Downsizing
-
Whatever is most comfortable to you.
I think its a good choice and good options.

-
@MacGyver said:
I think if you're going on that route, it's a great idea. But i'd suggest the Small Tinker (84mm) instead of the Tinker (91mm) plus the Classic SD, at least for urban/suburban EDC if you don't need the full 91mm length.
I carried the small tinker and classic sd alox on my keys for years. It's exactly the same as the regular Tinker, same tool thickness, it's juat a little shorter, there for more pocketable
If you must have full size scissors most of the time (like i do) than it's best to keep EDC-ing the Super Tinker ;)
I'm firmly with the Pioneer X these days, for a number of reasons.
Thanks MacGyver I was hoping you would comment. Where would you suggesting getting the small Tinker from?
-
@Steelej1976 said:
Thanks MacGyver I was hoping you would comment. Where would you suggesting getting the small Tinker from?Oh... i'm terrible suggesting online places to buy. I usually buy my sak's in the stores in my country, or sometimes a trusted national specialized online store.
Maybe some US members can give better pointers to places to buy over there than me...

-
Not a bad idea..... (yes I know... after having badmouthed combos forever)
I did the Soldier+Micra combo for a stretch because I wanted full-sized scissors. Then I switched to the Pioneer X that I EDC now, so that I can carry just one tool. Am I overjoyed with this single SAK option? No, not completely.
The extra weight of the Pioneer X took some getting used to, in a way that no other carry .... not even the Soldier + Micra, or a 111mm did. Also, it's not as versatile as I had hoped. if I'm honest... The extra bulk is a drawback when I'm wearing slacks... and that includes at work on some days.
In retrospect, there were times at work when I left the soldier in my coat and did all those little things with the Micra attached to the keys.... and the reverse as well, leaving the keys in the coat and the Soldier in the pocket.
Also, the combination provides you with a modular system for your different activities, instead of an all out switch to a different tool. You can carry one or the other... or swap one out, if you're going on a trip or vacation, or out on a hike.
I'm thinking that the Soldier+Ambassador combo would have been good for me in hindsight.
-
@MacGyver said:
Oh... i'm terrible suggesting online places to buy. I usually buy my sak's in the stores in my country, or sometimes a trusted national specialized online store.Maybe some US members can give better pointers to places to buy over there than me...

It's ok I can order it right from Victorinox directly. It is too much money on Amazon. Thanks again for the suggestion!
-
Sounds like a good idea to me. And I’m not a big minimalist.
I think my only preference if going that minimal would be to make it a Signature Lite. No need to double-up on even the T&T.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Not a bad idea..... (yes I know... after having badmouthed combos forever)I did the Soldier+Micra combo for a stretch because I wanted full-sized scissors. Then I switched to the Pioneer X that I EDC now, so that I can carry just one tool. Am I overjoyed with this single SAK option? No, not completely.
The extra weight of the Pioneer X took some getting used to, in a way that no other carry .... not even the Soldier + Micra, or a 111mm did. Also, it's not as versatile as I had hoped. if I'm honest... The extra bulk is a drawback when I'm wearing slacks... and that includes at work on some days.
In retrospect, there were times at work when I left the soldier in my coat and did all those little things with the Micra attached to the keys.... and the reverse as well, leaving the keys in the coat and the Soldier in the pocket.
Also, the combination provides you with a modular system for your different activities, instead of an all out switch to a different tool. You can carry one or the other... or swap one out, if you're going on a trip or vacation, or out on a hike.
I'm thinking that the Soldier+Ambassador combo would have been good for me in hindsight.
I think that is what hung me up is the single SAK that covers everything. What got me thinking of changing things up was my wife's classic and how handy that thing is and how much it can do on it's own. I know it is not as good as the 91mm scissors but I like the idea of always having a classic on my keychain and not that I want to sound cliche but the 2 is 1, 1 is none saying has some merit and given I only carry my Super Tinker right now it might be beneficial have a backup no matter how small it is. Also for most scissors tasks that I do I think the classic can cover it when I am out and about. I saw a review on here of a guy who torture tested a classic and he opened a can of beans or something like that with the scissors by cutting it open.
Also I was reading about MacGyver (tv show) and how he carried the Camper but never even used the Saw.
Main point being he got a lot done with just a Spartan, Recruit, and Tinker. I don't know I will see how it goes and if I don't like it all it cost me is the price of a Tinker and a Classic and I will still have my Super Tinker as a go too. If I was to get an Alox I agree with you it would be a Solider/Pioneer and pair it with a classic or like you said an Ambassador. Thanks ElevenBlade!
-
@kamakiri said:
Sounds like a good idea to me. And I’m not a big minimalist.I think my only preference if going that minimal would be to make it a Signature Lite. No need to double-up on even the T&T.
I might need to do that quick then. It looks like they are sale on Victorinox and that they are discontinuing them. Thanks for the suggestion.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
I think that is what hung me up is the single SAK that covers everything. What got me thinking of changing things up was my wife's classic and how handy that thing is and how much it can do on it's own. I know it is not as good as the 91mm scissors but I like the idea of always having a classic on my keychain and not that I want to sound cliche but the 2 is 1, 1 is none saying has some merit and given I only carry my Super Tinker right now it might be beneficial have a backup no matter how small it is. Also for most scissors tasks that I do I think the classic can cover it when I am out and about. I saw a review on here of a guy who torture tested a classic and he opened a can of beans or something like that with the scissors by cutting it open.Also I was reading about MacGyver (tv show) and how he carried the Camper but never even used the Saw.
Main point being he got a lot done with just a Spartan, Recruit, and Tinker. I don't know I will see how it goes and if I don't like it all it cost me is the price of a Tinker and a Classic and I will still have my Super Tinker as a go too. If I was to get an Alox I agree with you it would be a Solider/Pioneer and pair it with a classic or like you said an Ambassador. Thanks ElevenBlade!
I want to do a keychain size tool challenge at some point... I'm going to wait until next year when the planned 30 day challenges are done, so that everyone else can join if they want. Maybe because of lockdown, and not doing the outdoor recreation I normally do... I think I could get by with a keychain carry of some sort. Until this phase of life... I got a just about everything done with the soldier +/- scissors. The Classic won't do it for me though... I carried that on the keys for a while and never used it (but that could be due to it being old, second hand, and in disrepair)
As Kamakiri alludes to... the doubling up on the T&T would annoy me. But I think we're onto something Steelej1976.

