I'm getting fatter....
-
Probably some wise old coves are getting thinner. Carl seems to have slimmed down a good bit. Gareth seems to stay trim.
But me, I'm getting fatter.

*Classic, Cadet, Spartan, Evolution 14, Farmer X, Ranger, Deluxe Tinker, Handyman, Swiss Champ *When I was younger (and didn't want my pockets bulging with stuff) I carried thinner knives. For years I carried just a SAK Classic and a slim folding knife like a Buck Esquire or Osborne 940. While I may have liked to have a bit more capability in terms of tool selection, I wanted to stay "high speed, low drag".
Sure, on weekends I may have tossed a Spartan or Farmer in my pocket, but even three layers started to seem a bit much.
I recall quite distinctly a road trip back in 2007. Somewhere along the the way I lost the Climber that my grandfather had given me back in 1976. ( :'( ) I stopped in a little town in Wyoming and in a hardware store I debated between a new Climber and a Huntsman. The allure of scissors *and *saw was too much to bear....but I resisted and stuck with the thinner Climber.

After the road trip, the Climber went back into a drawer, and my weekday carry was the mighty Classic or Rambler....and a sandwich slicing folder.

On weekends or hikes, the Climber came along...or a Farmer..... And once I got used to three layers.....four layers started to seem reasonable. Four layers started to feel 'just right'.
Now, the Deluxe Tinker has become a favorite fishing knife. I like the tool set. And it is only four layers...right? But it is actually pretty close in size to a five layer Ranger.....maybe a bit bigger.
So a now a five layer SAK seems like a good idea.
Since I don't worry about my pants pockets bulging these days...a five layer SAK is no problem......so why not a six layer SAK?

And that SwissChamp has an excellent tool set. More than I really need or use.....but still.....nice to have a small screwdriver or mag glass........
Yeah, I'm getting fatter.......
What about you guys?
Are you trending thinner? You know what you like and need and can keep it down to a couple of layers?
Or, like me, is layer creep starting to set in? Do you find that your two layer SAK has grown a coupe of layers....?

-
As you I've started with an original Traveller (Climber without keyring). With my first self earned money a SwissChamp was next (aka more is better). Then a LM Supertool

At some point, probably when the Supertool tore a hole into my overall and fell onto my foot, I've realized that there is something like pocketability, and I was re-thinking my EDC.
A PST followed, then a Wave etc.
So I would say I went from Fat to Slimmer :PHowever, these days it is about what I would/could use/need and what carry method I have available for the task or event.
I do like to have multiple different options available to choose from then.
A Surge is there when needed as well as a Vic Classic or Executive.Sooo..... actually I went slimmer and fatter?
Maybe I justcannotdon't want to make up my mind.
:D -
I carry the Spartan. It has everything I need, and nothing I don't.
-
It's good to know what you like and need.

-
Not just you. I'm in the same boat.

I started with a Wenger Commander, a two layer opener layer/knife-nail file SAK and carried it from when I was twelve till maybe 17. Then I got a Wenger Forester in a trade for a Zippo. So I added a saw and scissors to the mix. And that was my true EDC for over a decade, about till I joined here some 10 :o years ago.
Then I carried multitools for a while, but got back to SAKs as my true love and carried a Wenger Traveller, so loosing the saw as I hardly ever, more like never needed it in an urban carry. And that remained my carry for years, in different scale variations.
As you may notice, I was and still am a big Wenger fan, but under influence of all this exposure to Vics here on the forum, I started looking at those too. I didn't like the size and weight addition the 91mm added compared to the 85mm Wengers, but the phillips tipped can opener won me over as I always preferred to have a corkscrew on the back layer so a back layered phillips didn't interest me. I still like the Wenger can opener better for cans, as a scraper and such, but I more often need a phillips screwdriver than I need a can opener.
I carried a variaty of SAKs for a while, to test them out and see what I liked and needed and liked the Rangers weight to size ratio the best. I personally think it's the most useful set of tools in a relatively small format ever made. But it was too much for me to comfortably carry in the pocket and a belt sheath with a knife seen doesn't fly in my line of work. So I carried smaller SAKs, like the Compact and Executive for some time.
Lately, like in the last year or so, I got back into carrying an EDC hip pouch. I always liked those as I'm not a fan of full pants pockets. And with the SAK not longer being pocket carried, the Ranger was back on the table, or in my EDC. :D And it remains my carry and it most likely will for a while. I haven't had a single moment when I wished that I carried some other SAK cause I needed a tool my EDC didn't have. I did exchange my old Ranger yesterday for another SAK, ... A NEW Ranger I got from Barry. :D My old one had the old style file that was basically only good for fingernails :p The new one has the new file, WAY better. Now it's perfect.

So my carry has varied throughout the years, it had gained and lost layers, and one could say my EDC SAK mainly depends on my method of carry. But I do prefer the versatility of the larger SAKs. I wouldn't go past the Ranger size thought, and I never liked the SAK pliers, neither Vic nor Wenger.
Wow, this post ended up a lot longer than I thought it would be :ahhh
Note to add. When I say EDC, I mean EDC in its true sence of the word, like in actuality carry every day for months, years even.

