Been doing some work in the Wiki
-
I totally disagree. Different size, different shape/frame type.
I'm with Max on this one.
We will never all agree I guess
Talking about Others: should we add models like the Outdoor Master Mic? Personally I'm not interested in them since they are not SAKs. But then again, we also mention the Travel Alarms

Also, I think we should add a "Specials" page, listing models like the HP SpatuClimber, Fuchs SAK with technician's screwdriver, Mammut Climber, 111mm Outdoortool with in-line awl, etc. What do you guys think? I know some of those are currently listed like the regular models or mentioned in the Variations and/or Identifiers sections.
-
I took the liberty to add a 93mm 4 layer page. Yes, I know there's only one model (yet :P ), but I see no reason why it shouldn't be added.
By the way, what does the rogue 3 in the 100mm section mean? (sidebar table)? The page does exist (https://sakwiki.com/Victorinox+100mm+3+Layer+Models) but there's no link and I can't think of any models to add. Maybe some vintage ones from a million years ago?
-
Definitely a prehistoric placeholder from the Cambrian era :D
-
We actually did have this discussion some years ago and it was decided that 3 models is too little for a separate page and newcomers to SAKs would find it difficult to find. Heck we have more models on a single Cybertool or a Champion page than we would on a parental level page as is the layer category.
And folks, especially newcomers don't go around with calipers to find out if their SAK is 74 or 75mm. Especially considering that with the downsizing of the 74mm line from the Vic lineup these will both be historical pages soon with no more additions to be added.
I was against the merger of model pages that were done for a number of reasons, but in this case, I think it would be better if we left them as is.
-
The fact that on Sakwiki we have only three models in 75mm range, absolutely does not mean that only these three models exists.
In general: 74 and 75 lineups definitely different entities and should be presented in different pages.
Just my 2 cents, nothing more. [emoji6]
P.S. AFAIK, 68mm range of SAKs are the same models as 75mm (just smaller). Should they have own page or share the same page with 75mm? (a rhetorical question)
-
Excellent point Alex

-
Afaik all so far included in this discussion are editors and admins on the wiki. So if you know of or have other 75 or 74mm models that aren't so far listed in the wiki, by all means add them.

-
Especially 75mm ones, thereby increasing their chance of getting their own page

-
@enki_ck said:
Afaik all so far included in this discussion are editors and admins on the wiki. So if you know of or have other 75 or 74mm models that aren't so far listed in the wiki, by all means add them.
I did it in the past (I mean adding / editing), but stopped this practice because I wasn't happy with changes there.
One of the reason for that was a situation, when some models were merged into one page. Even after long (senseless) discussions, even if me or other users and editors were completely disagree with such solutions.I didn't post anything in this thread last years I suppose (I promised to do not do that [emoji16]), but latest idea about combining different models into one article made me more nervous...
I'm afraid that one day I will open Sakwiki and will see one static page with all models on it (sort from A to Z in best case).
Sorry for the long text. [emoji36]
-
Personally, I don't like that newly added texts or other content immediately gets altered (always by the same editor) or moved to other sections within the page (intro/variations/identifiers). We don't all write in the same way and not all pages follow the same template. So I really don't see the point of correcting other people's contributions. It feels like "thanks for trying, but it's not good enough".
The wiki is not owned by one single person.
-
@Reinier said:
Personally, I don't like that newly added texts or other content immediately gets altered (always by the same editor) or moved to other sections within the page (intro/variations/identifiers). We don't all write in the same way and not all pages follow the same template. So I really don't see the point of correcting other people's contributions. It feels like "thanks for trying, but it's not good enough".The wiki is not owned by one single person.
On the contrary, I advocate the maximum standardization and use of templates, whenever possible.
At the same time, I do not make a difference between the pages created by me and others. And I don’t worry if someone changes the contributions I made. The wiki is not owned by one single person.

But, anyway, I don't have time to work on the SAKWiki project right now, so my opinion doesn't matter.

P.S. I apologize to everyone who was upset by my edits.

-
@Nick4 said:
On the contrary, I advocate the maximum standardization and use of templates, whenever possible.Maybe I have not searched well enough, but what exactly is the template for a SAK page?
What information do we put in the intro section? Because I sometimes mention some specific variations (because why not?) and it gets moved to the Variations section. And who decides which variations are mentioned there, and which ones only get an entry in the Identifiers section?
Re. Identifiers: the European and US identifiers are not always listed in the same way. I like the version with headings for the different numbering systems. Maybe we could also add the old model numbers under a separate heading within the section?
It's also not always clear which variations are actually listed as variations and which ones are under Identifiers only.
At the same time, I do not make a difference between the pages created by me and others. And I don’t worry if someone changes the contributions I made. The wiki is not owned by one single person.

