Running Lean: An Experiment
-
You have certainly dropped a lot of stuff already

Inspired by your challenge I have decided to do something similar. Trying to get by with only 4 MT‘s. After testing a lot of different SAKs and MT’s over the last year, I think I have found what works for me. I will go with the following:
Classic on a neck chain for scissors and the occasional finger nail. Pioneer for the jobs that come up everyday.
For everything that requires a tool neither the Pioneer nor the classic supply, I will reach for the Spirit.
For hard jobs like wood working, renovation (abuse kind of jobs for MT‘s) I will switch out the Spirit for the Swisstool.Those 4 tools should be able to handle everything that comes my way on a regular basis. Will see how that goes

-
@SirVicaLot said:
You have certainly dropped a lot of stuff already
Inspired by your challenge I have decided to do something similar. Trying to get by with only 4 MT‘s. After testing a lot of different SAKs and MT’s over the last year, I think I have found what works for me. I will go with the following:
Classic on a neck chain for scissors and the occasional finger nail. Pioneer for the jobs that come up everyday.
For everything that requires a tool neither the Pioneer nor the classic supply, I will reach for the Spirit.
For hard jobs like wood working, renovation (abuse kind of jobs for MT‘s) I will switch out the Spirit for the Swisstool.Those 4 tools should be able to handle everything that comes my way on a regular basis. Will see how that goes

You should be well covered by those.
The one I have on my neck lanyard is an alox Rambler. Occasionally that's all I have, particularly in summer when pocket space is limited. What duration of time do you intend? -
Don‘t really have a certain duration in mind, as I don‘t want to turn this into a XX Day Challenge. I just want to see if I even try to reach for other MT‘s and why I wanna do it.
Is it because I am missing something, or just because I want to change things up. I can see me grabbing the Explorer for example, because I like playing with the magnifier. But I don‘t think it will turn into my main pocket carry.The Fieldmaster Challenge has showed me which tools I mostly use, and the Pioneer plus classic seemed the logical conclusion. Will see if that will prove true.
-
AW,
I've followed this of and on sense you first posted. I must say a very impressive endevor with equaly impressive results. Before joining MTo I was content with just my Swisstool X and a single PE locking flipper. Then the MTo SAK bug bit and it seamed I "needed" every SAK out there. Fortunately finances kept things somewhat in control. Then I won a Spirt XBS in one of the monthly donation GAWs. (Thanks BOSS) That put all the other SAKs aside and started my Collection of Swisstools and Spirits. I love those tools and have way more than I need and I'm Ok with that and will probaly add more as I come across ones I don't already have. As to my daily carry, well now that most days are spent working in the office I find a Classic/ Rambler/ or Mini Champ, a Compact and a Spirit ALL I need or Desire. Other than an occasional Challenge I realy don't see that changing. I guess I'mgladfortunate to have not been bitten by the MTo bug any harder than I was, your journy seams to have been burdonsome at times. Glad to see you have found your peace.
Now just to stir things up a bit, would you have any interest in trading that beautiful Spirit Rt in the Multitool Snoozers section?
Go ahead!
I deserve it!

-
You asked for it:

You‘re welcome :D
-

NOT YOU!
Only AW!
But seeing you popped up first.
Those tools should do just about anything you're likely to run into on any given day, SVL.
I've just realy become fond of my Compact with it's full sized traditional Vic scissors.
It's also amazing how often the eye glass driver and straight pin come in handy. -
Well, AW can give you a
too, I was just lending a hand :DI tried the Compact, but it has too much stuff missing. It is just not working for me

-
@Douglas said:
AW,
I've followed this of and on sense you first posted. I must say a very impressive endevor with equaly impressive results. Before joining MTo I was content with just my Swisstool X and a single PE locking flipper. Then the MTo SAK bug bit and it seamed I "needed" every SAK out there. Fortunately finances kept things somewhat in control. Then I won a Spirt XBS in one of the monthly donation GAWs. (Thanks BOSS) That put all the other SAKs aside and started my Collection of Swisstools and Spirits. I love those tools and have way more than I need and I'm Ok with that and will probaly add more as I come across ones I don't already have. As to my daily carry, well now that most days are spent working in the office I find a Classic/ Rambler/ or Mini Champ, a Compact and a Spirit ALL I need or Desire. Other than an occasional Challenge I realy don't see that changing. I guess I'mgladfortunate to have not been bitten by the MTo bug any harder than I was, your journy seams to have been burdonsome at times. Glad to see you have found your peace.
Now just to stir things up a bit, would you have any interest in trading that beautiful Spirit Rt in the Multitool Snoozers section?
Go ahead!
I deserve it!

Several people have tried to get me to part with the RT. All have failed :D
My journey only really became burdonsome, once I had ticked all the boxes I needed to tick. For several years, it was an adventure, a quest for the best tools for me. Once I realised I had all I needed, I was also saddled with a vast amount of stuff I didn't need. I gradually sold of most of it, but all the stuff I've recently been wrestling with, was stuff that worked for me. Why on earth would I want to sell that, after a long quest to discover it or build it? Yet I was still overwhelmed with it all. This segregation to Users and Snoozers, is quite liberating from all the negativity it had started to cultivate.
I'm sure I will need to delve into that box in future. I have lost tools, had them stolen, and broke them or worn them out. I'd rather have some tried and tested tools in the box to fall back on, rather than have to restart the test based on whatever happens to be available at the time. Not only would I not be likely to get an RT again, I'd struggle for a good condition Sideclip, KF4, blunt nose integral cutter MP600, MP400 with corkscrew, all my 84mm Vics with scissors, and so on, and so on. I wish I'd added a spare Wings Slipit to the fold a few years ago. There's not really anything else like that on the market right now. Maybe other tools will go the same way.
So now, I am unburdoned and future proof (to an extent). Liberated yet secure. I might not have backups of every tool, but do have back ups for every role, and I don't need to worry what tools might be available in 15 year's time.
-
@SirVicaLot said:
Well, AW can give you a
too, I was just lending a hand :DI tried the Compact, but it has too much stuff missing. It is just not working for me

