Spartan carbon mod....
-
I would say O1 is definitely an upgrade if the heat treat is right. SAK steel tends to get a lot of micro-chipping in my use. While for most uses, 1.4034 is good steel, it's not as tough as most common carbon steels used in low to mid-end knives. My Kabar is 1095, and it rarely rolls or chips--even when being used to dig out thistles.
I am eventually going to send my old 1942 Soldier to Rothlisberger in CH to have it pimped out. At present, it is my only carbon steel SAK. I am mainly getting the main blade (2-3 centimeters short) and handles (shrunken badly and falling off the knife) replaced; as Vic cannot do the repair here in the US it seems. They told me that if I sent it in, it would be replaced; presumably with a Pioneer.
-
1095 is supposed to be better for heat treating with a blowtorch which I wish I’d known - it doesn’t need ‘soaking’ as much when at temperature apparently so I might try that if I do another blade.
Sounds like yours has been we’ll used and deserves a good pimping.
I’m properly attached to an old ‘champ’ that I have which still, to this day, remain my favourite. That’s had a new main blade as that was worn away to a stub too ;0)
-
I don't know if you're aware of Cedric and Ada's steel tests on youtube, but one of the things I've learned is that Victorinox steel is so soft it's almost impossible to find a knife with anything softer! Frozen butter is probably slicier... So my guess is your upgrade is already 3 or 4 times tougher than the original, even if every step was done by guestimation.
I'd never thought about those old Soldiers with carbon steel blades - it would be nice if Victorinox one day made a limited run of Spartans or Climbers with an old school carbon blade, or something super-tough and far-from-stainless like K390... But Victorinox isn't Spyderco, so it'll never happen! Imagine a Spyderco/Victorinox collaboration with a nice thumb hole on the main blade! -
I think the occasional limited Damascus bladed edition comes out but not sure if these are available to the general public or not! Now that would really be niiice...
-
@Thunderpants said:
I don't know if you're aware of Cedric and Ada's steel tests on youtube, but one of the things I've learned is that Victorinox steel is so soft it's almost impossible to find a knife with anything softer! Frozen butter is probably slicier... So my guess is your upgrade is already 3 or 4 times tougher than the original, even if every step was done by guestimation.
I'd never thought about those old Soldiers with carbon steel blades - it would be nice if Victorinox one day made a limited run of Spartans or Climbers with an old school carbon blade, or something super-tough and far-from-stainless like K390... But Victorinox isn't Spyderco, so it'll never happen! Imagine a Spyderco/Victorinox collaboration with a nice thumb hole on the main blade!This is exactly what I've been calling for. Yet, we get same old, same old LEs--common, existing models with wood handles and a Damascus blade, or 3 of the same Alox models with different colors.
Vic should really explore new blade steels and handle materials like G-10 and S30V; even if the price is stupidly much. They could probably sell for less, and probably sell more than the fancy Damasteel knives. From a user perspective, Damascus does nothing. If I'm gonna spend loads of money on an SAK, it better be a big one, or a rare vintage model. But, premium steels and scales that won't break--sign me up!
-
Good job HB

- it would be nice if Victorinox one day made a limited run of Spartans or Climbers with an old school carbon blade
that would be nice -
Nice work chap

-
Nice job 👍👍
-
Nice mod.
-
Nice work!

-
@Helvetica Bold said:
Cheers. I think the jury remains out as to whether it’s actually and improvement or not but it feels like it’s cool and glad I gave it a go at least....want to stick a short file in place of the small blade on a huntsman sometime too ....creating a ‘Bowman’ for my archery escapades!!Looks great!

What kind of archery? Hunting or just recreation? Longbow, traditional, compound?...

-
Excellent job

-
@pfrsantos said:
Looks great!

What kind of archery? Hunting or just recreation? Longbow, traditional, compound?...

Cheers. I do 3D archery - so hunting in the woods just with foam animals that don’t run away :0)
-
Thanks everyone for your comments. I’ve got it nice and sharp now and been using it for the last few day’s. Still happy with it as a first attempt just wish it would snap shut properly and that I’d stuck it in a Ranger instead!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login