NOT pleased with leatherman
-
From my POV there are two types of issues: (a) cosmetic/aesthetic "blemishes", such as machining marks or fuzzy lettering on the Ti scales, raw blade hole edges, etc, and (b) real-use issues, such as faulty linerlocks, plier head or file rubbing against handles, etc. If the tool is to be put in a glass case then you only care for (a)-type things; else, (b)-type problems come to haunt you. Overgeneralizing and stating that "these are all cosmetic stuff" or "these all get in the way when using the tool" are both wrong. Assuming they should be caught during QC checks, on the other hand, is a fact.
That said, QC slippage is not a LM-only thing. I've also had QC issues with Gerbers and Vics. As Dave said, it's the user expectations that are very high for a hyped-up/probably overpriced tool such as the TTi. However, what counts the most for me is that LM will always stand behind their customers (even via less-than-perfect reps) and in the end the tools they manufacture are all top notch no matter what. My older Ti has been "serving" along a certain totally tool-hostile marine officer for the last couple of years and, besides the occasional surface rust, it has pulled through just fine. My current TTi has all sorts of QC issues (including file rubbing, linerlocks not fully engaging, scales not perfectly aligned, etc.), yet it is still my go-to tool when I feel like carrying something heavier/more "tactical" than my EDC Spirit.
-
As I see it the Charge series is promoted as LM's "High-End" Tools. Their functions can be found in other LM products, but anyway they make the Charge with Titanium scales, ect... These pictures/text from the brochure shouts Quality very loud, and I wouldn't expect anything than perfect craftmanship/F&F, paying so much money for one...
(But that just me...) ;)
Keep in mind the legal 2HO costs 325$ here NIB & 280$ with "Discount".. :P :ahhh
-
Noth - I think you've just proved my point, which I know is really going to bug you :D
In what way is the file rubbing against the handle a "real-use", the (b) issue? It doesn't inhibit the use of the tool, and as far as I can tell doesn't cause damage to either the handle or the tool, so surely that's a type (a)?
The answer to the above is totally irrelevant btw, but I'm curious whether runs in the varnish on a broom handle would bother you? ;)
For the record, it doesn't bother me in the slightest, in fact it may prevent rattling or vibration when carrying the tool, so it might even be useful.
-
@DaveK said:
Noth - I think you've just proved my point, which I know is really going to bug you :D:D No bugging my friend (plus, I'm an expert in debugging... ::) :D). I consider the file rubbing against the handle a use issue because over time the last half cm of the file seems to have "discolored" and lost its abrasiveness, compared to the rest of it. That's even more so as the file rubs against the handle not only when opening/closing but also when I squeeze the handles in my hands during cutting/sawing. Considering how some people need a file that extends all the way to the tip of the implement this could be an issue, hence type (b). Note that a blade rubbing against the handles is still type (a) in my book as it only affects the face of the blade (although some people may consider it bad, making the blade less corrosion resistant due to a less than polished finish etc).
-
Ah I'm with you. Yes, if it was damaging the file then I would agree with you on that.
-
This is my 1000th post. Officially a no lifer :(
This all comes down to expectations. The Charge series have slightly different tool sets (extra bit driver, gut hook, better grade blade steel) than the Wave. It's like a high performance version. I view the scale materials as one would the bodywork on a car. Sleeker design, more exotic materials.
If one bought a Charge as a higher "performance" (or more specialized) version of a Wave, I don't think the blemishes will bother you. If you bought it in "collector" model (ie it's a thing of beauty to enjoy forever) then the standard, off the manufacturing run TTi will disappoint.
This is analogous, I think, to car collectors. If you've ever been to a collector's show, the vehicles on display are much cleaner examples than you could ever get from the dealer. Better paint, nuts and bolts pristine, body panels more perfectly matched, upholstry perfect.
Yes, you can go through and examine multiple cars to get the nicest example at the dealer, but it still won't match a show car. If you bought one sight unseen, it is likely to be less perfect than the hand picked one.
That said, it will still perform as designed.
OTOH, I recently succumbed and bought a Damascus Wave. I do expect that to arrive in collector condition, and if it isn't, I'll send it back--my expectation is, a limited run edition (that doesn't appear to have the same 25 year warranty) better be perfect in all respects when it reaches my hands--especially since it appears Leatherman expects this won't be my EDC user tool.
