SAK you hate most
-
@pomsbz said:
Can I volunteer a tool rather than the entire SAK? The combo tool offends me with it's low capability in actually opening a can. Could have been so much better, certainly should have been the usually excellent Victorinox engineering, there are so many SAK's which I won't even consider due to the combo tool rather than being able to enjoy the additional tool space that it creates.I love the combo tool. Give me a Waiter over a Spartan and a Compact over a Climber any day. π
-
@Frailer said:
I love the combo tool. Give me a Waiter over a Spartan and a Compact over a Climber any day. πI've got a Waiter in my pocket right now but as far as I'm concerned the combo tool is a bottle opener and nothing else. I tried one time to open a can and was simply flabbergasted at how bad the design was for a can opener.
-
@pomsbz said:
I've got a Waiter in my pocket right now but as far as I'm concerned the combo tool is a bottle opener and nothing else. I tried one time to open a can and was simply flabbergasted at how bad the design was for a can opener.I had a Bantam in my pocket, and that was it one time. Tried to open a 32 ounce can of green beans with the combo tool on it--thought I'd break the knife before I got the can open. Yet, any SAK with the regular can opener doesn't have that problem.
-
@pomsbz said:
Can I volunteer a tool rather than the entire SAK? The combo tool offends me with it's low capability in actually opening a can. Could have been so much better, certainly should have been the usually excellent Victorinox engineering, there are so many SAK's which I won't even consider due to the combo tool rather than being able to enjoy the additional tool space that it creates.
-
@cody6268 said:
I had a Bantam in my pocket, and that was it one time. Tried to open a 32 ounce can of green beans with the combo tool on it--thought I'd break the knife before I got the can open. Yet, any SAK with the regular can opener doesn't have that problem.Well I've gotten a new Bantam, so we'll see how it goes. Somehow... it seems that the profile on the Combo tool is a bit different compared to the Compact... I'm sure it's the same... but something feels a bit different.
I will say though, that the combo tool makes a good bottle opener.
-
I've used the combo tool to open a couple of cans, just to see. I thought it worked OK, if you don't mind a jagged edge on the can. It is a compromise, remember. The regular Vic can opener is much superior IME. It's actually all I use.
I prefer the Wenger combo tool over the Vic one both as a can opener and flat SD. Again, naturally it's a compromise. I like also that it's not as long and seems less prone to twisting, and that it locks as you push. A really nice touch. It'll turn Phillips screws as well, if you can use it at right angles.
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
I've used the combo tool to open a couple of cans, just to see. I thought it worked OK, if you don't mind a jagged edge on the can. It is a compromise, remember. The regular Vic can opener is much superior IME. It's actually all I use.I prefer the Wenger combo tool over the Vic one both as a can opener and flat SD. Again, naturally it's a compromise. I like also that it's not as long and seems less prone to twisting, and that it locks as you push. A really nice touch. It'll turn Phillips screws as well, if you can use it at right angles.

-
I have some I like less than others like the alox bantam which is just not enough knife for me. Some I thought Iβd love but didnβt like the harvester and some I like much more than I imagined like the Sportsman. I also donβt get the love for the classic I think the rambler/manager are 10 times beater for having the 58mm combo.
-
Why the classic, when for little more you can have the Rambler? There should be Alox Rambler, and special edition Rambler.
Why Huntsman and Mountaineer when for little more you can have a Ranger?
Tomorrow, ugliest SAK ever.
Combotool? Why? So that I loose the small blade, which for me is the blade I use most, and get inadequate drivers?Ξ£ΟάλθηκΡ Ξ±ΟΟ ΟΞΏ Redmi Note 8 Pro ΞΌΞΏΟ ΟΟΞ·ΟΞΉΞΌΞΏΟΞΏΞΉΟΞ½ΟΞ±Ο Tapatalk
-
@Sakpan74Gr said:
Why the classic, when for little more you can have the Rambler? There should be Alox Rambler, and special edition Rambler.
Why Huntsman and Mountaineer when for little more you can have a Ranger?
Tomorrow, ugliest SAK ever.
Combotool? Why? So that I loose the small blade, which for me is the blade I use most, and get inadequate drivers?Ξ£ΟάλθηκΡ Ξ±ΟΟ ΟΞΏ Redmi Note 8 Pro ΞΌΞΏΟ ΟΟΞ·ΟΞΉΞΌΞΏΟΞΏΞΉΟΞ½ΟΞ±Ο Tapatalk
Isn't it a great thing that there are so many different people with so many different needs and tastes from our own...? ;)

I agree on the Alor Rambler though...

-
Whilst Iβll stick to earlier comment (no hate from me) I started to wonder why Mr Shatner feels so strongly about a particular SAK? He was on my playlist today and I clearly heard him say βeverybody hates the Touristβ? Why???
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
As pretty much everything that I would say has all been said.But I'll say it again anyway!!
-
I don't hate any SAK >:D - But there are few I guess I would like least and they would be
-
Any SAK without scissors
-
Interesting comments on the 108mm range and - Yes that saw/SD is weird and dodgy
-
The biggies (XXs) I just see as collectors' items and for fun - They certainly would be interesting conversation starters
-
I too am not so keen on the Combi tool - But my very often EDC is a Compact :o .... Go figure!!

-
Also never understood the Ueli Steck blade - I mean really ??? A wrench with a deadly sharp edge - It's nuts :-[ (..... see what I did there ??? ;) ) :D
-
Never understood the Tomo hate - What is wrong with a Classic with nice colourful square scales - Although they really should have put the t&t on those - Maybe in matching colours - Bet if they had done that they would still be selling
-
Never understood why a Spartan and not a Climber or why a Classic and not a Rambler - Yep alox Rambler would be fab

Anyway - There is my (repeat) two penneth!!
-
-
@pomsbz said:
Can I volunteer a tool rather than the entire SAK? The combo tool offends me with it's low capability in actually opening a can. Could have been so much better, certainly should have been the usually excellent Victorinox engineering, there are so many SAK's which I won't even consider due to the combo tool rather than being able to enjoy the additional tool space that it creates.I agree. It's too thin also. Feels like it's going to bend or break. I understand it has to fit alongside a blade, but it feels useless. Also, for opening cans, it is crap, especially large cans.
-
Tool rather than SAK. I have to agree on the combo tool. I've tried to like the combo tool but it does nothing for me.
That's about all I can think of.
-
The tools that makes me wonder why they were made are the hook and the scaler. I know that a lot of people had found ways to make them useful, as they would with any other tool. But still, why?
-
@Andetto said:
The tools that makes me wonder why they were made are the hook and the scaler. I know that a lot of people had found ways to make them useful, as they would with any other tool. But still, why?The hook, I can see being a great idea, if parcels with string really were as common as stories would have us believe. The scaler is an odd choice.... I can see it being perfectly logical for a fishing kit if you would have the stomach to deal with the cleaning later on, and horrible surprise you are guaranteed to find at some later date due to imperfect cleaning. Years ago, other camping tools offered the scaler, and quickly retracted the offer.
Looking at my SwissChamp... part of what makes it special is the slight over-abundance of tools. If I narrowed it down to just what I need, I'd have a Climber in one hand and a Hiker in the other... But what fun is that?
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Agreed!
SwissBianco gunmetal grey alox Rambler:Nice Rambler FB!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better π
Register Login

