The Gas Station MRE challenge
-
@AlephZero said:
Yes, they are very shelf-stable, the paprika one has best before date at 30.11.2021

Awesome. Hope you'll be able to post an "action shot" of one of those on Chow Day!
-
@Nix said:
Hey, a big congratulations on losing that weight!
Do you have a target weight in mind?
Thanks!

Setting a target weight is tricky. I gained some muscle mass, and have been losing fat. I basically want to lose the belly and tone. So, no specific numeric target. Keto seems to be working, so we'll see what happens.

-
Well, we're a week out...and I ate everything in my last shot already :-[
but I've restocked!
Some minor changes for the "day" In order to stay in the spirit of things, I'm keeping my meals to things that would be available from a quix type store (Servos around here basically have attached grocery stores - it's to dodge trading laws. Grocery stores have to shut at certain times, service station don't...) but I'll be avoiding anything that has any prep requirements - we're sticking to individually wrapped single serve junk and impulse buys :DNo crisps, the packaging doesn't meet the "compact pack" intent.
I measured by seat-buddy thing that I use for food in the car, it's 5.6L or just under 1.5gal, so we're in good form there.
Now I've just got to tally up my new selection....
-
-
@ReamerPunch said:
I am not the first to come up with the idea of a keto MRE.Could a keto diet have any negative effect on a soldier's performance?
-
@Syncop8r said:
Could a keto diet have any negative effect on a soldier's performance?I've done a bit of reading about military ration design. The science they've used finds that carbs are an important part of optimal overall performance. In testing, Soldiers, Marines, and SEALs performing soldier tasks had worse performances when on a low carb diet.
Heat regulation via shivering is partly mediated by blood glucose levels. Muscles deprived of carbs may stop shivering, which can lead to hypothermia in cold environments. ( When I went through a cold weather survival school run by Navy SEAL instructors, they threatened to squeeze a tube of dextrose cake icing up our backsides if we developed hypothermia. I half-think they were hoping to demonstrate the wonders of colonic absorption of sugars on one of us. Or they just had an odd idea of fun. ) While indigenous people of the north eat a lot of fat and protein (which release heat during metabolism), the military is a firm believer in the utility of carbs in the cold for preventing hypothermia.
In addition, carbs don't require water to be metabolized. Sugars are used directly as a fuel. So, carbs are water sparing. In extreme cold, liquid water is hard to come by and dehydration is a risk, so carbs are valued for not creating a metabolic water requirement. In extreme heat, water and minerals are lost easily through sweating. Again, since carbs don't create a metabolic water requirement, they are a preferred fuel. Most life raft rations and survival kits emphasize carbs for the same reason: the provide energy without requiring water for metabolism.
Lastly, glucose is the preferred fuel of the brain. In the absence of carb intake, the brain will preferentially use available glucose. Some studies have found that students do better on academic testing if they have a carb-rich meal prior to testing. Not sure those studies will hold up or be replicated, but there is thought that some minimal level of carb intake may improve cognitive performance, too.
For these reasons, among others I'm sure, military rations tend to be carb heavy.
-
While it's entirely possible the military looked at all the available research in order to develop the most effective rations for hostile and austere environments, I think Nix missed out on one critical and possibly quite relevant factor.
Carbs are cheap
-
Good answer(s).

I'm guessing too that even if someone well-versed in keto could do fine on a keto MRE the military wouldn't be interested in taking any chances.
-

The layout of all the food/drink/soup/snacks for the challenge, it's really way more food than I usually consume nowadays. But it would serve me well for a car camping trip with the purpose to do a kinda strenuous 10-15 miles mountainous hiking(1000-1500+m elevation gain and loss) in semi-cold weather(12C 54F). Even then, I probably would only consume 70% of this amount of food.Most food can be easily acquired in gas station/food store/supermarket locally. The real interesting piece is the HaiDeLao Tomato Beef Hotpot with self heating pad. All it needs is some cold water and within 15min, a piping hotpot meal is ready in front of me. I love the idea since it doesn't even require water boiling or gas stove, but the weight is surely the penalty for this piece.

