Free P4 pliers stiffness after moderate or heavy use
-
@Aloha said:
I didn't realize you disliked LM Tosh
. To be clear its the plier heads? I've purchased the vast majority of mine used and never had one issue that comes to mind. Stiffness I've had but its always worked itself out and not anything like whats being reported by the OP on the P4 or what others have reported on other LMs.I'm going to take a guess and say you've tried enough to be firm in your view? While I admit I have limited experience with the new LMs my use of mine over years has not been similar to what others experience.
I've hammered, I've torqued, I've pushed mine pretty hard for a MT and I'm convinced mine are not only capable but dependable.
Bummer for all who experienced plier issues but I tend to not write off a brand in general. There are some really good tools IMO that LM has produced.
Steve, you misunderstand.
I like LM. I love the surge/wave/charge, the pruners etc etc love them
But I hate the LM plier head. I just hate it with a passion. And that’s the only reason why I won’t edc LM
If they would put proper pliers on the surge made from proper tool steel and charge £50 more, I’d buy it in a heartbeat. and would carry that everywhere.
But...they won’t!! Therefore all mine will remain in the box.
The beefy surge and ST300 cry out for proper pliers. -
LM pliers
. I think there are many who wish a "real" plier head would be fastened to MTs.For what a MT is for me I'm pretty satisfied. Thanks for the follow up Tosh.
-
@tosh said:
Steve, you misunderstand.
I like LM. I love the surge/wave/charge, the pruners etc etc love them
But I hate the LM plier head. I just hate it with a passion. And that’s the only reason why I won’t edc LM
If they would put proper pliers on the surge made from proper tool steel and charge £50 more, I’d buy it in a heartbeat. and would carry that everywhere.
But...they won’t!! Therefore all mine will remain in the box.
The beefy surge and ST300 cry out for proper pliers.Not me you quoted ;)
-
First of all, I don't often use the pliers on my Multitools, not for heavy use at least. And to be honest, the Free P4 wasn't the most sturdy multitool to begin with.
My first impression of the P4 was that it was a nice looking tool, good for edc and it would get you out of trouble in case of an emergency.
But I immediately added that, if I was going to use my tool 10 times a day, or when I'm doing chores around the house, I definitely prefer my Wave/Surge or ST300/Rebar, since they feel much more sturdy.
I'm one of the first to say that Leatherman's quality control has been far from perfect these last years, but I wouldn't go so far as to say they never produced a decent plierhead, all my 10 year old (and older) Leatherman tools are just rock solid.
And it's not only Leatherman that has these problems, the lens problem from the Victorinox magnifying glass is also one of those things that never would've occurred 15 years ago...
Anyway, I'm going to hold on to my 2 Free P4's for now. The way I see it, either Leatherman will fix this problem the next months, and I can replace my two P4's if I want, or they don't fix it and the P4 will be on the "discontinued" list in a matter of time, in which case I will definitely hold on to my 2 P4's :D.
-
I haven't seen a P4 in the wild yet. I might have to have a look when we get the clear to go out again.
-
For what it is worth, this issue is not isolated to just cutting with your P2 (or possibly P4- I only own a P2). Just gripping anything semi tightly with the pliers binds them up. I have had success loosening them by wriggling the handles as has been described. I have tried several different oils thinking, perhaps, the issue was not enough lubricant. None of the various oils (Hoppes, WD 40, Tri Flow, 3 in 1) has seemed to solve it.
I can also confirm that when I received mine, also purchased via Amazon as someone else mentioned, there was a substantial amount of grease on the pliers head.
So one trick that has worked for me to loosen the pliers when they stiffen has been to do the following: open the tool so that that handles are in line. At this point the pliers are sticking up out of the handle, I then turn the pliers face down and rapidly pull the handle apart several times. This opens and closes the pliers, and seems to consistently remove the stiffness. I am going to keep doing this as long as I can tolerate the aggravation and the the tool is not completely frozen up, over hitting my tool with a hammer. Rightly I should send it back, but I am not risking leatherman marring up my tool by hitting it with a hammer.
I am not however writing off LM entirely, I have a number of tools I love and I think they continue to push the technology, capability and industry forward; but they clearly have a considerable issue and the responses reported by their customer service are less than ideal (conscience that may be overly kind in that assessment)
I have to say I am thrilled I joined this forum. Amongst other things I learned from all the great people here, one is that this issue with the P2 is not isolated to just me.
Thanks for being such a great group!
-
@Max Stone said:
Out of interest, I asked the salesman if we could test the P2 and P4 they had in their display cabinet.Guest what...after a squeeze they both locked up nice a tight. The salesman’s eyes went large and he said he’d show the distributor when he came in.
Seems the problem is not so isolated... ???
Love it. Perhaps we should all hit the stores en masse (when we can) and "try out" as many P2/P4 pliers as possible? ;)
-
Has anyone tried the other fix for loose pliers that involved rotating the pivot? I think Sam came up with it.

