The Nessmuk Challenge
-
-
-
Actually got out in the woods today

Just a quick walk with the family so nothing exciting, but I did test my new Sawyer filter
First impressions are that it's a easy little filter that does what it's suppossed to. A bit slower to fill the squeese pouch than a water bottle, but not to bad. It doesn't remove any taste but I didn't think it would.
Filled it with very clean water without much debris in it, since I wasn't going to boil it or make some tea or anything. Overall I'm very happy with my filter and it feels like a great filter for the price

Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
That's awesome! The lightweight water bag really did revolutionize how people treat/carry water outdoors.

It's a shame the Juice and Leap line of plier-based MT is discontinued from LM, especially Leap, that's the perfect plier tool for outdoor use.
-
I was always a Juice fan. Glad I still have one.

-
@comis said:
That's awesome! The lightweight water bag really did revolutionize how people treat/carry water outdoors.
It's a shame the Juice and Leap line of plier-based MT is discontinued from LM, especially Leap, that's the perfect plier tool for outdoor use.
I still prefer a water bottle though

Was considering getting a Grayl filter, but it cost about 5x what I paid for the Sawyer.Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
@comis said:
That's awesome! The lightweight water bag really did revolutionize how people treat/carry water outdoors.
It's a shame the Juice and Leap line of plier-based MT is discontinued from LM, especially Leap, that's the perfect plier tool for outdoor use.
We still can get the Leap in stores over here, is it worth picking up?
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
@RF52 said:
I still prefer a water bottle though
Was considering getting a Grayl filter, but it cost about 5x what I paid for the Sawyer.Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
Though I think highly of the collapsible bottles, I too am actually a big fan of the Nalgene and Klean kanteen bottles. I did remember seeing the Grayl from a youtube review, it looks quite promising but I agree the higher price may not justify itself(especially I don't use it often enough).
@RF52 said:
We still can get the Leap in stores over here, is it worth picking up?Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
I think Leap is an acquired taste. In terms of MT, I tend to see different crowd of consumers, there are those whom want their tool to be super robust and overbuilt, so they could be almost indestructible unless serious abuse. The ST300 or Surge probably would fall in this category. On the other hand, there are also users whom don't mind trading that 'robustness' for lighter weight and easy carry. Juice and Leap are the perfect example of this category. I like Leap for outdoor use, since I probably don't need it for anything that may require 'heavy lifting', but the pliers are sturdy enough for very light tweaking or fixing(stove/tent/holding hold pot lid etc).
-
Day 6

Wildlife hatchet attended quick coffee duty today. Materials and gears are arriving soon, and am expecting more use for my tools soon.
-
@comis said:
Though I think highly of the collapsible bottles, I too am actually a big fan of the Nalgene and Klean kanteen bottles. I did remember seeing the Grayl from a youtube review, it looks quite promising but I agree the higher price may not justify itself(especially I don't use it often enough).I think Leap is an acquired taste. In terms of MT, I tend to see different crowd of consumers, there are those whom want their tool to be super robust and overbuilt, so they could be almost indestructible unless serious abuse. The ST300 or Surge probably would fall in this category. On the other hand, there are also users whom don't mind trading that 'robustness' for lighter weight and easy carry. Juice and Leap are the perfect example of this category. I like Leap for outdoor use, since I probably don't need it for anything that may require 'heavy lifting', but the pliers are sturdy enough for very light tweaking or fixing(stove/tent/holding hold pot lid etc).
And you have to change the Grayl filter cartridge every 3 months after you start using it, and the cartridge cost a little more than a Sawyer

I'm considering getting the Leap for the kid, for when she gets old enough for her own tool

Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
The Grayl is interesting but a bit pricey, I think.
I don't see the Grayl as having sufficient benefits to warrant switching away from my Sawyers.

-
The Sawyers can be damaged by freezing. It is easy to keep the filter in a pocket inside a jacket or sleeping bag to keep them from freezing.
I assume the Grayl is also vulnerable to freezing. Not sure how easy it would be to carry the Grayl without it freezing in cold weather. I've had water bottle freeze up on some cold weather hikes. At night, I'll keep a bottle inside my sleeping bag. Would you keep a Grayl inside your sleeping bag?

With enough snow, I just melt water as needed. So the water filter isn't a huge deal in the dead of Winter.
-
@RF52 said:
And you have to change the Grayl filter cartridge every 3 months after you start using it, and the cartridge cost a little more than a Sawyer
I'm considering getting the Leap for the kid, for when she gets old enough for her own tool

Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
Hope she will like it as much as I do.

@Nix said:
The Sawyers can be damaged by freezing. It is easy to keep the filter in a pocket inside a jacket or sleeping bag to keep them from freezing.I assume the Grayl is also vulnerable to freezing. Not sure how easy it would be to carry the Grayl without it freezing in cold weather. I've had water bottle freeze up on some cold weather hikes. At night, I'll keep a bottle inside my sleeping bag. Would you keep a Grayl inside your sleeping bag?

With enough snow, I just melt water as needed. So the water filter isn't a huge deal in the dead of Winter.
Very good point on freezing water bottles/filter, I most certainly didn't use it in freezing weather enough to even remember this potential issue. Awesome tips!

