NOT pleased with leatherman
-
@Tool said:
Sadly, this has pretty much confirmed any prejudices I had against American products and finishing. My next multitool will therefore probably be a Victorinox.I had a Swiss Watch that had horrible finishing on it. I guess this means that Swiss products and finishing are all no good. Good thing I don't own a Spirit.
-
@Crouton said:
Excellent fit and finish is designed into the build process of the tool, and it's also evidenced in the post build activities to ensure that the tools meets the design and quality assurance criteria. I am not intending this post to be a flame on any brand or manufacturer, but let's say we took ten examples of a Charge TTi and ten examples of a Victorinox Swiss Spirit and compare them. Just in comparisons among tools of the same kind, apples to apples if you will, how many small issues or differences would we find on the Spirit? How many on the Charge? Fit and finish cannot be dismissed, it's important.I don't think your doing quite a fair comparison here. I take your point with comparing new tools, but lets say we took ten examples of each tool after a year of hard use and then compared the "fit and finish"......I think the result would be quite the opposite.
-
You know what I find most disturbing about the pic's he posted? The scratches! I don't know about the rest of you guys who have a TTI, did they come with scratches like that? Every plier I have ever bought was pretty much "car shiny new".
I wouldn't be so surprised if those pliers he got were perhaps in someone else's hands before and were returned for the same reason he dislikes them?
I can't totally disagree with his beef with the pliers. He did spend quite a load of cash I presume as up here in Canada this is the pricest tool you can buy I believe. The plier head is questionable with the groove in it. The rough holes could have been smoothed out a bit, the file well... like I've said mine are like that. I give it a push sideways before closing them. Leatherman could take note perhaps and smooth them out a bit and stick a washer/spacer in there to fix the file issue.
The bottom line is I guess it could be any of us when receiving a new tool. If you feel unsatisfied you not likely to enjoy and or carry the tool.sean
-
@Ben X said:
You won't be disappointed with a Victorinox multi. I recently bought my first Swiss Tool and first Leatherman Kick, and they are from completely different quality levels. I have not personally handled the "higher end" leathermans, but there is no such thing as a "higher end" VIctorinox- the classic SD and the Swiss Tool both leave the factory oozing with the same world class quality.
Anyone got a sick bag?
I hope so, cause I need one now.
-
Its, kind of hard to see on the photo, but I find the same kind of scratches on my new charge, although i could hardly call them scratches. It seems to me they were made by some kind of abrasive media used on the scales after machining. They have no set pattern and barely penetrate the surface. I can't even see them unless i hold the tool at the correct angle. I suppose with extra polishing they could have been removed and leatherman would be spared some of the criticism its getting here.
The even, horizontal lines on the scales are clearly machining or grinding marks, and all the Tti Charges I've seen have them in one degree or the other.
-
There is also the aspect of the properties of Titanium.
I know from owning Titanium watches, that they scratch far easier then stainless steel. That is because Titanium is a softer metal then Stainless. That is its only shortcoming. It is lighter in weight, feels warmer to the touch, looks nice, and has greater tensile strength then stainless. It does scratch easily though (mind you, I am told that if you use an ink eraser, you can sometimes buff out the scratches). It all depends on the grade of Titanium as well. Pure Titanium is easier to work with. As you get into the higher grades, it becomes an alloy and gains different properties depending on what is mixed with it and in what ratios (some of them very scratch resistant) but also get harder to work with. Thus, lower grade Titanium is often used in watches. I would imagine that Leatherman probably also used a lower grade Titanium (not to mention that titanium is expensive to begin with, it gets very expensive up the grade levels ). They probably felt that having a super tough tool that is lighter, would appeal to more people then a perfect looking tool. If you want a tool to not scratch, stay well clear of the Charge Tti. It is not a fault of Leatherman; it is a product of the materials used.
This is what I am thinking after seeing this and several other discussions on the same topic. This does not in no way excuse the tool from coming into your possession as new with scratches though.