Fitted into a 35L Sea to Summit lightweight stuff bag(this is usually the 'liner' for my hiking backpack)
The bag itself is 200g, so a total of 2.2kg for food. Considering all the packaging and the self heating pad, it's really is only meant for car camping/emergency car ration.
All sealed and ready for action in about a week time3774 Kcal in total
Drinks: 225 + 574 + 63 = 862
5x UCC coffee with cups 45cal x5
2x Pocari sweat 287kcal (diluted with 1L of water with each packet)
3x Japanese miso soup packets 21 cal x3Food:
Breakfast 305 + 70 = 375 kcal
1x Acecook Miso better ramen 305Kcal
2x chilli garlic fish sausage. 35 kcal ea**Lunch ** 741 + 70 = 811 kcal
2x chilli garlic fish sausage. 35 kcal ea
1x Missing Pork salt and garlic flavor noodle 741 kcalDinner 77 + 220 + 46 + 750 = 1093 kcal
1x green giant can corn 77 kcal
1x black bean sea eel can food. 220kcal
1x d'aucy canned beetroot 46 kcal
1x HaiDeLao Tomato beef brisket self heating hotpot 750+ kcalSnacks: 186 + 120 + 56 + 69 + 202.5 = 633.5 kcal
1x Maltesers. 186kcal
2x Calbee shrimp cracker. 60Kcal ea
1x Mocha chocolate cigarettes. 1box 56 cal
1x Mala peanuts 69kcal
1x Gummas chip tomato and basil flavor 202.5kcal -
Wow! Great array of foods.
A side note: the Israeli military field ration, 'Manat Krav', is basically a box of canned foods. It usually contains canned tuna, halva, olives, crackers, and canned corn. When I saw your canned corn and sea eel, I instantly thought of the legendary Manat Krav. :D
-
@Syncop8r said:
Good answer(s).
I'm guessing too that even if someone well-versed in keto could do fine on a keto MRE the military wouldn't be interested in taking any chances.
My understanding is that since Ketones are an alternative fuel source, it's probably not the best for much more than sitting on the couch awaiting your next carbohydrate-rich meal. There's a lot of to-and-fro in the exercise and nutrition literature about it being a purely backup source for the brain to function, vs some sort of highly efficient fuel source for the whole body. Outcomes research with body function overall seems to show that ketones don't offer more energy than is required to sustain life (for as long as the ketones are still there). So my take on it is, a ketogenic diet will never be good for a soldier,
Indeed, as Nix correctly points out,,,, Diabetics who are in a crisis and not able to use their glucose due to critical insulin deficiency, and are in Diabetic Keto Acidosis, (where only Ketones are being produced and used), are often hypothermic as a result.
-
Right. After much research, I have finally gathered together what we on the U Boat consider to be the perfect blend of taste, energy, weight and scrumptiousness to survive, nay, thrive, for 24 hours.

-
@Nix said:
Wow! Great array of foods.A side note: the Israeli military field ration, 'Manat Krav', is basically a box of canned foods. It usually contains canned tuna, halva, olives, crackers, and canned corn. When I saw your canned corn and sea eel, I instantly thought of the legendary Manat Krav. :D
Thanks to this, I did learn something new and gonna look them up!
I took a little bit of inspiration from the WW rations, where they tend to be canned food and the pack of chocolate cigarette is a shout to the past.
I suck at running but did often admire those who can, one thing I did read about is the Tarahumara tribe described in Christopher McDougall's book 'Born to run'--and IIRC, most of their diet is 95%+ carbs, and I think in a soldier's prospective, there maybe some resemblance there and that's part reason why I have put so much carb on the menu too.
-
-
@magentus said:
Right. After much research, I have finally gathered together what we on the U Boat consider to be the perfect blend of taste, energy, weight and scrumptiousness to survive, nay, thrive, for 24 hours.:D To be honest that's all you really need for 1 day, i wouldn't want to go camping with you but that will work fine

I need to get my finger out, all i have added is a tin of tuna and a pack of biscuit things, i hope i can get to the shop before the 30th or i'm going to be very grumpy from 4PM onwards on Chow day

@comis said:
2x Pocari sweat 287kcal (diluted with 1L of water with each packet)I really want to know what a Pocari is now, and more importantly how they collect it

Very good spreadsheet work guys, very professional

-
@Borg said:
:D To be honest that's all you really need for 1 day, i wouldn't want to go camping with you but that will work fine
I need to get my finger out, all i have added is a tin of tuna and a pack of biscuit things, i hope i can get to the shop before the 30th or i'm going to be very grumpy from 4PM onwards on Chow day

**I really want to know what a Pocari is now, and more importantly how they collect it **

Very good spreadsheet work guys, very professional

I looked it up because I was similarly
- as I suspected, it's an electrolyte replacement drink like Gatorade. I feared that Comis had gone cannibalistic since his younger days in California USA (iirc).
If that was the case, this challenge was bound to get a lot more interesting. -
@magentus said:
Right. After much research, I have finally gathered together what we on the U Boat consider to be the perfect blend of taste, energy, weight and scrumptiousness to survive, nay, thrive, for 24 hours.Wow! :ahhh
I see you have loosened the purse strings and gone all out for fresh oats and commercial salt. None of that nasty stuff you scrape off the uniforms after a long watch. The crew must really be looking forward to Chow Day!
(You are going to share, aren't you?)
-
I see you have loosened the purse strings and gone all out for fresh oats and commercial salt. None of that nasty stuff you scrape off the uniforms after a long watch. The crew must really be looking forward to Chow Day!
(You are going to share, aren't you?)
Ah! I'm glad you fell for the old 'commercial' ploy (as if).
I found the pot in an old chemical waste bin, cleaned the glowing acid stuff off it and hey presto! You'd never know! I've filled it with some salt crust from around the lavvy outlet. Genius. Free salt!Of course we all share in the goodness. It's a workers paradise here and woe betide anyone who says different.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


