What Traditional Knife are you toting today?
-
Case Whittler & GEC Mustang
-
-
@Jim the Brave said:
There are some interesting ones on eBay right now, around the world....Bargeon = correct, if it is stamped Bargeon somewhere, usually on tang. Bargeon and Pradel made these sorts of multitool knives in large numbers after 1945, less in the depression of the 1930s. Not sure about war time production numbers. I believe both were made in Thiers after the war.
Bargeons seem to be better quality than Pradel on these low end knives and bring more on EBay France generally. These French knives tended to tarnish and pit and scale crack and few pristine examples come up on E Bay. If it says Bargeon you can probably trust it. Pradels on the other hand were widely copied within France since the early part of the 20th Century. Outside the familiar white with a Red Cross Pradels you have to know an awful lot about Pradels to be confident you actually have one. Bargeon seems to have been the better knife post war, but the French reputedly preferred the action and distinct closing sound of the knife pivot on the Pradel. For a time the French supposedly had a saying: nothing else sounds like a Pradel closing, or something like that. Hopefully one of our French knights will weigh in and clear up my vague recollections. But Bargeon seems to have been the more desirable maker post war.
Pradel’s fisherman’s folders originated somewhere on the Atlantic coast of France and are prized collectibles, if one can be found in good condition, which is extremely rare. I recall they date to late 19th Century, maybe early 20th. They had a fishing weight logo etched into the blade. Alas these early knives began to be copied widely to the point there were far more fakes than authentics even in the first half of the 20th Century. Couple rust in salt air and scads of fakes and real Pradels with fishing weight logo are rare and tough to identify. Copies called themselves Pradels and some even had fishing weight logos! Eventually Pradel moved to Thiers, France’s Centre Couteau. That is the limit of my French. 😀 Bargeon either started in Thiers or wound up there also.
Many French knife brands/types were copied in France long before today’s Asian and Turkish copies proliferated. Five years ago I once read a knowledgeable French knife person about how hard it was to identify a good Laguiole style knife even after one reads the things to look for. His advice was to get some recommendations of custom knife makers working today in France and have a good knife made, according to tradition rather than risk being fooled by copies. He said the artisan knife makers are scattered around France. He said they are often reasonable in price, if you do not insist on lots of engraving, which he said unfortunately too many foreigners want more than a good knife. He said in Thiers that one often bought a knife of Turkish components only assembled in Thiers with a little engraving added and then branded as made in France. Thus he said pay a bit more and get a good knife made by a local craftsman. All that being said, I really like those old Bargeons like yours for vintage production knives. Like so many things French, they “feel” good. There is another brand that begins with a B also that is decent. After my last trip to France I kind of read up on French knives, looked to buy some, but then lost interest because of authentication and condition constraints. Next trip I hope to order one made, while over there. But I have forgotten the fellow’s name in a little town 20-30 km south of Versailles I had recommended to me.
A long way around the barn to say nice Bargeon!
-
Lots of great knives today, gentlemen

-
@SgtTowser said:
edit for brevityA long way around the barn to say nice Bargeon!
That's some excellent information Sgt.
Thanks for taking the time. -
My first Case (quite a few years back now); a good old medium stockman, yellow Delrin and CV blades.

-
That's a classic Gareth !

-
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-

Little guy, 65-69
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Buck 501 and a #29 Whittler

-
It's the specialty blades that wouldn't be useful for anything else such as that triangular blade in what would otherwise just be a regular Stockman.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=keuRiJrNqGI -
@Alan K. said:
It's the specialty blades that wouldn't be useful for anything else such as that triangular blade in what would otherwise just be a regular Stockman.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=keuRiJrNqGIThanks, I'll need to watch that video when I have time! Looks great.
-
Posted this one awhile back.
The Old Coyote lockback in green saw cut delrin scales, brass bolsters and “HIGH carbon steel” that will rust even in a smidge of humidity if I don’t keep it waxed. But oh how I love HCS on a traditional folder, rather than stainless.
This is my favorite cheap traditional of all time. I always say I am done carrying it, but after a couple months I go dig it out and am happy all over again. I never tire of brass bolsters and green delrin. I suppose emerald would be more accurate. I know. I know. Exotic wood or torched bone are the standards in traditionals, but this is my own little idiosyncrasy. Brass bolsters and green saw cut delrin. There is no explaining it. I just love it.
Here it is drawn in my car while waiting in a parking lot.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



