One Man Army - Show your Soldiers
-
Nice pics Chidling

-
In 20 years from now, people will be searching for these modern Soldiers as a BYSAK. It's all about perspective.

-
Exactly, and wishing for a time machine
-
:) Thank you for the link and research!!!
@Myron said:
Fellow Knights and Soldier SAK collectors,I just published an article on my blog highlighting my experience collecting the Model 1961. If you'd like to read it, it can be found here: http://www.roverhaven.com/the-rover-haven-blog
Enjoy!
Myron
Teaser pic:

-
@ElevenBlade said:
In 20 years from now, people will be searching for these modern Soldiers as a BYSAK. It's all about perspective.
I lack three SAKs to have every year of issue from 1962 to 2019, and all of them are harder-to-find Model 2008's. If they are scarce now, imagine 20 years from now.
And speaking of the Model 2008, I can't wait to see what supersedes it. I wonder if the venerable can opener will finally sunset.
-
@Myron said:
I lack three SAKs to have every year of issue from 1962 to 2019, and all of them are harder-to-find Model 2008's. If they are scarce now, imagine 20 years from now.And speaking of the Model 2008, I can't wait to see what supersedes it. I wonder if the venerable can opener will finally sunset.
That will be interesting. It's fascinating as to the amount of thought, or lack thereof, that's put into the Soldier model. For the last two major iterations, it's been a riff on the Outdoors model of the time. I've heard that the Soldier model isn't actually issued to everyone any more... that some get other models.
I wonder if they're going to base it on a SwissTool.... or if they will change the backspring mechanism to make the OHO easier. I doubt the latter, somehow.
When does a SAK become not-a-SAK?
-
@ElevenBlade said:
When does a SAK become not-a-SAK?I think that’s an excellent question.
Some days ago I was “sorting” (my euphemism for “fondling”) my knives, and I came across my sole 111mm knife, a Hunter I purchased in the late 80s. While it’s a good knife that always did whatever was required of it, and there is no doubt that it is indeed a SAK, there is something intangible that just doesn’t sit right with me. And I don’t know why.
I’ve given this question much more thought than it deserves, yet I remain both firm in my conviction and completely mystified as to why I feel this way. I have no significant issue with the 108mm models, so I don’t think the size alone is the problem. Maybe it’s the asymmetry?
I suppose it’s a very good thing we don’t all like the same things; otherwise finding those special SAKs from bygone days would be even harder than it already is.
Edited to add: I think I might have had an epiphany. I got “into” SAKs around 1985. I think perhaps if it doesn’t look like a SAK that was around at that time it isn’t a “real” SAK to me. Maybe.
-
@Frailer said:
I think that’s an excellent question.Some days ago I was “sorting” (my euphemism for “fondling”) my knives, and I came across my sole 111mm knife, a Hunter I purchased in the late 80s. While it’s a good knife that always did whatever was required of it, and there is no doubt that it is indeed a SAK, there is something intangible that just doesn’t sit right with me. And I don’t know why.
I’ve given this question much more thought than it deserves, yet I remain both firm in my conviction and completely mystified as to why I feel this way. I have no significant issue with the 108mm models, so I don’t think the size alone is the problem. Maybe it’s the asymmetry?
I suppose it’s a very good thing we don’t all like the same things; otherwise finding those special SAKs from bygone days would be even harder than it already is.
Edited to add: I think I might have had an epiphany. I got “into” SAKs around 1985. I think perhaps if it doesn’t look like a SAK that was around at that time it isn’t a “real” SAK to me. Maybe.
I too have given this more thought than it deserves. (I also think that it deserves its own thread) I have to say, your criteria of symmetry is a good one.
If I ask you to define "chair"... I guarantee that you'd have some trouble.... Four legs? My chair right now has one leg and 5 feet. Square slab to sit on? Mine is triangular. Has a back support to it? Mine is an ergo-chair that has support in the front when I lean forward. We can go on an on..... But wait..... three legs and no back but you can sit on it? "Not a chair - a stool!" I say. Long flat rectangle with four legs and no back that you are sitting on? "Get off the table, I tell you!"
Plato called this "The Theory of Forms". In our somewhat collective imagination we have an idealized "form" of a SAK. We can't quite describe it but we know it when we see it. In this idea, we may have certain attributes - red, symmetrical, nonlocking, slipjoints, tools on back AND front..... or can it be locking, but must have a slipjoint anyway? The symmetry gets just one outlier in the 111mm shape - or does it?? Is a thumb stud going too far? If it doesn't have the patented dual-sided spring mechanism that Elsener invented, is it a SAK? Are the Alox models a SAK then?
In our collective imaginations, we have an "ideal" SAK, and we do have differnet ideals. In my mind, I can't imagine what "improvement" could be made on a SAK Soldier that would still allow it to be called a SAK. My only thought is to swap out the saw with one or two tools designed for use with other Swiss Army weapons or equipment. This would make it less useful for civilians but more of a "Soldier" tool.
-
-
@ElevenBlade said:
In 20 years from now, people will be searching for these modern Soldiers as a BYSAK. It's all about perspective.
Have these been discontinued?
Another question I thought I'd ask here, does the German version of the newer soldier have the date stamp? -
Nope and nope. The Model 2008 is current issue and has been from 2008. In my experience the hardest to find is 2008 itself and 2012. The rest are fairly easy. I usually look for the current year issue around the end of the year.
The equivalent GAK has never had the year of issue on its shank.
Myron
-
Thanks to an amazing forum member, I am now the happy owner of a Mod 1908 Elsener from 1936. I had been looking for one for a long time, since it's my father's birth year.


-
A hell of a relic.

-
Thanks guys! I used it for dinner tonight and it was amazing. :)

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