Woohoo! One thousand posts in 6 months. :ahhh
-
Mr. W, wow! Congratulations! ;)
A look at the tti and most would consider it a premium tool from Leatherman, at least the price certainly reflects that. Few would dispute the quality and function of it. It's just disappointing for some who have shelled out that premium price for a tool that has a bit of shoddy quality control in some instances that might have been overlooked. If it was a cheaper price maybe not much would be said about it. This tool up here in Canada, the new batch coming in will run you about $150.
Damn rights the Damascus better be flawless. :D -
the file rubbing not only wears down the file, but the inside of the scales get worn, resulting in shavings in your tool that will get into the other joints if not cleaned.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
OTOH, I recently succumbed and bought a Damascus Wave. I do expect that to arrive in collector condition, and if it isn't, I'll send it back--my expectation is, a limited run edition (that doesn't appear to have the same 25 year warranty) better be perfect in all respects when it reaches my hands--especially since it appears Leatherman expects this won't be my EDC user tool.I would agree. Anything sold with the intent that it shouldn't be used and is for collecting purposes only should have a much higher degree of finish.
-
Congrats Mr. W on the 1K posts

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
This is my 1000th post. Officially a no lifer :(This all comes down to expectations. The Charge series have slightly different tool sets (extra bit driver, gut hook, better grade blade steel) than the Wave. It's like a high performance version. I view the scale materials as one would the bodywork on a car. Sleeker design, more exotic materials.
If one bought a Charge as a higher "performance" (or more specialized) version of a Wave, I don't think the blemishes will bother you. If you bought it in "collector" model (ie it's a thing of beauty to enjoy forever) then the standard, off the manufacturing run TTi will disappoint.
This is analogous, I think, to car collectors. If you've ever been to a collector's show, the vehicles on display are much cleaner examples than you could ever get from the dealer. Better paint, nuts and bolts pristine, body panels more perfectly matched, upholstry perfect.
Yes, you can go through and examine multiple cars to get the nicest example at the dealer, but it still won't match a show car. If you bought one sight unseen, it is likely to be less perfect than the hand picked one.
That said, it will still perform as designed.
OTOH, I recently succumbed and bought a Damascus Wave. I do expect that to arrive in collector condition, and if it isn't, I'll send it back--my expectation is, a limited run edition (that doesn't appear to have the same 25 year warranty) better be perfect in all respects when it reaches my hands--especially since it appears Leatherman expects this won't be my EDC user tool.
Woohoo! One thousand posts in 6 months. :ahhh
Cograts Mr icecream man. A Nolifer & an owner of a Damascus Wave , what a flamboyant entry into the the CLUB.
:D :D :D -
well... maybe if they start manufacturing them in China you might see quality control start to even out more. :P
Maybe be cheaper as well :)
seriously though, what isn't made in china these days.
Leatherman Tools? ;)
I still don't buy the "LM QC sucks" argument, and I think I see where the different opinions are formed - in individual expectations.
To my mind, good QC really means making sure that the product (in this case the tool) is fit for purpose and within tolerance for things like aesthetics etc. It seems that many people here place high priority on the latter, whereas I don't as the former is far more important to me.
Thinking back to the car analogy used earlier in the thread, I don't see tools and cars as comparable really. Maybe a better anology would be something like a broom? As long as it's functional, robust and I'm not going to get splinters from using it, I really couldn't care less whether the varnish was applied to the handle evenly. I reckon some of you lot would be apoplectic!! :D
Shininess, clickiness whatever aren't important to me at all really, although, as I've said a number of times on here, I do enjoy pawing the Swisstool & Spirit from time to time, but let's be honest, it makes bugger all difference to the intended use of the tool does it?
Some of the things listed are genuine problems, but mostly it's grumbles about things that really don't matter to most users of tools I would suggest.
In summary, rather than being poor - it's more likely that Leatherman's QC is based on what their customers *generally *consider to be important, not what you guys see as important.
Dave if I spent $200+ on a broom that fuc$er had better be perfectly balanced, french polished, poetry with brushes. If I spent $200+ on a broom it would also make me a 'nut bag' or a witch :P :P.
If said $200+ broom was then to give me a splinter because the French polish guy did not like his job or could not give an arse. I think I would be well justified in being ticked at the 'Insane Broom Company'.
$200+ tools that are not as well put together as $5 tools is a recipe for bankruptcy & narky customers.I think it is safe to say that far too many Charges are leaving Portland with files that rub & a smaller number have lock issues. -
Except from the Leatherman website FAQ.
"Why should I buy a Leatherman tool?
Tim Leatherman's standards for quality, durability, precision and attention to detail are what make Leatherman tools like no other. Ever since Tim invented the category, we've focused on just one thing — manufacturing the world's highest quality multipurpose tools."We have a right to expect performance, precision and quality.
