Do most knives need points?
-
An interesting and thought provoking discussion to say the least. Over the years my needs for a knife have changed considerably.
When I was working in the body shop a pointy knife was good for digging out old Bondo(plastic body filler).A large folding hunter was used when I relocated to the parts department and spent a great deal of time making cardboard boxes and reducing others to scrappable size.When I was elevated to the parts manager's job,a smaller pocket knife was more than sufficient for everyday chores.
When I retired and began my second full time career as a sign painter a multi-blade scout/utility was the order of the day.I also began using a small coping blade to cut out intricate patterns. I still use one but it is now an old dogleg jack that the pen blade had broken and I re-ground it into a sort of coping blade.
So I guess what it all boils down to is whatever the particular use is determines what type of blade you use.And there are MANY styles of knives out there that do not depend on a point to complete their functions.Grapefruit knives;table knives;palette knives;all a re specially suited to their tasks. -
@Ray S said:
An interesting and thought provoking discussion to say the least. Over the years my needs for a knife have changed considerably.
When I was working in the body shop a pointy knife was good for digging out old Bondo(plastic body filler).A large folding hunter was used when I relocated to the parts department and spent a great deal of time making cardboard boxes and reducing others to scrappable size.When I was elevated to the parts manager's job,a smaller pocket knife was more than sufficient for everyday chores.
When I retired and began my second full time career as a sign painter a multi-blade scout/utility was the order of the day.I also began using a small coping blade to cut out intricate patterns. I still use one but it is now an old dogleg jack that the pen blade had broken and I re-ground it into a sort of coping blade.
So I guess what it all boils down to is whatever the particular use is determines what type of blade you use.And there are MANY styles of knives out there that do not depend on a point to complete their functions.Grapefruit knives;table knives;palette knives;all a re specially suited to their tasks.
Thanks for your response. You nailed it. Knives for needs. Different activities and stages of life trigger different needs. My life has had different phases and I have changed my carry for each phase, too.
-
@SgtTowser said:
Yes, but...my SAK has a pin and tweezers. So: I’ve never been tempted to use one of the knife points instead for splinters.And reamers. Don't forget reamers. :D
-
For me, a sheepsfoot blade is almost ideal for EDC. But that is due to my most frequent use for a knife: stripping the outer sheath off of non-metallic cable (Romex, SE cable). A pronounced belly is a hinderance. I was very excited when I saw the blade above, and I keep reaching for that MT seen above every few days due to that blade's utility to me.
However, I do wish there was a drop point blade paired with the sheepsfoot. A point comes in handy sometimes.
That blade shape is just fine with me. Sheepsfoot, reverse tanto, whatever you wanna call it. Perfectly adequate for edc.
-
After thinking on this topic since last posting and reading the answers I don't NEED a knife whose edge and spine meet to a point. Having said that even the knives pictured have a meeting where its "pointy" enough. So to answer the OP question NO most knives do not need a point. But thats not the point for me. Dive knives came to mind when this topic came up. To my mind thats a knife that has no point to speak of. Victorinox my first SAK does not have a point. Oyster knives are pointless ( haha ).
I used a clever for many years as a sole knife both professionally and in my home. The cutting edge is parallel to the spine with a front "nose" meeting the edge at 90 degree creating a point or corner that is more than capable. Could I stab with it? No. Back to me saying thats not the point. I have been carrying my Barlow pictured a lot. The geometry of the blade has changed im sure since its been sharpened badly by previous owner/s. There is a edge/corner that is capable tho i wouldn't be able to stab. Because its not the purpose of this knife or any of my knives in my use no stabby point needed.
So I stick to my Yes and No to points on knives.

