Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • World
Skins
  • Light
  • Dark

Collapse

NodeBB

Dating in the '70s - Victorinox chronology - Part 2 Catalogs

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
33 Posts 1 Posters 7.2k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • U
    U
    ulli
    wrote on last edited by
    #9

    @kamakiri said:
    One of the more glaring pieces of evidence, and perhaps the line of thinking that I should have started with considers the actual issue date of the ‘1985’ pdf catalog. It does seem pretty clear that both ‘80s-A and B predate this one. But right in its introduction, it hints at the exact date of 1981. See attached annotated picture.

    Very interesting subject. For a long time I thought that catalogs can help date knives. But after a while, I dont think that they really help a lot. As an example: if you have a catalog dated 1934. The only thing you can say about the content knives, that the beginning of the production of a specific model in the catalog could not be after 1934. You can not say that in 1934 that model was still in production, and you can not say that the picture of the knife shown in the catalog was taken in 1934 from a knife produced in that year. But also I have seen knives in catalogs that were never in production, just shown in a catalog. So sometimes, Victorinox also showed some knives that they wanted to produce, but never did. And as you mentioned, a catalog was there sometimes for a time period of around 10 years. I have seen catalogs with hand written notes were some knives were just crossed or some options crossed, and other new options mentioned. Also victorinox always produced stocks of knives, like they do also today. So for some less common knives, victorinox did just one production session for some days, produced the whole amount for the next years. So production time is no the same like selling time. Also in the catalogs are some errors, like the picknicker knife without the saw, or the 90 mm officer knives, that were always 91 mm, and so on.

    And Im also not sure about those 90 or 100 years of procution from the advertising. One time, you take the year 1884, the other time 1891. When its written "90 years of craftsmanship", why not take the year 1884? Would make more sense. Also, Karl Elsener was a knifemaker before 1884. So you could also easily take the year 1880 as a start of his career as a knifemaker, so 1970 would also mean 90 yeares of knowledge of knifemaking.

    I think the best way to specifiy the dates of the knifes in production is to create a table were everybody can put in their thoughts and evidences, advertising knives with dates, catalogs, other sources, for every tool or change in process. One table for "Canopener", one table for "Corkscrew", then for all the different sizes. There I see the best way to narrow the dates were knives were produced.

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • kamakiriK
      kamakiriK
      kamakiri
      wrote on last edited by
      #10

      @ulli said:
      Very interesting subject. For a long time I thought that catalogs can help date knives. But after a while, I dont think that they really help a lot. As an example: if you have a catalog dated 1934. The only thing you can say about the content knives, that the beginning of the production of a specific model in the catalog could not be after 1934. You can not say that in 1934 that model was still in production, and you can not say that the picture of the knife shown in the catalog was taken in 1934 from a knife produced in that year. But also I have seen knives in catalogs that were never in production, just shown in a catalog. So sometimes, Victorinox also showed some knives that they wanted to produce, but never did. And as you mentioned, a catalog was there sometimes for a time period of around 10 years. I have seen catalogs with hand written notes were some knives were just crossed or some options crossed, and other new options mentioned. Also victorinox always produced stocks of knives, like they do also today. So for some less common knives, victorinox did just one production session for some days, produced the whole amount for the next years. So production time is no the same like selling time. Also in the catalogs are some errors, like the picknicker knife without the saw, or the 90 mm officer knives, that were always 91 mm, and so on.

      I generally agree with that whole paragraph. But as time progresses there are more apparent consistencies between what is advertised and what is produced. There’s an evolution of sorts.

      @ulli said:
      And Im also not sure about those 90 or 100 years of procution from the advertising. One time, you take the year 1884, the other time 1891. When its written "90 years of craftsmanship", why not take the year 1884? Would make more sense. Also, Karl Elsener was a knifemaker before 1884. So you could also easily take the year 1880 as a start of his career as a knifemaker, so 1970 would also mean 90 yeares of knowledge of knifemaking.

      There are two separate catalogs I am referencing.

      Catalog marked 1985, that I suggest is 1981 - 24 pages

      and

      Catalog Marked ‘84-‘85 “Extended” with addenda that I say starts with a 1984 catalog

      It seems Victorinox is the one that has focused on various dates for marketing purposes. I can’t argue the significance or history of any of it, but empirically they’ve attached significance to those dates. Hence the huge serialized 1984 Anniversary release. But I’m just looking for how they fit.

      Basically, I can confirm that the catalogs aren’t produced before the dates I suggest. And also suggest that they don’t lag that range by very much, as seen in both the ‘81 and ‘84 printing.

      @ulli said:
      I think the best way to specifiy the dates of the knifes in production is to create a table were everybody can put in their thoughts and evidences, advertising knives with dates, catalogs, other sources, for every tool or change in process. One table for "Canopener", one table for "Corkscrew", then for all the different sizes. There I see the best way to narrow the dates were knives were produced.

      Somebody else can try that.

      It seems that there is only so far an effort like that will go with decisions made in committee. For many nuances in machining, I need the knife in hand to see and understand the differences.

