Knife Snobs?
-
I've got a Knife-snob streak in me. However, over several decades of knife use, I've come to the conclusion that knife snobbery is completely unwarranted.
Most days my fancy knives stay at home and it's a SAK that is carried. SAK's are too useful to not carry one. And that usually makes a secondary knife redundant. So, the default pocket knife is the ubiquitous SAK. Appropriately so, says I.
-
The blade steel snobbery is why I cannot stand most of the knife reviewers on youtube.
There are only two guys (Nick Shabazz and Pete from Cedric & Ada Outdoors) that I can think of offhand that enjoy talking about, testing, and reviewing all sorts of both humble and insanely nice knives and yet still carry a SAK around the house. For all his high-end knives Nick still carries a Cadet at home and Pete uses a Skeletool CX or SAK on a regular basis for house chores. Heck, Nick has a custom Vic Classic with his name on it from BladeHQ.
It is my humble opinion that this means it is these basic, no frills knives that are their true day to day workhorses and that this is also the truth for many other "knife guys". They just don't want to admit it to themselves.
The SAK is a humble, no non-sense tool that will always perform as it was designed to do, which is why I love it.
-Wes.
-
@Wessaen said:
The blade steel snobbery is why I cannot stand most of the knife reviewers on youtube.-Wes.
I have to agree there, in my possibly unpopular opinion. I'd bet that most people wouldn't be able to guess the type of blade steel the way a sommelier can guess an expensive vs a cheap wine. Any steel with a "name" to it is going to be good enough. It will cut. Nobody is cutting up things for hours to the point that they dull the blade to uselessness - and if they are they shouldn't be. What do people cut anyway? One of the more dulling tasks I can think of is stripping wire - in which case, use a wire stripper. Do these folks put the same thought into the steel in the razor they shave with? Yup snobbery in my estimation.
That said, one of the nice things about Victorinox is that they use different steels for different tools, They make calculated decisions about what steel they use. They could use "premium steel" but they choose not to.
Similar to Leatherman's choice in ferro rod on the signal - they made a conscious decision to use a softer ferro rod which - at that size - will throw a better spark but wear away faster. The idea is - if you are in the unlikely situation where you are using your Signal ferro rod - you have ONE shot to make a fire because you're in dire straits. If you make it home alive, lucky you - you can buy a replacement. You were never meant to make a years worth of campfires with your signal, like you were never meant to not sharpen your SAK ever.
While I'm on my rant - I think that's a problem we have in general nowadays. We forget that some decisions are made for us with some high level thought behind it, and we criticize it without realizing why it is so. I was reading in the news yesterday. A company stopped doing XYZ. The headline says that Company is not doing XYZ any more! Comments galore of how bad the Company is. I even talked to people today about it - everyone's up in arms... how can the company do that and make it harder to get their product?. Not one person realizes that the reason the company stopped doing XYZ is that due to complex regulatory issues, if Company does ABC instead, then their product is more easily obtained. Just need to wait for ABC to get underway. But 99% of people don't know the complex regulatory stuff, and they just criticize the company. Sometimes one needs to step back and not mess with the universe.
Sorry - rant over.

-
@ElevenBlade said:
While I'm on my rant - I think that's a problem we have in general nowadays. We forget that some decisions are made for us with some high level thought behind it, and we criticize it without realizing why it is so. I was reading in the news yesterday. A company stopped doing XYZ. The headline says that Company is not doing XYZ any more! Comments galore of how bad the Company is. I even talked to people today about it - everyone's up in arms... how can the company do that and make it harder to get their product?. Not one person realizes that the reason the company stopped doing XYZ is that due to complex regulatory issues, if Company does ABC instead, then their product is more easily obtained. Just need to wait for ABC to get underway. But 99% of people don't know the complex regulatory stuff, and they just criticize the company. Sometimes one needs to step back and not mess with the universe.In general I agree with you but for many of the larger corporations these days it is often the board or the bean counters that make the choice to use different (less expensive) materials that the engineers/designers then have to try and make the best use of. I'm sure the Gerber Armbar back-spring is a victim of this as it is a glaring issue I'm willing to bet that the engineers saw early in the design process but were not able to fix. I would have paid another $5-10 if the spring worked correctly.
If I buy something I want it to last and because of that I often try to track down an older version of an item that was produced before cost cutting changed the basic design. For all the bad vibes surrounding Kickstarter I have been able to back several original designs that were implemented before anyone other than the original creator got to it. The creator's profit margin might not have been as high as it could have otherwise been but my item is usually better off for it.
I want companies like Gerber(and SOG I guess, but they are reportedly revamping their tool lines this year) to survive, but they have to raise their standards a bit more if they want my money.
-Wes.