I think some people sometimes force their opinion onto others. I'm not the only one who thinks that. Maybe I shouldn't make such a big deal out of it.
But seriously: one page for all Cybertools? Makes no sense to me. Just one example.
And merging two model lines with different designs and different sizes into one page? I don't get it.But, anyway, I don't have time to work on the SAKWiki project right now, so my opinion doesn't matter.

Your opinion matters! To me anyways :) You are a huge contributor (unlike myself). But even if you were not, your opinion would still matter of course.
P.S. I apologize to everyone who was upset by my edits.

I did not mean you in my previous post.
All good friends?

-
Thank you very much for your frank opinion, Reinier!
@Reinier said:
Maybe I have not searched well enough, but what exactly is the template for a SAK page?Strange, but I found it easily. ;) (And if it did not exist, it would have to be created.)
And, surprisingly:
*Last Modification: Friday 04 of January, 2019 19:10:55 MSK by Reinier. *
Perhaps this template is imperfect and needs to be reworked (for example, now everywhere the title of the section 'Related Knives' is replaced by 'Related Models').

But this is also nothing more than a private issue of standardization.@Reinier said:
What information do we put in the intro section? Because I sometimes mention some specific variations (because why not?) and it gets moved to the Variations section. And who decides which variations are mentioned there, and which ones only get an entry in the Identifiers section?IMHO, all these issues can (and should) be discussed.

Of course, standardization does not exclude flexibility and creative freedom.
@Reinier said:
Re. Identifiers: the European and US identifiers are not always listed in the same way. I like the version with headings for the different numbering systems. Maybe we could also add the old model numbers under a separate heading within the section?I do not know. This can also be discussed.
But my reasons for the preference for standardization are very simple:
-
SAKWiki for visitors is just a site like the others.
-
And any professionally made site should have a clear navigation, an unified design and formatting (so to speak, as in the army - "albeit ugly, but uniform"). In particular, there should be no empty sections, physical specifications, etc.
-
The information must be accurate, consistent, complete and easy to find.
My little coloboration experience at Wikipedia also tells me that templates and guidelines should be used as often as possible.
But, of course, this is all nothing more than my personal opinion.
@Reinier said:
It's also not always clear which variations are actually listed as variations and which ones are under Identifiers only.IMHO, all possible variations should be described in the 'Variations' section.
@Reinier said:
I think some people sometimes force their opinion onto others. I'm not the only one who thinks that. Maybe I shouldn't make such a big deal out of it.Maybe.
But for me personally, working on the SAKWiki project is an opportunity to thank all those who have generously shared information.
And I don’t worry if someone changes my contribution (the experience of working on Wikipedia is very helpful here - it’s much more stressful there).In the end, as one friend of mine says, "calm, children are not born from this." ;)
@Reinier said:
But seriously: one page for all Cybertools? Makes no sense to me. Just one example.And for me, too, it looks rather strange (I somehow missed this moment and was now very unpleasantly surprised).

@Reinier said:
And merging two model lines with different designs and different sizes into one page? I don't get it.Yes, I agree. In my opinion, the accurate classification is just as important to an encyclopedia (which is SAKWiki) as standardizing design templates.
@Reinier said:
Your opinion matters! To me anyways :) You are a huge contributor (unlike myself). But even if you were not, your opinion would still matter of course.Thank you very much!
But you are exaggerating my contribution.@Reinier said:
I did not mean you in my previous post.All good friends?

Of course! All good friends.

-
-
@Nick4 said:
Thank you very much for your frank opinion, Reinier!
Strange, but I found it easily. ;) (And if it did not exist, it would have to be created.)TBH I didn't search at all :P

And, surprisingly:
*Last Modification: Friday 04 of January, 2019 19:10:55 MSK by Reinier. *
That's weird. I must have been drunk or something back then

OK we should definitely update that template :)
-
I plan to begin working on the incomplete "Tang Stamp" page https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Victorinox+Tang+Stamp+Guide
The Wiki deserves a good guide as a reference to this important SAK element, so I welcome input and comment from all contributors.
Before I start, does everyone agree that we should continue with the guide separated by SAK size, as it is now? This seems sensible, as it follows the indexing we use for the rest of the Wiki. Some of the missing sizes will need adding, and I may need image and info contributions.
The table format will need updating; the blank third column (Earliest Date) can be dropped as the timeframe will be listed in the notes column. I think it's OK to continue with the table format for each SAK size, as it's easy to build this out for each tang stamp style, and it locks the text to the images?
We will also need to agree on dates/date ranges to list, as these are often uncertain.
(edit: this is obviously a potential rabbit-hole of a topic, as there have been many different (and rare) stamps used since the beginning of Victorinox, so the update will be biased towards more recent SAKs where there is more reference material avalable).
-
Added the Spirit MXBS :cheers:
SAKWiki | Spirit
SAKWiki - The online Swiss Army Knife Encyclopedia. Information and Identification on Swiss Army Knives by Victorinox and Wenger.
SAKWiki (sakwiki.com)
-
Good job on the tang stamp page Max

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login