Need Advice on EDC
-
Alox is overrated. And Celidor gives you a few extra tools.
-
-
Whoa, I didn't expect so many replies so quickly. I just went to sleep and ya guys already made it to the second page.

Again just want to thank everyone for their suggestions and opinions
The thing about my choice comes from the fact that Victorinox in India is still in a very primitive stage. Buying some of the rarer models is very complicated and most likely unavailable. The have only in production models, no Compacts, and just checking now and they don't even have Red Classic SD but have some rare models like limited edition classics and Aloxes even from 2018 in stock. This is how I feel towards them-

As for the plus scales, we have literally send them back to Victorinox and tell them to add Plus scales and instruments as no one sells them here.
We have our biggest festive season (Diwali) in a few weeks so I am hoping to get some good discountsMy God you guys have given loads of suggestions to get through:
The Compact: Currently unavailable in India but I know a vendor who can try to get it for a little higher cost
The Cadet, Pioneer, Tourist, Sportsman : I am so addicted to the 91 mm scissors that I probably can't do without those
The Scientist, Yeoman: would be a perfect combination if they weren't almost impossible to get
The small Leatherman models: It is almost impossible to get any Leatherman models here except for the Leatherman Rebar for some unknown reason
The 58, 65 mm models: They could definitely work and the mini champ has a extremely useful spatula for me but I am worried is they can handle tougher jobsThe best option are probably
Explorer Plus with a small flashlight
Climber Plus/Evo 14 and a fresnel Lens and a small flashlight
Pioneer X with a swisscard Lite
Executive or Ambassador with a flashlight and fresnel lensStill really conflicted about the Alox. To buy or not to buy. I love the more robust tools but they also have lesser tools
As for mods I will definitely try them sometime in the future but as of now shipping them halfway across the world and their cost is not in my budget
And as for getting them awl: Definitely someday because we "got to catch em all"
Thanks for listening to me rambling out essays. Still lots of choices to make
-
-
@FanaticExplorer said:
Whoa, I didn't expect so many replies so quickly. I just went to sleep and ya guys already made it to the second page.
Again just want to thank everyone for their suggestions and opinions
...
I'm glad you came back and actually read all this

-
@McStitchy said:
Newer 111mm don't have the sewing eye anymore
Many of Victorinox newer decisions irritate me like this one. Also why replace the best multitool scissors with the limited opening one in the Swisstool Spirit series, why not provide Plus scales on all models etc.
I feel like it is Victorinox's first rule while designing any multitool to make about 95% perfect and deliberately leave out a feature or two just so that we are never satisfied and we try to achieve 100% perfection by pairing multitools or to get us to collect all their models just to see all the features
-
@McStitchy said:
I'm glad you came back and actually read all this
Of course, how could I start a post, wait for replies and simply abandon it? If I ever did that you are welcome to kick me out of the (Not so Secret Order of) Swiss Army Knights
-
Have a great DiwAwli!
-
Another Explorer Plus fan here. After years of trying to find the perfect edc, I’ve realized that sometimes there is a certain threshold where form and function come together to form a balance that works better than either the extreme minimalist/miniature route or the carry everything including the kitchen sink and a pair of channel locks route.
This law is especially true of pocket knives and pocket flashlights.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@Thunderpants said:
Have a great DiwAwli!I see what you did there ;)
Thanks for the advanced wishes, appreciate it -
@dmattaponi said:
Another Explorer Plus fan here. After years of trying to find the perfect edc, I’ve realized that sometimes there is a certain threshold where form and function come together to form a balance that works better than either the extreme minimalist/miniature route or the carry everything including the kitchen sink and a pair of channel locks route.I too am thinking maybe the Explorer Plus is the best route for me. Has basically everything I need and is a mid size option while not sacrificing too much
-
@FanaticExplorer said:
I too am thinking maybe the Explorer Plus is the best route for me. Has basically everything I need and is a mid size option while not sacrificing too muchIt’s an excellent edc pocket knife. It’s worth it for the in-line Phillips driver alone.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@FanaticExplorer said:
The Scientist, Yeoman: would be a perfect combination if they weren't almost impossible to getWith its inline phillips, blade, flat driver, scissors, pen and magnifier, all in 3 layers, the Yeoman is, for me, the "perfect" SAK. It has all of my essentials, without the Explorer's "unnecessary" 4th layer. What you might do is rock the Explorer Plus for the time being, and hope that Swiss Bianco releases the Yeoman again someday. Or pay some mad scientist to mod an Explorer Plus into a Yeoman.
Or, consider a Compact with the addition of a separate phillips driver on your keys. This gives the basic functionality of a Yeoman, minus the magnifier.