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • kamakiriK
        kamakiriK
        kamakiri
        wrote on last edited by
        #11

        For a long time I thought that catalogs can help date knives. But after a while, I dont think that they really help a lot.

        Yes, and especially when they aren’t dated correctly.

        It is one of my hopes to ‘fix’ that as much as possible.

        But one thing they are capable of doing is validating my chronology. I mean, I can’t possibly say a catalog is 1981, if it contains knives that the chronology says are produced in 1985, right? There is broad agreement between the two. And that is all I could have hoped for.

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • kamakiriK
          kamakiriK
          kamakiri
          wrote on last edited by
          #12

          FWIW, I’ve said essentially the same thing about catalogs and dating in the past. Nothing I’ve found in over a year and a half from the post below has changed much in my view. I’m just providing more context, background and clarification. And reviewing all of the posted 0.3102 variants in the thread, isn’t it curious that all take the same form and with the black double-leaf scissor spring?

          @kamakiri said:
          In the hope to clarify what I believe is an error, I don't think the LNF versions like the 244k were ever Golfers.

          I believe the Original Golfer is based off the 136ka Craftsman, but with horn scales. First listed that I know of in the 26 Model Catalog (which I believe is mid-late '60s) My guess is that it was directly succeeded c. '73 with the 0.3102 version and followed by the 0.1602 in the late '70s.

          1 Reply Last reply
          0
          • kamakiriK
            kamakiriK
            kamakiri
            wrote on last edited by kamakiri
            #13

            Interestingly enough, some proof shows up only days later. 😄

            Regarding the “ ‘70s-A “ catalog and the actual Original Golfer, proof of this model production comes from two others that follow my c. ‘66 copy and run into the mid-‘70s. Production that essentially transitions very directly to the 0.3102 version mistakenly referred to as the ‘original’.

            Here -with thanks to jnoxyd and FolderBeholder for their pictures! I also need to acknowledge Karl, aka ColoSwiss for teaching me about the Golfer through one of his posts I read long ago searching for 136ka info while I was a lurker here. FolderBeholder’s knife is/was part of his collection. 🙂

            Mid-‘70s Golfer:

            c.’70 Golfer:


            Attached- my Golfer from c.’66/‘67 (top knife in the pic) and the catalog cut from the ‘70s-A which I *still *think was first issued in the mid-late ‘60s.

            81C7059A-B393-425D-970E-9F356A34EA70.jpeg

            811D7260-CC6C-4F9E-9069-38BBDF680414.jpeg

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • kamakiriK
              kamakiriK
              kamakiri
              wrote on last edited by
              #14

              I think I’ve found something that links the “ ‘80s-A “ catalog to being c.’78. It’s the US 5036 code for the 84mm Combo Tool Golfer, in a price sheet effective 2/1/78. The fact that the same number references the combo tool version instead of the clip blade version up through the ‘81 and ‘84 catalogs is proof, because it didn’t change. If 5036 referenced the clip blade version in ‘78, the ‘81 and ‘84 catalogs would have used another number. And that number would be odd, not even, like all other later issued 50XX numbers. Likely it would have been 5037. For example, the Waiter which did change in that period, was 5080 for the alox version pre-‘78, but was changed to 5081 for the Combo Tool version pre-’81.

              B2631E4F-6852-48CD-ACCF-7B51FC4DF227.jpeg

              0974DCDD-4100-4EB5-BB01-06EF390B91C5.jpeg

              8E11A128-D47E-4A71-B496-F95184C732D1.jpeg

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • rookieR
                rookieR
                rookie
                wrote on last edited by
                #15

                @kamakiri said:
                I thought proof for earlier use of the combo tool would come from a Golfer, but I’ve found it here on a Waiter. Early style combo tool on a knife with a shield from c. ‘78-‘79. My work studying the shield style is confirmed somewhat by the change in several other knives on the Wood Saw tip, and the tweezer tip change from Aluminum to Plastic, and from the density of Hoffritz stainless inlay knives of this period. It all ties together neatly.

                The other thing I didn’t mention previously is the ‘thematic’ change and the use of the deeper green color. It shows up in the green flocked presentation box liners. I find many knives that date in the ‘77-‘78 range in those boxes.

                Hello kamakiri,
                some months ago I bought this bantam together with another vic. Then I did some research because the scales did not match the stamp. But what confused me even more was the combotool, because everywhere I read that it was introduced about 82-86. According to sakhome.com this stamp (ESSR/empty) exists since 1973.
                Maybe you can bring some clarity into the age of the knife. And maybe it helps you to find the age of the combotool in general.

                Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)

                P1020008.JPG

                P1020006.JPG

                P1020012.JPG

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • kamakiriK
                  kamakiriK
                  kamakiri
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #16

                  @rookie said:
                  Hello kamakiri,
                  some months ago I bought this bantam together with another vic. Then I did some research because the scales did not match the stamp. But what confused me even more was the combotool, because everywhere I read that it was introduced about 82-86. According to sakhome.com this stamp (ESSR/empty) exists since 1973.
                  Maybe you can bring some clarity into the age of the knife. And maybe it helps you to find the age of the combotool in general.

