SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
I don't mind either, but I think my preference would be for the corkscrew for untying knots, and for the wicked little screwdriver :)
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I don't mind either, but I think my preference would be for the corkscrew for untying knots, and for the wicked little screwdriver :)Sums up my thoughts exactly. The mini screwdriver is great, and can be used as a mini pokey-thing if needed (it scrapes the lint from the layers of my SAK quite nicely :D). The corkscrew does help with knots, and I've used it loads for its intended purpose as well.
-
Why not go for a Scientist or Yeoman and have the best of both worlds? ^^;
The question is about backspring tools though, so unless you have some wicked mods, I doubt you have them both on there. :D
I do agree though, both is nice, but when carried with a MT it's pretty pointless added bulk IMO.
I think Spork is the only person to have ever done that but I don't think he bothered to peen the resulting monster as it was a bit unweildy.
Corkscrew is good for holding the mini screwdriver but I think I've only opened two bottles of wine in my entire life with a SAK. The backspring phillips is in a pretty crap place and I'd rather use the can opener instead if the SAK didn't have a proper in line one. The phillips does make the SAK comfier to hold though, especially if it one old the older style square shank jobs. Frankly I think its time we had a better option than either.
-
Corkscrew for me i am a wine drinker. I live in the San Joaquin valley in California we have wineries everywhere and i am a big fan of the eye glass screwdriver.
Mike -
Corkscrew. The Phillips should be on the end!
-
@max6166 said:
Phillips for me. I absolutely hate the way the corkscrew the handle feel.+1
Hate corkscrews!
Hate the feel, hate the aesthetics.
Corkscrew ruins the smooth, sleek lines of a SAK.
A decent Phillips is crucial for me. The backspring Phillips on my Tinker has proved its utility many times over the years.
Would never buy any SAK with a corkscrew, unless it also offered an inline Phillips, like the Wenger S557.
.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I don't mind either, but I think my preference would be for the corkscrew for untying knots, and for the wicked little screwdriver :)
Sums up my thoughts exactly. The mini screwdriver is great, and can be used as a mini pokey-thing if needed (it scrapes the lint from the layers of my SAK quite nicely :D). The corkscrew does help with knots, and I've used it loads for its intended purpose as well.
I do that too

-
Looks like there are a few more corkscrew fans here than phillips fans. I thought it would have been the other way round TBH. I'm never usually part of the majority. :D
-
A pox on backspring philips drivers ! Give me a corkscrew every time , can't live without the eyeglass screwdriver .
Chris
-
My vote for the corkscrew is more a vote for the mini eyeglass screwdriver.
Phillips drivers I have on my main multitool, and on the Vic can opener in a pinch.
-
Give me the Phillips any day over a corkscrew. I don't drink wine, and haven't used a corkscrew in ages.
Now to make me really happy, switch that Phillips to a Robertson.

-
I would normally say phillips, but the one on my OHT is slightly damaged after using it once. Don't really like the metal used for it. So corkscrew for me, like the other, because you can attach the mini screwdriver.
-
I need the small screw driver and cork screw is really use full on pick nicks. Plus I have a bad experience on the philips, I used mine philips everytime, it ruined lock/springs above it.
-
I voted phillips which is surprising because my first Vic was a Camper and later I was introduced to the mini screwdriver.
I use to just skip over SAKs that didn't have the corkscrew just because I loved the mini so much until one day the mini
failed me and I ended up using the nail cleaner on my Wenger nail clippers to tighten the screw.Now I don't even like the look or feel of the corkscrew. I still think that an inline phillips is the best thing going.
-
Well thanks to you guys I am going to carry my SAK with the Phillips and try it
-
Phillips all the way for me, even going as far as wanting to mod my otherwise faves to get rid of the corkscrew. I will have a few corkscrews lying about going spare so if anyone's desperate for one, let me know!
I don't drink often, any very rarely wine so I have no use for the things.. I use the toothpick for de-linting etc so don't miss the mini screwdriver really. :)
-
i have never had a need for a cork screw. worse, they don't feel right during normal use of an SAK. for that matter i have found no use for the hook on my super tinker but at least it's out of the way. the corkscrew looks and feels uncomfortable to me.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



:D
