Been doing some work in the Wiki
-
Thanks Nick.
Perhaps we could split the 84mm page into three distinct pages? Since there are three different versions of the 84mm frame (regular, slim and lobster, right?).
-
Hi Guys,
I don't think the **74/75mm split **was discussed before - The 75mm models were actually embedded in the one single list originally !!
- I took them out into a separate section a couple of years ago .
I would **<u>not </u>**do the split - Also **<u>not </u>for the 84s !! **
For me - Less is more.If you think about our Wiki users:
- Making them go to another page, where there is very little variation, or limited new content - when they can clearly and easily see all the information on one page, is, at least IMHO, user-unfriendly/unnecessary.
Although as you mention - I do agree that the 75 vs 74 families are pretty different!!
However I do have an idea for the 75s - Which I will implement as soon as I finish this post - Check it out here - Let me know - And we can keep or revert back. If we keep it - I'll make all the columns align
**Re: Addition of the scissor Accountants **- Yep add them in - Great !!

**Re: The 84mm Accountants **- Yep - I would recommend a new section in the 84mm page, as per the above

**Re: Addition of any old model numbers **- Yep add them in - Great !! :tu
Thanks Reinier for the recent updates and also NeleDo for the updated Delemont image - Has anyone put it in yet??
-
Your link goes to the main page.

-
Yep - That's it
Although on my screen the line does not wrap - Which looks a bit better
I think if you dont leave gaps also it does not wrap....Thoughts?
-
I vote separate page.
Yes, less is more, but correct is better :P -
There is a stub reference to the 75mm range under "Others", with a link to the gallery....
SAKWiki | Victorinox Plier Multitools - Swiss Card - Others
SAKWiki - The online Swiss Army Knife Encyclopedia. Information and Identification on Swiss Army Knives by Victorinox and Wenger.
SAKWiki (www.sakwiki.com)
I would vote to have a separate page for the 75s if there's enough content?
-
Yes and I just fixed the gallery link on the 74mm page but there is no link to the 75mm gallery there.
The 75mm section on the Others page should be removed in my opinion.
Also, the Baker's Knife should not be listed under 91mm
Just my 2 cents.
-
I added the 75mm gallery to the relevant 74mm pages - To at least get the current set up *more *correct, whilst we discuss !!
And as it was a quick and easy change
At the moment we seem to be 3:1 in favour of a new page for the 75s!!
;) >:D
If we did do this: .......
Would we put the new page under ***Others ***to replace the current gallery link - As the 75s are not really a proper or large family and the three models themselves are a little different from each other
(We did this for the non mainline Wenger sizes....)
Or would we create a new 75mm line in the main menu section in the side panel ? ???
**
Re the Bakers' knife: **
Again that model was originally just in the main alphabetical list - So I moved it out to the bottom!!
However - Agreed Reinier - It is a bit of an anomaly on the 91mm pages - Would you put it on the ***Others ***page? ???
Probably a better home for it! - I'd say go for it! -
My interpretation is that the "others" page is dedicated to Victorinox products that do not fit into the traditional SAK pocket knife design, so is a catch-all for unusual products, or divergent product lines, like the Hunter and Swisstool.
So I would rather see the 75mm removed from the "others" page and promoted to their rightful place alongside their larger and smaller brothers and sisters. Even if there are only three models, it will help to give them the visibility they deserve (and maybe create more interest for collectors).
-
Think the 74/75 listing works well, easy to find and considering just the 3 models, having them listed at the bottom as they are seems fine
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@Max Stone said:
My interpretation is that the "others" page is dedicated to Victorinox products that do not fit into the traditional SAK pocket knife design, so is a catch-all for unusual products, or divergent product lines, like the Hunter and Swisstool.So I would rather see the 75mm removed from the "others" page and promoted to their rightful place alongside their larger and smaller brothers and sisters. Even if there are only three models, it will help to give them the visibility they deserve (and maybe create more interest for collectors).
I'd think it may be beneficial to move Swisstool out of 'others' too, since I think it is an important product offerings in Victorinox lineup, and to place it along with Travelling alarm seems to diminish it's importance(maybe Pliers-based tool?). Another humble suggestion is to create a new page for 'Knives', since Vic does have a large offering in various kind of knives(kitchen, fixed blade, folding knives, etc) -
I totally disagree. Different size, different shape/frame type.
I'm with Max on this one.
We will never all agree I guess
Talking about Others: should we add models like the Outdoor Master Mic? Personally I'm not interested in them since they are not SAKs. But then again, we also mention the Travel Alarms

Also, I think we should add a "Specials" page, listing models like the HP SpatuClimber, Fuchs SAK with technician's screwdriver, Mammut Climber, 111mm Outdoortool with in-line awl, etc. What do you guys think? I know some of those are currently listed like the regular models or mentioned in the Variations and/or Identifiers sections.
-
I took the liberty to add a 93mm 4 layer page. Yes, I know there's only one model (yet :P ), but I see no reason why it shouldn't be added.
By the way, what does the rogue 3 in the 100mm section mean? (sidebar table)? The page does exist (https://sakwiki.com/Victorinox+100mm+3+Layer+Models) but there's no link and I can't think of any models to add. Maybe some vintage ones from a million years ago?
-
Definitely a prehistoric placeholder from the Cambrian era :D
-
We actually did have this discussion some years ago and it was decided that 3 models is too little for a separate page and newcomers to SAKs would find it difficult to find. Heck we have more models on a single Cybertool or a Champion page than we would on a parental level page as is the layer category.
And folks, especially newcomers don't go around with calipers to find out if their SAK is 74 or 75mm. Especially considering that with the downsizing of the 74mm line from the Vic lineup these will both be historical pages soon with no more additions to be added.
I was against the merger of model pages that were done for a number of reasons, but in this case, I think it would be better if we left them as is.
-
The fact that on Sakwiki we have only three models in 75mm range, absolutely does not mean that only these three models exists.
In general: 74 and 75 lineups definitely different entities and should be presented in different pages.
Just my 2 cents, nothing more. [emoji6]
P.S. AFAIK, 68mm range of SAKs are the same models as 75mm (just smaller). Should they have own page or share the same page with 75mm? (a rhetorical question)
-
Excellent point Alex

-
Afaik all so far included in this discussion are editors and admins on the wiki. So if you know of or have other 75 or 74mm models that aren't so far listed in the wiki, by all means add them.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