Compact.
Swiss Bianco Yeoman. -
@powernoodle said:
What you might do is rock the Explorer Plus for the time being, and hope that Swiss Bianco releases the Yeoman again someday. Or pay some mad scientist to mod an Explorer Plus into a Yeoman.Yeah this is probably my best and most cost friendly option for now
Custom SAKs are the greatest no doubt but also cost as much as Swisschamp XLT or maybe more so I don't see going into that path for some timeI know this sounds weird but I actually like the dedicated openers especially because they each have a screwdriver and allow space for a pen knife and I heard the combo Opener doesn't work as great as the two openers separately
-
@Echotech said:
A set up after my own heart
Evo14 doesn’t get anything like the love it deserves, basically a shorter but a little fatter climber
I’d add bantam alox as another lightweight option but of course combo tool not as versatile. Adding a flashlight would recommend nitecore tiki or tube both lightweight and great for their size.
Agree fresnel lens good option you can also get these little jobs on eBay very cheaply and tbh they’re just as if not more effective than the one on my explorer
With a waiter for sizeI'd missed the requirement for a magnifying lens in the original post... So I'd second this idea of a separate lens.
Though now we're getting into the too-many-dangly-things problem of EDC. It may be helpful to do a test run on a carabiner and join the EDC in DEC Challenge.

-
@ElevenBlade said:
I'd missed the requirement for a magnifying lens in the original post... So I'd second this idea of a separate lens.I keep a thin, flexible fresnel magnifier in my wallet.

-
@FanaticExplorer said:
Yeah this is probably my best and most cost friendly option for now
Custom SAKs are the greatest no doubt but also cost as much as Swisschamp XLT or maybe more so I don't see going into that path for some timeI know this sounds weird but I actually like the dedicated openers especially because they each have a screwdriver and allow space for a pen knife and I heard the combo Opener doesn't work as great as the two openers separately
Looking at your more recent post, it narrows down to two more reasonable EDC options...
Explorer plus with keyring flashlight
Pioneer X with swisscard liteThe others are not as streamlined for an urban EDC system. Something that I've noticed when you have too many moving parts in an urban environment is that you start to rely more heavily on a certain aspect of your EDC system. For me, three years ago that turned out to be a Micra on my keys... When keys also became more important (work office key, work bathroom key, work closet key, front door key, mailbox key, package room key, apartment key, deadbolt key)
I envision one of the following eventualities...
- Explorer with the flashlight gets used one way or another
- Pioneer X gets used, and flashlight and lens are avoided (this happened to me with the flashlight)
- Swisscard lite gets shirt pocket carry and maximal use, and the Pioneer X stays in the pocket most of the time
- the awl on the Pioneer X gets used awl the time and it's awl you end up carrying
The first and third of these scenarios seem to be the most "fun". Those are also quite different in the way the system works, and how often you want to bring out the heavy artillery.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Looking at your more recent post, it narrows down to two more reasonable EDC options...Explorer plus with keyring flashlight
Pioneer X with swisscard liteI envision one of the following eventualities...
- Explorer with the flashlight gets used one way or another
- Pioneer X gets used, and flashlight and lens are avoided (this happened to me with the flashlight)
- Swisscard lite gets shirt pocket carry and maximal use, and the Pioneer X stays in the pocket most of the time
- the awl on the Pioneer X gets used awl the time and it's awl you end up carrying
The first and third of these scenarios seem to be the most "fun". Those are also quite different in the way the system works, and how often you want to bring out the heavy artillery.
First of all thanks a lot again for all the help, really appreciate it
Secondly yeah you are right. I will make the EDC combos of:
1.Explorer Plus and a small flashlight like the Nitecore Tiki which Echotech recommends
2.Pioneer X and Swisscard LiteI have an Explorer that I need to send for upgrading and buy the other 3 items
I will test out both the pairs by alternating between them and see what works out best. And the best thing is if I get bored of one pair I can just switch to the other. This way I get to use both Celidor and Alox too. It's the best possible win win scenario I guessAnyway thanks again to everyone that posted and don't waste your precious time on me, you guys over there have very important and interesting news to follow on the next most powerful person in the World (except maybe Putin
)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
