Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
Most annoying

-
@Reinier said:
I just missed out on a MoP Champion with old triangular awl. First one I've ever seen for sale and it has been on my wanted list since August 2010 :'(Sorry to hear.
MoP Hoffritz Champ for me. I estimate I missed it by minutes. MoP isn’t really high on the list for me, but it’s not like I turn down opportunities when they show up.@FolderBeholder said:
Wasn't me, but I bet someone would be able to clean it up nicely. What price did it go for?Under $30 with shipping. Not quite sure what would be really salvageable there. Scissors and the scaler are probably most of the value. But almost everything else looked pretty abused or missing. Even though the ends weren’t clearly shown, the ‘squareness’ of the scales mean the liners are probably smashed and smurfed a lot.

-
@Reinier said:
I just missed out on a MoP Champion with old triangular awl. First one I've ever seen for sale and it has been on my wanted list since August 2010 :'(I missed the same... I just check that platform for alox master craftsman. I think the mop one went for a low price... Maybe it will be put on another platform for a lot of money in some days.
-
Any Hoffritz lovers ? Nice but pricey (not mine to my regret ;) )
-
I have the Champ, a bit much to pocket carry. Nice though

-
@jnoxyd said:
Any Hoffritz lovers ? Nice but pricey (not mine to my regret ;) )I might know what they bought it for. ;)
And I know 100% it’s not ‘73 or really even c.’73.
I have a similar one produced after this one that is c.’77. Small clip points were used in more places and ways than most understand.
-
Who can help me date this SAK? It's a horn scaled standard with these tang stamps:
According to Ulli's tang stamp guide the main blade stamp should be 1943-1951 but the cap lifter says 1891-1935. Obviously I may be totally wrong here.
-
@Reinier said:
According to Ulli's tang stamp guide the main blade stamp should be 1943-1951 but the cap lifter says 1891-1935.??? Like many other things, Ulli's table works much better when you use the latest version.
-
No need to be grumpy I think?
But thanks, I thought I was using the latest version but had not noticed it was an old one.
So 1943-1945 probably.
-
I didn't realize that my response sounded grumpy. It was not my intention. Sorry.
With that said, the fact that people keep using older versions of Ulli's table seems to be a recurring problem. I think that it will be good if something will be done to make it easier for people to end up using the latest version. Maybe it will help if someone who can do such things will add a remark with a link to the latest version at the top of the Victorinox Tang Stamps thread.
-
Added link to Tang Stamp Wiki page

-
Hi Folks
Just caught up on the last four pages of this thread - Amazing discussions and knowledge as always

Particularly interested in all the discussions around Bear, Hoffritz, SABI, Forschner and the US Vic imports etc
And of course all the old SAKs goes without saying!!The Chief moderators and Grant prefer us never to alter any previously posted content - And certainly not without the permission of the OP.
With that said - MiniChamp's suggestion is a very sensible proposition.So I could add the latest Ulli TS image to the very first post in his thread - with his permission - Shall I ask him? (I did that for my dating spreadsheet recently)
Max if you want I could also add it to your first post in the Tang Stamp project - Let me know
-
Yes, makes sense to include it. There are some dates on Ulli’s table that don’t align 100% with the Wiki page, but as you’ve stated before, dating SAKs is not an exact science.

-
@MiniChamp said:
I didn't realize that my response sounded grumpy. It was not my intention. Sorry.OK I apologize, I probably misread your post.

-
Just caught up on the last four pages of this thread - Amazing discussions and knowledge as always

Particularly interested in all the discussions around Bear, Hoffritz, SABI, Forschner and the US Vic imports etc
And of course all the old SAKs goes without saying!!The Chief moderators and Grant prefer us never to alter any previously posted content - And certainly not without the permission of the OP.
With that said - MiniChamp's suggestion is a very sensible proposition.So I could add the latest Ulli TS image to the very first post in his thread - with his permission - Shall I ask him? (I did that for my dating spreadsheet recently)
Max if you want I could also add it to your first post in the Tang Stamp project - Let me know
I m happy if I could help. I stopped uploading newer version of my tang stamp sheet, because people always take the one on page 1 (approx. 7000 download) and not the newest one (approx. 1000 downloads) and some use the sheet without permisson on their pages.
Tang stamps are just one tool to date knives. I really like the tang stamp project on the other thread. I would stick on the mainly and regular used stamps. Because on knives before 1950, there are so many variants, around 5 versions of the VICTOR-INOX crossbow stamp. I dont think that would help people much when they just want date a knife in a timerange of some years.
MT is a really good place to bring people together, to share the knowledge, but I m not sure if its the perfect place for content based on facts and evidence. I m not sure if you know what I mean. Its a platform for discussions, for sharing. My intention with the tang stamp sheet was not to bring a perfect product that is 100% correct, because almost every day I see and learn something new. And thats the way I like it, to create something as a base for discussions. Thats very common in science. If you buy today a book in biology, in 5 years its worth nothing, because its already too old, not accurate, because now in 2020 people know much more than in 2015. But the problem with online content like here on MT is, that you cant replace old content with new content. So I see old tang stamp sheets everywhere, on online auctions, on homepages, most time with a claim that its 100% correct. -
Hi Ulli! You're right, I'm tired of fixing guys using old versions of your date sheet and reminding them that it's not good to share this cool sheet without the name of the creator. However, could you please post the most recent version with a proper title with your name.
-
Thanks Ulli for your comment/feedback. I hope that by adding your most recent table to these threads and to the updated Wiki tang page, we can steer people to this version. I do believe (and have stated before) that the Wiki tang page should follow the general format and content of the rest of the Wiki, which has a bias towards more recent models. Winding the clock back before 1950 becomes a lot more challenging for content and data, and almost deserves its own Vintage section that would require a lot of work. I think that threads like this one are of more value for those with an interest in vintage SAKs and willing to share/discuss information.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
Which of you bought this fine specimen of a ‘pwar’ 235faU today?