What Traditional Knife are you toting today?
-
@SgtTowser said:
Time Tunnel...Sarge, is the top knife the one you've really connected to?
-
@old Lefty said:

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Nice Trapper !
@Gareth said:
Well, I actually stuck with the Sodbuster Jr for quite a few days. I'll admit it wasn't a knife I instantly fell in love with but we seem to be rubbing along well enough now. That said I've changed today and put my Baregeon in my pocket.Gareth

@SgtTowser said:
Time Tunnel...
-
The Sod buster is what it is. I think thats part of the appeal and part of why it takes a moment to connect to. The handle shape and the boringness of it all makes for a knife thats purely utilitarian, which is not a bad thing. There are other knives that evoke immediate emotion, the Sod Buster was not one of them. Great knife, just eh in pizzazz.
Funny enough tho, my simple little REX knife is one that I immediately connected to. Its also a simple little knife but theres that "something" that resonated with me.
I'll pack my Soddie with full confidence its a performer but it doesn't put a smile on my face when I take it out my pocket. Thats ok tho because thats where my Pemberton comes into play. Love that little knife.
-
Jack and a Stockman

-
- Those look great together.
-
@Aloha said:
Sarge, is the top knife the one you've really connected to?Yes, if you mean the Camillus rope knife. The Western and I are just trysting so far. 😀
I just can’t stop using the Cam on my home construction projects. I feel a little embarrassed to show it to tradesmen that all seem to carry pretty good stuff these days, or to pull it out at a barbecue, because it’s blade is so badly ground, but I have finally come out of the closet and faced up. I have fallen in love with an ugly knife!
I looked at a couple Camillus coping knives on EBay just like it that were in good condition, but then I thought: what’s the point? The fates brought me this one by chance. It went through building my rolling planter box that turned out pretty well; so, I feel it’s a good luck knife. Good luck is not for sale on EBay or Etsy. There is no sort command for luck.
If this one cuts for me and brings me luck; then if I stand pat I am leaving the other coping knives for other SAK knights to find and decide for themselves.
Note: the blade is a coping blade (thick spine end to end); NOT a “cleaver,” or “sheep’s foot,” at least if I understand the definitions and categories correctly.
And it’s a full 3.5 inches long. Lots of the other brands of coping knives look the same in the pictures, but are 3.0 or 2.75 inches; and that literally wouldn’t “cut it” for me. And though you hold it like a straight razor at times, it is NOT a razor either.
The idea of a coping blade is to have a nice long straight edge to slide across the rope (or bag), so the knife does most of the work and not you. That is my definition of a good tool. It’s why I love Stihl chain saws. Press bulb 6 times. Choke. Pull. Warm up. Hold near the bark. Give it the gas. Let it drift down through the limb, or trunk. Similar with a coping knife. Let it slide through the rope.
Other knife patterns can do this, of course.
But this pattern encourages it, when mated with a swayback handle.
Forget those coping blades not mated to a swayback handle. I cannot explain it, but a swayback works better. The Navy and CG were unwise to retire this knife in 1944 and replace it with the combo 3 inch blade and marlin spike with a cigar shape. Not the first time the military has evolved ineffectively. Won’t be the last. Think of some of the awful camouflage patterns they tried after effective olive drab, before finding the current effective pattern.
Used right, this knife slices. It doesn’t saw or cut. I did use it a little as a one handled draw knife, but that’s like drinking wine from a beer bottle. But
One other interesting thing: It inserts and slides under the edge of a card board box top and slices through the packing tape just as easily as a pointed knife, once you get the hang of using it (slightly different angle of approach).
Back to how bad it looks.
I don’t look so good anymore myself.
A beautiful thing is as useful as a useful thing, but ugly has its place to.
If I were buying, I would get the best, prettiest one I could find. Why not have both. But if all I could find were an ugly one, I would happily take it.
Age and experience make me feel a kinship with this old slicer.
But despite the scarred looks...
I stroke it 5 times away and 5 times toward on my DMT BLADE STEEL and the thing cuts like crazy, despite how ugly it looks.
And to reiterate, there is no pointy tip to worry about on a Coping blade and because the spine is thick all the way to the blunt nose of the end, it slices the same rate of cut with the same applied force all the way along the blade edge; none of that sliding round the belly (or back), or worrying about the tip, if I slice through the cut object a little sooner, or later, than I expect, which I often do. It’s a predictable knife. One could learn a lot about the kind of person to marry from living with this knife awhile.
It may sound lame to some blade masters, but it helps me focus more on what I’m building and how I’m going to make it work and less on avoiding getting cut, or actually getting cut.
I know I’m old, but this thing was made before my time, so I’m not caught up in nostalgia. I just picked up a new Cold Steel SK5 Fixed blade Survival Tanto and enjoy how it takes hair off my arm, stabs without breaking a tip, and can baton. But most of the time I’m not cutting hair, stabbing or batoning; though if I can lose another 15 pounds off the 20 I am now down, I may be able to drag my tired ass up the Sierras once more like the old days. 😀🤞 Regardless, mostly down here with the flatlanders, I’m cutting something draped over something else and being held in place with one hand and cutting with the ugly stick in the other. I have learned at a very late date that blade control is as important as sharpness and a long straight edge with a blunt nose and stiff spine is more controllable for me than all the curved, pointy, flippy, stabby blades. Maybe this is only so for me. Maybe I am an anomaly. But I am at least one data point.
I just don’t stab much when I am building chicken coops, garden planters, fences, window boxes, and opening bags of gardening materials and feed bags for bottomless pit dogs, cats, chickens and horses.
I know; this knife was made for Navy swabjockeys and Coast Guard coast huggers, but it’s darned good for life on the hard, too.
All for now.
-
@Aloha said:
The Sod buster is what it is. I think thats part of the appeal and part of why it takes a moment to connect to. The handle shape and the boringness of it all makes for a knife thats purely utilitarian, which is not a bad thing. There are other knives that evoke immediate emotion, the Sod Buster was not one of them. Great knife, just eh in pizzazz.Funny enough tho, my simple little REX knife is one that I immediately connected to. Its also a simple little knife but theres that "something" that resonated with me.
I'll pack my Soddie with full confidence its a performer but it doesn't put a smile on my face when I take it out my pocket. Thats ok tho because thats where my Pemberton comes into play. Love that little knife.