-
I love Leatherman multitools but it would have been better if they step up there QC, little attention to details would take them a long long way. Both a Swisstool way back and I really notice the difference, the swisstool is very well oiled, not a single scratch or marks very smooth and shinny. Leatherman have a lot to learn from Victorinox in terms of QC.
-
Excuse me guys, but I do not agree with some of the replies favoring LM here. I think the essence of the topic is that, because of the factors of brand reputation and price, the OP was really expecting a tool to be worth its own salt. Why would anyone pay hard-earned $$$ for something which needs further "refinement" (i.e. tweaks, adjustments) out of the box, when these things should have been taken cared of at the factory to start with? I'm pretty sure none of us here would find that acceptable, especially with products from known name-brands like LM.
My LM Wave also has the rough edgings on the thumbholes, but my Charge doesn't. Imagine I had to sand-down the thumbholes myself (because I live half-way around the world from LM), just to avoid the jaggies from scraping-off my thumb. All this hassle with a tool I paid US$157 for!
IMO, fit and finish is of foremost importance in working tools. F&F doesn't necessarily mean "shiny" or "polished" (in the literal sense), but rather how the different elements fit together perfectly or imperfectly.
-
@josekym said:
IMO, fit and finish is of foremost importance in working tools. F&F doesn't necessarily mean "shiny" or "polished" (in the literal sense), but rather how the different elements fit together perfectly or imperfectly.IMO, I believe function is way ahead of F&F in terms of importance. I can sympathize with the "collectors" on this board who would like to own a tool that looks as nice as possible. Having said that, for those who actually buy a tool to use it I can't understand the need for a level of finish that will be meaningless after the first couple of uses. Scratches on titanium scales or pliers? Unless it's going to sit in a glass case I don't see a problem. I'm not trying to knock anyone's opinion but I honestly can't see the problem. Now if the thing does not function properly or safely then that is a big issue, but surface scratches and things of that nature I don't mind. Honestly I'm not a huge buyer or collector of multitools. Is there a ton of unsafe and non functioning LMs out there?
-
I'll just chime in my €0.02 and agree with the LM guys on this one. The Charges -- and especially the TTi -- are great tools. Somewhat overpriced perhaps, due to premium (could-be-gimmicky) materials but it has a great tool selection and is put together very well. I've used mine in anger and keeps coming back for more.
The issues the OP has been facing are not critical or anything like that. FWIW the scratch on the plier head might be caused by handling since it was making "bad noises when closing" but "this has disappeared after opening and closing 3 times". The file rubbing is not that much of a hassle, given the fact that you actually have a diamond-coated file in a multitool (don't know of many MTs that feature one of these guys) and it only requires some attention when closing the file implement. The tooling marks on the handles are also somewhat reasonable, given that they probably come from different CNC batches and LM doesn't polish those handles so that any marks would go away. If there were a faulty liner lock I'd understand the strife; as it stands, though, I think that TTi is as good a TTi as any other such tool, and a much better multitool than most, if not all, (US made :P :D) multitools...
-
@josekym said:
Excuse me guys, but I do not agree with some of the replies favoring LM here. I think the essence of the topic is that, because of the factors of brand reputation and price, the OP was really expecting a tool to be worth its own salt. Why would anyone pay hard-earned $$$ for something which needs further "refinement" (i.e. tweaks, adjustments) out of the box, when these things should have been taken cared of at the factory to start with? I'm pretty sure none of us here would find that acceptable, especially with products from known name-brands like LM.My LM Wave also has the rough edgings on the thumbholes, but my Charge doesn't. Imagine I had to sand-down the thumbholes myself (because I live half-way around the world from LM), just to avoid the jaggies from scraping-off my thumb. All this hassle with a tool I paid US$157 for!
IMO, fit and finish is of foremost importance in working tools. F&F doesn't necessarily mean "shiny" or "polished" (in the literal sense), but rather how the different elements fit together perfectly or imperfectly.
+1! Fit and finish are primary indicators of attention to detail and quality. This is reassuring when you go to use the tool - you know you can count on it to work as advertised.
-
What goes on at the factory? a freshly made charge comes down a conveyor belt, and is robotically sealed in the clampack or gift tin? Are you guys telling me nobody tries these out before they are packed?