-
I think part of those discrimination may come from a critical view on SAK steel. Many hold the view that it is 'cheap' steel so it's not worth carrying.
But think about those folks a hundred years ago, where their lives do rely on knives, they all get by just fine with whatever steel they had. And I seriously doubt most modern knife enthusiast will use their knives as hard and as much as those folks back then, so isn't it silly now to think that we all need super steel in order to survive.
Don't get me wrong, as a knife enthusiast, I too enjoy the benefits from these new super steels. But to argue non super steel is inferior is like arguing the world only needs Ferrari, yet Toyota/GE/VW are some of the biggest names in the world.
-
@Wessaen said:
The blade steel snobbery is why I cannot stand most of the knife reviewers on youtube.There are only two guys (Nick Shabazz and Pete from Cedric & Ada Outdoors) that I can think of offhand that enjoy talking about, testing, and reviewing all sorts of both humble and insanely nice knives and yet still carry a SAK around the house. For all his high-end knives Nick still carries a Cadet at home and Pete uses a Skeletool CX or SAK on a regular basis for house chores. Heck, Nick has a custom Vic Classic with his name on it from BladeHQ.
It is my humble opinion that this means it is these basic, no frills knives that are their true day to day workhorses and that this is also the truth for many other "knife guys". They just don't want to admit it to themselves.
The SAK is a humble, no non-sense tool that will always perform as it was designed to do, which is why I love it.
-Wes.
Can't agree more with what you said, Wes.
In terms of nit picking, I think Shabazz may still have decent value as a reviewer. And originally I have some respect for Cedric & Ada Outdoor channel for putting in all the hard work of cut testing, though it is often eccentric and Dean(IIRC) criticize the testing method is hardly uniform and fair, however, since his "Knife Company Tier List (Best to Worst) 2020" video came out, that respect just drop down to zero.
I don't know he was doing it just because those companies gave him knives or rebate, but ranking companies based on how novelty they are is just silly. So Cold steel is a 'top tier' knife company, two levels higher than CRK and Victorinox, because they make javelin and shovel? ::)
-
Good points on both sides ELEVENBLADE and WESSAEN
.Theres status with owning certain knives within the knife community. Its the same with most any hobby. I enjoy reviews of knives most part. Knife people all pretty much relate up until brands come into play, at least from my observations
. I don't think it is about money. If certain knives were "affordable" to you would you buy them? I cannot see myself owning certain knives. There are some that just don't appeal to me aesthetically. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, yes/no?I've wondered if it's something to do with after a purchase of a certain item, justifying the price paid? Is the price paid somehow tied into perceived performance/value/quality? Is it the mentality that after the purchase one simply cannot say they don't like it or it was hype?
We all need our knives to cut. Aside from that what else should a knife do?
A SAK as said is an honest knife. It does what its creator created it to do. Its 91mm and 58mm ( in my case ) of solutions to everyday real life stuff. Yes my blades cut stuff too.
-
I'll deviate here a bit.
Vic steel is a good steel. I value it mostly for its rust resistance. It is a nearly 'worry free' steel. After that, it find it to be a 'good enough steel'. It doesn't hold an edge nearly as well as some premium knife steels.
That's OK. I keep a sharpening stone handy and can touch up a Vic if needed. I enjoy sharpening.
Still, I really enjoy sharpening and using 154CM steel knives. High-carbon steel knives are a joy to sharpen and use.
In the kitchen, I have a Vic knife that performs well. I think the steel in their kitchen line is different from that used in their SAK line. But...even that is not as nice as my High Carbon or German steel knives.
I think there is a place for high-end steel knives. I agree that most users will never really take advantage of the benefits of Elmax or S90V. However, that doesn't mean the difference isn't noticeable. It is.
As previously stated, a SAK is my EDC of choice. It works and works well. I think anyone who 'looks down' on a SAK doesn't understand the real world use of pocket knives. But I still love my S30V knives and will likely always have one.
-
I get some pushback on other forums about this. Apparently if it's not a $300+ knife, it's just a toy. Go figure. I've been using my Case and Schrade knives and been quite happy with them. I actually really appreciate some of the cheaper Chinese knives, which are leaps and bounds better than stuff from even just a few years ago. I'm going to use something I like, and if it's inexpensive all the better. I can't see spending $300 on a knife. I'd rather buy several knives and multitools and work out which ones I like best, for what specific purpose. I think a lot of it is, they spent way too much money on a knife, and now need to justify it to themselves. Otherwise they'd realize that perhaps it wasn't as useful as they had hoped. That's my take tho.
Charles.