-
You both might enjoy the quest for a Robert Herder version of a sodbuster. Robert Herder (not to be confused with Frederick and Richard) makes almost only high carbon kitchen knives that are lusted after by chefs. And he does not cater much to USA, except for a few vendors. But he makes two folders—one a kind of overgrown sodbuster with a wooden handle, and the other a folder with a locking blade on top that his web site says dates back several centuries in Holland or Belgium, I forget which. The second one I suspect he makes simply to poke a little fun at those claiming today to have innovated similar locks recently, like the Buck 840/841 Marksman with strap lock, A.G. Russell’s one hand knife with something like a strap lock, and probably some others back in early American cutlery influenced by the Amsterdam streak of New Amsterdam (New York) culture.
The Herder knife closest to the sodbuster is called a hippeknieppe, or something close. This is a review of its virtues and vices. Herder knives are “about the blades.”
I am not entirely sure he still makes the sodbuster style knife. Might have to search used.
He has made his strap lock folding knife modeled largely on the old locking folk knives made by Europeans in the Low Countries (Belgium, maybe Holland too) several centuries back. Here is a link to this recent model called a ROBERT HERDER LIERENAAR FOLDING KNIFE. It is an American retailer that is sold out. But it gives the idea.
Robert Herder Lierenaar Folding Knife
Since 1872, Robert Herder has been crafting extremely sharp and versatile knives from the small town of Solingen in the West of Germany. Made by hand, every Robert Herder knife is one-of-a-kind and can find a place in the kitchen, shop, or field. The Lierernaar Folding Knife has a long history as a companion sort of kn
Hand-Eye Supply (www.handeyesupply.com)
Robert Herder’s knives are often underestimated by non Euros, because the firm makes no effort to doll them up for marketing. But his high carbon blades are serious business. I have not splurged on any, but I have used a neighbor’s paring knife and “it cuts”!
I am not promoting Herder and have no business interest in them or any retailers that carry them. I just think he is an interesting German cutler in Solingen. I first learned of him when researching to see if any high carbon blades today claimed to be made like thos of many decades past.
-
Gareth.

-
Sgt good pair.

-
Couple Pennsylvania knives. :D
-
Great post Sgt. I was pondering why I like knives that look like they've been kidnapped, mistreated, abused, and tossed aside like a bottle top. Theres a lot you said that I completely agree with
. I need a knife to cut. Pretty is great but I'll take ugly so long as it is a performer. Oddly tho, I do have an eye for the ugly one so long as its not broken.Here's a selection of rag tag Trads I picked up. While these are not going to win the hearts of a collector they cut and carry beautifully. They wont win fit and finish competitions but they are well made. They have all been used by who knows how many folks and have stood up to some real abuse by the looks of many. Most are a few decades old and still going strong and will for a while yet.
These are knives that get the task done just like any good knife should. They have the battle scars to prove they were used and sadly abused by previous owners. While I don't buy broken knives I am always happy to pick up one of these warriors.
Sure I like a pretty knife just like the next aficionado its why I carry my Pemberton daily. That little knife brings a smile to my face when I retrieve it from the sheath I carry it in. It was used by the previous owner which is nice but theres decades of character still yet to develop. I have the Schatt/Morgan as well and its a looker however I just dont carry it as much as I thought. My Queen Barlow ( blue ) is another looker. Thats one I love to carry and show off.
The warriors pictured are part of my growing trad collection. They are knives I enjoy buying and using. The companies that produced them are incredibly interesting to read about and important to the cutlery industry. I find I'm excited when I come upon one of these battle scared warriors as if it were mean to be. Whats made this new area of collecting so fun is how deep the history is with trads. While my collection of rag tag trads wont amount much in terms of dollar value the experience and what I've learned has been invaluable. My rag tag bunch wont win a beauty contest but they'll cut just as good as any knife. Its a shame so many if not all the makers are now gone. I happy they produced so many that finding them will be easy. As I was with collecting multitools, I love a bargain so the fleamarket and thrift stores are my hunting grounds. My last haul was a whole $9 which garnered my a couple gems.
If its not stamped Case then the fleamarket venders generally ask for $10 but I tend to get them for half that most times. Case is a brand they ask top dollar for and the ones I tend to leave to those folks who will pay top dollar. My interest is the other brands. I have a couple Case knives and I'm happy to have them. I didn't include all my trads just what I consider my rag tag examples.
1 Opinel
2 Imperial
3 Camillus 35
4 Camillus 64
5 Robeson ShurEdge
6 Kutmaster7 Buck Creek
8 Craftsmen 9494
9 Sears 95234
10 Schrade 1940T
11 Schrade 660T
12 Boker 99-08
13 Hammer Brand
14 REX15 Xcelite
16 Rough Rider
17 Queen
18 Queen Steel 27
19 Powr Kraft
20 Schatt and Morgan
21 Northfield GECI know some were made by the big companies but its still interesting to see the tang stamps with other names. Now I realize the GEC and Schatt and Morgan are not rag tag nor is the Queen Barlow ( blue ) those were added solely to make my point. They all cut and they all carry wonderfully regardless of perceived or real value.

