Challenge's.
-
Challenge's.
We do them often here on this forum. A challenge now and then is a god thing as it puts ideas and concepts to the test. I've always liked a challenge now and then, and I've learned from them. Like my dad's peanut challenge.
Dad was a city guy who worked in the government machine in Washington D.C.. He was one of those guys who survived the Great Depression and then went off to fight in WW2. Like millions of other men, like my Uncle Sonny, Uncle Mike, and Uncle Charlie. But unlike them, dad was an under the table guy. He was mixed up with the cloak and dagger types, and after the war was in one of those agencies with all the letters. But aside from that he was a typical suburban dad. Fishing on the weekends, mixed in with some boy scout activities and camping, some shooting with .22's, and hikes in the woods. Of course being residents of Washington D.C. was also a rich cultural environment with all the buildings of the Smithsonian Museum complex, the National Gallery Of Art, and lots go history in all the civil war and Revolutionary war sites in and around the Washington D.C. and surrounding Maryland and Virginia country side. In this environment it wasn't hard to get by with a little pen knife size pocket knife.
The very first knife I ever got was the Camillus scout knife dad gave me when I joined the local boy scout troop. I quickly got use to that knife as a gold standard in my young mind as to what a pocket knife should be. Later when I stated to get infected with the knife nut bug, I branched off and got into the stockman pattern, a Barlow now and then, and SAK's. All in the same or close size of my old scout knife. About 3 1/2 to 3 3/4 inches in closed size.
I always wondered about dad and his little Case peanut. It just seemed too dinky for real world pocket knife duty, and in my young mind totally incapable of handling real emergencies like Russian paratroopers, being marooned in the Alaskan wilderness, or the end of the world. Not that a kid in the greater Washington D.C. suburb had to worry about that stuff. Then I enlisted in the army.
In the army engineers they issued, of all things, a scout knife. The Camillus M-L-K 8 something designation, what everyone called a 'demo' knife. Just an all stainless steel version of a Wenger SI/Victorinox Pioneer. Just cruder in construction, and bit heavier due to the stainless steel scales instead of aluminum. It was natural that it re-enforced my feel for larger scout type knives.
But, once out of the army and into civilian life as a machinist, things stated to change. I noticed most of the older men I worked with were more like my dad in that they all carried a very modest size pocketknife. Old shell handle imperials, one guy an old Wenger patriot with two blades and alox scales in a very flat watch pocket size knife. Then in the 1980's my dad passed away from leukemia. I had his old Colt woodsman and his Case peanut on my dresser in a wooden tray. One day, in a fit of some kind of nostalgia, I dropped his Case peanut in my pocket. I'm not really sure why.
Little by little I started to use it. A cut here and there, opening my mail. It was badly worn by 40 years of service, and with the sentimental value of it, I didn't want to use it too much. I ended up buying one just for an experiment. A challenge, if you will. Over the next few months, I used the new one more and more, and found out that it did indeed handle 99% of my cutting chores. Opening packages, mail, cutting jute twine for the garden out back, whatever. It was my very first challenge when one day, I made my self walk out the door with just the peanut in my pocket. No Buck 301 stockman, no Vic alox pioneer, just the little peanut. Of course I missed having a screw diver and can opener on hand, so I carried my dad's old Sears 4-way keychain screw driver on my keyring and my old army P-38 was in my wallet.
That self imposed challenge cleared the way for my biggest downsize of SAK's.
One day my wife came home from work with a cheap, horrible, abysmal, Chinese knock off of a classic. Her boss had got a bunch of them made up with the company logo on them. I went out and got a real classic for her to show her boss. Mistake realized, her boss returned all the junk fake classics and had real classics with company logo made up. That started my challenge.
For the next few months I watched Karen put that tiny SAK to work, to the point of abuse, torture, and I waited for the thing to just disintegrate into pieces. It didn't happen. Even when she used the SD tipped nail file as a small crowbar. :o So I bought another classic and did my challenge. I walked out the door every morning off to work in the machine shop and did what I had to do. No other SAK in a pocket as stand-by, no bigger knife as backup. Much to my surprise, the classic and I both survived my challenge. The world didn't end, no Russian paratroopers dropped from the sky that needed eliminating while yelling "Wolverines!", and somehow in the wilds of American Suburbia, I just didn't need much more knife or tool. I still had to carry the P-38 in my wallet as the classic was a little limited. So sometimes I carried a recruit or my old Wenger SI to deal with sandwiches or such. I got so attached to the classic that it became my most carried and used EDC pocket knife. My wife likes her burgers cut in half, so I bought her an Opinel number 8 with hearts all over it for Valentines day, and I stopped carrying an extra knife to cut food with.
I found much to my suprise, that aside from kitchen or the woods, I just didn't need that much SAK to get by in modern suburbia. my tinker got carried on fishing trips and my Wenger SI lived in hibernation in my trucks glove box. Then in the early 2000's, my wife showed me how to get on line with a computer and I found knife forums, and blade forums and British blades, and other forums. For a short while, I was doomed as a knife nut that was like a smoldering fire that gasoline was tossed on. Very high octane gasoline.
