'Hate Like' knives
-
I was thinking about this the other day when I, yet again, reached for my Evo 17 when going out on an errands day.
I brought this knife on a whim instead of a Ranger as it had a layer less but still had a file of sorts. It's my first Delemont and didn't really like it right out of the box. Wasn't keen on the scales, hated the scissors, file was a bit limp. Size was good and quality the same as you normally expect but something wasn't quite there.....
However, because I didn't then worry about using it and the associated wear that comes with that I started taking it our more and more regularly and it's now my go to work SAK. Saw is still great (my most used tool outside of blade) and it has everything else I use regularly in one package. Got used to the scissors (still prefer Victorinox style though).
Upshot is I now use it more than any other knife I have!
'Hate Like' or 'Like Hate' anyone else got a knife that's like this for them?

-
Interesting point.
I do see how a knife you don’t care for gets use. Especially one that has a ‘good enough’ tool set.
-
Wenger made such weird design decisions, almost everything they did had a What-the-heck?! moment on first encounter.
Some of the odd things, like the claw can opener, became much loved (at least, by me) while others I hated and will never love, such as the ultra-stumpy philips screwdriver and their comedy magnifying glass, set at the end of a stem of metal to waste an entire layer instead of just half...Talking of magnifying glasses, for many years I didn't think much of the Victorinox Explorer. A better screwdriver than Wenger's and a better magnifying glass but are they that important?
Well, yes. A few years ago all the kids in my daughter's class had headlice so I spent days shampooing and combing her hair looking for the darn things. Thank God I didn't have to rely on Wenger's Christmas-cracker quality magnifying glass for that. The Explorer's proved to be pretty useful in the headlice hunting season.
So, thanks to headlice, the Explorer went right up in my estimation. Feel free to use my true story in your next advertising campaign, Vic! -
@Thunderpants said:
Wenger made such weird design decisions, almost everything they did had a What-the-heck?! moment on first encounter.
Some of the odd things, like the claw can opener, became much loved (at least, by me) while others I hated and will never love, such as the ultra-stumpy philips screwdriver and their comedy magnifying glass, set at the end of a stem of metal to waste an entire layer instead of just half...Talking of magnifying glasses, for many years I didn't think much of the Victorinox Explorer. A better screwdriver than Wenger's and a better magnifying glass but are they that important?
Well, yes. A few years ago all the kids in my daughter's class had headlice so I spent days shampooing and combing her hair looking for the darn things. Thank God I didn't have to rely on Wenger's Christmas-cracker quality magnifying glass for that. The Explorer's proved to be pretty useful in the headlice hunting season.
So, thanks to headlice, the Explorer went right up in my estimation. Feel free to use my true story in your next advertising campaign, Vic!Didn’t I once read that the Wenger glass was supposedly a fire starter first that doubled up as a loupe? And that the tip was actually a micro screwdriver? hence its length. thinking now the glass would give a very precise hold between finger and thumb ??
They weren’t daft Wenger, Everything they did was for a reason. - not just to pad out gaps - looking at you 3-slot-driver-leatherman
-
Hi Tosh, still got your epic Wenger collection?
-
@Thunderpants said:
Hi Tosh, still got your epic Wenger collection?I still got them
I wouldn’t call it epic. There’s a lot I never got and now probably never will given the prices asked.
Have to say I really do miss Wenger now. Seems like there’s no radical kid to strut his stuff. -
I miss 'em too! (But I still think their magnifying glass was bonkers!)
-
@Thunderpants said:
I miss 'em too! (But I still think their magnifying glass was bonkers!)I’m on the fence as I never read what the “”official”” idea was behind it. So many questions left unanswered ....
BUT, I have to say I hate HATE the newer vic mag layer, absolutely loathe it. It looks cheap and fragile. I much prefer the older grey version.
What I would love...Is a juice sized spirit. That to me would be perfect. A truly pocketable mini multi tool.
-
Yes a mini-Spirit would be an absolute grail... the Juice is the only LM I really liked, it has got so many things absolutely right. And one or two things absolutely wrong, which is where Victorinox's eye for mass-produced perfection would come in nicely. I would love to know if Vic is considering such a thing or has considered it in the past.
Mind you the main blade would be getting pretty tiddly! -
I'll take a Juice or Squirt sized Spirit. (just kidding, I'll buy'em both!) -
Mini Spirit would be interesting.
I’ve never gotten a Vic plier-based tool. Right or wrong - I always viewed them as being Leatherman knock-offs. I have a few Leatherman tools and knives. Skeletools, Squirts, Juices. But they don’t get a lot of use. I hardly need a pliers based tool because if I need pliers or wrenches, I have lots around.

-
I'm currently feeling that about the Micra. I got it about 4 years ago, and never really took a liking to it. I took it off the keyring before a run of 30-day challenges earlier this year. I just put it back on last week and have already used it several times. And here I am revitalizing old threads to see if there's something better..... to no avail.

