The Gas Station MRE challenge
-
Thanks Jack and Sherry

I've spent some time thinking about a stove for hiking and figured that a gas one will have problems with wind (we have some here sometimes :D ).
I'm not sure about an alcohol one either.
I've used a simple Espit stove a couple of times and it's not ideal.
When I saw Borgs pics of the Kelly Kettle I knew that would work for me... if not too big... and expesive
-
@Sos24 said:
Nice and small little set-up. I love the green cup.I haven’t tried the fancy feast style alcohol burner, but I did a soda can one. You also really need something to use to snuff it out, unless you plan on just letting it burn until all fuel is gone. Both present their own safety hazards. If doing alcohol, I prefer the Trangia style (also RedCamp, Solo, Goshawk, etc) burner. The simmer rings can be used to snuff it out and the cap with o-ring usually allow storing excess fuel in the burner so you don’t waste if you misjudge. The trangia style burner also fits and can be used in my twig stove, so for me it is a win.
Great tip!
I actually ordered a Trangia a little while back, but haven't gotten it yet.

While my double can system works fairly well, I'd like something a bit more durable and liked the idea that you can 1) use the simmer plate to control the flame/snuff the fire, and 2) save residual, unburnt, alcohol in the stove. I suspect the Trangia is just plain more efficient, too.
Remind me of the name/brand of your twig stove?

Does it work well with the Trangia?
My windscreen is great....but not durable. Easy to replace, but, again, something more durable would be great. The old "Trangia Triangle" doesn't seem ot be be made any more. I love the idea of your dual purpose twig stove/Trangia unit!

( Goshawk stoves are hard to find ( here in the USA ). They are available, but expensive compared to a Trangia.....or empty cat food can..... )
-
Ah, ha.....
Found your other thread on the Firebox Nano. Very nice!
Checked on Amazon....Ti is pricey, SS is still a bit much, but I am tempted. There is a version that comes with a packing box that serves as an ashtray:
In wildfire country, that ash tray seems like a good idea.

-
@McStitchy said:
Thanks Jack and Sherry
I've spent some time thinking about a stove for hiking and figured that a gas one will have problems with wind (we have some here sometimes :D ).
I'm not sure about an alcohol one either.
I've used a simple Espit stove a couple of times and it's not ideal.
When I saw Borgs pics of the Kelly Kettle I knew that would work for me... if not too big... and expesive
The Kelly kettle feeds off the wind, makes it burn hotter :D but yes a bit on the bulky side and not cheap, but fuel is free, i saw it as an investment that will last me years and i don't see any reason why it wont, great for food heating, for hiking it would depend what else you are carrying and pack size but it fits in my small pack no probs, its not heavy though, with the hobo stove over the fire base you can keep heating if the chimney top stove didn't heat it already, the water boils quick, if i was to buy mine again i would just get the kettle, hobo stove and the chimney top stove, i wont use the cups and dont have to use the pots, the wire grill can be easily made

-
Borg, is your Trekker the aluminum or steel version?
Our "Scout" is steel. We got just the kettle (with fire base) and the hobo stove thingy. Great for a small fry pan.

The Scout (1.2L) is too big for backpacking, but is great for car camping.
I agree about the Kelly being fairly windproof. Once that chimney starts drawing, it is soup time!
-
Found your other thread on the Firebox Nano. Very nice!
Checked on Amazon....Ti is pricey, SS is still a bit much, but I am tempted. There is a version that comes with a packing box that serves as an ashtray:
In wildfire country, that ash tray seems like a good idea.

I'm not going to go there as i am sorted but... does that all fold up into the metal case/ash tray ? Asking for a friend...
-
@Nix said:
Borg, is your Trekker the aluminum or steel version?Our "Scout" is steel. We got just the kettle (with fire base) and the hobo stove thingy. Great for a small fry pan.

The Scout (1.2L) is too big for backpacking, but is great for car camping.
SS, i think it's fine for hiking, obviously its a lot bigger than a small gas stove but wood is free and the wind wont be an issue

@Nix said:
Yes. Awl fits into that tiny metal case. 7oz. Slips into a cargo pocket. That's what I told my friend.Interesting
nahh i'm all set, no more stoves for me, but twig burners have a lot going for them, even if you have to carry some dry wood from home its still worth it i think 
-
Mrs Nix: that's clearly a windscreen, not a roasting tray.

-
Found your other thread on the Firebox Nano. Very nice!
Checked on Amazon....Ti is pricey, SS is still a bit much, but I am tempted. There is a version that comes with a packing box that serves as an ashtray:
In wildfire country, that ash tray seems like a good idea.

If you decide to get a Firebox Nano, I recommend going straight through the site. I’m not sure about Amazon’s pricing, but I know some sites charge more than you can get directly through Firebox. Also, I think they are running a 10% for Father’s Day (fathers10) right now. Under value kits the SS with the metal packing box (x-case) is $44.99.
The Trangia fits into the Nano either suspended on pins or on the bottom. In addition to the lid and simmer cap, the Trangia style does seem to be a little more efficient.
Here it is pictured with the x-case and the Goshawk (which is exact same size as Trangia) suspended on pins.

The flame guard (helps prevent flames from making handles hot) is an add on. -
@Borg said:
I'm not going to go there as i am sorted but... does that all fold up into the metal case/ash tray ? Asking for a friend...Yes. As Nix said it all fits into the metal case


I replaced the carbon felt with a piece of suede. The 6 inch ruler is shown for size and it is about .75in thick when closed.The thread Nix shared above is me going on about how much I love this little stove.
@Borg said:
Interesting
nahh i'm all set, no more stoves for me, but twig burners have a lot going for them, even if you have to carry some dry wood from home its still worth it i think 
Agree, with the twig burners having a lot going for them. I can easily boil 12oz of water with just a handful of twigs.
-
Thanks Borg, Jack and Sherry... I might stick with the 0.6l Kelly Kettle idea. Will decide after another coffee or two

-
@McStitchy said:
Thanks Borg, Jack and Sherry... I might stick with the 0.6l Kelly Kettle idea. Will decide after another coffee or two
Won't you need a stove to make that coffee? Seems like you've gotten yourself into a catch-22 situation......

-
Stashed in a cool, dry spot awaiting the day :D

-

Climate control conditions are recommended!

-
Buddy, it'd be the first time!!

-
That was my thought, too!

-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login