The Gas Station MRE challenge
-
I am very pleased with my MRE. Mostly. Having started a keto diet for May, and since we had to actually eat our MREs, I had to adjust a few things. We had a minimum of 2400 Kcal, which is ok for an MRE but a little high for a weight-loss diet. Thankfully, I was able to achieve the caloric goal while staying at low carb levels.

As an MRE, it did quite well. Not too heavy, not that bulky, good shelf life, good assortment of items, low carbs. A little too artificial, but that's a little unavoidable. And putting it together was tons of fun! :D
The biggest advantage apart from being a keto MRE, is that it requires no cooking. Everything can be eaten straight out of its can/pack with the exception of the coffee and tea of course.Eating was quite enjoyable. Understandable, considering I packed it myself, for myself. Nonetheless, I was looking forward to everything, throughout the day, except for the almonds anyway.
The tastiest components were the peanut butter cups, no contest.

They are absolutely mindblowingly tasty. 1g of carbs, less than 1g of sugar, no bad polyols; only erythritol, the good one. They even come in tiny paper cups and feature a cardboard tray, to protect them. Outstanding.
I also enjoyed the sardines. Nice little can, a good amount of food, soft, tasty, not salty, and they have a shelf life of three years. Quite a nice emergency food.Looking back at everything, I could have included a small sheet of tin foil, or maybe a ziplock bag or something, to pack any leftovers for later. I did not eat all the cheese at once, so it had to stay in its original foil, which barely survived the first unpacking.
I do not think I would make any big changes. I had already taken out the pork rinds, due to excessive bulk and weak packaging. I would have liked to have added a small packet of olives, or dried tomatoes, or pickles, so that I could have some vegetables. Sadly, all these go downhill compared to fresh produce, more so than dried meat. And I did not find any small packets anyway. I had a 125g packet of dried to-mah-toes, but it had an insane amount of carbs, so it was removed.I do not think I would recommend my MRE.

Sure, there are some tasty items, the shelf life of everything is good, nothing was that expensive, the total weight was good (3.5 lbs/1584g), and the components are all well-packaged, able to withstand some abuse in a bag. The thing is, this was assembled specifically to comply with my weight-loss diet while fulfilling the parameters of this challenge. There are not enough carbs to fuel an arduous day-long activity, like trekking, climbing, survival training, etc. Even for a keto MRE, it is still a little high in calories for a single day. Understandable, since weight-loss and MRE don't really mix. At least, at 20g of carbs, it will not kick you out of ketosis, and there are some nice treats you can enjoy regardless.
Summing up, this was a great experience. It was tremendous fun scouting for components and assembling the set. It also exposed me to a variety of low-carb snacks I was unaware of, so it made my diet not only bearable, but enjoyable as well. I had been thinking of giving up on the diet from the very first day, and this challenge helped prevent that. I've lost 8kg so far.

If we ever do it again I am in. And hopefully it won't have to be a weight-loss entry for me. ::)
-
@AlephZero said:
We had those Weetabix in a bottle thingies here too for some time couple years ago, but then they just vanished... I kinda liked 'em :-\Looking good, bro!

I liked it too

-
@magentus said:
Great start so far everyone!
Unable to handle a big meal until 10.30/111.00 am I went with a couple of nut bars with chocolate - Decadent as Steve1989 would say.
Tea with creamer is, to be honest, a chore. Probably tastes like heaven when you're up to your knees in mud, dodging bombs and mortar fire, but sat in the relative comfort of the U Boat, it just tastes wrong.
The National drink should contain real, full fat milk, so that's what I'm looking forward to getting back to on the morrow.
Also, if the crew knew I had special food on board, they would have my head. If you don't hear back from me at any time in the next 24 hours, consider me headless.
:D ...that's the Captains tray? Fancy

@magentus said:
Weetabix in a bottle sounds intriguing! Good?It was rather enjoyable

-
Chow day - no lunch yet :-/
Waiting in the car for our daughter to finish shopping ::) ...good I took the Veggy Jerky with me. I'm surprised, they're really good


