Running Lean: An Experiment
-
@Aloha said:
Your journey is one that I enjoyed. I know others do not put this much effort into their carries but I do so
. The conversations with a thread like this also help me with those SAKs that are distracting me :D. I don't have to cover all bases but I want to be happy with what I carry.We do have a lot of similarities in our approach, and both have a desire to "get it right", whatever right happens to be based on the priorities at the time.
Distractions is right too, particularly when they are agonisingly close to fitting our needs. They can draw brain power trying to figure out how to accommodate and compensate for the elements that don't align how we want, and attention is drawn away from something else that already works perfectly fine. I think (hope) this reduced array is free of all that.@Aloha said:
Fact is tho, with the right combination and experience with that combination and we are pretty well covered in most all situations.Did your brain just fail, or mine?

-
@SirVicaLot said:
Inline Awl, Bottle Opener (as sturdy as possible because i use it mainly as a prybar/scraper), Philips driver, Large blade, Scissors. As of today, there is only one SAK that checks all these boxes, and that is the PX. Yet I don‘t like the scissors on the PX, because they are mounted the wrong way compared to the 91mm line.
This is why I chose Pioneer plus classic with the added bonus of a nail file.

-
MINE BRAIN FALIED 
What I meant to say was, With those combinations ( of tools left out ) and experience with them, you can tackle most anything.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
All my available to use pocket carry tools, now fit comfortably in one drawer, along with a few matching accessories - the tool adaptor for the Switchplier, Victorinox L wrench, bit adaptor and bits for the Fuse, a clip lanyard, and a small pair of nail clippers.
Not just an idiot photographer, but an idiot typist too 
That should have said tool adaptor for the Sideclip ::)
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
This experiment is now over!I know there should be another 6 months to go, but I had a revelation last night. I was thinking how much happier I've been during the course of this experiment, and realised that it isn't just going to lead to a solution to my frustrations, it*** IS*** the solution. I wasn't getting annoyed with owning stuff that wasn't getting used, but with SEEING it all every time I wanted to change something. Stuffing the rest of the stuff out of sight, and just keeping regular carry in a drawer, gives the scale of array I want, without having to sell off tools I'd really rather not part with.
The thing that had been holding me back from selling stuff, is knowing it will likely be at a loss, and knowing it would be both pricey and difficult to source them again, should I need to replace any of the items I leave out. Each of the items that I was undecided about, have proven themselves to be great in use, and well suited to me. I just had too many items available in each role. I'll be opening the box again today, sorting through everything, and refining what stays confined to the box out of sight, and what remains in the open for use. The rest will be shut away in the box until I break or lose something, and need to fish out a replacement.
The first thing I'm going to change, is all carbon steel stays out. That way I can keep them maintained. Shutting stainless "spares" away for 5-10 years or whatever, should be far less risky. The second thing that stays out, is anything that's already been used heavily, or items that had 6 months or more of near exclusive carry. That includes a few slippies from the early days. On top of this, I'll leave out a few options so that whatever crops up in life, I have a suitable option in the drawer, and spares in the box.
Tools that neither get chosen to be left out, nor are direct spares for that role, probably need ditching (selling, giving away, or breaking for spares). Exemptions are thing I might need on very rare occasions, such as the marlinspike on a British Army Knife. Stuff like that will go in the toolbag with hammers and screwdrivers and stuff - away from the regular carry drawer, but still available if needed. All that leaves then, is mod fodder. These can be put in yet another box for tinkering with at my leisure.
I'll update with the new line up once it's sorted

