Dreaming here.....84mm Compact
-
@Nix said:
Barry your point about the usefulness of the saw is a good one.
I can't recall a camping trip where I didn't have a saw with me, either in a knife or a multitool. Very useful for starting a small camp stove or feeding small bits of wood into a wood burning stove. Long distance guys seem to mostly use fuel stove (alcohol, or isobutane) and body heat to stay warm. And while a saw is handy for help to get to dry wood on a wet night, it is possible to start a camp fire without one.But saw.....brings us back to a Huntsman or Farmer X?

Or My First Vic Plus + 84mm scissors ;)
-
@Golivio said:
I think an 84mm compact would be a great tool but for a long distance híke I’d prefer a victorinox walker, still in 84mm but with saw instead of scissors. Would complement with Classic on the keyring. Other good option is the old 85mm Wenger Lumberjack. Its incredibly lightweight and slim. Id never go to the woods without a saw so a Camper would be a good option, with the awl included and still in a reasonable weight.Cheers.
Sound reasoning. I find the scissors get used more frequently than the saw. But...I do love my little Vic Saws. Adding a Classic is sort of cheating in this game: I was looking for a knife to replace the Classic as a long-distance trail knife. I'm really surprised by how many ultra-light long distance hikers carry only a Classic. Maybe the lesson here is: don't underestimate the Classic. :D
-
@Nix said:
I've never used an 84/85mm saw. For me the 91/93mm saws are marginally short. The 130mm saws rock! How do the 84mm saws work in the real world?
Personal preference I guess. I haven't used an 84mm Vic one, but the Wenger 85mm rocks, comparable to the 91mm one. And I personally don't like the 130mm one, too thick and you have to remove more material when sawing. The 111mm one works far better for me. That's why the Outrider is my go to for outdoors if I'm not carrying the Laplander/Mora Clipper combo.
-
@Nix said:
So, as long as I'm dreaming, I thought....Compact....with an awl....but smaller (and lighter): the awl-some 84mm Compact. I'd name it the 'Trail Angel'.84mm Golfer is what you're looking for, but it won't be easy to find (pictured center below). I'm not sure how you would incorporate an awl though.
I think your best bet would be to start with a Delemont 14 and mod it.
-
I did an informal test between Vic, Wenger and Leatherman saws awhile ago. All three are really good, but the Wenger seemed to be the most aggressive.
I carried my Huntsman, exclusively, for everything 32 years and never needed anything else. It's retired now, but it's a great platform. You're right Nix about that Classic. It's been my workhorse for awhile now and Cbl51 is right: they're a lot tougher than they look! With that and a small camping saw (Opinel), I think you're covered in most cases on the trail. Shoot, for the cost, you can even get a few backups
-
Um....in a situation like you described, I would say the SwissChamp would be the way to go....nothing wasted.... Hardly noticeable in the pocket.... YMMV....

-
@enki_ck said:
Personal preference I guess. I haven't used an 84mm Vic one, but the Wenger 85mm rocks, comparable to the 91mm one. And I personally don't like the 130mm one, too thick and you have to remove more material when sawing. The 111mm one works far better for me. That's why the Outrider is my go to for outdoors if I'm not carrying the Laplander/Mora Clipper combo.Indeed, the 111mm saws are great, too.
-
Yup, Golfer is basically an 84mm Compact. Not easy to find these days sadly.
The old Wenger Diplomat also does a lot of what you want and is more recently retired. https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Diplomat&highlight=diplomat
The Ambassador is basically and oversized Classic. :)
-
@Gareth said:
Yup, Golfer is basically an 84mm Compact. Not easy to find these days sadly.The old Wenger Diplomat also does a lot of what you want and is more recently retired. https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Diplomat&highlight=diplomat
The Ambassador is basically and oversized Classic. :)
I love the Ambassador. True, an oversized Classic. But....what a difference there is between 58 and 74mm!
I did a quick Ebay search: no reasonable results for the Vic Golfer.
I'm disappointed that Vic has stopped supporting the 74 and 85mm line of tools.
-
Oh, I'm a massive fan of the Ambassador as well. Much more useful as a knife and slightly bigger pair of scissors is a win in my book.
-
@Gareth said:
Yup, Golfer is basically an 84mm Compact. Not easy to find these days sadly.The old Wenger Diplomat also does a lot of what you want and is more recently retired. https://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Diplomat&highlight=diplomat
The Ambassador is basically and oversized Classic. :)
That's my Diplomat in that wiki page :D I should give it some more love and carry it sometimes.
-
-
This is a great question Nix. Especially for those of us who have a tendency to carry more layers.
Main thing I’d want to add for a long hike is the wood saw. Some saw at the very least. And I’m often okay with the metal saw outdoors, even if that’s not the preferred option.
But if I were bent on carrying the minimal weight, I’d dump the scissors and subsequently the hook. I love scissors, but in reality, there is little that couldn’t be dealt with by either the blade or saw of either type.
My absolute minimum could be an 84mm serrated main and a modified in-line awl. Could be alox scaled to ditch both T&T or mixed to keep the tweezers.
Maximum considering most of your input plus the saw would be an 84mm, with Combo Tool in the main blade slot, Small blade or hawksbill in the typical spot. Backside awl in the Corkscrew slot. Shave the backspring and awl and ditch all the nickel silver spacers otherwise needed for that layer. (Or use opener layer backspring and ~0.5mm spacers on the topside) Woodsaw with modified 91mm backspring for the chisel. Scissors with a modified backspring for the hook.
Or do the same with a 91mm to save most of the backspring mods.
Add some decorative file work to reduce weight further. Maybe liberal use of carbide drillbits for misc. weight reduction where possible.
-
This thread got me thinking. The SwissBuck Advantage / Sidekick has the tools you mention in three layers vice 2. But it is as hard to find as an 84mm Golfer.
-
If you haven't heard of Andrew Skurka, he is a well-known long distance hiker with several long solo trips in remote places. I just googled his name and "pocket knife" and found this Vic endorsement:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
In the video he mentions a 'Tinker', but I've seen a presentation by him where the knife in his gear (first aid kit) is a Classic.
My personal hiking hero, Colin Fletcher, wrote that he used a 'Tinker' during his treks. The text and illustration makes it clear that he is referring to a Super Tinker. However, he notes that when he (temporarily) lost his 'Tinker', he replaced it with a....wait for it....Vic Classic.

-
@Sos24 said:
This thread got me thinking. The SwissBuck Advantage / Sidekick has the tools you mention in three layers vice 2. But it is as hard to find as an 84mm Golfer.Why.....? Whyyyyyyyyy?

Why is it that so many good ideas, e.g. Compact small with awl or 84mm Golfer, never make it to market or don't thrive? Why is the Classic SD the all-time best selling SAK, but the Ambassador has gone the way of the Dodo?
Why haven't we seen a Cadet X? (That would be a great trekking knife, too!)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