What's your minimum requirement of a Swiss knife? I have a Compact in a first aid kit, and think it's a great knife. My minimum requirement, is generally "Climber" like. Blade, scissors, openers, drivers, awl. While the driver compliment is compromised, there's only really the awl that's missing on the Compact, and I can fudge it with the fixed arm of the scissors if I'm desperate.
-
That's a heck of a clear out, but at least it has solid logic behind it

-
"I know there should be another 6 months to go, but I had a revelation last night. I was thinking how much happier I've been during the course of this experiment, and realised that it isn't just going to lead to a solution to my frustrations, it IS the solution. I wasn't getting annoyed with owning stuff that wasn't getting used, but with SEEING it all every time I wanted to change something. Stuffing the rest of the stuff out of sight, and just keeping regular carry in a drawer, gives the scale of array I want, without having to sell off tools I'd really rather not part with."
It all made sense when you posted the above sentiment. There is a balance for those of us who have amassed a lot of really good tools. After looking thru what you've decided on and why
. I do think you'll be quite happy as would anyone. Theres are lot of capability and diversity. -
Cheers Mark.
I think the quantity of tools I've left out, is about on a par with what I had before I joined MTO, except they're far better suited to me. -
@Aloha said:
"I know there should be another 6 months to go, but I had a revelation last night. I was thinking how much happier I've been during the course of this experiment, and realised that it isn't just going to lead to a solution to my frustrations, it IS the solution. I wasn't getting annoyed with owning stuff that wasn't getting used, but with SEEING it all every time I wanted to change something. Stuffing the rest of the stuff out of sight, and just keeping regular carry in a drawer, gives the scale of array I want, without having to sell off tools I'd really rather not part with."It all made sense when you posted the above sentiment. There is a balance for those of us who have amassed a lot of really good tools. After looking thru what you've decided on and why
. I do think you'll be quite happy as would anyone. Theres are lot of capability and diversity.Thanks mate

Yes, this was all about finding the right balance of tools - enough to stop me wanting more, but not too much as to feel swamped. Capability wise, they are all tried and tested, and I know they suit me well. The diversity feels right too, and doesn't leave me hemmed in to one particular kind of load out. I can grab any one item, and build a combo around it, or just grab either the Balance or the Deluxe Tinker as solo tools.
Thanks for following along through this process

-
@AimlessWanderer said:
What's your minimum requirement of a Swiss knife? I have a Compact in a first aid kit, and think it's a great knife. My minimum requirement, is generally "Climber" like. Blade, scissors, openers, drivers, awl. While the driver compliment is compromised, there's only really the awl that's missing on the Compact, and I can fudge it with the fixed arm of the scissors if I'm desperate.Inline Awl, Bottle Opener (as sturdy as possible because i use it mainly as a prybar/scraper), Philips driver, Large blade, Scissors. As of today, there is only one SAK that checks all these boxes, and that is the PX. Yet I don‘t like the scissors on the PX, because they are mounted the wrong way compared to the 91mm line.
This is why I chose Pioneer plus classic with the added bonus of a nail file. -
Pioneer plus Classic is a strong pairing. Whenever I chose a scissorless SAK I always paired it with a 58mm. This combo eventually led me to the Manager.
-
Your journey is one that I enjoyed. I know others do not put this much effort into their carries but I do so
. The conversations with a thread like this also help me with those SAKs that are distracting me :D. I don't have to cover all bases but I want to be happy with what I carry. Fact is tho, with the right combination and experience with that combination and we are pretty well covered in most all situations. -
@Aloha said:
Your journey is one that I enjoyed. I know others do not put this much effort into their carries but I do so
. The conversations with a thread like this also help me with those SAKs that are distracting me :D. I don't have to cover all bases but I want to be happy with what I carry.We do have a lot of similarities in our approach, and both have a desire to "get it right", whatever right happens to be based on the priorities at the time.
Distractions is right too, particularly when they are agonisingly close to fitting our needs. They can draw brain power trying to figure out how to accommodate and compensate for the elements that don't align how we want, and attention is drawn away from something else that already works perfectly fine. I think (hope) this reduced array is free of all that.@Aloha said:
Fact is tho, with the right combination and experience with that combination and we are pretty well covered in most all situations.Did your brain just fail, or mine?

-
@SirVicaLot said:
Inline Awl, Bottle Opener (as sturdy as possible because i use it mainly as a prybar/scraper), Philips driver, Large blade, Scissors. As of today, there is only one SAK that checks all these boxes, and that is the PX. Yet I don‘t like the scissors on the PX, because they are mounted the wrong way compared to the 91mm line.
This is why I chose Pioneer plus classic with the added bonus of a nail file.

-
MINE BRAIN FALIED 
What I meant to say was, With those combinations ( of tools left out ) and experience with them, you can tackle most anything.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login