Since hitting the pivot seems to be a possible fix for both loose and tight pivots, perhaps this would work for both as well.
I know, I know, you shouldn't have to but it might be a lot easier for some than sending them back.EDIT: Sam's trick here: /topic/75195
-
Good suggestion Syncop8r. I’ll try it when I get home this evening of no one does it before that.
-
Well, I tried turning the rivet for the pliers as a solution, but I was unable to get it to turn using conventional locking vice grips, or even channel locks. As light marring and scratching is now appearing, I’m abandoning this as I don’t want to beat up a brand new $120 tool. The solution I mentioned above, aligning the handles into a straight line and then rapidly opening and closing the pliers by pulling the handles apart when the pliers tighten works decently enough for me at the moment.
Sorry to disappoint.
-
Nothing to be sorry for.

I'm sorry that idea didn't help.
-
My Wave (2011) binds up a bit if I squeeze hard on the handles. I can get it to loosen by basically gripping something fixed and twisting the handles to rock the jaws apart. So this design problem is not just the Free series. None of my Gerber/Sog/Victorinoxes do this....

-
My replacement P2 came in today. It looks like a new one, hard to tell really.
Not sure what I’ll do with it yet, maybe just use it for a while to see how it goes. It is an interesting design to fiddle with.
-
-
That’s encouraging. If they fix it and it just becomes a matter of being without a tool for a few days, I’m okay with that. It’s not great and the QC must improve, but when they fix it at no cost, I am happy they stand by their product in that sense
-
You know what I came up to recently... I don’t have a Free LM. I do have a Wave that I upgraded with a 154cm Charge blade myself after the stock blade chipped a few times without being used at all(!!!).
I didn’t have any issues with it afterwards, though a closed tool does scratch my hands when I use a screwdriver with an extender plugged in which is a sign of a bit poorly designed product. But that’s it - cuts nails and wire and works perfectly fine.
Then I got a used 0697 Micra - a tiny piece of quality - what more can I say. Love it.
I bought a Signal about a year ago. In two days I got it replaced because the saw and the blade won’t stay locked. The replacement started doing just that in a few days too and I had to fix it myself bending the liners. The Signal also has stiff pliers that cut even tiny nails and regular wires way worse than the Wave and despite all lubrications and trying to work it in the pliers remain stiff.
I bought a Vic Forester between the Wave and a Signal and brought it to Alps twice - on Tour du Mont Blanc and the Mont Blanc ascent as well.
It did help one of us a lot fixing a loose flashlight screw during the toughest part of the Mont Blanc ascent which happens at night - you can’t really climb rocks when you can’t see where you’re going.I didn’t expect much improvised usage of the Forester due to it’s simplicity, though did prefer the saw and screwdrivers on LMs because they lock (sometimes).
Then I watched some Felix Immler guides on using SAKs. Then I bought a Work Champ. Figured ways to use the saw right with a fire steel and not needing it to lock. Using the can opener as a screwdriver not fearing it will collapse into my fingers. Then I started using it even more. Now I just can’t believe I didn’t do it earlier - Vic is so dramatically superior in quality than LM in every single aspect to me as I use the tools. It’s just better designed, more convenient, easier and therefore more enjoyable. Don’t think I’ll get more LMs in the future...
-
@Mcfal12 said:
That’s encouraging. If they fix it and it just becomes a matter of being without a tool for a few days, I’m okay with that. It’s not great and the QC must improve, but when they fix it at no cost, I am happy they stand by their product in that senseThey exchanged it for a fresh one and I’m happy with that. I don’t know if there have been any changes to the design, and if there were I kinda doubt the revised models would have made it over here already.
At the very least it is a failed P2 that will show up in the statistics at Leatherman headquarters. If the return rate is high surely some corrective action will be taken.
Most customers probably only buy one or maybe two LM tools in a lifetime. Between the price point, their reputation and the 25 year warranty they should be expected to last a lifetime. It is nice how they really do stand behind their products if something does go wrong.
-
I bought a new Leatherman Free P4 and it arrived today. It cut 4d and 8d nails. The pliers did not bind up. I also tried squeezing the handles as hard as I could without cutting anything. Still, no binding. So far, so good.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login