Help needed for newbie
-
Nothing exists with your specs that I can think of anyway

-
New here and looking for advice from seasoned users
I'm looking for an EDC for work and hopeing you guys can point me in the right direction.
My requirements are a pliers based tool around 4" with pocket clip
Smooth blade preferably outside which is non locking or can be easily modded to be and is under 3" (UK)
Full length locking woodsaw
1/4" standard bit driver preferably locking
Awl
That's it, all I need.
What would you recommend?
Reassessing your requirements,to be honest!
My personal take would be to look at the older Leatherman models like the Fuse,which can be modded for the bits...al eith the LM 2d type,or an older SOG like a PPP or a Paratool. In all cases you need to do a mod to add the pocketclip, and pair it with a dedicated folder.
Having g said that,I will quote TaxiDads maxim: If the police are going to stop you,they will find a reason. (A case can be made that a lockable screw driver can be a weapon). In which case you might as well just get a tool with a OHO locking blade. On the basis of your other requirements,that might well be a Wave.
I lived in London for 18 years and carried a variety of multis ,SAKs and tactical folders without issue. I still carry a Spirit or Swisstool on a regular basis
-
Oh,and welcome to MTo

-
I would strongly consider something like the bladeless Leatherman Rebar or bladeless Gerber MP-600 paired with your regular daily carry knife.
-
Welcome to MTo.
Yeah that is a tough spec - Locking saw but not knife - Is very tricky! Usually if any tool is locking it is the blade!!
And I think the problem with the LM locking blades is that they fold in if you take out the locking mechanism.
I don't know the non-LM tools so wellDoesn't the law in the UK state that you cannot carry a locking blade > 3" etc etc ............ unless you have good reason to do so.
And wouldn't "I need it/use it every day for my work" .... be that good reason ?As mentioned LM Wave would be good
-
@Huntsman said:
Welcome to MTo.Yeah that is a tough spec - Locking saw but not knife - Is very tricky! Usually if any tool is locking it is the blade!!
And I think the problem with the LM locking blades is that they fold in if you take out the locking mechanism.
I don't know the non-LM tools so wellDoesn't the law in the UK state that you cannot carry a locking blade > 3" etc etc ............ unless you have good reason to do so.
And wouldn't "I need it/use it every day for my work" .... be that good reason ?As mentioned LM Wave would be good
You are correct Huntsman. I can carry my Surge whilst at work because I have both parts of the requirements covered. These are know here as "Statutory Defences" and are;
-
Lawful Authority: I am a Crown Servant, which also covers me for firearms (no I don't have one ::) but do handle them) and very few professions would cover the situation described.
-
Reasonable Excuse: It, the Surge (and seperate lock knife) are "tools of the trade"
However, outside of work (off duty) I can only rely on 2 (Reasonable Excuse) Therefore, I could argue that I was transporting it to/from my place of work. This happens frequently as I often work at different locations and need to take kit home the day before.
This defence may not cover me if I decided to stop off at the pub on the way home (see scenario below)Obviously, there are other situations where 2 may apply such as fishing, woodland camping etc. However, the onus is on the carrier to satisfy the Police Officer that the carriage/use is reasonable and, if not considered such by the Officer (I should have taken my Surge home and then gone to the pub) then I may face sanction. This could be arrest and prosecution where I will have to show why it was reasonable and therefore lawful (there is no published list with a set of activities that are considered exempt by default)
In the UK we have a lovely catch all defintion of "Offensive Weapon" which essentially means anything can be made out to be one if it's either "made" OR "adapted" and "intended" for use as such. This covers the obvious such as firearms and automatic knives, amongst others, which are "made" but also your standard, non-locking, sub 3" SAK if the use, intended or actual, is unlawful e.g. "I'm carrying it for self defence" "intended"
Therefore, a bunch of keys protruding between the fingers (knuckle-duster style) means a perfectly legal everyday item has been "adapted" and therefore falls foul.
I'm used to the law and understand it's application so would rarely be found in an awkward situation without "reasonable excuse" (hence my intended carry for the EDC in DEC challenge) but others may not and then will potentially find themselves in a world of pain.
As I have said previously, it's not the article (Surge) that is the potential problem rather the circumstances in which it is carried/used.
-
-
Thanks for the replies guys
I work from a van and cover a large area of the south of UK working in public areas, the highway and private, peoples property, I have to wear company issued ppe with logo, so maybe I can carry a locking tool/knife at work.
-
@Gasman said:
Thanks for the replies guysI work from a van and cover a large area of the south of UK working in public areas, the highway and private, peoples property, I have to wear company issued ppe with logo, so maybe I can carry a locking tool/knife at work.
I think you'd be safe in those circumstances