-
Such a critical and overlooked aspect of enjoying and using something is whether or not you have to worry about it -- it can really take away from enjoyment and use.
It's like that with everything. One common example I see is guitars, where people have a nice expensive one that never comes out, while their "beater" guitar gets played all the time, brought to the cottage, etc...
It's a bit of a funny time we live in where the finish of items is so pristine that it's tough to not want to just keep it safe -- even on items like SAKs which are tools meant to be used. The nicer the tool finish, the less you want to use it -- it's a bit of a dilemma.
I've assigned some of my SAKs as dedicated workhorses that I won't worry about the finish. A few with sentimental value or other aesthetic/rarity qualities have been set aside for only light-duty work or special occasion.
I'm sometimes envious of people who can buy just one of a given item and use it to its fullest for years and years.
-
@Altis said:
Such a critical and overlooked aspect of enjoying and using something is whether or not you have to worry about it -- it can really take away from enjoyment and use.It's like that with everything. One common example I see is guitars, where people have a nice expensive one that never comes out, while their "beater" guitar gets played all the time, brought to the cottage, etc...
It's a bit of a funny time we live in where the finish of items is so pristine that it's tough to not want to just keep it safe -- even on items like SAKs which are tools meant to be used. The nicer the tool finish, the less you want to use it -- it's a bit of a dilemma.
I've assigned some of my SAKs as dedicated workhorses that I won't worry about the finish. A few with sentimental value or other aesthetic/rarity qualities have been set aside for only light-duty work or special occasion.
I'm sometimes envious of people who can buy just one of a given item and use it to its fullest for years and years.
This is so true
My main hobby is photography
I now have kit I could only dream about a few years ago. Fantastic Full Frame dslrs, a selection of canons finest L lenses ( read expensive ) yet I seem to pick up the cheapest camera/lens combo every time.I could never sell my expensive gear, so it sits there unused!!
It’s almost like it brings comfort knowing I have the best, regardless that it never sees use.
I am a victim of marketing it seems.
-
@Altis said:
Such a critical and overlooked aspect of enjoying and using something is whether or not you have to worry about it -- it can really take away from enjoyment and use.It's like that with everything. One common example I see is guitars, where people have a nice expensive one that never comes out, while their "beater" guitar gets played all the time, brought to the cottage, etc...
It's a bit of a funny time we live in where the finish of items is so pristine that it's tough to not want to just keep it safe -- even on items like SAKs which are tools meant to be used. The nicer the tool finish, the less you want to use it -- it's a bit of a dilemma.
I've assigned some of my SAKs as dedicated workhorses that I won't worry about the finish. A few with sentimental value or other aesthetic/rarity qualities have been set aside for only light-duty work or special occasion.
I'm sometimes envious of people who can buy just one of a given item and use it to its fullest for years and years.
I know just what you mean , it's both a tragedy and a freeing relief when the first nick/ scar etc shows up on the knife . Its not perfect any more , but then you can just tear into the work with no fear. That said , I did buy my Pioneer specifically to be a work beater .
Thankfully for me and my cellidor Tinker , some kind folk have also shown me online how to get rid of scratches etc, so there's always the option of a rewind of the clock so to speak :) -
@tosh said:
This is so true
My main hobby is photography
I now have kit I could only dream about a few years ago. Fantastic Full Frame dslrs, a selection of canons finest L lenses ( read expensive ) yet I seem to pick up the cheapest camera/lens combo every time.I could never sell my expensive gear, so it sits there unused!!
It’s almost like it brings comfort knowing I have the best, regardless that it never sees use.
I am a victim of marketing it seems.
I am more than happy to help you out with those L lenses. I will take good care of them, I promise
:D -
I admit I felt/feel to some degree a little apprehensive when putting a new ( fill in the blank ) item to use for the first time. I've not narrowed why that is. I am always enamored with items that show the love of use. I am equally fond of pristine items. I take care of what I have but things will show wear.
I watched about a gentleman who had a puppet opera. He designed sets for movies and over time he designed puppets that articulated better than what was available. His passion was his puppet opera. He had two heirs whom he willed his puppets to. He had one stipulation for this inheritance, if the show could not continue the puppets and costumes they wore were to be destroyed. The point for him was the puppets were created to perform and not be on display. He felt ( paraphrasing ) the life of a violin for example was to be played not sit behind glass. It disturbed him greatly to think his puppets would serve no purpose.
I can understand when an item is bought for collection purposes. I've bought items for those same reasons. Over the years however when I buy an item with the intention of using, I do just that. I want to use and see the usage wear/marks over a life of enjoyment of that item. It brings me a great deal of satisfaction.
-
I'm on both sides of the fence as well. I keep my tools pretty well (except for the small blade on my Champion which is covered in glue... go figure) The first several times I use a new knife, I'm almost hesitant. I'd say though, none of my knives are "beaters" I use them all with as much care as I would use a kitchen knife. I don't have too many scratches or dings on my tools in general.
-
@Altis said:
Such a critical and overlooked aspect of enjoying and using something is whether or not you have to worry about it -- it can really take away from enjoyment and use.It's like that with everything.
Wise words. Apparently, I need to think about this more often than I do.
@Altis said:
I'm sometimes envious of people who can buy just one of a given item and use it to its fullest for years and years.I used to be more like that. I need to head back in that direction for more things...except knives. I’ve fallen down the slippery slope. First knife was used solo for 15 1/2 years. I was perfectly happy with it.
-
I don't "hate" any SAKs, but I really dislike the EVO scales. Just very uncomfortable to hold or use and feel "hard" in the hand. Only have one, the EVO equivalent of Tinker that I got about a year ago. Took it out of the box, fondled it for a while and it has been in my no-use box ever since. Give me flat Cellidor or Alox anytime.
Rich
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login