Your Favorite Traditional Pattern
-
Does the sodbuster is a pattern or is part of another?
-
@CAMPBELL03 said:
Does the sodbuster is a pattern or is part of another?Yes and no. Technically, it is considered a "Clasp Knife"; though Sodbuster is a term actually trademarked by Case. You'll see lots of generic versions to get around this. Rough Rider calls theirs the "Work Knife", Maserin "The Plow, Boker the "Range Buster" and so on.
-
Hands dówn it's a whittler, for me.
-
@CAMPBELL03 said:
Does the sodbuster is a pattern or is part of another?Interesting question. Certainly one of the challenges with something like this is that some of the terminology is a bit vague, everyone doesn't necessarily agree on standard definitions, and some terms can refer to a specific subset of knives that also fall under one of the broader definitions (for example, all barlows are technically jack knives, but not all jack knives are barlows).
At one time I would certainly have considered sodbuster a pattern, though as Cody helpfully and correctly points out, the term Sodbuster has now been trademarked by Case (which muddies the waters a bit IMO)...
@cody6268 said:
Yes and no. Technically, it is considered a "Clasp Knife"; though Sodbuster is a term actually trademarked by Case. You'll see lots of generic versions to get around this. Rough Rider calls theirs the "Work Knife", Maserin "The Plow, Boker the "Range Buster" and so on.What is your definition of "Clasp Knife"? I might say a sodbuster is a type of jack knife.
-
I am very much a newbie when it comes to defining patterns. I had a look at another site to try to determine what patterns I like. I guess Jack is the group (?) I like and within that group are lots of patterns?
Moose, Barlow, Trapper, Canoe, Congress, Toothpick, and I'm sure more. Which is my favorite is not possible to determine at this time. I also like ones with cap or can opener, awl, and blade, Scout?
-
I picked the stockman.
I like having three blades to choose from.
-
@Aloha said:
I am very much a newbie when it comes to defining patterns. I had a look at another site to try to determine what patterns I like. I guess Jack is the group (?) I like and within that group are lots of patterns?Moose, Barlow, Trapper, Canoe, Congress, Toothpick, and I'm sure more. Which is my favorite is not possible to determine at this time. I also like ones with cap or can opener, awl, and blade, Scout?
I had to look up the patterns as well
It's hard to tell because it seems that size plays into the patterns - particularly in the larger blade. Hence my confusion with the Canoe vs Pen.
One think I do know is - yes, the blade, openers, and awl is a Scout pattern.If you asked me this question 18-ish years ago when I was actually "into" traditional knives, I'd probably have said a Canoe - two blades, one of them a pen, and the other a good three-inch blade sturdy enough to make feathersticks.
-
I am realizing that a little larger blade is what I like. Funny thing is, on my SAK I don't really feel like I "need" the smaller blade on my 91mm or 84mm. On my Trad while I like a single blade I also really like then with two
. -
@nate j said:
What is your definition of "Clasp Knife"? I might say a sodbuster is a type of jack knife.I would agree that "jack" would be more specific than "clasp". A clasp knife is any knife that has a blade that folds into a slot into the handle. So, any knife in the poll can be considered a clasp knife.
Some may argue that "jack knife" has the same definition but, in my experience, the accepted definition of "jack knife" is a folding knife that has a hinge on only one end of the knife. Therefore, it is slightly more specific, and wouldn't describe all patterns in the poll.
-
@NutSAK said:
I would agree that "jack" would be more specific than "clasp". A clasp knife is any knife that has a blade that folds into a slot into the handle. So, any knife in the poll can be considered a clasp knife.Some may argue that "jack knife" has the same definition but, in my experience, the accepted definition of "jack knife" is a folding knife that has a hinge on only one end of the knife. Therefore, it is slightly more specific, and wouldn't describe all patterns in the poll.

-
I am the one one who went peanut, because of my long history of my dad and his Case peanut. I carried a peanut for several years and it was most often my sole EDC and did well in the American Suburbia environment. I only abandoned the Case peanut when age and some arthritis in my hands made it difficult to deal with a small stiffly sprung slip joint with jerky hand stops.
My EDC knife these days is the Victorinox executive, which is a peanut size knife, but with a few 'extras' tossed in. A 2 inch blade is all I need on my lifestyle.
-
So few voters/trad users :(
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
So few voters/trad users :(I voted!
I went with pen after days of deliberation.
I have a pen and a stockman as a shelf queen, and I bought a pen and lost it. I'd have bought a canoe years ago (if I had seen one I could afford), but that canoe sailed long ago when I bought a traditional-ish jack. I like em all but pen is my favorite. Now if you asked me what traditional would I get if I could only have one for the rest of my life - a canoe where the large blade has a long pull, and a swedge.
-
Voted Jack but
. These polls sure are difficult. -
I also voted Jack and

-
@AimlessWanderer said:
So fewvoters/trad users :(Quite sad really ;)
-
More for us
. I do hope those who enjoy the looks would try one. I was a little reluctant however early one I did buy a Buck 3 blade and the CRKT Toothpick. I carried both infrequent but enjoyed them, if than makes sense. Later as I began to desire something I picked up my Buck Creek and my interest did spark again. Off and on I carried a trad but maybe its because SAKs seem to make a little more sense for some
.Now that I have a few more I can say for my uses that a Trad is just a fun knife to have. I enjoy very much carrying one and while I am still very much limited in my knowledge I will pick up several more. A Trad and a SAK pair wonderfully BTW
. -
I think the only Swiss knife I'd carry with a traditional pocket knife, would be keyring sized (65mm max), and then paired with something similar in size to a Soddie Jr (almost any of my single bladed trads would do the job). A larger Swissie, or a smaller trad, would feel a little too much like duplication to me.

-
@Aloha said:
Off and on I carried a trad but maybe its because SAKs seem to make a little more sense for some
.That's what ultimately did in the whole traditional knife thing for me, the sheer utility of the SAK. I stopped carrying my beloved Buck 301 and 303 just because the same size in a small tinker or recruit game me so much wider mission capability. Had two cutting blades, plus tools for flat and Phillips screw driving, can opener that did double duty for staple removing, pot hooking, and many other jobs. Flat screw driver pried off lid of plastic wood can or putty, and then did duty as putty knife filling a hole.
Finally I saw the knife as just a knife. A one trick pony.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
