PTC vs. MC
-
In my opinion, the MiniChamp's origins were simply to (originally) use up the band cutter, pill counter, and trach (Wharncliffe) blade tools originally made for various pharmaceutical advertising knives. It sold a bit better than they thought, it was redesigned to add the combo tool, and is still being sold today. The MiniChamp has a lot of "fluff" features, while the PTC is as practical as it gets. I've done an entire challenge with the MiniChamp but would carry my PTC as an EDC. Why? Because the toolset is so much more practical and slightly bigger. With the PTC, I have two screwdrivers that do most of what I need, a blade, scissors, and an awl. The awl is my favorite tool on it by far.
-
Size wise I much prefer the PTC. The MC is very usable tho.
Main blade. Its a tough call. They are small knives with small blades, obviously right? The extra length of the PTC is nice to have. Again, the MC is no slouch.
Files. Draw. They both work.
Scissors. Draw. Great scissors on both.
Flat drivers. Different beasts. PTC is thick but come to a nice taper. MC is very good. I pick PTC because its narrower and can get into smaller spaces.
PTC micro flat driver. Awesome.
PTC Awl. Awesome.
PTC bottle opener. Irrelevant for me.MC Philips. Awesome.
MC secondary blade. Awesome.
MC Picker blade. Awesome.
MC coke spoon. Indifferent.
MC pen. Awesome.
MC ruler. NiceMy PTC has decidedly won space in my pocket sheath along with my Camillus and AAA light. Its no so great that my MC has lost its usage tho. I like to carry my MC when at home so I have a tool with me. I use the picker blade a lot. I use my wharncliff blade to cut dogs meds in quarters.
The little extra length of the PTC blade and thinness over the MC won space in my pocket sheath. As always I wish there were an iteration of both these great tools.
-
If the PTC had a ball point pen it would be no contest. I love the Wenger sizes!
-
I've used all the tools on the Pocket Tool Chest several times. On the Minichamp, everything that isn't on a Rambler/Manager seems surplus to requirements, and as such, I never bought one. I never bought myself a Swisschamp or Farmer either. Just because something is popular, doesn't mean it's right for everyone. Maybe there are some benefits to the Minichamp that I'm missing, but I've never been carrying/using the Rambler or Manager, and wished I had something off the Minichamp on it.
-
everything the MC has in addition to the Rambler is just fluff.I make this mod to me PTC and find it much more useful.

