84mm SAK love
-
Actually, on second thought, I think you're right. The Waiter has such a lightweight profile that it just feels wrong.
But I looked closer at my recently bought Tinker and the liners seem to be the same material.
Thanks,
Jeff -
-
My passion for 84mm had to see this thread on the front page! I'm very new to SAKs (3 weeks!) but five out of a the eight I've acquired are 84mm. My first "real" SAK (after my excelsior many years ago) was a Tinker Small. On paper this seemed like the perfect SAK with its balance of size, layers and backside tools.
How wrong I was! As soon as it arrived I could only look upon it with disgust. My opinion on the backside Phillips had changed during the time the Tinker had spent in transit. I had underestimated how effective the can-opener driver would be, and I am now of the (controversial) opinion that all Cellidor SAKs should have a corkscrew! Not that I've ever used it, or the mini-driver. It's all about the character...
The Sportsman (or Tourist) are the perfect balance of layers to tools for my use (and aesthetics), although I do see the appeal of the Waiter as an ultra-light carry. The Waiter is noticeably thinner and lighter than the 2 layer 84mm's, but this makes it feels slightly unbalanced in my hands.
Despite its obvious omission, the Walker is also an excellent little knife. The saw is very efficient for the size and I find it performs fairly similarly its 91mm cousin. I'm not a huge fan of the combo tool as a driver (although it has surprised me on a few Phillips heads), but it's a price I'm willing to pay to stick to 2 layers. Alox isn't really my thing, but I have to admit lusting over the alox Walker.
-
Today I received another custom made copper scaled Victorinox. This time an 84mm Excelsior and a right little beauty she is too.
Customised solid copper scales on a new SAK with subtle brass pins.
I'm rather looking forward to her developing a decent unique patina (and probably many scratches) over time.She's got a bit of heft and gravitas (60g vs the standard 22g) which I really like.
(Those interested can see her sister here: /topic/40930)




-
@uno más said:

My passion for 84mm had to see this thread on the front page! I'm very new to SAKs (3 weeks!) but five out of a the eight I've acquired are 84mm. My first "real" SAK (after my excelsior many years ago) was a Tinker Small. On paper this seemed like the perfect SAK with its balance of size, layers and backside tools.
How wrong I was! As soon as it arrived I could only look upon it with disgust. My opinion on the backside Phillips had changed during the time the Tinker had spent in transit. I had underestimated how effective the can-opener driver would be, and I am now of the (controversial) opinion that all Cellidor SAKs should have a corkscrew! Not that I've ever used it, or the mini-driver. It's all about the character...
The Sportsman (or Tourist) are the perfect balance of layers to tools for my use (and aesthetics), although I do see the appeal of the Waiter as an ultra-light carry. The Waiter is noticeably thinner and lighter than the 2 layer 84mm's, but this makes it feels slightly unbalanced in my hands.
Despite its obvious omission, the Walker is also an excellent little knife. The saw is very efficient for the size and I find it performs fairly similarly its 91mm cousin. I'm not a huge fan of the combo tool as a driver (although it has surprised me on a few Phillips heads), but it's a price I'm willing to pay to stick to 2 layers. Alox isn't really my thing, but I have to admit lusting over the alox Walker.
Very nice start to the collection uno

84’s are great for edc as disappear in your pocket. Many years ago my first 84 was a waiter and I still rate it highly, walker and tinker for a change too. Horses for courses, if you find the waiter too small (unbalanced) maybe for those times you need your bigger SAKs but good to have as back up
You say alox isn’t your thing, fair enough, we’ll see, MTo has its special ways

but I highly recommend the cadet and alox bantam that’s small enough to fit in your wallet

-
@Grunthos said:
Today I received another custom made copper scaled Victorinox. This time an 84mm Excelsior and a right little beauty she is too.Customised solid copper scales on a new SAK with subtle brass pins.
I'm rather looking forward to her developing a decent unique patina (and probably many scratches) over time.She's got a bit of heft and gravitas (60g vs the standard 22g) which I really like.
(Those interested can see her sister here: /topic/40930)
Absolutely gorgeous Grunthos

-
-
My 84’s
Cadets, one of my all time favourites, all slightly different

Popular
Waiter
Waiter ecoline (my first)
Walker
Golfer
Tinker
Bantam
-
I do believe I'm starting to become addicted to off beat scales ;)
Took a fancy to some 84mm brass scales I noticed on Fleabay and decided to take a punt on ordering.
Scales duly arrived and were promptly fitted.
I think they look good (although photos do not do them any justice).
What you will not experience is how weighty they are!
This has turned my standard Sportsman into something with heft (similar to the copper ones I mentioned earlier in this thread but more so...).This SAK now weighs in at 107g compared to the usual 52g - roughly the same as a Farmer X.
Looking forward to it ageing well...
web.jpg)
web.jpg)
web.jpg)
-
@Grunthos said:
I do believe I'm starting to become addicted to off beat scales ;)Took a fancy to some 84mm brass scales I noticed on Fleabay and decided to take a punt on ordering.
Scales duly arrived and were promptly fitted.
I think they look good (although photos do not do them any justice).
What you will not experience is how weighty they are!
This has turned my standard Sportsman into something with heft (similar to the copper ones I mentioned earlier in this thread but more so...).This SAK now weighs in at 107g compared to the usual 52g - roughly the same as a Farmer X.
Looking forward to it ageing well...
Those look awesome!

-
Nice mod

-
nice work, Gareth!

-
Cheers all.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