-
As for holding the edge, I carry a sharpener on my key chain. I am quite sure I'll be cutting far longer than most people with their super steels... :D
-
@Aloha said:
Good points on both sides ELEVENBLADE and WESSAEN
.Theres status with owning certain knives within the knife community. Its the same with most any hobby. I enjoy reviews of knives most part. Knife people all pretty much relate up until brands come into play, at least from my observations
. I don't think it is about money. If certain knives were "affordable" to you would you buy them? I cannot see myself owning certain knives. There are some that just don't appeal to me aesthetically. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, yes/no?**I've wondered if it's something to do with after a purchase of a certain item, justifying the price paid? Is the price paid somehow tied into perceived performance/value/quality? Is it the mentality that after the purchase one simply cannot say they don't like it or it was hype? **
We all need our knives to cut. Aside from that what else should a knife do?
A SAK as said is an honest knife. It does what its creator created it to do. Its 91mm and 58mm ( in my case ) of solutions to everyday real life stuff. Yes my blades cut stuff too.
This!
there are many studies that identify factors that change the perception of value - some of those are: brand loyalty, price paid, rarity, who else has the product.
-
@Nix said:
I'll deviate here a bit.Vic steel is a good steel. I value it mostly for its rust resistance. It is a nearly 'worry free' steel. After that, it find it to be a 'good enough steel'. It doesn't hold an edge nearly as well as some premium knife steels.
That's OK. I keep a sharpening stone handy and can touch up a Vic if needed. I enjoy sharpening.
Still, I really enjoy sharpening and using 154CM steel knives. High-carbon steel knives are a joy to sharpen and use.
In the kitchen, I have a Vic knife that performs well. I think the steel in their kitchen line is different from that used in their SAK line. But...even that is not as nice as my High Carbon or German steel knives.
I think there is a place for high-end steel knives. I agree that most users will never really take advantage of the benefits of Elmax or S90V. However, that doesn't mean the difference isn't noticeable. It is.
As previously stated, a SAK is my EDC of choice. It works and works well. I think anyone who 'looks down' on a SAK doesn't understand the real world use of pocket knives. But I still love my S30V knives and will likely always have one.
Well said, my friend!
-
I have about ten or twelve knives in the snob category. Over 200 dollars each.
But I got them because of their craftsmanship and handle materials, and not all of them have premium steels.
As a rule I don´t carry them, I have cheaper folders that may get damaged by use without me starting to cry.
And of course I carry SAKs. In common daily life, a man needs more just than just a blade.
So if you´re carrying a high end folder but no SAK / MT on the side I think you´re missing out. -
I've bought knives and multitools that were too expensive for what they actually are, but as a collector I can appreciate the craftsmanship, or the used materials, or the rarity of them without ever having to really use them.
I consider that part of my collection as "luxery", like others have sculptures, or paintings etc... No real use for them, just fun to own.
And for my users I have a couple of self-made rules.
First of all, if I have two knives with me and need to use one of them in a (more extreme than usual) way, I'll end up using the cheapest one 9 out of 10.
Second, I'll only use knifes/tools that are easily replaceable. For example, I'll reach for my Wave + rather than using one of the previous Wave models (first or second generation), because if I break the +, I'll probably get another one, but if I break my first generation Wave, I'll end up with another Wave +.
And last, how easy can it be replaced under warranty. For example, if I bought a Leatherman in the Netherlands, or the U.S.A., Leatherman Belgium will make a fuss about it. When I bought it at an official Belgian retailer they will be a lot more willing to help.
Long story short, while I can appreciate special types of steel, handmade knives etc... Most of my users are found in the "cheaper" part of my collection.
-
Knife snobbery, like gun snobbery, motorcycle snobbery, car snobbery, house snobbery, is a sickening condition of the human psych.
I've been a member of gun, motorcycle, gun, canoe clubs and more. IN every single one of them I didn't bother to be a member past the first year. The BMW club was a sickening example of the snobbery of it you didn't have the "right" model BMW then you were a lower level member. The Harley club was even more so, that if you had a sportster you were the red headed step child from the other side of the tracks. Knife clubs the same. I'm genuinely surprised more people don't carry a step ladder around with then s they can look down on others at will.
Heck, it was the extreme knife snobbery at a well known knife forum that was instrumental to me selling off/giving away most my knife collection and my SAK becoming my sole pocket knife.
As for the Victorinox steel not being good enough, I unwrapped a large soft from a cardboard cocoon that it was shipped in with a tinker. After I cleaned the glue off the blade it was as good as when I started, and a minute on the bottom of a coffee mug got it shaving sharp again.
I've had high end customs forged by master smiths of the American Bladesmith Society, and SAK's and most things in between. The SAK is good enough for 99.9% of what you need a pocket knife for. That's including the over priced and over hyped famous Randall Knives of Florida. I had a few, and they were no better than most store bought knives of modest price, including Buck knives at a small fraction of the price. In fact, my Buck 102 woodsman outcut a similar sized small hunter by a well known master smith of the American Bladesmith Society.
