SAK you hate most
-
I don't hate any of them, but I do have two least favourite implements: serrated blades and scissors with springs... The Victorinox can opener is a close third.
-
I don’t hate it, but among the popular SAK models my least favorite is probably the Tinker.
-
I'm not fond of the 108 mm line, and I'd never want to carry that combination saw and bottle opener. I like the idea of a lot of utility in a little package, but it's just not practical for me.
I've got a hot and cold relationship with the 58mm line.... Classic and MiniChamp to be specific. I want to like it a lot more than I do... and I don't. Closed, they're just the right size. In use, they're suddenly too small. The blade just seems too delicate and narrow, and the scissors are just good enough for the errant whisker. I just feel like I'm better off going with something larger, or even a small "disposable" box cutter.
-
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I'm not fond of the 108 mm line, and I'd never want to carry that combination saw and bottle opener. I like the idea of a lot of utility in a little package, but it's just not practical for me.I've got a hot and cold relationship with the 58mm line.... Classic and MiniChamp to be specific. I want to like it a lot more than I do... and I don't. Closed, they're just the right size. In use, they're suddenly too small. The blade just seems too delicate and narrow, and the scissors are just good enough for the errant whisker. I just feel like I'm better off going with something larger, or even a small "disposable" box cutter.

I just can't get on with the Classic (sorry
)I like the MiniChamp (Alox only) but, even then, it's just too small for my EDC

-
The 85mm Evo SAKs. I know they are suppose to be ergonomic, but they just feel uncomfortable to me. The Evo scales make the knife even fatter than comparable 91mm SAKs.
-
There are no SAKs I hate or dislike or frown upon or anything - only those I feel no need for. There are so many models available that one can make one's choices and ignore the others.
-
What he said.
Personally, the Tinker is my current pocket dweller. Ive previously had a Pioneer in the same role.
It'd be a boring world(and forum) if we were all the same -viva le difference as our French comrades would say.(also the Classics to small for me and anything over 3 layers is too big. There, I have confessed my shame)
-
What Storm said: TINKER for 30+ years, despite having 60 some others.
Rich
-
Of those I actually own:
The Caddy Compact. It was a limited run, I think mostly made for online retailer Proozy (came in classic red, as well as black and blue, the company colors of the retailer). Normally, I would not buy them, but they had a sale and the black and blue ones were $3 there at one point. It's the least practical of the 58mm line. To me, the main draw of 58mm is the small scissors and the nailfile. It has neither. The combo tool is slotted, not Phillips like the Rally and most other modern 58mm with it. Instead of a nailfile/screwdriver combo, you have a silly divot repair tool. It's so small, you could not possibly use it to fix a divot made while golfing. And given how cheaply they were discounted (I ordered a set of red/white/blue when they were new, and I believe I paid $15 each). I bought a bunch for use as gifts, and think that was a mistake, they are so impractical.
-
@cody6268 said:
Of those I actually own:The Caddy Compact. It was a limited run, I think mostly made for online retailer Proozy (came in classic red, as well as black and blue, the company colors of the retailer). Normally, I would not buy them, but they had a sale and the black and blue ones were $3 there at one point. It's the least practical of the 58mm line. To me, the main draw of 58mm is the small scissors and the nailfile. It has neither. The combo tool is slotted, not Phillips like the Rally and most other modern 58mm with it. Instead of a nailfile/screwdriver combo, you have a silly divot repair tool. It's so small, you could not possibly use it to fix a divot made while golfing. And given how cheaply they were discounted (I ordered a set of red/white/blue when they were new, and I believe I paid $15 each). I bought a bunch for use as gifts, and think that was a mistake, they are so impractical.
Wow, sounds like a real stinker.
-
Can I volunteer a tool rather than the entire SAK? The combo tool offends me with it's low capability in actually opening a can. Could have been so much better, certainly should have been the usually excellent Victorinox engineering, there are so many SAK's which I won't even consider due to the combo tool rather than being able to enjoy the additional tool space that it creates.
-
@pomsbz said:
Can I volunteer a tool rather than the entire SAK? The combo tool offends me with it's low capability in actually opening a can. Could have been so much better, certainly should have been the usually excellent Victorinox engineering, there are so many SAK's which I won't even consider due to the combo tool rather than being able to enjoy the additional tool space that it creates.I love the combo tool. Give me a Waiter over a Spartan and a Compact over a Climber any day. 😉
-
@Frailer said:
I love the combo tool. Give me a Waiter over a Spartan and a Compact over a Climber any day. 😉I've got a Waiter in my pocket right now but as far as I'm concerned the combo tool is a bottle opener and nothing else. I tried one time to open a can and was simply flabbergasted at how bad the design was for a can opener.
-
@pomsbz said:
I've got a Waiter in my pocket right now but as far as I'm concerned the combo tool is a bottle opener and nothing else. I tried one time to open a can and was simply flabbergasted at how bad the design was for a can opener.I had a Bantam in my pocket, and that was it one time. Tried to open a 32 ounce can of green beans with the combo tool on it--thought I'd break the knife before I got the can open. Yet, any SAK with the regular can opener doesn't have that problem.
-
@pomsbz said:
Can I volunteer a tool rather than the entire SAK? The combo tool offends me with it's low capability in actually opening a can. Could have been so much better, certainly should have been the usually excellent Victorinox engineering, there are so many SAK's which I won't even consider due to the combo tool rather than being able to enjoy the additional tool space that it creates.
-
@cody6268 said:
I had a Bantam in my pocket, and that was it one time. Tried to open a 32 ounce can of green beans with the combo tool on it--thought I'd break the knife before I got the can open. Yet, any SAK with the regular can opener doesn't have that problem.Well I've gotten a new Bantam, so we'll see how it goes. Somehow... it seems that the profile on the Combo tool is a bit different compared to the Compact... I'm sure it's the same... but something feels a bit different.
I will say though, that the combo tool makes a good bottle opener.
-
I've used the combo tool to open a couple of cans, just to see. I thought it worked OK, if you don't mind a jagged edge on the can. It is a compromise, remember. The regular Vic can opener is much superior IME. It's actually all I use.
I prefer the Wenger combo tool over the Vic one both as a can opener and flat SD. Again, naturally it's a compromise. I like also that it's not as long and seems less prone to twisting, and that it locks as you push. A really nice touch. It'll turn Phillips screws as well, if you can use it at right angles.
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
I've used the combo tool to open a couple of cans, just to see. I thought it worked OK, if you don't mind a jagged edge on the can. It is a compromise, remember. The regular Vic can opener is much superior IME. It's actually all I use.I prefer the Wenger combo tool over the Vic one both as a can opener and flat SD. Again, naturally it's a compromise. I like also that it's not as long and seems less prone to twisting, and that it locks as you push. A really nice touch. It'll turn Phillips screws as well, if you can use it at right angles.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
