Climber vs Explorer
-
@Sos24 said:
Whether or not it is worth it really depends.Three layers is such a sweet spot for SAKs, especially if just throwing in a pocket, but the inline Phillips is really nice. So for you it probably comes down to how much you need a 3D phillips vs how much a thicker SAK would bother you.
Personally, I use the inline phillips a decent amount and I also think the mag glass is pretty useful too. I normally carry my SAK in pocket organizer in a cargo pocket in which case 4 layers doesn’t phase me. However, if carrying loose in a front pocket, I feel anything larger than 3 layers is just uncomfortable.
Ok, not nit-picking, just asking for clarification. Are we saying that an inline Phillips is the same thing as a 3D Phillips? Why the two terms? To me, every phillips I've ever seen on a 91mm knife has been a 3d phillips, whether it's on the magnifying glass layer, or on the backspring.
-
@Jim the Brave said:
Ok, not nit-picking, just asking for clarification. Are we saying that an inline Phillips is the same thing as a 3D Phillips? Why the two terms? To me, every phillips I've ever seen on a 91mm knife has been a 3d phillips, whether it's on the magnifying glass layer, or on the backspring.The tip of the can opener would be considered by many to be a 2D Phillips.
-
@Jim the Brave said:
Ok, not nit-picking, just asking for clarification. Are we saying that an inline Phillips is the same thing as a 3D Phillips? Why the two terms? To me, every phillips I've ever seen on a 91mm knife has been a 3d phillips, whether it's on the magnifying glass layer, or on the backspring.Exactly as nate j said. The inline phillips is a 3D phillips, as is the backside phillips. The can opener can be used for some phillips screws, so some consider it a phillips driver, but it is not 3D (cross shaped).
-
@Sos24 said:
Exactly as nate j said. The inline phillips is a 3D phillips, as is the backside phillips. The can opener can be used for some phillips screws, so some consider it a phillips driver, but it is not 3D (cross shaped).Ok, I see. But I would never call that a phillips driver, I would call it a flat-head or slotted screwdriver, which could in some cases be used to drive phillips screws.
Now I have seen what might be called a "2D" phillips driver on some multi-tools. It looks like a phillips, and is intended to act as one, but is flat and only has fakish cross lines on it to remind you what it's for. I think I've seen it on a Gerber MT....can't recall for sure. I was confused thinking that some people thought the backside phillips was only 2D.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
I just recently got a Climber and love it. However it got me thinking about the Explorer. For those of you that have the Explorer is the Phillips worth the extra layer? I find that can opener works pretty well and the Climber is very pocketable.Totally worth it. But mostly if it’s an older version, for the longer shank and the ability to drive much smaller screws. Like found in small electronics. Pre-‘02 if you want the hook. Pre-‘91 if you don’t.
The ‘02+ stubby does have the advantage in confined spaces especially when 90° use is required or helpful.
And the magnifier was always useful to me. Moreso after I turned 40. Good for more than burning ants.
-
If you don’t want the extra layer, and are happy with a combo tool and one blade only, then why not look at a Yeoman (with plus scales)? I had to mod one myself from an explorer and a compact, but it wasn’t that hard to do.... For me, it gives all the functions of an explorer in only 3 layers, but I know many miss the small blade and don’t get on with the combo tool preferring the opener layer.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
I just recently got a Climber and love it. However it got me thinking about the Explorer. For those of you that have the Explorer is the Phillips worth the extra layer? I find that can opener works pretty well and the Climber is very pocketable.I guess the main thing is: what do or would you use a SAK's SD (phillips) for. That IMO would be the most important fact on wether you would be bothered to carry a 4 layer SAK just for the inline philips alone.
For MY use i don't consider the inline phillips justifiable to carry a 4 layer SAK, even if i like that inline phillips. I rather carry my Deluxe Tinker that is the same thickness and gives me the pliers that's a lot more useful to me, and i also have the 3D phillips on the back, as well as the SD in the can opener. Anything more specific i can use the bottle opener with my SD bits. For more serious (non incidental) work i'll use an actual Philips SD. These days however, i get by with either a Rambler or Minichamp, it cover 90% of what i'd need. If i need a bigger blade i'll just grab the DT.So from your two options i'd take the Climber (or the Super Tinker if you don't really need to have the CS...) ;)
-
*
In my view, the extra layer is definitely worth it to get the inline phillips. The whole world is held together with phillips screws, and the inline driver gives you the reach and accessibility not available from the backside phillips or the 2D can opener. As for the comfort of a 3-layer SAK vs. 4 layers, I cannot tell if either is in my pocket until I reach for it so for me that's a non-issue. After a short while, one's brain becomes accustomed to your pocket toys and tends to forget about them.* -
@SirVicaLot said:
Depends on if you like to have a 3D Phillips on you, i guess. Just remember that the Explorer is noticeable thicker than other 4 layers, due to the thickness of the Phillips/Mag layer.Do inline phillips drivers take more space than back-side ones?
-
@powernoodle said:
In my view, the extra layer is definitely worth it to get the inline phillips. The whole world is held together with phillips screws, and the inline driver gives you the reach and accessibility not available from the backside phillips or the 2D can opener. As for the comfort of a 3-layer SAK vs. 4 layers, I cannot tell if either is in my pocket until I reach for it so for me that's a non-issue. After a short while, one's brain becomes accustomed to your pocket toys and tends to forget about them.[/i]Yes, I agree. As has been said before, I suppose everybody eventually has their limit. I can carry a SwissChamp in my front pocket without it bothering me. I can carry 7 knives of different sizes (in the winter) and not notice. Not everybody can, and eventually summer comes and we shed layers..... at which point it becomes more critical.
I just sold my Swisschamp, though....time to buy another one. I hardly dared use it because I knew I was planning to resell it in nice condition.
But I agree, one's brain quickly adjusts to what you're carrying....may as well carry a lot more!
-
I can take or leave the inline Phillips. When I use the Explorer, it's so I can look at everything within 300km through the magnifying glass, like I'm an 8-year-old or something.
-
@Jothra said:
When I use the Explorer, it's so I can look at everything within 300km through the magnifying glass, like I'm an 8-year-old or something.They were funny an interesting as kids. I’ll have to remember that. So know when I need to use the magnifying glass to see small part or something, it isn’t because I’m getting old like an 80year old, it is because I’m Exploring like an 8 year old.
-
I’m with you there, Sos24- I’m not blind, really...... 
-
As someone who really likes the Explorer Plus I say YES. The inline phillips is very nice and while I've used the can opener for phillips screws the inline is just so perfect. I also appreciate the mag glass very much as well. Its been clutch at the flea market for looking at tang stamps and other small print things. I also like to look at a variety of other things just because I can. The extra layer for me is non issue as I carry mine in a Skinth or Zermatt sheath.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
I just recently got a Climber and love it. However it got me thinking about the Explorer. For those of you that have the Explorer is the Phillips worth the extra layer? I find that can opener works pretty well and the Climber is very pocketable.VERY late to the party...as a multiple-Explorer owner, it's a great model. As someone earlier in the thread said, the world is held together with Phillips screws; but beyond that, EVERYBODY'S got a phone with a camera, and dangit, the magnifier makes a good zoom lens with a lil practice.
They say the TV adds 20 lbs to you...well, a dangler clip subtracts at least a layer from a SAK. Get a dangler like a TEC and your Explorer will stand off in a quiet corner of your pocket and feel like a Climber or even a Spartan. Give it a try.
-
The inline Phillips driver is basically like having a screwdriver in your pocket at all times. Which for me is indispensably handy. The Magnifying glass- besides it’s normally uses - also gives you the ability to start a fire in a survival situation if it’s sunny out. Personally I can’t tell the difference between a three layer in my pocket or a four layer especially when using a Sbiner or pocket Dangler clip. The difference in weight is less than 20 g I think.
But let’s see what Arnold says...

