Combo tool vs opener layer
-
@jph_777 said:
I prefer the combo tool on a day-to-day, general use basis, as I get more bang for the buck in a smaller carry. If I know I am going into a situation where I will need to use the can opener a lot, I may carry a SAK with an opener layer. My usual carry is a Yeoman mod, so I have a great philips SD, and the combo tool is a good flat head/slotted SD. In short, it depends on what I'm going to do each day. If I had to choose one or the other, it would be the combo tool.Although, having the Philips along with the Combo tool does significantly increase the utility of the model overall, doesn't it? So then the question is - would you rather have a Compact or a Climber?
-
ElevenBlade... Yep, a real philips always works better than either the combo tool, or the can opener tool. That's why I love the Yeoman setup so much. Regarding Compact vs. Climber for pocket carry, I have always taken the Compact, as it is only two layers compared to the Climber's three layers, and I have never found myself (yet) wishing that I had the opener layer over the combo tool in any given real life situation. Having said that, I think the climber is a great model, and I have 3 of them. When I want to carry three layers, it will be the Yeoman. If I am carrying in a bag, and size doesn't matter, my usual choice is an Explorer or perhaps a Champion (or maybe multple SAKs!) :D
-
@jph_777 said:
ElevenBlade... Yep, a real philips always works better than either the combo tool, or the can opener tool. That's why I love the Yeoman setup so much. Regarding Compact vs. Climber for pocket carry, I have always taken the Compact, as it is only two layers compared to the Climber's three layers, and I have never found myself (yet) wishing that I had the opener layer over the combo tool in any given real life situation. Having said that, I think the climber is a great model, and I have 3 of them. When I want to carry three layers, it will be the Yeoman. If I am carrying in a bag, and size doesn't matter, my usual choice is an Explorer or perhaps a Champion (or maybe multple SAKs!) :D
I carry a Compact instead of a Climber too. But it seems that when I have my "just in case" carry.... which is 90% of the time.... its the opener layer. Because even though I may not need it, it's just in case. -
I’ve been experimenting with the combo tool either in standard knives or my own combination of tools and because I don’t ever open cans I prefer the layer reduction myself - that’s what I voted. I have a Compact at the moment but I expect it won’t be long before I take it apart and transplant the combo into something else. I have a red Alox bantam too though and that is probably one of favourite formats full stop for edc at least ....mind you my absolute favourite combo too is the one on my Manager keychain carry! Incorporate that in an 84 or 91mm and you have a whole world of other options!!
-
I think I finally made up my mind on this topic:
I prefer the opener layer on the 91/93mm series, but prefer the combo tool on the 84mm series. The reason for this is that the combo tool is a little sturdier than the can opener on the 84's when being used as a screwdriver. I twisted the tip on my cadet the other day, but have not managed to twist the combo tool yet :D
-
Still a firm believe in the opener layer, in any size, and still the two more used tools on a sak, for me.
However i can get by with the combo tool if i'm carrying a Compact or similar ;)BTW, never forget that loosing the opening layer also means you are loosing the awl and the small blade, not just the individual bottle and can opener

-
wooo....necro thread!
My issue with the combo tool is that it does none of its jobs well. The combo tool, since it it's also a can opener, will punch through a bottle cap if you're not careful. Also it's sorta pants as a screwdriver.
But... that's sacrifice you have to make if you want to drop a layer. For example: Climber vs Compact.
The combo tool: If I never think I'll use it, then I'll have it on a SAK. It's perfect as a "better than nothing" option. That makes the combo tool perfect as a minimalist EDC option.
-
Since I never, ever use either the bottle opener or can opener, I'm for the combo tool all the way.
-
Now I know the mod I must make.
Normally, I somewhat dislike the repetitive ’debates’. But sometimes they get you to revisit old ideas and paths not yet taken.
-
@kamakiri said:
Normally, I somewhat dislike the repetitive ’debates’. But sometimes they get you to revisit old ideas and paths not yet taken.good point. I was just thinking more about the combo tool today and I had this thought:
-
**for 84mm; combo tool
-
[b]for 91mm; opener layer
The rationale: the bottle and the can openers on the 84mm are a little too small to be as effective as their bigger 91mm counterparts. So if I'm going [b]small** with 84mm, I might as well also go thin and drop the opener layer.
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login