-
I recently got my Ranger from Alan. So far it seems like a great size and an excellent set of tools.
But....chomp, chomp, chomp....the Handyman has some very handy pliers......


-
Well I started fat and went through rapid weight loss, yet I'm starting to put it back on, cause I started with a champion+ and went to a farmer, then a PioneerX, and am looking to go with a farmerX, so I guess I burnt off the plastic and now getting an alox gut,,
JR -
My tastes and carries vary like my waist line
. I'd say I've actually gone thinner over the years. For decades it was the Huntsman. Now, it's probably a Spartan or Soldier, or occasionally a Climber. More often than not, a Yeoman from Sos24. It covers almost everything I run into on a normal day. My Alox live affair is reheated with the Old Cross Challenge. Decisions 
-
I've always been a 2 layer fan , started with a Spartan 3 decades ago, been through recruit , tinker, Pioneer, centurion since . Still, there's always more time , and as long as your carry brings you joy, who cares how fat you are

-
@Nix said:
After the road trip, the Climber went back into a drawer, and my weekday carry was the mighty Classic or Rambler....and a sandwich slicing folder.Or, like me, is layer creep starting to set in? Do you find that your two layer SAK has grown a coupe of layers....?

You know how I feel about sandwiches. What folder did you carry?
Layer creep ... Good terminology
I've been holding steady at the 2 to 3 layer mark. I envision that at some point I'll go to one extreme or the other.... Either Classic or Swisschamp. I don't know which one, but one day I'll probably decide to go for broke one way or another.
-
I think it has just become fun for me to carry a bigger toolset now. :D
With the Minimal challenge coming up....we'll see how much I miss some of the tools from the Swiss Champ and others......
@ElevenBlade said:
You know how I feel about sandwiches. What folder did you carry?For a long time it was either a Buck 501 Esquire or a Benchmade 940. Both slim, both capable of field dressing a sammie or burger. ;) I'm sure there were others, but those are the ones that stick out as my go-to EDC folders when paired with a Classic.
For several years my EDC was just a Cadet. The Cadet is super slim and as capable for most tasks as a Spartan.

-
Pretty much same here. I got a Farmer first but there was a period where the Bantam was mostly in my pocket. Then a Pioneer, then the Farmer again. Currently it is the '08 Soldier because I have to sharpen the Farmer's blade, but I'm looking at the Farmer X and Ranger to add a bit more capability
-
Started with a Explorer, but haven't quite gotten to Swisschamp level just yet.
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
@Nix said:
With the Minimal challenge coming up....we'll see how much I miss some of the tools from the Swiss Champ and others......I know you feel . I'm nervous about halving my layers, cant imagine how much of a change dropping multiple layers would be.
That's the whole point of the challenge though :) -
I think the layers I'd like to carry totally fluctuate with my waist line. It goes up and down from year to year, recently it's on a down tread(at least what I plan to with my waist line).
-
I'm afraid i've gotten a little fatter too....
I was mainly on the 84mm 2 layer camp (small tinker or tourist) with the classic on the keys, but i started to need the full sized scissors more, so i've gone to the Climber/super tinker, than went with the Compact gor some time, byt missed the opening layer and went back to the Climber and ocasional Huntsman when i go to rural areas. Went with the Explorer for a while, but i just couldn't justify it's bulk over the Climber only for the (fat) inline phillips layer (mag glass is near irrelevant to me)
Lately i've gone with the Deluxe Tinker, cause i figured i'd get real use out of the pliers, and i do.But i still wouldn't want to go past 4 layers though, it's still a good compromise between a pocket knife format and a "tool combo", and overall bulk for pocket carry and use comfort (not really bothered by the weight factor). I don't really feel the need to have the saw's on a regular edc basis.
-
I we always more is more advocate when I was younger - had 2 Swiss champs and a Explorer and still rate these as my favourites overall. These days I’ve slimmed down considerably for edc mainly relying on my key ring Manger for most eventualities - great knife. If I supplement that now I am almost always picking up a 1or 2 layer 84mm like a sportsman or waiter. Other than that if I’m in the woods with my bow I have a modded ranger that I call an ‘Archer’ that covers everything I could need. Soooo....slimmer but with the occasional pig out!

-
I've yo-yoed. I've carried a Swisschamp then slimmed to a Explorer. Very early on I carried a Recruit then tried a Ranger. I've tried Wenger 2 layers and 3 layers. I've gone to 84mm Recruits, Tinkers, and Salesman, then back to the Explorer. I got the urge to try the Champion again so thats what I am carrying vs my Wenger Cyclist these days for work. At home I enjoy carrying 2 layers. I go up then I go down in layers then back up.
-
I awlways enjoy these topics
I was doing just fine with the same Recruit for 25+ years then I met you guys
I'm quite comfortable with the 4 layer Fieldmaster in my pocket now, or the 111mm Outrider on my belt
-
As my waistline has gotten fatter in 2020 belt carry options for larger SAKs are a less comfortable option. The only Victorinox sheath I have is one that fits the Champion...and actually the sheath seems to be one layer too small 😕... So it doesn't matter in that regard. But the waistline needs to go.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