Its amazing how that seems to have hit you like a ton of bricks.
I think I'm in the same boat as you.
I start amassing tools for use, and there's quite a bit of thought behind what I get. It's true - once you tik all the boxes, it becomes worse. It's rather irritating to have to look at tools that you thought you'd use, but don't. It becomes a reminder of spent mental energy. I find that when several boxes are checked off, there's one new one that comes up.
Last May, I gave away, sold, or junked several of my tools. Just three months ago, I gave away my Vic Huntsman. The Huntsman is the one that meets all the criteria for what I need and use. It did, however, had one glaring feature that none of my main users had - it didn't fit in my watch pocket. The more you try to get things right, no more you're going to get yourself frustrated. And as someone on another thread said: "I don't want the perfect multi-tool".
Seeing a giant box full of my "not-quite-right-anymore" or "that-was-before-they-invented" tools was indeed frustrating.
I think you've hit the nail on the head - it gets to the root of our existential crisis. Separating the ones you won't use out helps quite a bit. Whether you're comfortable selling them is another story. Suffice it to say I was content with throwing a few unsafe liner-locking ones in the trash.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I think you've hit the nail on the head - it gets to the root of our existential crisis. Separating the ones you won't use out helps quite a bit. Whether you're comfortable selling them is another story. Suffice it to say I was content with throwing a few unsafe liner-locking ones in the trash.For the most part, I'd already got rid of the ones I won't use well before this thread begun, and simply had too many good options left. Just look how few were losers, and some of them have moved to the mod fodder box. I'd invested time, money and energy into modding tools to knifeless for example, and ended up with seven of them! I don't need seven, but each one was "too good to part with". I had a great swathe of traditional knives that worked for me, and a good clump of non-locking clipped one hand opening folders too. It wasn't that I had tools I wouldn't use, rather too many that I would.
The other thing was that I'd had fun doing those mods, both in the preparation and the modifications themselves. I'd also enjoyed using the fruits of my labours. That makes parting with them harder too. The Swiss knives are the same. A lot of effort and beer vouchers went into putting everything together, either as tools that already work for me, or as ingredients for mods. Undoing all that effort, wasn't a palatable solution either.
Turns out that sorting them into "now" and "later" was the answer, and as you said, it hit me like a ton of bricks once I finally got there. Once i'd gotten that concept in mind, the tools almost sorted themselves.
-
Combos are king!
Picking the right individual tools, wasn't enough by itself. Those tools have to work well with others. While I have reduced the number of tools in play, combinations are not something I am short of. Here's an overview of the combinations I have left myself. Obviously tools can be combined in other ways too, but these are the main configurations.
-
Keyring - unchanged
-
Neck lanyard - unchanged
-
Wenger Evowood 14 and companions
-
Wenger stainless PTC and companions
-
Gerber Splice and any traditional slippie
-
Gerber Balance and any traditional slippie
-
Leatherman Sideclip and any Swiss knife




-
-
More combinations:
8 ) Spirit X and Voyager Lite
- Modern clipped OHO slippie and Balance
The modern slippies can also compliment any of the other traditional slipjoint or Swiss knife combinations. The two primary lights are the same. A well used 4Sevens Quark AA2 Tactical, and the infinitely variable Sunwayman V10R.
- Fully loaded. When a very comprehensive carry is wanted, the orange tools come out to play. There's also a bit adaptor set for the Fuse which isn't included in the picture




-
Nice combinations AI. The orange set is awesome!
Enviado de meu moto g(6) usando o Tapatalk
-
Sounds like you have it figures out Al

-
Yeah that orange kit is great. HiVis is the way to go out doors. I love camo just as much as the next but not for outdoor stuff. I've actually changed out a lot of my lanyards to bright green and orange on everything.
-
Cheers fellers.
I seem to be a lot more eager to swap stuff around, but that might be just having access to stuff that's been locked away for 6 months. I expect that to settle down soon. However, when I do open the drawer to swap something, I'm no longer frustrated or angered with the excess, which is the main thing. 
In the last 10 years, I've had two slippie backsprings crap out on me (Byrd Firebyrd, and CRKT Li'l Guppie), two pliers tool crap out on me irreparably, (MP700s), and the scissors on the Style PS broke so often, I'm sick of sending them back. I've also lost (or had stolen) a few things too. As such, I genuinely don't mind having a box full of spare tools stashed away, which are already proven and tweaked to my needs.
-
@Aloha said:
Yeah that orange kit is great. HiVis is the way to go out doors. I love camo just as much as the next but not for outdoor stuff. I've actually changed out a lot of my lanyards to bright green and orange on everything.It can be useful indoors too. A cursory glance will quickly spot any tools you've put down and forgotten about because you were focussed on the task at hand. The engine bay on the boat was an easy place to lose tools, as can helping someone whose moving house, and it might be several months later before they ask "is this yours?". It can also be useful, when you get a glimpse of orange in the corner of your eye, for spotting somebody using something without your permission - especially when they're about to MISuse it.