-
^^ Man's got a point......
-
@Crouton said:
Except from the Leatherman website FAQ."Why should I buy a Leatherman tool?
Tim Leatherman's standards for quality, durability, precision and attention to detail are what make Leatherman tools like no other. Ever since Tim invented the category, we've focused on just one thing — manufacturing the world's highest quality multipurpose tools."We have a right to expect performance, precision and quality.
Was this before or after he became a millionaire? Doubt he cares about these issues. Main problem is that we represent a small minority of buyers, and we don't know how many are returned/repaired vs. sold, so we don't know how big or small this issue really is.
-
@Crouton said:
Except from the Leatherman website FAQ."Why should I buy a Leatherman tool?
Tim Leatherman's standards for quality, durability, precision and attention to detail are what make Leatherman tools like no other. Ever since Tim invented the category, we've focused on just one thing — manufacturing the world's highest quality multipurpose tools."We have a right to expect performance, precision and quality.
Touché...

-
@MultiMat said:
$200+ tools that are not as well put together as $5 tools is a recipe for bankruptcy & narky customers.I think it is safe to say that far too many Charges are leaving Portland with files that rub & a smaller number have lock issues.Are you really saying that you believe that Charges are not as well put together as $5 tools? I'll take a few of those $5 tools from you then please. Hell, if they're better put together than Charges, I'll pay double.
Let's keep a little bit of reality in these posts guys, it'll help your arguments IMO.
@Crouton said:
Except from the Leatherman website FAQ."Why should I buy a Leatherman tool?
Tim Leatherman's standards for quality, durability, precision and attention to detail are what make Leatherman tools like no other. Ever since Tim invented the category, we've focused on just one thing — manufacturing the world's highest quality multipurpose tools."We have a right to expect performance, precision and quality.
Of course we do. And if you aren't happy with it then the warranty will look after you. And, as I've pointed out already, I have (I think) more 'perfect' Charges in my own collection than defective ones that people have managed to list on the increasing number of "Charge bashing" threads on the go at the moment.
It's a bloody tool, not fine jewellery ::)
That's not aimed at you specifically Crouton, more at the angry mob sharpening their pitch-forks above. ::)
-
It's all good Dave, I love to see a good debate.
-
$200+ tools that are not as well put together as $5 tools is a recipe for bankruptcy & narky customers.I think it is safe to say that far too many Charges are leaving Portland with files that rub & a smaller number have lock issues.
Are you really saying that you believe that Charges are not as well put together as $5 tools? I'll take a few of those $5 tools from you then please. Hell, if they're better put together than Charges, I'll pay double.
Let's keep a little bit of reality in these posts guys, it'll help your arguments IMO.
How about we bring some impartiality too the argument Dave

OK , how about my $0.99 Paul Chen is better put together than the 3 Titanium Charges I have owned. The Paul Chen operates faultlessly, every thing works on it as it should.Is it a better tool than the Charges NO , is it made with better materials NO. But if I was to fill out a survey giving feed back I would say "great stuff Mr Chen you sold me a tool that works great with no problems". The titanium Charges are very expensive MT's across the board , I have a right to expect this very expensive tool will operate as well as my $50 Spirit , my $60 SOG PPP. Given that Charges cost almost double what most MT's cost I think I am well justified in expecting them to be better than opposition when it comes to them performing as they should. 3 out of 3 have files that rub & one of the TTi's linner locks would often not engage .Dave I love Leatherman tools all of them are great. The only ones I have ever had a problem with is the 3 Titanium Charges . It is clear to me that they are leaving the factory with issues.Given the $ they charge for them they should be made to standard as, good/better than their Kick , not worse.
Dave if Victorinox's Swisstools had a problem with rubbing files or lock's that were a bit iffy you would be all over them . Dave , Leatherman is not perfect .
You owe me $1.98 for my Paul Chen :P :D -
It is interesting. My ALX has a spacer on the file and the saw. There is no way they'd be able to rub. On my Wave Damascus, there is no spacer on either. (No rubbing either, btw).
I suspect (since I don't own a TTi) there is no spacer on the Charge TTi files, and therefore there is less clearance. Someone mentioned that the TTi is thinner than the ALX, so perhaps that's the problem.
Then again, maybe most people who purchase them don't really use them and don't notice the rub. If it were as big a problem as it appears here on MT.O, I suspect LM would simply add a small spacer--end of problem.
jmo
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login