Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
@FolderBeholder said:
It has a an eyelet.Then ‘86 it should be!

-
@kamakiri said:
This is exactly why argument for %u201876+ would be %u2018weak%u2019. Lots of things would have to be from the bottom of their respective bins. And that%u2019s rarely done with main line construction.My feeling without seeing more detail is that it%u2019s about early %u201875.
This doesn't answer my question. How is the argument weak? You make a lot of assertions as fact without explaining the logic behind them. Not saying you're wrong, I'd just love to know the thought process.
-
Thank you, Kamakiri, Holder_Beholder, Jnoxyd, all you guys, for sharing your knowledge.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
It has a an eyelet.This is why I suggested the "list of changes" above. Taking into account various changes in knife construction, materials, tools, stamps and keeping in mind the "parts from the bottom of the bin" (I like this meme! ) we can determine the possible production time range of the knife.
My mother-in-law doctor calls this differential diagnosis. -
Lisa, that knife is gorgeous! It looks like it just came out of the shipping box

-
@MexSAK said:
Thank you, Kamakiri, Holder_Beholder, Jnoxyd, all you guys, for sharing your knowledge.
That’s what the thread is for!@jazzbass said:
This doesn't answer my question. How is the argument weak? You make a lot of assertions as fact without explaining the logic behind them. Not saying you're wrong, I'd just love to know the thought process.A knife assembled in or after ‘76 should have parts made in or shortly before ‘76 and have ‘construction’ details consistent with ‘76 or later. Doesn’t have all of that. And that’s why I’d say an argument for ‘76 or later would be ‘weak’.
I’m assuming I don’t have to get into details about why it can be ‘74-‘75.
@jnoxyd said:
This is why I suggested the "list of changes" above. Taking into account various changes in knife construction, materials, tools, stamps and keeping in mind the "parts from the bottom of the bin" (I like this meme! ) we can determine the possible production time range of the knife.
My mother-in-law doctor calls this differential diagnosis.I think you get it. I don’t blindly ignore the ‘binning’ issue. But it’s not as widespread and random as some might think.
-
@jazzbass said:
Esp the older knives in times when things were changing a lot (like the 73-80 time frame).I think it’s all the little changes make it easier to separate production into individual, perhaps even discreet annual production. The interesting part is how they can tie different product lines and even different frame sizes.
-
Any guesses on this one?



Anybody have one like it? Parts-wise, that is.
Again, seems original to me and despite the unique parts combination, I think it can be dated to sub half year accuracy from just these pics.
-
An Angler with a file...
I'm stumped. -
@kamakiri said:
Anybody have one like it? Parts-wise, that is.Yes, many of us do. It's a Fischermesser F235fmaU (like the one in the attached brochure). The scales were probably blue, once upon a time, and it looks like the fish inlay was destroyed by corrosion. It's well known that the blue scales on these SAKs were often very unstable. This particular discoloration seems to be a bit unusual, though. Quite interesting.

-
Very nice FB!

-
I’m sorry, everybody! I thought it would be clear what it is...but less so on when it is from.
Mine pictured below are all +PAT...
Does anybody have one like the other beat up one in their collection...and can anybody make a guess about when it was produced?
.

-
@kamakiri said:
I’m sorry, everybody! I thought it would be clear what it is...but less so on when it is from.Mine pictured below are all +PAT...
Does anybody have one like the other beat up one in their collection...and can anybody make a guess about when it was produced?
.
Do you mean your knife has no +Pat can opener (post 1971) and all other tools from Victoria era (till 1973) and was made in this time range?
Yes, all of my blue "Fischermessers" also have +Pat but very close 234f doesn't have it. It also has pre73 blades and corkscrew but already has ruler on fishtool. So it was made a bit later than yours.

-
@jnoxyd said:
Do you mean your knife has no +Pat can opener (post 1971) and all other tools from Victoria era (till 1973) and was made in this time range?The knife I posted on the other page is from an auction knife. It does not have the +PAT. All three of my knives above with the black background do.
One reason I have used auction pics for examples is that we can all look at the same picture and I won’t have the distinct advantage of taking the pics or using a knife I own and can hold or inspect under a loupe. Essentially, I can often asses a precise date with smurfy *bay auction pics, when they are ‘good enough’ to see what I need to.
Yes, all of my blue "Fischermessers" also have +Pat but very close 234f doesn't have it. It also has pre73 blades and corkscrew but already has ruler on fishtool. So it was made a bit later than yours.

Excellent example...what is your date estimate for this one and the damaged one I posted earlier? All estimates and guesses welcome. Please include reasons why.
....
I feel my answer to jazzbass did not satisfy. One or all, regarding my process. My earlier attempts to ‘show’ differences about the “1973” Hoffritz didn’t seem to help. So I am trying again with a new example.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Not sure of age of this one, but it seems to be similar to jnoxyd's:



FB-
If you show what’s under the in line phillips, it will be clearly different from jnoxyd’s. It should either have a brass collar/spacer surrounding the pin/rivet...or the updated backspring where the center ‘hump’ is rlongated so it touches the pin. Either is possible.My guess is that it’s the brass collar.
-

FB-
If you show what’s under the in line phillips, it will be clearly different from jnoxyd’s. It should either have a brass collar/spacer surrounding the pin/rivet...or the updated backspring where the center ‘hump’ is rlongated so it touches the pin. Either is possible.My guess is that it’s the brass collar.
Interesting, I just noticed that collar on one of mine today and posted a question about it. I had to go back and check, the backsprings are different on the newer ones and the older Champs have no hump or collar. Just out of curiosity, is there a timeframe known for this?
-
@nitram said:
Interesting, I just noticed that collar on one of mine today and posted a question about it. I had to go back and check, the backsprings are different on the newer ones and the older Champs have no hump or collar. Just out of curiosity, is there a timeframe known for this?Yes, it’s believe it to be roughly ‘81 to ‘86. I’ll expand a bit more in your other thread.
-
@kamakiri said:
The knife I posted on the other page is from an auction knife. It does not have the +PAT. All three of my knives above with the black background do.
...
Excellent example...what is your date estimate for this one and the damaged one I posted earlier? All estimates and guesses welcome. Please include reasons.To be honest, we still do not have a consensus here on the sequence and dates of changes in the 1973-1975 transit period. So I usually use 1973 as a reference year for the end of the Victoria era and the introduction of new tools such as magnifier, Phillips, 2.4mm blade, spear point blade, new file / metal saw, screwdriver on back, ruler on hook remover. So (roughly) your self-destructive knife is from 1972 (no +Pat) -1973(VOS stamp, Victoria age tools) and mine - from 1973. I will be happy to hear the arguments in favor of your, I am sure, more detailed dating ;)
P.S. Remind me please where we had discussion here about different fonts on fish hook extractor .
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
