Gareth's Sword Collection.
-
This one remimded me of a Shashka (russian sabre). Do you have any kind of experience, yelding or using those swords?
I think some folks here in MTo are into historical fencing.
Here, this might inspire you:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
:salute: :tu:
-
@pfrsantos said:
This one remimded me of a Shashka (russian sabre). Do you have any kind of experience, yelding or using those swords?I think some folks here in MTo are into historical fencing.
Here, this might inspire you:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
:salute: :tu:
Never studied any Russian systems but I did spend a good few years studying and teaching various other European sword systems. Mostly 19th century British sabre and 16-17th century Italian rapier and a few other things along the way :).
-
Nice

-
@Gareth said:
Never studied any Russian systems but I did spend a good few years studying and teaching various other European sword systems. Mostly 19th century British sabre and 16-17th century Italian rapier and a few other things along the way :).Some time ago, I looked for a place to learn/practice historical fencing. Found one, but they couldn't tell me how the classes worked, who would be teaching, what variants were available, would I need to buy any (and what) equipment/weapons... I just didn't like how disorganized it seemed, so I never tried it.
:P :-\
-
@Gareth said:
Today we are going to have a look at this infantry sabre. As mentioned above, civilians (in Western Europe) tended to either carry smallswords or light cuttoes/hangers and full on sabres were normally the preserve of the military. Even in this context though there is a distinction between the cavalry sabre and the infantry sabre. With cavalry swords tending towards the heavier and longer, infantry lighter and shorter and a grey area somewhere in the middle. So this particular sabre is definitely of a infantry proportion and is much lighter than it might at first appear at just 1 lb 8oz or 680g and with a blade length is 30" or 765mm. It's of a style that just pre-dates the more regulated sabre of 1803 so most likely dates from the 1790s. In general curved sabres were the normal choice for the officers of the "flank" companies; the Light and the Grenadier. The straight sword was intended for the "line" companies. What no photograph of mine can convey is just what a joy this sabre is to pick up and swing. The weight and balance is perfect. Nimble but strikes with authority. If I ever ended up in some weird Highlander-esque duel for my life this really would be the blade I'd pick.I really like this one , very cool

-
@pfrsantos said:
Some time ago, I looked for a place to learn/practice historical fencing. Found one, but they couldn't tell me how the classes worked, who would be teaching, what variants were available, would I need to buy any (and what) equipment/weapons... I just didn't like how disorganized it seemed, so I never tried it.:P :-\
Unfortunately the only instructor I've ever heard of in Portugal has been accused of being abusive to his students and claiming all kinds of qualifications and affiliations that he has no right to. I'd not recommend him. ;)
-
-
So next we come to the 1796 Infantry Officer's Sword. As with the bone handled sword from the 1770s we've already looked at this is of a type known as a spadroon. The British Army first brought in a set of regulations in 1786 and then updated them in 1796 to roughly standardise on a hilt and blade type that was already proving popular, so while these sword are universally know as 1796 swords the truth is that some of them will be a few years older. As we will see with our next sword there was still a huge amount of room for interpretation, though this example is quite typical. Sadly what was not standardised was any form of quality control...
This is a period when officers were required to purchase all their own equipment; uniforms, horse, campaign furniture and arms etc etc. How much time and money they spent on choosing their swords seems to have varied hugely. Some are perfectly good fighting weapons and others are, most definitely, not. The poor examples have blades of such inferior execution that they will all but droop under their own weight when held out horizontally. You would have about as much luck stabbing someone to death with a pool noodle. ;) This may be part of the reason Captain Mercer of the Royal Artillery said:
*
"Nothing could be more useless or more ridiculous than the old Infantry regulation [sword]; it was good neither for cut nor thrust and was the perfect encumbrance. In the Foot Artillery, when away from headquarters, we generally wore dirks instead of it."*However not all of these swords were anything like as bad as Capt Mercer claims and also I think it reliant that he was an Artillery officer and I can easily believe that a sword would indeed get in his way while trying to execute his duties, especially as he was even less likely to use it than was an officer of a regular line infantry. I'm happy to say that this example is IMO much better than Capt Mercer would have you believe.