They can hype the wonder steel of the month all they want, is is all bull hockey to stimulate sales in an artificially created market to part gullible people from their money. Theres a definite point of diminishing returns, and you reach that point very fast with good quality production knives of mass produced steel. And 99% of most people taking a knife out of their pocket to cut something, will never know the difference.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
This!there are many studies that identify factors that change the perception of value - some of those are: brand loyalty, price paid, rarity, who else has the product.
While there is no doubt some internal "price justification" going on--accompanied with a healthy dose of "Fear Of Missing Out" that drives many purchases in the first place--I think "value" merits additional discussion.
One place where the value proposition interests me is the world of watches. I've worn a wrissmurfch since I was a wee lad for one purpose only: to tell me exactly what time it is. Specifically, I want any watch I wear to be accurate enough that I never have to re-set it outside the mandatory (and silly) semi-annual standard/daylight saving time change. Furthermore, I hate watches that require batteries, as I've had watch batteries crap out on me when I was in the middle of nowhere. Finally, I need the watch to be reasonably water-resistant and durable. I was never completely satisfied with a watch until the advent of the Citizen Eco-Drive. Since I live in one time zone and work in another, I own two (a 7170 and an 8180), and I am absolutely, completely happy with them.
While I understand the lure of high-end automatic watches, they don't appeal to me enough to actually buy one. There's something marvelous about a completely mechanical thing that can mark time to a very high level of accuracy, but--for me--the juice isn't worth the squeeze. Many people purchase a Submariner or a Seamaster for the "snob factor," but many others own one (or several) because they truly love the beauty inherent in these mechanical marvels. I'm a fully-flawed human with an ego as fragile as the next guy's, but I don't tend to rub elbows with people who'd be impressed with my watch, so I don't belong in the former group. On the other hand, as someone who loves well-made mechanical things I could easily find myself in the latter. Nevertheless, I'm simply unwilling to pay used car money for the privilege of wearing a mechanical marvel on my wrist, because--for me--a watch is fundamentally about telling time.
Similarly, I managed to avoid the lure of "high end" knives for a very long time, because--again, for me--a knife is fundamentally a tool. But not too long ago I watched a pair of YouTube videos from BladeHQ where they were taken on a shop tour by Chris Reeve. While I'd been aware of the Sebenza since its initial development, I'd never had the urge to purchase one...until I watched those videos. While Chris Reeve as the reputation of being something of a prickly character, I learned I really liked the cut of his jib. This is a guy who really wants to make the "best"--using his criteria--knives he possibly can. All aspects of his design are focused on the way he thinks a knife should be used--from actual cutting to sharpening to routine maintenance. So over the following months I bought three--large and small Sebenzas and an Unmumzaan. I really like them. Do they cut things better than my beloved Compact? Nope, and they will never kick an SAK out of my pocket. But they bring me joy when I carry and use them, and in my autumnal years I'm very fortunate (thanks to a perennially frugal wife and grown, self-sustaining children) to be in a place where the price of that pleasure is relatively affordable.
Thankfully, Rolex doesn't make $400 watches... ;)
-
I may carry other knives but I am never without a SAK in my pocket.
-
I’ll freely admit to being a Vic fanboy, but I’d never look down upon or denigrate some one because they chose a different knife than me. That’s just stupid.
We all have different wants and needs and fortunately also have lots of options to fill them.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
2. Are you supposed to have that thing?LOL!
IMO the reason to carry a SAK is that you won't scare too many people using it in public. A 4" OTF with a blacked out S35 blade...thats another story.Most of the knife snobs I have encountered were more like "You carry a production knife? Lame, mine was hand made by XYZ famous knife maker and cost $2300."
Though admittedly in elementary school the few SAK kids gave the few Wenger kids quite a hard time.
-
Me too Jack, and I've not been let down yet! I'm the oddball here in that I like Spyderco, it can't tell you anything about the steels. For a kid that grew up in Southwestern Pennsylvania that's probably not a good thing. I like them for the fact that they are fairly lightweight, durable, and the company is law enforcement friendly. I know they're out there, but I haven't met any more snobs there than I have in any other knife owner's group. I think it's just people thing. Some folks just get too caught up in the details and forget that this is probably the dumbest hobby there is.
@Nix said:
I've got a Knife-snob streak in me. However, over several decades of knife use, I've come to the conclusion that knife snobbery is completely unwarranted.
Most days my fancy knives stay at home and it's a SAK that is carried. SAK's are too useful to not carry one. And that usually makes a secondary knife redundant. So, the default pocket knife is the ubiquitous SAK. Appropriately so, says I.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login