-
I’ve picked up s couple of PTCs last year, but haven’t made the effort to carry either.
The MCs get the most use in Midnight form with the light and pen. And I find I rarely grab the Alox MCs, but they have a nice compactness to them...and take keychain duty really well.
MCs ‘win’ by default for me. But I will try to work the PTCs into some rotation this year.
-
I'm going to start with the screw drivers on the two tools. The PTC utilizes a small jewelers and large flat head on the combo tool. The MC utilizes a thin large flat head with a small Phillips on the combo tool. Both SD sets are are very useful but so far it appears to me the Wenger combo is more useful. I'll start with the large flat head (the large flat head on both work's on Phillips screws also). Both SD's fit the same size screws but the PTC is a beefier thicker tool compared to the thin SD tip on the ruler of the MC. When heavy torque is needed the thin MC SD well flex and it feels like it's going to bend. The large SD on the PTC is twice as thick and handles heavy torque better in my opinion.
When I compare the small SD's of the two tools The MC uses a small Phillips on the combo tool opposed to the thinner jewelers SD on the PTC. I have to admit the Phillips on the MC is a nice tool but because it's a committed 3D Phillips it's less useful than then the slotted jewelers SD on the PTC. The PTC can get all the small Phillips that the MC can plus it can get small slotted screws (like the screws in eye glass).
In my opinion the PTC edges out the MC when it comes to the wider range of screws you can use it on.
-
The main reason most of is carry SAK's is to cut stuff so let's look at the cutting blades. From what I can tell there are pros and cons to both tool's. Well start with size of the main blade. There are times the extra length of the PTC have come in handy. ( ever try to cut a thick steak with a tiny 58mm Vic blade?) So I would give a small advantage to the PTC main blade but the MC has two extra cutting blades the PTC doesn't have. Are they worth having?
Starting with the emergency blade. Some would argue that the e blade on the Vic is "frivolous and unnecessary". I use to believe that very way until I used one on a regular basis. If I need a small cutting blade I find myself reaching for the 58mm e blade more and more. It's a tool I'm really starting to love and we'll worth having so point for the MC on that one.
The cut and picker blade is another tool I use to think was frivolous overkill on the MC. Boy was I wrong. This is a tool I could see myself missing if I was not carrying the MC. I'm really seeing the value of this tool so another point to the MC.
-
@cody6268 said:
In my opinion, the MiniChamp's origins were simply to (originally) use up the band cutter, pill counter, and trach (Wharncliffe) blade tools originally made for various pharmaceutical advertising knives. It sold a bit better than they thought, it was redesigned to add the combo tool, and is still being sold today. The MiniChamp has a lot of "fluff" features, while the PTC is as practical as it gets. I've done an entire challenge with the MiniChamp but would carry my PTC as an EDC. Why? Because the toolset is so much more practical and slightly bigger. With the PTC, I have two screwdrivers that do most of what I need, a blade, scissors, and an awl. The awl is my favorite tool on it by far.I've always felt the same way but I figured I would put it to the test. I learning some of MC tools are more useful then I originally thought. Like the cut and picker and the emergency blade.
-
Love that picker blade. Its my go to for a variety of things around the house. Just the other day I used it to cut the plastic protective wrap off an ice-cream container lid. I've used it to un stitch a hem so I could do a better job.
-
@Aloha said:
Size wise I much prefer the PTC. The MC is very usable tho.Main blade. Its a tough call. They are small knives with small blades, obviously right? The extra length of the PTC is nice to have. Again, the MC is no slouch.
Files. Draw. They both work.
Scissors. Draw. Great scissors on both.
Flat drivers. Different beasts. PTC is thick but come to a nice taper. MC is very good. I pick PTC because its narrower and can get into smaller spaces.
PTC micro flat driver. Awesome.
PTC Awl. Awesome.
PTC bottle opener. Irrelevant for me.MC Philips. Awesome.
MC secondary blade. Awesome.
MC Picker blade. Awesome.
MC coke spoon. Indifferent.
MC pen. Awesome.
MC ruler. NiceMy PTC has decidedly won space in my pocket sheath along with my Camillus and AAA light. Its no so great that my MC has lost its usage tho. I like to carry my MC when at home so I have a tool with me. I use the picker blade a lot. I use my wharncliff blade to cut dogs meds in quarters.
The little extra length of the PTC blade and thinness over the MC won space in my pocket sheath. As always I wish there were an iteration of both these great tools.
Your findings are on par with what I'm learn about the two. I have to admit I'm liking the MC more then I thought I would.
-
So, size wise (length), both are the same size as a Rambler?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@AimlessWanderer said:
I've used all the tools on the Pocket Tool Chest several times. On the Minichamp, everything that isn't on a Rambler/Manager seems surplus to requirements, and as such, I never bought one. I never bought myself a Swisschamp or Farmer either. Just because something is popular, doesn't mean it's right for everyone. Maybe there are some benefits to the Minichamp that I'm missing, but I've never been carrying/using the Rambler or Manager, and wished I had something off the Minichamp on it.I've always felt the same way till I bought a MC. I really like my Rambler but I could see where a Vagabond with the two extra cutting tools would be a great tool set. If I could add a emergency blade and a cut and picker blade to a PTC that would be perfect.
-
Of the 58s, the Rambler/Manager has most of the tools I need most of the time. However the second blade and especially the orange peeler are great tools. I can scrap, pull cut and pierce stuff with it.
Therefore the Vagabond is the optimum 58 for me. All the good stuff from the MC, minus the useless coke spoon. I cannot understand why it is no longer in production.
I would love to see a Vagabond with the mini screwdriver and the awl. That would have been excellent. Maybe make it bigger at 65mm. Alox too, and pair it to a Leatherman Style PS for pliers and tweezers.

Στάλθηκε από το HUAWEI VNS-L31 μου χρησιμοποιώντας Tapatalk
-
Vagabond looks great. I've done great with my Manager for years now on my keychain. I came from a MC but never lost my love for the MC. AimlessW kept talking about the PTC so I finally come upon one. I was off and on with it till I made time for it. I'm impressed with it so I carry it.
-
No PTC here so I can´t compare. But that awl looks nice.

PS I love my MiniChamps.
-
I can’t imagine using a 58mm tool! That is soooo small!
I bought a Rambler and just stuck it right back in the box. Way too small for me to even hold onto the thing!
My 74mm Executive is as small as I think I can go! Haha
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@zrxoa1 said:
I can%u2019t imagine using a 58mm tool! That is soooo small!I bought a Rambler and just stuck it right back in the box. Way too small for me to even hold onto the thing!
My 74mm Executive is as small as I think I can go! Haha
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
There's a lot of love here for the 74mm's. I've owned and used a few including an Executive and for me they are an awkward size. They're to big for my change pocket to long for a keyring and they sit in the bottom of my pocket in an awkwardly on the side hard to get to way.
For me personally the 65mm's are the perfect compromise between carry and handling. -
Yes the tool is small but even in my mitt its very usable. The drivers are like jewelers drivers without the long shaft.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