Personally, I'd go for the Surge if the bulk doesn't matter
(I guess we begin to resemble our tools
)I've had a Wave (not +) and loved it, until I got my Surge (again, not +) No reason for not buying the + models, they just weren't around at the time and I didn't have to pay for the Surge (issued, although not anymore :ahhh )
*NB: The Surge has been with me for about 8 years and, although the blade could do with replacing (heavy daily use) it is in perfect, if slightly grubby, nick. *
-
New here and looking for advice from seasoned users
I'm looking for an EDC for work and hopeing you guys can point me in the right direction.
My requirements are a pliers based tool around 4" with pocket clip
Smooth blade preferably outside which is non locking or can be easily modded to be and is under 3" (UK)
Full length locking woodsaw
1/4" standard bit driver preferably locking
Awl
That's it, all I need.
What would you recommend?
I don’t think there is one MT that covers everything you are looking for, unless you heavily mod it. But how about this combo:
Victorinox Farmer, for blade, awl and wood saw. The wood saw is non locking, but the backsprings are really strong. Never had one collapse on me.
Knipex Cobra. Very capable and more so than any MT pliers out there.
Victorinox L wrench and bit set.This set would cover all your needs, and should be perfectly UK legal

-
Given you are intending it to be part of your workplace tool kit I believe that you'd be well covered by the "good reason" clause, however I'm not a lawyer and you should still make your own judgement. :)
Gotta admit; I'm still coming up blank for something that covers everything you want. A Wave comes close if you buy the pocket clip but you're then tied to their in house flat bits. You could buy their bit driver extension that takes standard 1/4" but it's all starting to feel a bit clunky to me.
1/4" bit driver and pocket clips are still fairly uncommon features on multitools sadly.
-
These SOG tools might be as close as you'll get.
https://sogknives.com/poweraccess/ no saw but you could add one https://sogknives.com/double-tooth-saw/
https://sogknives.com/poweraccess-deluxe/ no pocket clip but you could add a NitIze pocket clip
https://www.amazon.com/Nite-Ize-HipClip-Attachable-Smartphones/dp/B007CBSBM4/ref=asc_df_B007CBSBM4/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=242029317319&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=3658463348938611664&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9019691&hvtargid=pla-421071754279&psc=1 -
I'm still waiting for the release date but...
GOAT Tools
Shop GOAT Tools for the ultimate in customizable, modular multi-tools. Our tools are built to last and come with a lifetime warranty. Whether you're a DIYer or a professional, GOAT Tools has the tools you need to get the job done right.
GOAT Tools (goat.tools)
-
@SurgeUk said:
I think you'd be safe in those circumstances
Personally, I'd go for the Surge if the bulk doesn't matter
(I guess we begin to resemble our tools
)I've had a Wave (not +) and loved it, until I got my Surge (again, not +) No reason for not buying the + models, they just weren't around at the time and I didn't have to pay for the Surge (issued, although not anymore :ahhh )
*NB: The Surge has been with me for about 8 years and, although the blade could do with replacing (heavy daily use) it is in perfect, if slightly grubby, nick. *

-
I pocket carried a wave for work for many years and i have not found a better tool if a pocket clip is essential. you would have to use leatherman screw driver bits if not using an extender, but i never wore one out. Although i only used it for when i unexpectedly encountered a screw or two and did not have a screwdriver to hand ( a regular occurrence ) otherwise i would go and get a screwdriver.
If you plan to put the saw to good use on a regular basis i would opt for a surge as the saw blade is replaceable. but if you are pocket carrying invest in a good belt to keep your trousers up :D
-
Thanks guys, a few options to look at there 👍
I'll take a look at a few but maybe wait until the end of the year to see what happens with the goat 😀
-
@SurgeUk said:
I'm still waiting for the release date but...
GOAT Tools
Shop GOAT Tools for the ultimate in customizable, modular multi-tools. Our tools are built to last and come with a lifetime warranty. Whether you're a DIYer or a professional, GOAT Tools has the tools you need to get the job done right.
GOAT Tools (goat.tools)
Wow - That looks interesting :think: - Looks like we have a thread on it too - And Mr. Goat is a member here :tu:
/topic/78900
-
I'd really like to see what you all come up with for the Goat.
I'm a simple man with simple needs these days.
-
Ok, I lied, I'm hooked
I can't wait for the goat
I now own, a dime, a Ambar drive (despite the terrible reviews) , a sidekick and a juice cs4 if it's in stock and not just lazy stocktaking.
I think that'll do for now but I feel a wave + & crunch on the cards before the years out.
That should be enough.
-
@Gasman said:
Ok, I lied, I'm hookedI can't wait for the goat
I now own, a dime, a Ambar drive (despite the terrible reviews) , a sidekick and a juice cs4 if it's in stock and not just lazy stocktaking.
I think that'll do for now but I feel a wave + & crunch on the cards before the years out.
That should be enough.
Seems like we have another convert. >:D

I've not tried the Armbar and some of those are quite Marmite multitools but in the end it comes down to what YOU want/like.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login