-
@Steelej1976 said:
I might need to do that quick then. It looks like they are sale on Victorinox and that they are discontinuing them. Thanks for the suggestion.And thanks for the heads up on the discontinuation.
MTO- co-enabling and team enabling at its best!

-
If you want to avoid double T&T you could also get a classic in alox. I actually prefer those for the keychain. My wife has hers on for over a year now, and it still looks good as new.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
Well after much debate I think I have decided to Downsize from my Super Tinker to a Tinker&Classic SD. I love the Super Tinker but I like the idea of splitting the load between two pockets instead of one.What do you guys think?
Never hurts to try it out. I tried going from a Climber to an Alox Soldier + Classic for a while (this was before the Pioneer X existed as a factory model). I appreciated the extra toughness and robustness of the Alox Soldier, as well as the superb end-mounted awl; I also got some use out of the nail file on the Classic. However, I ended up switching back to the Climber/Mountaineer at the time. YMMV, but there were several major reasons I ended up switching back:
-
The extra edge length and leverage afforded by the 91mm scissors over the 58mm scissors really does make a difference in some situations, e.g. trimming fingernails.
-
I didn't like having an extra EDC item to keep track of, having gone from one SAK to two SAKs.
-
Carrying two SAKs created an additional decision point: every time I needed a tool, I had to consider (consciously or subconsciously) which one would be better for the task. When you only carry one SAK, that's the one you reach for; no consideration required.
Finally, you're not saving or re-distributing much weight. Consider the followings weights (all weights in ounces):
-
Super Tinker: 3.0
-
Tinker Small: 1.9
-
Classic: 0.7
So, by going from the Super Tinker to the Tinker Small + Classic, you're saving 0.4 ounces and redistributing 0.7 ounces. 0.4 ounces is basically the weight of two US quarters...
-
-
I quite like a slimmer primary SAK, and a secondary 58mm in a coin pocket.
I often end up with an alox Cadet or Pioneer, plus a Manager.
I prefer tough alox for the large SAK, but also want T&T, nail file and scissors. The 58mm is also small enough to be used unnoticed around the sheeple.
-
@nate j said:
Never hurts to try it out. I tried going from a Climber to an Alox Soldier + Classic for a while (this was before the Pioneer X existed as a factory model). I appreciated the extra toughness and robustness of the Alox Soldier, as well as the superb end-mounted awl; I also got some use out of the nail file on the Classic. However, I ended up switching back to the Climber/Mountaineer at the time. YMMV, but there were several major reasons I ended up switching back:- The extra edge length and leverage afforded by the 91mm scissors over the 58mm scissors really does make a difference in some situations, e.g. trimming fingernails.
- I didn't like having an extra EDC item to keep track of, having gone from one SAK to two SAKs.
- Carrying two SAKs created an additional decision point: every time I needed a tool, I had to consider (consciously or subconsciously) which one would be better for the task. When you only carry one SAK, that's the one you reach for; no consideration required.
Finally, you're not saving or re-distributing much weight. Consider the followings weights (all weights in ounces):
- Super Tinker: 3.0
- Tinker Small: 1.9
- Classic: 0.7
So, by going from the Super Tinker to the Tinker Small + Classic, you're saving 0.4 ounces and redistributing 0.7 ounces. 0.4 ounces is basically the weight of two US quarters...
Call me crazy, but that extra decision point to make is quite concious and can slow you down when you're a SAK nut like me. I get enjoyment out of using tools, and I have to decide which one is more enjoyable for that particular instance.
-
Alox 58mm would also be a good way to eliminate the redundant T&T, if the pen and lite don’t appeal for the added ‘bulk’.
@ElevenBlade said:
The Ambassador is on sale and already out of stock.
Good thing I don’t need one (or any more) of those. Sapphire isn’t on sale for the Signature/Swiss Lite...and I guess the name was changed. Sale price for the standard red is pretty nice. Might be a good enough excuse to get one.
-
Second suggestions for a small Tinker instead of a regular one.
My personal choice is a Tourist (84mm Spartan) with Rambler. I find the corkscrew more useful than the back Phillips, if less comfortable in the hand. The Rambler gives you a slim combo tool with a #0 to #2 Phillips that can sub in for the back Phillips as long as torque is kept reasonable. The blade and scissors open in the same direction, away from the keyring.
The Rambler is a capable carry on its own, and ideal for those times when you leave your larger knife behind by accident or design.
The Recruit is a lightweight and comfortable 84mm choice if you don't think you need the CS or back Phillips or awl.
You don't have to buy new. All aforementioned 84mm knives and the Rambler are common used and in good condition on the big auction site.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login