SAK Polygamy?
-
@SgtTowser said:
Ron Who,I cannot decide if backpack SAKs should be part of pocket symbiotics, or separate.
Hmmmmmm.
I clearly have to work on the epistemology here.
Here are the basic levels of system interaction:
—Back. Pack SAKS
—Key Chain SAKs
—Pocket SAKs
We are faced with a conceptual choice of at least three types at this stage that I am not yet ready to face.
**1. Nested systems—maybe even concentric rings (pocket SAKs at the center, keychain SAKs next ring out, and backpack SAKs outermost.
-
Hierarchical
-
Networked **
Fascinating concept.
I've thought of the times where I have used multiple SAKs as a "Modular" concept, though I think that setting up the all-encompassing paradig at the outset is important - as you're doing.
For me... I really don't compliemnt my pocket carry with a keychain SAK. I suppose the complimentary models would be what you are referring to as Networked.
My idea of a modular system is what I suppose you would calll Nested. E.g. I would add a Trekker or a Champ to a Pioneer X if I am going on some sort of outdoor excursion. The pocket carry remains the primary tool. There is redundancy here, but the purpose is to add some extra functionality.
Now a hierachical system is something that I do... but that leads to SAK monogamy. It's the sort of decision that would lead me to carry a Compact instead of a Pioneer X for example.
Nested is more descriptive than Modular, in this scenario. So I rather like the idea.
-
-
You're not alone. I carry a Recruit in the watch pocket for the excellent small blade and a Pioneer in the main pocket for the beefy tools and awesome reamer.
-
I'm absolutely a polygamist.
At all times: a Rambler on my keyring for scissors, nail file, #0 Phillips, and a backup blade. A truly excellent light duty all rounder, just a fantastic model.
At work and in the country: a Camper for the saw and small blade. Used to carry a Trailmaster at work until I got tired of the blade lock and lack of a small blade.
At work also: an alox Soldier for a longer blade than the Camper and general sturdiness and awl.
Sometimes also a Swisschamp for the metal saw/file, pliers, magnifier, and scaler. Too much of a pocket load to replace the Camper entirely. Ideally I'd have a SC stripped of the Spartan toolset to reduce size and redundancy!
Around town: a Tourist. Fits perfectly and discreetly in my jeans knife (watch) pocket. Has a tool pattern I've been accustomed to since I was a kid.
Travel: Tourist + SC.
All combos cover most eventualities in most situations.
-
Sawl Goodman,
Glad to hear SAK polygamy works for you.
And you trigger a question.
Why doesn’t Vic (and Wenger when they were still in business) make two ownership paths: a) free standing knives with same basic layers plus specialized layers [their current approach]; or b.) knife suites that include a basic 2-layer knife and a specialized multi layer knife that leaves out the first 2-3?
Obviously they have thought this through and decided to sell only free standing knives at the 91/93/111/130mm level that can be a suite with their 58s, or be replaced by a freestandings with more layers.
Still, what you suggest makes sense: one 2-3 layer knife with the basics, and other multi layer knives with all but the two basic layers. This way they could sell one knife and the buyer would then buy a complementary knife, instead of a replacement knife.
By doing the above, then their installed user base would have a chance to buy, or upgrade not one, but two knives, as needed. And those that want only free standing solutions could still have them. On set of cap lifter/can opener is enough in SAK polygamy.
I know they must have a good reason, but I don’t understand it and I am hoping someone can explain their reasoning to men.
-
Variety is a good thing. I like to let myself carry a large range of different models.
In the pocket I'll carry a 2 or 3 layer knife, then in my EDC bag I'll rock a Swiss Champ or other large SAK, in case I need more speSmurfpillsed tools.
-
Amen Knight Charlie P
-
I am a SAK polygamist.
These days, I always have at least a primary 91mm or 93mm SAK in my pocket, plus an Alox Bantam in my wallet as backup.
In the past, I tried carrying an Alox Soldier + a Classic, but moved away from that combo.
I have also, in scenarios like work, camping, or farm, sometimes carried two large SAKs, typically of the 91mm, 93mm, and or 111mm varieties. The idea here was/is to have a SAK (preferably in a belt sheath) for dirty jobs and another SAK (in pocket) for clean jobs. I can use the dirty SAK with abandon, not worrying about the dirt, oil, chemicals, manure or whatever that may get on it, because I have the clean SAK always ready for food, cigars, etc.
In addition to the above, I also occasionally carry a Money Clip, which I then use primarily as a...you guessed it...money clip.
-
Went with huntsman and waiter today, like the mix of sizes
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I'm definitely in the SAK polygamist camp. For my EDC I have a MiniChamp on my key ring and an Explorer in my pocket. At work it's a MiniChamp with my keys and a Swiss Champ in a pouch on my belt. This combination covers about 90% of what I run in to in a given day at work. My EDC combo covers just about everything outside of work.
-
Cybertool 41 in a pouch in my front right pocket and a Rambler on my keychain.
Originally, I carried the Compact and added the Rambler for the Philips driver. Then I changed out the Compact for the CT41 and never removed the Rambler from my keychain.
Today I am a polygamist but the Rambler is redundant so I may be monogamous tomorrow.
-
To all...

-
If I'm going Alox, I also go 58mm, so I have those scale tools and scissors to hand.
If I'm going standard cellidor, chances are I'll only need the one knife with me.
-
EmarkM
Sound protocol.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login