OOPS! - SAK Production Errors
-
A spacer is missing from the Electrician on the right.

-
Wow - That's significant!! - Does the awl rattle/slip/move ?
-
@miklospinter said:
A spacer is missing from the Electrician on the right.
That’s gotta be a rare mistake! Thanks for sharing.

-
Maybe a stretch on the definition of error...but this time, a copy of the ‘rare’ c. late ‘72 scaler with the first ruler markings. The bottom copy shows clear wear of the metric side numbering. The ‘1’ mark isn’t really visible.
.

-
I bought the pictured "Huntsman with Pouch" in a (sealed) blister pack some time ago on eBay (I like gifting them, so I usually keep at least one "in stock"). When it arrived, I first noticed what you can see in the first image: The SAK is improperly placed in the blister pack (it should be placed with the front scale being the visible one). Upon closer inspection, I discovered much bigger issues that can be seen in the second image:
-
The SAK is dirty.
-
The (visible) back scale is only partly attached (there is a big gap between the scale and the liner it's supposed to touch).
-
The front scale is completely missing (and I'm thus guessing that the tweezers are also missing).
So this is a seriously messed up SAK in a sealed blister pack. ??? Not very common, I think (but seems to speak for itself about the imperfection of quality control at Victorinox). The question now is what should I do with it? If I'll keep it as is, I will be in possession of a somewhat unusual item, but will never know how messed up this SAK really is. If I'll open it, my curiosity will be satisfied, but I will likely end up owning nothing other than a messed up SAK (unless I'll discover some interesting defect other than dirt and a missing scale that could explain why the SAK is in this state). So...
What should I do?
Opinions?

-
-
^^^ That is completely bizarre - How could that possibly happen? ??? - Double/treble QC errors!!
And how they actually put that thing in a blister pack is staggering- I am assuming that the only way that could be - Is if the packing process is automated and somehow that duff SAK made it to the packaging machine.
You gotta save it / keep it - But send Vic the photos and ask for compensation.
Eg Another Huntsman -
Trouble is I guess for that they'd insist on getting the old one back@KK - Is that a stamping error? - I assume it's not wear and tear
-
@Huntsman said:
You gotta save it / keep it - But send Vic the photos and ask for compensation.
Eg Another Huntsman -
Trouble is I guess for that they'd insist on getting the old one backI expect that they will be happy to exchange this smoking gun in order to erase it out of existence, but find it hard to believe that they will provide any compensation for just photos.
I'm going to keep it, but find it frustrating that I don't really know exactly what's inside the pack (how bad is it?). Maybe I'll open it just to know. Maybe not. Blister packs can be VERY annoying.
:ahhh -
@MiniChamp said:
I expect that they will be happy to exchange this smoking gun in order to erase it out of existence, but find it hard to believe that they will provide any compensation for just photos.I'm going to keep it, but find it frustrating that I don't really know exactly what's inside the pack (how bad is it?). Maybe I'll open it just to know. Maybe not. Blister packs can be VERY annoying.
:ahhhThis is really unusual. I would visit the Victorinox store and open the blister with the staff. It seems that the packer decided to update his knife.
-
Never been quite sure about this one. I bought it new something like 6-7 years ago so I know it's direct from the factory and was on a current card back. I understand that the Sportsman sometimes doesn't have a keyring, but the missing sewing eye on the awl has me confused.
So; mistake or not?
-
@jnoxyd said:
This is really unusual. I would visit the Victorinox store and open the blister with the staff. It seems that the packer decided to update his knife.Good suggestion...but I suspect the ‘Bay seller. Sincerely doubt this is a Victorinox issue.
Blister packs with card stock aren’t the same as those that are sealed by melting the two PE layers together at the perimeter.
-
@Gareth said:
Never been quite sure about this one. I bought it new something like 6-7 years ago so I know it's direct from the factory and was on a current card back. I understand that the Sportsman sometimes doesn't have a keyring, but the missing sewing eye on the awl has me confused.
So; mistake or not?Seems like a mistake to me, but there were other size models that the eye was deleted.
-
Very good point KK - As I said - Hard to imagine how that could happen at the factory
And there are some suspicious creases etc in the card.@MiniChamp - Can you have a look at the pack card to see if it has been opened and re-glued?
If that is the case that is pretty dastardly deception by the eBay seller
-
@Huntsman said:
Very good point KK - As I said - Hard to imagine how that could happen at the factory
And there are some suspicious creases etc in the card.@MiniChamp - Can you have a look at the pack card to see if it has been opened and re-glued?
If that is the case that is pretty dastardly deception by the eBay seller
agree -
@jnoxyd said:
This is really unusual. I would visit the Victorinox store and open the blister with the staff.Interesting idea. Unfortunately, it's not something that is practical to do at my location.
I ended up opening the blister by myself. The SAK that I found inside can be seen in the attached images. What cannot be seen in the images is that the knife blades are dull and somewhat damaged from usage (they also have some scratches). To cut a long story short, it's a dirty used+abused SAK.
@kamakiri said:
Blister packs with card stock aren’t the same as those that are sealed by melting the two PE layers together at the perimeter.I have some familiarity with this generation of Victorinox blister packs. I tried to open such blisters "undestructively" quite a few times with no success. The card is very brittle and tends to get completely messed up. The only way I know how to open them while keeping the card in reasonable shape is to cut the plastic without touching the card at all.
@Huntsman said:
@MiniChamp - Can you have a look at the pack card to see if it has been opened and re-glued?I looked very carefully (with a magnifying glass, etc.), but found no signs of any foul play. It looked like a normal factory-closed blister pack. Also, suppose someone was talented enough to open and re-glue it in such a perfect undetectable way. Why didn't they bother to also make the SAK look more presentable by cleaning the outside dirt and tightening the loose scale? (Those issues were very visible with the closed blister; much easier to notice than the missing scale.) While I cannot completely rule out the possibility that such foul play is involved, I believe that it isn't very likely.
If that is the case that is pretty dastardly deception by the eBay seller
The eBay account in question exists since 2003 and has hundreds of 100% positive feedbacks. I find it a little hard to believe that they would intentionally do something deceptive of this sort.
@Huntsman said:
Hard to imagine how that could happen at the factoryIndeed. That is the $24.94 question. I wonder: What happens to open blister-packed SAKs that get returned to large US retail stores like Target and Walmart? Is it possible that they are sent back to Victorinox (the US branch) for examination and repacking of those of them that are in fact new? If so, it can put some messed up used SAKs just one human error away from being repacked as new. Is that possible?



-
I found this one interesting. Not sure if it is a production error per se but I have not seen the shield and tang paired before. I assume one is economy line and one is regular so think it's odd?

-
Old Classic with cross cut file and no tang stamp

-
Didn’t notice how bad this was until I looked at it under a loupe.
Especially the part inside the teepee.
c. ‘76 Ranger.

-
...not a serious "error" but I noticed on a brand new Classic, scratches on the blade from the nail file blade?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login