-
-
@Aloha said:
Great post Sgt. I was pondering why I like knives that look like they've been kidnapped, mistreated, abused, and tossed aside like a bottle top. Theres a lot you said that I completely agree with
. I need a knife to cut. Pretty is great but I'll take ugly so long as it is a performer. Oddly tho, I do have an eye for the ugly one so long as its not broken.Here's a selection of rag tag Trads I picked up. While these are not going to win the hearts of a collector they cut and carry beautifully. They wont win fit and finish competitions but they are well made. They have all been used by who knows how many folks and have stood up to some real abuse by the looks of many. Most are a few decades old and still going strong and will for a while yet.
These are knives that get the task done just like any good knife should. They have the battle scars to prove they were used and sadly abused by previous owners. While I don't buy broken knives I am always happy to pick up one of these warriors.
Sure I like a pretty knife just like the next aficionado its why I carry my Pemberton daily. That little knife brings a smile to my face when I retrieve it from the sheath I carry it in. It was used by the previous owner which is nice but theres decades of character still yet to develop. I have the Schatt/Morgan as well and its a looker however I just dont carry it as much as I thought. My Queen Barlow ( blue ) is another looker. Thats one I love to carry and show off.
The warriors pictured are part of my growing trad collection. They are knives I enjoy buying and using. The companies that produced them are incredibly interesting to read about and important to the cutlery industry. I find I'm excited when I come upon one of these battle scared warriors as if it were mean to be. Whats made this new area of collecting so fun is how deep the history is with trads. While my collection of rag tag trads wont amount much in terms of dollar value the experience and what I've learned has been invaluable. My rag tag bunch wont win a beauty contest but they'll cut just as good as any knife. Its a shame so many if not all the makers are now gone. I happy they produced so many that finding them will be easy. As I was with collecting multitools, I love a bargain so the fleamarket and thrift stores are my hunting grounds. My last haul was a whole $9 which garnered my a couple gems.
If its not stamped Case then the fleamarket venders generally ask for $10 but I tend to get them for half that most times. Case is a brand they ask top dollar for and the ones I tend to leave to those folks who will pay top dollar. My interest is the other brands. I have a couple Case knives and I'm happy to have them. I didn't include all my trads just what I consider my rag tag examples.
1 Opinel
2 Imperial
3 Camillus 35
4 Camillus 64
5 Robeson ShurEdge
6 Kutmaster7 Buck Creek
8 Craftsmen 9494
9 Sears 95234
10 Schrade 1940T
11 Schrade 660T
12 Boker 99-08
13 Hammer Brand
14 REX15 Xcelite
16 Rough Rider
17 Queen
18 Queen Steel 27
19 Powr Kraft
20 Schatt and Morgan
21 Northfield GECI know some were made by the big companies but its still interesting to see the tang stamps with other names. Now I realize the GEC and Schatt and Morgan are not rag tag nor is the Queen Barlow ( blue ) those were added solely to make my point. They all cut and they all carry wonderfully regardless of perceived or real value.
Freaking outstanding collection of Dirty Dozen Knives!!!
I could love every last one!!!
You have become a adoption agency of wayward child knives!!!
To rephrase Ray Stevens’ “Everything is beautiful”...
“Every knife is beautiful/
In its own way/
Under knife God’s heaven
The world’s going to cut away!”You will get into knife heaven for this collection alone!!!
-
And pulling down a NORTHFIELD at a flea market means the knife god already has you on his A list!!!!
-
Robeson Suredges are what my dad swore by. They were often undervalued until about two years ago. The brand also went through a lot of owners. Some better, some worse. Keep that Robeson close to your vest till you learn which era it came from.
A fine flea market collection.
Why do we love those rag tags?
Hypothesis: Americans, however they claim to identify, instinctively love underdogs, especially in periods when the Crown is having its way with us.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login