-
Don’t forget about the ever popular Victorinox One Handed Trekkers. By design, these have a relatively blunt tip. I’m not sure that this is a particular advantage, but it certainly hasn’t been a drawback.
-
Some,"pointless" knives.
#1 Parker,"18 Wheeler".Supposedly used to remove pebbles from between tire treads.
#2 Bonum folding palette knife for spreading paint.
#3 Case & Cattaraugus folding machetes;part of a WWII bailout package for air crew members.
#4 Clauss bread knife.
-
A few more.
#1 A combination dog/horse grooming knife and hoof pick.
#2 Fruit peeling knife by Edward Wusthof.
#3 Supposedly called a,"sliming"knife. Not sure of it's purpose.
#4 A herb/vegetable chopper designed to be used in a bowl made in France. -
Still more.
#1 Harrison Bros. & Howson hunter with an unusual point.
#2 Called the,"Klever Kleaver" it does a lot of tasks. How it it does these remains to be seen.
#3 Lamson grapefruit knife.
#4 A couple of oyster shuckers. -
More points for no points:
#1 Another fruit peeling knife by Pfeilring.
#2 A picnic set with various utensils that clip onto the extra handle.
#3 A rase knife used to cut letters and numbers into wooden barrels and the like. Also to scribe water lines on boats.
#4 Marked,"Rogers Pat Apr 11 91(1891 I assume),I have no clue as to what it was used for.
-
And they just keep on comin'..........
#1 For removing the pin feathers of poultry by Russell
#2 Grapefruit knife by Russell
#3 A joke of sorts:a knife to hold your garden peas on while you eat them.
#4 A military issue pocket knife from WWI by Schatt & Morgan
-
Got a few more yet........
#1 A scraper/putty knife made by Whitehead & Hoag.
#2 Sailor's knife from 1968.
#3 A handmade knife similar to the Harrison Bros. & Howson knife previously pictured.
#4 Ulster pill sorting knife advertising Tums.
-
Last batch.
#1 One armed man's knife by United Boker.
#2 Sailor's knife by Warris dated 1940.
#3 Sailor's knife by Whittingslowe Adelaide Australia.
#4 A trio of fish scaling knives.

-
If, after reading this thread, anyone feels they no longer have need of their pointed knives, please let me know. I will gladly PM you my address, and take all those useless pointed knives off your hands :-D
-
Ray and everyone: THANK YOU! You have made my day. Pointless knives are awesome in their variety!!! Great pics.
Ray, what is the use of the concave end of the one armed man blade? I have seen many and never understood.
-
@SgtTowser said:
Ray, what is the use of the concave end of the one armed man blade? I have seen many and never understood.Not Ray, but I’ll field this one. The purpose of the concave end is to allow the blade to be opened by catching that end on the edge of a pocket, belt, etc. thus allowing the knife to be opened by someone with only one arm, hence the name. I have read that the design and name came about in the aftermath of the Civil War, from which there apparently were enough amputees to make marketing products specifically to them worthwhile.
-
@nate j said:
Not Ray, but I’ll field this one. The purpose of the concave end is to allow the blade to be opened by catching that end on the edge of a pocket, belt, etc. thus allowing the knife to be opened by someone with only one arm, hence the name. I have read that the design and name came about in the aftermath of the Civil War, from which there apparently were enough amputees to make marketing products specifically to them worthwhile.Thank you, sir!!!!
It makes sense. Have you tried it? Does it work?
Maybe this is where Emerson got his idea for the wave?
-
@nate j said:
Not Ray, but I’ll field this one. The purpose of the concave end is to allow the blade to be opened by catching that end on the edge of a pocket, belt, etc. thus allowing the knife to be opened by someone with only one arm, hence the name. I have read that the design and name came about in the aftermath of the Civil War, from which there apparently were enough amputees to make marketing products specifically to them worthwhile.Had no idea. Thanks for telling us.

-
@SgtTowser said:
Have you tried it? Does it work?I would assume it does work, though I have not personally tried it. I prefer my knives with points, so the style doesn't really appeal to me, and I don't own any.
-
Ive been fidgeting with a Gerber Armbar, which has a sheepfoot blade. It's slowly been growing on me.
I've had a long affair with tanto and sheepfoot blades in the past. 2 years ago I threw out two of my unserviceable wharncliff blades.
Having spent the better part of two decades with Leatherman and Victorinox, I'd lost any feeling that a sheepfoot blade is particularly advantageous.
This thread, combined with some research on Tradional British pocketknife styles has me curious once again to try them out.
Not so fast though... I'll be waiting for the September SAK-alike Challenge.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