To me LM either knows about this problem or their workers are lazy, or have been instructed to ignore it, because it would cost alot of $$$ to reengineer and retool the factory to fix these problems.
I'm not a LM hater, I have many LM MT's and a knife of theirs, and i'm extremely satisfied with all their products.....except the TTI
-
Hi Chako,
Being a Mechanical Engineer wirh my graduate sudies in Metallurgy, I can say that anyone who believes that Titatium is stronger than stainless steel hasn't a clue. There are some Titanium alloys with very great yield strength (as opposed to tensile strength where they break), but guess what, a there are a bunch more stainless alloys which beat them.
The big thing is the modulus of elasticity - Titanium alloys versus Aluminum alloys lose every time. Try Wikapedia should you either not believe me or not understand that MOE deals with the flex of metals. Have great fun - I spent 7 years of college studying all this.
Cheers - Joe
-
Being a Mechanical Engineer wirh my graduate sudies in Metallurgy, I can say that anyone who believes that Titatium is stronger than stainless steel hasn't a clue. There are some Titanium alloys with very great yield strength (as opposed to tensile strength where they break), but guess what, a there are a bunch more stainless alloys which beat them.
The big thing is the modulus of elasticity - Titanium alloys versus Aluminum alloys lose every time. Try Wikapedia should you either not believe me or not understand that MOE deals with the flex of metals. Have great fun - I spent 7 years of college studying all this.
Cheers - Joe
+1 This is one of the few things that has actually stayed in my brain from my degree ::) :)
-
I stand corrected.
-
"IMO, I believe function is way ahead of F&F in terms of importance."
I believe that F&F and function are inseparable. You can't have good "function" in a tool without good "fit & finish" on the same in the first place, and vice versa.
Just think about it this way: Price = Materials+Workmanship
If the Materials are cheap and the Workmanship is sub-par (if one can see it), then one would think twice of paying a high Price.
I think that you just can't have a high-priced tool with a low level of workmanship at the same time. There is really something wrong in there.
-
I don't know how many Charges that ppl on here are having problems with but how many ppl here have them and don't have problems with them
I am willing to say that the majority that have them have no problems it just so happens that they don't go around talking so much about it :) -
My Charge ALX has been awesome. I use it hard. I've been using it as an"electrician's" plliers in our current renovation project. I sent it in this week because the plier jaws have loosened to the point where it won't cut small gauge wire-- still great for large gauge though. I'll make do with the SURGE!! or Wave until it returns
-
@Poncho65 said:
I don't know how many Charges that ppl on here are having problems with but how many ppl here have them and don't have problems with them
I am willing to say that the majority that have them have no problems it just so happens that they don't go around talking so much about it :)Having just read through this post, I decided to take a look at my Charge TTi. I mean really take a look at it. This is the first multitool I've ever owned, bought about 19 or 20 months ago. I haven't abused it, but it has been used extensively. Heck, for a while, it, a hammer, and a 5" crescent wrench were the only tools I actually owned. Up close, it has all of the imperfections mentioned by the OP. The file scrapes, which has never bothered me. I figured it was par for the course (this is the only full-sized leatherman I own). The handle slabs aren't quite even, and there are grind marks on the one-handed opening holes. Doesn't bother me in the least. There may have also been scratches when I first purchased the tool from Amazon, but it has gathered so many in the time I've had it that I can not tell which are O.G. and which are acquired. The only gripe I had about my Charge was that the pliers did not close completely without Herculean strength. Maybe the pivots were too tight, which has since been remedied by LM's warranty.
The point of my rambling post? That despite other multis (Vic included), despite its imperfections, despite its price-point and basically buying the Leatherman name, it's still my favorite tool for its versatility, workmanship, and materials. I know that should I snap it in half, Leatherman will have my back and fix or replace the tool. I don't foresee this happening, but you never know.
I won't say that I'm a lifetime customer, because you never know what may come down the line. But, given the outstanding performance and warranty service I've received so far, I will definitely be purchasing further multis from them for the foreseeable future. Probably starting with the ST300 (it looks fun :D)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login