-
Pockets! It all comes down to pockets!
When I was working, having trouser pockets crammed with stuff, was normal and essential. Now that I don't work, I don't have the tolerance for carrying around all that crap. Pockets are still dictating my carry though.
My trouser pockets (these days) carry much less, and hardly ever see a plier tool. Also the type of pocket has an influence too.
Some folks always wear the same type of stuff. They're always in jeans OR cargo/hiking type trousers OR slacks/chino or whatever. I don't. Throughout the course of a week, the type of clothing I wear will change, as will they type of pocket, and how likely stuff is to fall out. No reason, other than I like to vary what I wear. Some trousers will "keep" a traditional knife better than others, and some are more prone to vomiting it out to be lost forever in the lining of the sofa/armchair or under the seat in the bus or taxi.
I've been unconsciously compensating for this for a while, but it's now coming into awareness. The Deluxe Tinker is carried on a lanyard that clips to a belt loop, as does the Splice/light/pen combo. I automatically reach for those on the less retentive pockets. If I'm wearing jeans for example, I'm less likely to have tied tools.
Also, pliers tools only get reached for if other pockets are available. I've been wearing a bodywarmer around the house over the last few days (what some of you might call a padded vest, or quilted vest maybe). That thing has pockets galore, and what goes in there, stays there. That's made carrying the Gerber Balance or the Fuse very comfortable, and other carry falls in automatically around that.
Usage and situation dictated my carry needs in the past, but now it's mainly sartorial. Neck lanyard where pockets are sparse, tied on lanyard when pockets can't be trusted, clipped knife where pockets are deep/tight, and all pocket carry chosen to compliment whatever happens to be being carried (or not) in the jacket, bag, bodywarmer, fleece or waistcoat.
That must have all been rattling round in the back of my mind, when I was selecting my reduced carry options. There's nothing in the wardrobe that doesn't have a suitable carry option, and all the stuff I've left out is carryable in everyday clothes.
It's also gone a long way to stop me feeling overwhelmed with choice, as while the drawer still has a wide array of options, there's only a few which are sensible for whatever I'm wrapped up in on any given day.

-
I've been thinking about this lately myself. Since I have been carrying a 3 layer SAK after having been used to a 2 layer... I notice it. Especially when I wear slacks. I've gone as far as to order one of those suspension clips to hang it from the inside of my pocket, if the SAK isnt in a watch pocket.
I pocket carried a Wave for a couple of years back in the day ... times change.
-
I typically wear jeans when off and cargo 5.11 type pants at work. I rarely if ever wear slacks or suits. Pocket space if a premium in my jeans so I love to utilize the 5th ( coin/watch ) pocket. No medium sized plier tool for me when off. I prefer the Squirt for my plier when off. I also love to utilize my belt to carry stuff. I like the Victorinox belt hanger for my wallet and keys. This way they dont plop in the bottom of my pocket.
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
Pockets! It all comes down to pockets!I know the feeling. Left to my own devices, I generally wear cargo pants or cargo shorts with 6-8 pockets. I refuse to carry a murse, man bag, backpack, etc. unless I'm actually hiking. I also rarely wear a jacket, vest, or shirt with pockets, so I'm generally limited to what I can get in the pants pockets. On the rare occasion that I have to wear dress slacks or a suit (or when I used to have a job that required me to wear the company-issued jeans), I definitely feel (felt) constrained in my carry.
-
@nate j said:
I know the feeling. Left to my own devices, I generally wear cargo pants or cargo shorts with 6-8 pockets. I refuse to carry a murse, man bag, backpack, etc. unless I'm actually hiking. I also rarely wear a jacket, vest, or shirt with pockets, so I'm generally limited to what I can get in the pants pockets. On the rare occasion that I have to wear dress slacks or a suit (or when I used to have a job that required me to wear the company-issued jeans), I definitely feel (felt) constrained in my carry.Yup, sounds familiar. Before things changed, trouser pockets were the only option. On the boat, or working round heavy machinery, the jacket was off, and I was moving around over too large an area for a bag to be helpful. Belt carry was a serious entanglement risk too, so that was out. If I couldn't carry it in my trouser pockets, it essentially didn't exist.
Now I'm more sedate, a jacket/top of some description is more "helpful" in this respect, in cooler temperatures. I'm not dashing around over a wide area either, so even if I've taken the jacket off, it's close by.
Belt carry is still something I'm uncomfortable with for several reasons.
-
It bumps and snags on stuff, especially as I don't always walk in the direction I'm aiming for ::)
-
It advertises something is being carried, and can raise questions/unwelcome attention
-
Everything falling off the belt when you go to the loo. I HATE that!
-
I'm not as streamlined as I used to be, and it can dig in.

Light pocket carry, supplemented by (optional) carry elsewhere, seems to suit where life currently has be sited.
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login