-
I've mentioned this in other threads - the inline Phillips takes a hex bit adapter, letting you use your SAK with all of the hex bits and sockets out there.
(The photo is with a Swiss Champ, but works just as well on the Explorer.)

-
2D Phillips is the one found on Leatherman Squirt. Victorinox could add that, it is very flat and thin.
On the other hand, you could reshape the can opener to look like that, all you have to do is firm the tip as a triangle with the proper angle.
The Hex adapter on Swisschamp works and it works on Swiss tool too. I used it for years, but I carry Cybertool and Leatherman bits now. It always remains an option though. -
@Intorikata said:
VERY late to the party...as a multiple-Explorer owner, it's a great model. As someone earlier in the thread said, the world is held together with Phillips screws; but beyond that, EVERYBODY'S got a phone with a camera, and dangit, the magnifier makes a good zoom lens with a lil practice.They say the TV adds 20 lbs to you...well, a dangler clip subtracts at least a layer from a SAK. Get a dangler like a TEC and your Explorer will stand off in a quiet corner of your pocket and feel like a Climber or even a Spartan. Give it a try.

The Explorer is my default SAK for EDC. I got mine specifically for the magnifying glass; the inline Philips driver is just a very useful bonus. I also carry mine on a dangler clip, and it hangs very unobtrusively in the rear corner of my right jeans pocket.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login