                  Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)

                  Wow! Excellent! Thanks for posting pics of your knife rookie! It certainly helps to confirm ‘70s production of the combo tool! The ESSR/blank tang use is definitely confirmed at least into the ‘76-‘77 range:

                  Dated advertising knife thread HERE

                  I suspect only a little later than that based on other knives I own which are c.’77-‘78. ESSR/blank likely ends at that time and probably not as late as ‘79.

                  Thanks again for posting! :cheers:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • rookieR
                    rookieR
                    rookie
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #17

                    :hatsoff:

                    I'm happy if i could help and thank you for dating my knive :cheers:

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • kamakiriK
                      kamakiriK
                      kamakiri
                      wrote on last edited by kamakiri
                      #18

                      :hatsoff:

                      I’m beyond happy! And very glad you could get an answer on your knife.

                      :woohoo:

                      It’s better proof of my theory than I could have hoped for. :tu: :cheers:

                      EDIT:
                      This is an ESSR/Blank tang advertising knife that I date to c.’78

                      F8681FCD-8814-4A65-8638-BAF4A907E461.jpeg

                      77AA1552-9BE1-40A1-8F1D-75C2474C8D9D.jpeg

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • kamakiriK
                        kamakiriK
                        kamakiri
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #19

                        I’ve been working on a post for the Hoffritz catalogs and when I think they were printed, but got a bit sidetracked.

                        I’ve provided many reasons why I think the “1985” catalog is actually 1981. But I think I’ve found some proof that the printing is later and perhaps for 1982 or 1983. Putting these two printings out and all the addenda within two calendar years still does seem possible. Even if they are ‘83 and ‘84. They still do share 7 photographs, so the closer dates still make sense.

                        C81F4DF7-949E-430F-AA50-6325B133FD1E.jpeg

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • xfileX
                          xfileX
                          xfile
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #20

                          I'm curious. What kind of tool is this? It doesn't look like a bottle opener :think:
                          @kamakiri

                          QQ图片20201210085500.jpg

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • kamakiriK
                            kamakiriK
                            kamakiri
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #21

                            @xfile said:
                            I'm curious. What kind of tool is this? It doesn't look like a bottle opener :think:
                            @kamakiri

                            Because it’s not a bottle opener! It’s just a ‘crab claw’ can opener. I probably should have used or taken another pic of the actual Original Golfer next to it. But this one was taken recently for something else, so I used it here.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • xfileX
                              xfileX
                              xfile
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #22

                              @kamakiri said:
                              Because it’s not a bottle opener! It’s just a ‘crab claw’ can opener. I probably should have used or taken another pic of the actual Original Golfer next to it. But this one was taken recently for something else, so I used it here.

                              If you can provide detailed pictures, I will be more grateful :like:

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • kamakiriK
                                kamakiriK
                                kamakiri
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #23

                                @xfile said:
                                If you can provide detailed pictures, I will be more grateful :like:

                                My apologies, but my policy is not to post hi-res pics of ‘valuable’ knives that could be used for fake auctions and such. And this knife in particular is one that I will not handle unnecessarily or open multiple tools for display purposes.

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • xfileX
                                  xfileX
                                  xfile
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #24

                                  @kamakiri said:
                                  My apologies, but my policy is not to post hi-res pics of ‘valuable’ knives that could be used for fake auctions and such. And this knife in particular is one that I will not handle unnecessarily or open multiple tools for display purposes.

                                  OK, I'm just curious why the crab claw doesn't have a clasp, as shown in the picture :climber:

                                  QQ图片20201212090521.jpg

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  0
                                  • ReinierR
                                    ReinierR
                                    Reinier
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #25

                                    Because the one you posted now is even older. The crab claw opener was produced only a few years. 1940s? Kamakiri knows exacly when 🙂

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • xfileX
                                      xfileX
                                      xfile
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #26

                                      @Reinier said:
                                      Because the one you posted now is even older. The crab claw opener was produced only a few years. 1940s? Kamakiri knows exacly when 🙂

                                      This type?

                                      QQ图片20201212165422.jpg

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • ReinierR
                                        ReinierR
                                        Reinier
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #27

                                        Yes 🙂

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • kamakiriK
                                          kamakiriK
                                          kamakiri
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #28

                                          @Reinier said:
                                          Because the one you posted now is even older. The crab claw opener was produced only a few years. 1940s? Kamakiri knows exacly when 🙂

                                          Thanks Reinier. :cheers:

                                          Main line use is thought to be ‘46-‘51. But I have theories about how late they may have been used. Before the design was modified for reverse/mirrored and thinner when used like a combo tool in a knife layer. There would likely be some that had to be ‘disposed’ of like so many discontinued tools have been.

                                          I was looking at a ‘Climber’ LNF from the late ‘70s last night and noticed that it might have a very early stamping of the OSCB rear tang stamp.

                                          All a bit off topic though.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0

                                          Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                          Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                          With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                          Register Login

                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Popular
                                          • World