The Comprehensive Knife Based Multitool Thread
-
I've never seen that before!

-
@ReamerPunch said:
I've never seen that before!
It's gotten suprisingly little press. I can only find one review on it (on the Amazon site) and they give it 1/5 stars because apparently the liner lock is poorly designed (the tool next to the liner lock stands out higher than the lock itself so you can't reach it).
It looks cool though. I am a fan of the Camillus claw can opener (for nostalgic reasons) so its a bit of a bummer that they use the quarter circle - but I suppose adding the small SD is worth it.
-
That's pretty cool. Though I'm partial to a beer and beans knife myself... Gotta have a can opener.
I used to know a guy that had spent time in Europe, and had gotten into the habit of using tinned fish. Who knows where he would find so many varieties of tinned herring, sardines, mackerel etc. He'd bring them to work for lunch and drive everyone in the break room crazy. Fortunately he had a SAK with a slot in the Phillips to help open those up. Just a random memory....
-
RR1464
-
Well it looks like the Leatherman Crater lineup is being discontinued. Meanwhile, the Free series knife based tools like the T2 haven't really been all that impressive. I'm really curious to see what they come up with in the future.
-
Does this count?
It has a bottle opener built in.

-
This topic has been called "knife based multitools" but honestly I'm really confused what the definition is..seems like its getting mixed up with pocket knives etc.
-
something that is mainly a knife/dominated by a knife that also has other tools.
Can be a Sanrenmu 763, a knife with a bottle opener or a Victorinox Camper etc., a knife with several other tools included
The multi part means more than one tool, dedicated function. A two blade folding knife will not be a multitool, based on the many discussions had previously here -
@Maxlvledc said:
This topic has been called "knife based multitools" but honestly I'm really confused what the definition is..seems like its getting mixed up with pocket knives etc.It's been hotly debated on other threads. But suffice it to say that...
- the handle is that of a knife, not pliers (or a hammer or wrench)
- the knife blade is the base of the tool as well... it runs the whole length of the handle (the aforementioned knife handle). A knife that can stand on its own as a folding knife
- it is a multitool... it has multiple tools .... a pocketknife such as a Trapper or a Canoe doesn't count
A 91mm SAK doesn't count... But a 111mm or a 130mm SAK does.

My (somewhat half heartedly submitted) Skeletool KBX might count as it has a bottle opener on it... but frankly it's not the point. A curious pocketknife combined with the occasional comb or bottle opener isn't going to derail the thread from the real focus.The focus of the thread is ... in a sense.... is.... most of the tools that have been pictured. We can't always define it, but we know one when we see one. They're out there.
-
why the rejection of the 91mm?
-
Just my gestalt of what a knife based MT is. On a 91mm, the handle isn't categorially that of the knife, and any tool is as central to the device as any other - it may as well be an opener layer based MT, or a metal file based MT, or a saw based MT for that matter.
-
It is knife dominated, what with being called a swiss army knife.
We also had the screwdriver based multitool discussion a few years ago, Gerber centerdrive
-
@dks said:
It is knife dominated, what with being called a swiss army knife.We also had the screwdriver based multitool discussion a few years ago, Gerber centerdrive
Fair enough. I just draw the line a bit farther along in my head when I'm looking for someting that is "knife based" - either when I want something with a more substantial knife, or just the usual day-to-day when my PioneerX or Compact is as much a scissors based tool as it is a knife based tool. I realize I'm being somewhat arbitrary.
-
It is hard enough to define a multitool, let alone to define knife and pliers etc based categories. A LM skeletool has pliers and also a big blade, same with the SOG powerduo, so which one wins, the knife or the pliers?....
-
Ok lets simplify (for my own good)
- OHO locking knife (seems consistent)
- Knife handle shape and format
- Additional tools included besides the blade.
sound about right?
In that case how about these:



-
@Maxlvledc said:
Ok lets simplify (for my own good)- OHO locking knife (seems consistent)
- Knife handle shape and format
- Additional tools included besides the blade.
sound about right?
In that case how about these:



Sounds about right ... im unsure that the first one is a knife or a box cutter. The second and third definitely fit the bill.
-
Knife based, but dominated by the comb....
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Sounds about right ... im unsure that the first one is a knife or a box cutter. The second and third definitely fit the bill.Lol, last time I checked a utility blade is still a knife..and in many cased you can do more with it than I can with a SAK blade (both because of shape and the fact that you don't care about hitting the edge on hard surfaces)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