-
@Nix said:
The Sawyers can be damaged by freezing. It is easy to keep the filter in a pocket inside a jacket or sleeping bag to keep them from freezing.I assume the Grayl is also vulnerable to freezing. Not sure how easy it would be to carry the Grayl without it freezing in cold weather. I've had water bottle freeze up on some cold weather hikes. At night, I'll keep a bottle inside my sleeping bag. Would you keep a Grayl inside your sleeping bag?

With enough snow, I just melt water as needed. So the water filter isn't a huge deal in the dead of Winter.
Melting snow for water is great in cold weather and usually everywhere in winter so waterfiltration shouldn't be needed then

But it's good to keep in mind that filters can freeze
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
@Alan K. said:
I think the site went down for awhile. I was unable to log in for a couple of hours this afternoon, and it might have been out longer than that.Ahh ok

@comis said:
Love this setup, do you use the fuel tablets or prefer something else? I felt the tablets sometimes would create a thick layer of soot at the bottom of the pot, and I'd have to smear a layer of detergent on the bottom to save me from cleaning it up afterwards.I go Military style, Firedragon fuel with a simple BCB fold up stove, i found that works best for my needs as more often than not i'm just boiling water, it packs up into nothing and goes with a spark in any weather. I didn't like Hexamine or any liquid fuel and mostly used gas but the last time my gas run out i started using the BCB stove i kept in my car for emergencies and just stayed with it, of course gas is quicker but i'm never in a rush and happy to wait an extra few minutes, you can also store three tabs in it when folded and that's plenty enough, the BCB setup ticks all the boxes for me
As far as soot is concerned, its minimal and just washes off

Day 6 Just the Ka-Bar today, it had the important job of cutting a Danish pastry in half


-
Actually got out in the woods today

Just a quick walk with the family so nothing exciting, but I did test my new Sawyer filter
First impressions are that it's a easy little filter that does what it's suppossed to. A bit slower to fill the squeese pouch than a water bottle, but not to bad. It doesn't remove any taste but I didn't think it would.
Filled it with very clean water without much debris in it, since I wasn't going to boil it or make some tea or anything. Overall I'm very happy with my filter and it feels like a great filter for the price

Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
Glad to hear your happy with it and that you got to get out.
@Nix said:
The Sawyers can be damaged by freezing. It is easy to keep the filter in a pocket inside a jacket or sleeping bag to keep them from freezing.I assume the Grayl is also vulnerable to freezing. Not sure how easy it would be to carry the Grayl without it freezing in cold weather. I've had water bottle freeze up on some cold weather hikes. At night, I'll keep a bottle inside my sleeping bag. Would you keep a Grayl inside your sleeping bag?

With enough snow, I just melt water as needed. So the water filter isn't a huge deal in the dead of Winter.
Because of how hot it gets here, I love the insulated SS bottles, but I can also see where there could be some advantage in freezing temperatures as well.
@RF52 said:
I still prefer a water bottle though
Was considering getting a Grayl filter, but it cost about 5x what I paid for the Sawyer.Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
I prefer a water bottle as well, but the soft bags are nice for minimizing weight on longer hikes or just in case.
Depending on the type of bottle you have there are some filter options that you can buy that fit right on the bottle. My favorite combination is a hydroflask trail bottle that I use an Aquamira Shift filter cap on.
-
I go Military style, Firedragon fuel with a simple BCB fold up stove, i found that works best for my needs as more often than not i'm just boiling water, it packs up into nothing and goes with a spark in any weather. I didn't like Hexamine or any liquid fuel and mostly used gas but the last time my gas run out i started using the BCB stove i kept in my car for emergencies and just stayed with it, of course gas is quicker but i'm never in a rush and happy to wait an extra few minutes, you can also store three tabs in it when folded and that's plenty enough, the BCB setup ticks all the boxes for me
As far as soot is concerned, its minimal and just washes off

Day 6 Just the Ka-Bar today, it had the important job of cutting a Danish pastry in half


Very beautiful picture.
I never tried the Firedragon fuel. I have a small stove that I carry some Esbit fuel tabs I use sometimes for heating water for.
-
@Alan K. said:
Day 06
The cat is still not clear on the concept of sleeping late on Sundays even though I've tried to explain it to him several times.
He woke me up to fix his breakfast so I used the Little Black Talon to open a new case of cat food. I put the plate of food on the floor and the little smurf walked away without eating any.

Great use. I frequently hear cats waking owners up.
I guess I’m lucky that my dog loves sleeping in and rarely wakes me up.
-
@Sos24 said:
Glad to hear your happy with it and that you got to get out.Because of how hot it gets here, I love the insulated SS bottles, but I can also see where there could be some advantage in freezing temperatures as well.
I prefer a water bottle as well, but the soft bags are nice for minimizing weight on longer hikes or just in case.Depending on the type of bottle you have there are some filter options that you can buy that fit right on the bottle. My favorite combination is a hydroflask trail bottle that I use an Aquamira Shift filter cap on.
Thanks Sos

I think the Sawyer micro squeeze fits on regular soda bottles so that shouldn't be a problem
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


