Evergreen topics
-
@hiraethus said:
:ahhhToo many possible topics... 84mm scissors, custom (read: poorly thought through) configurations direct from the factory, one-handed anything, non-locking Swisstools, locking SAKs, ‘why can’t I have x colour scales’ etc etc
Good examples, along with the steel hardness. Demanding a "Cadet X" has been hot of late. I really have to restrain myself in replying to some of the wants I see.
This isn't to say I don't have my own peeves with Victorinox. The other day I broke a hollow cellidor scale just by sitting on the knife in my back pocket. :(
One thing I'd like to see more of is gratitude shown for the knives and tools that Vic produces already. What's offered is vastly preferable to nothing at all.
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
One thing I'd like to see more of is gratitude shown for the knives and tools that Vic produces already. What's offered is vastly preferable to nothing at all.To be honest, on this particular forum this would likely be a very boring thread: one person declares how much he/she appreciates Vic and how they entertain us all with their wide array of SAKs, and the vast majority consequently just agrees :)
-
I'll agree with the steel question- if they have to ask, they wont understand the answer.
Come on people, we're living in a golden age of cutlery, where you can get any length, style, steel options etc for a reasonable price. If you don't like what Victorinox is offering, no one is holding a gun to your head making you buy it are they now. Buy what you like, and as Sawl says, there's plenty to love about what Vic is putting out. I'm happy with the ones I've got , thats for sure
-
This thread is about to turn into one of the evergreen topics itself.

-
I wouldn't miss topics (like this?
;)) that are specifically looking for the negative, such as the current thread "SAK you hate most". Hatred somehow doesn't fit into this friendly forum. SAKs are a hobby and a passion for me, so I focus on what I like. -
Well said Sneider!
I hate negativity! (see what I did there?)
-
@Reinier said:
Well said Sneider!I hate negativity! (see what I did there?)
Well played Reinier, well played.
I agree that negativity is offputting. I have to suspect, though that the most recent negative thread in question has more to do with language than negativity. I'm sure that was unintentional.
For native English speakers "hate" is an ugly word... It has an aesthetic to it. Just like the word "moist" brings a visceral reaction of disgust to many people (even if it is in reference to a chocolate cake), and "emoluments" has a nice ring to it until you know what it entails... "hate" has an ugly, angry aesthetic to it.... separate from what it actually means.
So I try to let it slide, even though I had the same reaction as many of you. -
@ElevenBlade said:
...For native English speakers "hate" is an ugly word... It has an aesthetic to it...True, which is why so many responses in that thread (my own included) start with, “I don’t hate any of them, but...”
I think the discussions I enjoy the most revolve around tool selection. IMHO the SAK is all about sub-optimal utility. By that I mean having a tool at hand that—while it might not be ideal—will get the job done. Hearing what other people want to have immediately available as they negotiate their day interests me. I’m much less interested in discussions about blade and scale materials.
-
@Frailer said:
True, which is why so many responses in that thread (my own included) start with, “I don’t hate any of them, but...”I think the discussions I enjoy the most revolve around tool selection. IMHO the SAK is all about sub-optimal utility. By that I mean having a tool at hand that—while it might not be ideal—will get the job done. Hearing what other people want to have immediately available as they negotiate their day interests me. I’m much less interested in discussions about blade and scale materials.
Language is the most important multitool we have.

-
Yes, you turned it well, Reinier.
OK, I didn't think that hate meant anything else in other languages. Thanks ElevenBlade, that helps me understand the meaning. In German, my mother tongue, hate is perhaps the word with the most negative meaning of all. That's why the title irritated me so much.
-
@Sneider said:
Yes, you turned it well, Reinier.OK, I didn't think that hate meant anything else in other languages. Thanks ElevenBlade, that helps me understand the meaning. In German, my mother tongue, hate is perhaps the word with the most negative meaning of all. That's why the title irritated me so much.
I wasn't sure about it, so I didn't mention it....my understanding is that German is very nuanced in what words mean, so it probably is a good example. Many years ago... I think I was not even a teenager, I had met a family friend's new husband who was a native German speaker. Excited to show off the German I was learning in school I said something to him. Picture this - he stared at me in silence for a few seconds and says "That is very very low German", with his outstretched hand parallel to the ground he slowly bent down until his palm was a few inches off the ground... to demonstrate just how very low it was.
The next day I transferred to Spanish class. 
hate - detest - abhor - loathe - despise - dislike - avoid .... these all have nuanced differences. Hate is among the most negative in English
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I wasn't sure about it, so I didn't mention it....my understanding is that German is very nuanced in what words mean, so it probably is a good example. Many years ago... I think I was not even a teenager, I had met a family friend's new husband who was a native German speaker. Excited to show off the German I was learning in school I said something to him. Picture this - he stared at me in silence for a few seconds and says "That is very very low German", with his outstretched hand parallel to the ground he slowly bent down until his palm was a few inches off the ground... to demonstrate just how very low it was.
The next day I transferred to Spanish class. 
hate - detest - abhor - loathe - despise - dislike - avoid .... these all have nuanced differences. Hate is among the most negative in English
That was not very polite from your family friend's husband! :-[
Unfortunately, because I only really know one language, I cannot compare how strongly the meaning of words is nuanced in other languages depending on the situation. In my environment, hate does not refer to objects but usually to living beings (e.g. I hate the murderer of my family members), maybe also to situations (daily worker traffic jam on the highway). Hatred means in the mildest case wanting something to cease to exist, at the other end that you want to kill it slowly and painfully.
But hate a
? Never!Phew, that was enough bad fibrations on my part, I'm out.
-
Slugs and aphids in the garden - you can only "hate" them.
-
@Sneider said:
That was not very polite from your family friend's husband! :-[Unfortunately, because I only really know one language, I cannot compare how strongly the meaning of words is nuanced in other languages depending on the situation. In my environment, hate does not refer to objects but usually to living beings (e.g. I hate the murderer of my family members), maybe also to situations (daily worker traffic jam on the highway). Hatred means in the mildest case wanting something to cease to exist, at the other end that you want to kill it slowly and painfully.
But hate a
? Never!Phew, that was enough bad fibrations on my part, I'm out.
I'm overjoyed that I have a friend in Europe with so much in common but only speaks German, and we can effortlessly communicate.

-
I like a derailed thread as much as the next man, but at this very moment we already have a "may one use the h-word?" semantics debate going in the "Which SAK do you hate most?" thread. So if derail we must, we might as well stick to the "should Vic use better steel?" off-topic

-
@Simon_Templar said:
So here is my question to the long-time members: if you could select one topic around SAKs to be henceforth permanently removed from debate, which would it be?I wouldn't remove anything.
I'm a SAK user and small-time collector, and I enjoy discussing my hobby with like minded folks, even when we sometimes go back to questions we've covered before. It's also interesting to see folks who are new to SAKs and or new to the forum bring their fresh perspectives.
And sometimes the perspectives of even long-time members change over time. The Climber was my regular carry, at least on my days off, for a number of years, and seemed just about perfect for me. Since I got a PX and FX, however, one of them has been finding their way into my pocket more often than not. As another example, last I heard, the OP of the epic "Alox forever!" thread was happily carrying an Executive daily.
So, even though a topic may have been covered before, we may have some new people involved in the conversation, and or some new opinions from folks who were involved last time.

-
@ElevenBlade said:
I'm overjoyed that I have a friend in Europe with so much in common but only speaks German, and we can effortlessly communicate.
Yeah, my translation program makes it possible.

-
@SirVicaLot said:
I would have never guessed that you use a translation software. Better than google translate for sure :D
Um, I mostly use google translate...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login