But a funny thing happened, I got to a saturation point, and started to not get on forums. I went back to the way I was, just the minimal, and my interest waned. Waned a great deal, to where I didn't want all those other knives.It was like waking from some kind of temporary insanity. I reverted to the minimalist my dad was. My little classic on my keyring, maybe sometimes a Leatherman squirt in my pocket and I just went on with life. Sometimes the classic was too small, but I worked around it.
Then came a Chuck Yeager challenge and Nix. I ended up retiring my classic and now the executive is the one SAK/pocket knife I carry. Unlike the classic, the executive can cut Karen's burger in half, slice a pie, cut a fresh baguette into sandwich size slices out in the woods, cut a slice of gouda cheese, and much more. If it wasn't for a challenge, I'd never had been introduced to the executive.
So, challenges are a good thing. It makes us take a sometimes critical step outside our boundaries to experiment. To push our envelopes that are often self imposed on ourselves. And of we learn from it, then we evolve.
Sometimes.
-
Great read cbl51

My eye opener was the fixed blade challenge last year. I realized that if it were not for carry restrictions, a fixie would probably be my EDC.
-
Great yarn chap , as always. I'm still a happy man with my pioneer personally, but thats the joy of SAKs, there's a model for everyone

-
Well worth the read. Thanks for sharing. :)
-
It's true - The challenges are fun and teach you things
I have not done too many here, but I can recall lessonss from a couple.
Even though I am a massive SAK fan and I love their quality and would never carry a CAK - I was always surprised how disparaging and rude everyone here was about the knock offs
I had bought a couple just for research/interest and they seemed OK to me.
So an ***Off Brand Challenge ***came along - So I thought here is a great chance to test one out.
Well all the criticisms were justified. I can't remember everything
The most dramatic was the back spring Phillips bust open the whole knife whilst turning a screw with hardly any pressure/torque
The funniest was the flat screwdriver was too wide to fit the slot on a regular sized screw - Hilarious -
- I don't think those CAKs have seen the light of day since!
Another one was the Skeletool Challenge
I do like the Skeletool, but rarely carry it - I bought it to be my climbing knife due to the caribiner to attach to my climbing harness
Well lessons there just confirmed my bias towards SAKs- One of my main uses for a SAK blade is to cut up food (eg slice apples) - The Skele blade really was not too good at that
And (one of) my most used tools daily is the scissors ... and often the toothpick.....
Say no more ....... SAK wins again!!
-
I've carried a scout-type knife almost continuously since I was about 12. I can't imagine being without one. A traditional is too restricted in applications. Likewise, for me, a 58mm or 65mm on its own. I find the Sportsman, Tourist, and alox Soldier are easy enough carries with much greater utility, and are comfortable to use. A Recruit is on my radar.
That said, I carry a Trailmaster and Swisschamp at work. The TM is a real outdoors workhorse. I like the 111mm saw. Some of the tools on the SC have saved me considerable time and trouble.
-
I'll be doing my first of a few challenges here on MTo in April. I'm going to be a purist, and challenge myself, without any backup tools.
While I can't say that I grew up with an actual scout knife in my hand, I did grow up with the idea of it as the benchmark for a tool that can handle anything. Norman Rockwell created several illustrations of it. I knew that with a simple change in scales from Delrin to Stainless Steel, Camillus was issuing the same knives to both the Boy Scouts and the US military.
In the mid-2000s when I was in the market for a SAK to EDC I was looking at the Spartan Lite if I recall correctly. As is common for just about everything I get, I deliberated for months. When I did go into the store to buy the SAK I saw the Soldier. I saw an identical tool set to the scout knife with nice shiny scales. I bought it without a second's hesitation.
For about a decade I made it my personal challenge to use nothing but the Soldier, as many soldiers and scouts have done. It was my one and only EDC and I fulfilled that challenge. I used the awl where the small blade would have worked, and the can opener where any number of poking and prying objects would have done the trick.
After that approximate ten year period, the need for scissors became progressively more frequent. Once it became "necessary" for work, I caved in and put a Classic on the keyring. Honestly, the scissors weren't strong enough, and I got a Leatherman Micra.
My challenge was over, after a good run for many years.
What that challenge taught me...
I'll never EDC pliers again.
I don't really need a locking blade.
I don't need a file... Ever.
I can get by without the small blade on the SAK, though it's the tool I use the most when I have it.
I don't need a ruler anymore but I know how long 93mm is.I need scissors in town nowadays and like a saw (to save my blade) in the woods
The MTo challenges this year will be fun, and the Soldier challenge will be nostalgic.
But thinking about challenges in general... I think I know what my bare necessities are now, so anything going forward is more of a convenience than a challenge.
-
@Huntsman said:
Even though I am a massive SAK fan and I love their quality and would never carry a CAK -I took an outdoor backpacking survival class years ago. The instructor was using what I thought was a 111mm CAK. Maybe it wasn't, perhaps it was a badly beaten up and discolored SAK. The scales were maroon in color and there was no shield. I wonder if they made them as copies, and if they were good enough for a survival instructor.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
