Need Advice on EDC
-
My first SAK was a Climber and served me very well for years. It is hard to beat the combination of a good knife blade plus a pair of scissors. The Compact is worth considering if you are looking for a thinner SAK. However, the opener layer is a great addition and very useful at times. And I use the awl a good bit for small incidental tasks. The Evolution 14 or 16 is another attractive option. At 85mm, these are essentially smaller versions of the Climber. I'm not crazy about the ergonomic scales, but my Evo 14 gets regular carry because it is such a good size for EDC. The Victorinox Executive is another brilliant EDC knife. A couple of blades, scissors, and a nail file. The Executive will cover most of your daily needs and more!
I love the Pioneer X (PX). It is a nice sturdy SAK. As an awl fan, I also really lie the in-line awl. So the PX does have some nice advantages, despite not storing the T&T in the scales. It is really hard not to like the PX.
I went through an Alox phase for a while. I really liked the ruggedness of the Alox scales. But, you know what? I've had some Celidor models that have last a long, long time. Decades. The Celidor does get scratched up...but I kind like the nice worn look of old Celidor scales. And you get the Toothpick, tweezers, a pin, and maybe a small pen (with plus scales). If the scales break (never happened to me), you can replace them easily.
My recommendation for a first time EDC SAK would either be a Climber or a Compact, leaning a bit more toward the Climber.


-

... if you find a Climber still minimalistic enough.
-
@McStitchy said:
I think you have a great solution already
For urban/public situations I have a Swisscard lite in my wallet and pair that depending on the situation with a...
- Pioneer
- some small traditional folder
- Leatherman Mini tool
- Leatherman PST
Or minimalist with just an...
- Alox Minichamp
- Executive
- Leatherman Squirt
What are you talking about? ???
He needs scissors!

-
-
If the Explorer was too thick, so will every other sak that has a mag glas, opener layer and scissors. There are a few models that have the flashlight opposite the mag glass, but the flashligt is weak at best.
I'd go with a Climber with plus scales and add a magnifying card, a thin fresnel lens to the wallet and buy a more capable AAA fladhlight to the mix. There are a few good options that offer far more usable light -
You must resist the Alox Pox... You're going to lose the scale tools and the small blade for a more rugged tool that you'll use as a science student in the city. It's not worth it, on once you go Alox ... You're stuck.
A Climber with plus scales and a micro flashlight attached to the keyring would be ideal for your needs. The flashlight might be more practical for your uses as an attachment to a SAK that has everything else you need.
-
@enki_ck said:
If the Explorer was too thick, so will every other sak that has a mag glas, opener layer and scissors. There are a few models that have the flashlight opposite the mag glass, but the flashligt is weak at best.
I'd go with a Climber with plus scales and add a magnifying card, a thin fresnel lens to the wallet and buy a more capable AAA fladhlight to the mix. There are a few good options that offer far more usable light
... as for the magnifier the Swisscard lite got that covered too :P
Here's one accompanied by an Executive...

-
@FanaticExplorer said:
Large Blade
Scissors (my most used tool)
Pen Blade
Bottle Opener with large flathead
Can Opener with 2d Philips
Reamer/Awl
Magnifying Lens
Tweezers and Toothpick
Straight Pin
Backup Pen
A small light (for practical work)Looks as if you figured out the best options already. If you can bring yourself to ditch the mag glass, you could combine a 58 mm Jetsetter with a Sportsman, Spartan (Lite) or Pioneer.
-
@enki_ck said:
If the Explorer was too thick, so will every other sak that has a mag glas, opener layer and scissors. There are a few models that have the flashlight opposite the mag glass, but the flashligt is weak at best.
I'd go with a Climber with plus scales and add a magnifying card, a thin fresnel lens to the wallet and buy a more capable AAA fladhlight to the mix. There are a few good options that offer far more usable lightThis is the route I was thinking.
I love the Yeoman which gives you one less layer, but the opener layer is replaced with the combo tool, you lose the pen knife, and due to being discontinued they are hard to find. Fresnal lens wallet cards fit in the wallet even easier than the SwissCard and are cheap.
As far as flashlight, I think a seperate one like AAA or even smaller rechargable 10180 type are more capable and will give you more options.
-
@enki_ck said:
If the Explorer was too thick, so will every other sak that has a mag glas, opener layer and scissors. There are a few models that have the flashlight opposite the mag glass, but the flashligt is weak at best.
I'd go with a Climber with plus scales and add a magnifying card, a thin fresnel lens to the wallet and buy a more capable AAA fladhlight to the mix. There are a few good options that offer far more usable light
-

Climber, PX, Compact, Evolution 14, Executive, CadetThe Cadet doesn't have scissors, but makes for a brilliant EDC in my experience.

-
I would say Man Up and get used to an Explorer Plus.
Once your brain accepts that its going to live there forever, you no longer notice its in your pocket.
*
The new clear, Lexan blade on the Explorer Plus is awesome.* -

But...it's true....doesn't take long to get used to your Explorer in your pocket. Great SAK.

-
You're fooling yourself, you need them all

-
@powernoodle said:
...
*
The new clear, Lexan blade on the Explorer Plus is awesome.*:ahhh
-


Just wait until Fuzzbucket shows up.......

-
Yeoman, Climber or Scientist. Even better, have Robert do an Alox Yeoman!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

