, it's always enlightening to understand the psychology of such things - you've boiled the change in mindset into a couple of concepts, which I can appreciate. Unfortunately, I seem to be a maximizer in this regard. My memories are vivid in times when I didn't have a good standard Vic can opener with me (twice), each time I extracted a splinter, or the 2 times I used the micro-SD. It seems to be about saving the day, unfortunately.
I could say that some of those were different times in my life - like the times I needed pliers. But they're not, really.
These days it is about the little things - the splinters and the broken eyeglasses. And I'm not even half-way there.
-
Yes Simon_Templar I am certainly overanalyzing
. I'll admit, one aspect it this process of trying to determine the best fit for a given days activities. Truth is my Explorer Plus handles most everything. I've said more times than I can count, if I cannot handle whatever the day throw at me, then so be it. I am going to be just fine.When it stops being fun it'll be time to put all tools aside and go about my day. I sure hope that doesn't happen any time soon tho
. -
@Aloha said:
Yes Simon_Templar I am certainly overanalyzing
. I'll admit, one aspect it this process of trying to determine the best fit for a given days activities. Truth is my Explorer Plus handles most everything. I've said more times than I can count, if I cannot handle whatever the day throw at me, then so be it. I am going to be just fine.When it stops being fun it'll be time to put all tools aside and go about my day. I sure hope that doesn't happen any time soon tho
.I enjoy overanalyzing! I always keep an eye on what people carry, and what's out there - I lived in blissful ignorance of the vastness of options for many years before I joined MTo, and I got things done. It's a matter of what you like to get done on your own.
We are the stories we tell ourselves, I say. If you tell yourself that you can fix anything and everything you may never be satisfied. The trouble is, when you know you could have done something, but weren't prepared for it.
While I have that mindset, I know I shouldn't. That will come with time.
-
So as not to derail CBLs newly minted thread, I'll add some thoughts here. They fit here, along the lines of the topic.
When CBL says "habits", without so much as second to anticipate what ideas will be raised, my immediate thought was "needs". More illustrative of sub-conscious associations than anything else.
We're all in the habit of all sorts of things, and having certain capabilities that come out of those habits. We've all proven our elementary school teachers wrong. "You need to learn to do simple math in your head - you won't always have a calculator in your pocket!", they said. Well.... guess what? I cant... and I do.
Especially if you've carried the same or similar MT or SAK for a considerable length of time, it becomes an extension of what you're capable of doing yourself.
There's perceived need, and then there are habits - ones that when you're thrown off here and there, you just don't feel right. The kind of habits that indirectly get you to work on time, indirectly get you to comfortably and safely complete your exercise program, or indirectly allow for some quick fixes, first-aid, or simple comforts. Any of those categories can be seen as needs to get through the day - but they're really just things like getting your morning schedule down like clockwork, making sure you have a good lunch, and carrying whatever MT or SAK you've grown accustomed. to.
Once that's there - and then it's not - it just throws you off. That's how you know its more than just spare change in your pocket.
-
We're straying into things which are very individual.
For example, a knife will mean different things to different people. For some, it's the comfort of being able to handle certain tasks at any given moment. For others, it may be safety (in marine activities for example). For some it may be jewellery, or even a status symbol of sorts, either in terms of wealth or a statement of personality.
All these are perceived needs (which may or may not correlate with actual needs), and learned behaviours. The same blade may be too much for one, and not enough for another, some knives that others carry may have me facepalming so strenuously there's risk of injury, and my choices may have the same effects on someone else.
One of the great things about this forum, is it places us in the midst of people with very different needs and preferences. It's an easy trap to fall into, to assume that out choices would be the best for someone else too. Suddenly we are faced with people who's physical abilities differ, and who may have difficulties extracting blade. People who work in different environments, be they corrosive to steel, damaging to plastics, or politically restrictive. Maybe there's extreme temperatures, oils and greases, or a need to be operated with gloves on.
Part of understanding my own needs over the years I've been here, is taking time to understand the needs of others, the challenges they face, and how they overcome them. Cracking of natural handle scales may be an issue to one climate, but not another. Some users might need an easy clean sheath rather than a leather one.
My own habits are based on perceived needs, which in turn are based on comfort. Comfort of carry, comfort of use, and comfort of having what I need, whilst also having the comfort of not carrying stuff I don't. For me it's all about making like easier. I don't overly care what others think of my choices, because social acceptance of my choices is lower down my comfort priorities than it may be for someone else. I sussed that peer pressure was a mugs game in my mid 20s.
Our habits and perceived needs, are as unique as our personalities, even though as members of this forum, we may share some common traits. Even at the UK meet, in the same climate, largely with people of a similar age group, there's a broad difference in perceptions of what their personal needs are perceived to be, and the perception of how best those needs should be met. Several of use use and carry stuff that the others wouldn't carry if you paid them.
-
Fascinating subject
As far as MTs and SAKs go I bought mainly for collection, never for use. So on that front the manufacturers and advertisers fails miserably especially as the vast bulk were also bought used.But my other passion ...Photography has seen me purchase relentless amounts of gear even thought deep down I need none of it really. Just this week I’ve purchased 3 more canon lenses - 2 of which are L lenses. Truth be told they will hardly ever see use...but I wanted them as opposed to needed them.
Same applies to tools. Be it hand tools or power tools. I sold tons of the stuff over the past few years...yet I still can’t budge for the damn things. did I really need them, No. most of it has never seen use .
Advertising is clever stuff orchestrated by clever people. Things will get much much worse soon tho, Amazon and their ilk have been data mining for years, we all now rely on our smartphones. Every search, purchase is duly logged and a very very accurate picture of our unique self is now harvested away. They now know enough about us to know when to tempt us, what time of month we normally buy, where we look.
The future is terrifying.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