-
@Gareth said:
Yeah, this and the messer are from the same lineage. The residual guard is part of why some see it as a poor choice for fighting and, while I utterly take the point, guards are somewhat secondary to good technique in parrying with the blade. The viewpoint gets skewed when modern martial artist fence over and over and get struck in the hand, so they understandably think less of a sword with poor hand protection. ** However a genuine life and death struggle is either going to be very short and bloody or very nervous and protracted.**Exactly.
Gorgeous sword btw. -
Excellent, enjoying very much!

-
So now we are going to see just how much flexibility there was in the interpretation of the 1796 regulation for officers sword. The option of a double edged blade was always there but they seem to have been MUCH less commonly used. While the previous spadroons could fairly be called cut-and-thrust weapons this sword, by the weight distribution and the way it handles, is clearly optimised for a thrust bias with some cutting ability. However the very stiff blade and fine point would punch through several layers of heavy woolen uniform, a problem often overlooked.
Also the guard is notably different in a few ways. Firstly; it has one side that can fold down flat. This was actually quite a common feature that was chosen as the shell was known to rub uncomfortably when being worn at the hip and damage the wearer's coat. Trivial as this might seem keep in mind that the officer was responsible for the purchase of his own uniform and they weren't cheap! 99% of the time you are wearing your sword, not holding it, and all that time it's potentially costing you money. The big downside is that the folding guard was poorly executed and shockingly weak. While this hilt is the same general shape as the previous one you can hopefully see that it's also very different in a may dimensions.
The fold flat guard also give another very interesting thought. On this particular sword it's clearly set up to sit flat against the right hip, indicating it was for a left handed gentleman. The replacement leather grip (in lieu of the missing silver wire) of would seem to back this up. Now there are definitely some other military sword that were specifically made for the left handed, but they are incredibly unusual. It's possible that this sword was taken apart at some point in it's life and reassembled incorrectly but if it was then it was a long time ago and I can't see any evidence of it. If only it could speak. :)




-
Extra pics.


-
Very cool !

-
Very nice

-
@Gareth said:
Yeah, this and the messer are from the same lineage. The residual guard is part of why some see it as a poor choice for fighting and, while I utterly take the point, guards are somewhat secondary to good technique in parrying with the blade. The viewpoint gets skewed when modern martial artist fence over and over and get struck in the hand, so they understandably think less of a sword with poor hand protection. However a genuine life and death struggle is either going to be** very short and bloody or very nervous and protracted**.Yeah, in HEMA the hands are popular targets if you want to play it safe (e.g. if you nee only one more point for the victory). I would assume that a lot of things we learn from HEMA translates to dueling. But battlefields are a completely different beast.
-
@Gareth said:
The fold flat guard also give another very interesting thought. On this particular sword it's clearly set up to sit flat against the right hip, indicating it was for a left handed gentleman. The replacement leather grip (in lieu of the missing silver wire) of would seem to back this up. Now there are definitely some other military sword that were specifically made for the left handed, but they are incredibly unusual.Maybe it was for the even rarer dual-wielding :D... which I, until recently thought is bonkers... but apparently it existed.
The example below is dated 1579, and if you look carefully you can see that the swords can be linked together at the handle.
-
-
@Etherealicer said:
Maybe it was for the even rarer dual-wielding :D... which I, until recently thought is bonkers... but apparently it existed.
The example below is dated 1579, and if you look carefully you can see that the swords can be linked together at the handle.Or to give it it's proper title a "case of rapiers". :D Very in vogue in the 16th Century dueling scene but never intended to be used in battle. The likes of Di Grassi recommends it as good practice in general and also because you might be challenged by someone who has taken the time to become proficient. I've tried it and fought against it but, if using properly weighted C16th rapiers, it'd be my last choice of off handed item. Give me a dagger, buckler, cloak or target over a second sword.
-
@Etherealicer said:
That is a gorgeous one... definitively my favorite so far.I love it too...aesthetically speaking anyway. ;) As a fighting sword I have my issues. It's only 480g (and most of that's in the hand) so while it would definitely be capable of slashing cuts it lacks any mass at the point of percussion to make for any kind of true impact. It's also very whippy so if your hand isn't perfectly behind the point it'll almost be guaranteed to flex rather than penetrate even a light coat. Still a lovely piece to own though. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login