-
<u>Chow Day 1942</u>
I had been having too much food thru out the day, so dinner is a little later than usual.
The self heating pad within the Tomato hotpot soup is a real nice touch. I filmed the whole making-of process, and if you look carefully, you would see a stream of hot air coming from the top of the lid. The meal is 'cooked' and ready to eat in just 15min, pretty impressive stuff. I wish I would have something like this as a constant emergency food supply, except those ingredients are pretty fresh(real meat/veggie etc), and the package is only good for 3 months of storage IIRC. The portion is ok for a meal, slightly on the light side if you are really hungry.
The can of corn and blackbean sea eel reminded me much of my car camping trips, where I usually went out for long hikes during the day around the campground, and return camp for a hot meal of freeze dried and canned food. Finally finished my Pocari Sweat drink by dinner, but I only manage to finish 1 pack of it today(since I was exercising and had no need for large amount of water/electrolytes). The sport drink is literally packed with calories(really high sugar content, ~280kcal per packet) and pretty close to 1 liter of coke in calories.
I still have a few snacks left in the food bag, so I gonna wrap up later tonight when I try finishing those.
-
09:00
Snack time
Peanutbutter M&Ms (1 serving; bag contains 3 servings) - Delicious!
Slim Jim & Cheese - spicy, greasy, strong flavors. Hope it does not give indigestion.
-
Chow Day 08:30
Breakfast of butter flavored instant grits, a cup of Earl Grey tea, and half a packet of lemon flavored Propel drink mix which I added to my tea, I had taken out one of my chocolate, peanut butter zone bars in case I needed more, but after the bowl of instant grits I wastoo disgusted to eat anything elsepretty full. I can't say how many calories were in the grits because that info is not printed on the individual packets. I used half a packet of Propel lemon flavor crystals so that's 5 calories. Not sure if the tea by itself even counts. -
2330
I am still burping the essence of the cheese crisps. Hopefully it will not haunt me for much longer. -
@ReamerPunch said:
I can still smell the cheese crisps on my breath.
-
Just catching up on awl the feasting whilst I was asleep. Great stuff, guys!
I think I may have to go back and take notes on what worked and what didn't, but the variety is outstanding!

-
Chow Day 07:13 ( accessory packet ):
The GSMRE has been packed away long enough that I forgot what some of the components were.....so I still had a little sense of surprise. Step one was to investigate the accessory packet and reassess my options....

Let's get that spread out....

Clockwise from the empty, but for three (3) paper towels:
• Extra plastic bag ( Presumably for trash or emergency chamber pot if stuck in foxhole. )
• Small baggie with matches, Tabascos sachets (2!), Sriracha sachets (2!), salt/pepper/sugar sachets.
• Chapstick, cinnamon flavored ( I think this was meant to be a cold weather ration? )
• Gerber Spork. ( So nice to find they included a spork and not just a spoon. But, more on this particular spork later..... )
• Toothbrush and toothpaste ( finally! )
• Scouring pad in storage bag
• Cleaning wipes ( Don't leave the FOB without them! )
• Energy gum in the center. ( Some specialized rations started including caffeinated gum. Had to be careful to avoid chewing too much too often, but not a bad idea. )Well, well, this is the accessory packet from my dreams. I'm sure it could be improved upon, but I finally feel I've got a decent accessory packet in an MRE. ( Does come at a bit of a weight cost, however. )
-
Chow Day 10:30
Mid-morning snack. I've just had the chocolate, peanut butter Zone bar that I didn't have with breakfast. That's 220 calories, 14g protein, 1g fiber, 24g carbohydrates. -
-
Chow Day ( more on the spork ):
This Gerber spork is both a triumph and a fail.
It comes as a two-piece 'multitool'. The spork bit is thin titanuim. The accessory multitool is mid-weight steel. They snap together around a rubber knob:

The Ti spork bit is really well designed....for right handed eaters. The offset tines work well with noodles and soft stuff like fruits, but maybe less so for chunks of meat. The bowl is a good size and holds a nice mouthful of soup, apple sauce, etc.... The edges are fairly straight and work well to cut soft foods. Anything you could use a butter knife form this spork will do a decent job with. And it is wonderfully light! The handle could use an extra inch of length and the spoon/tines section might be slightly improved by being polished smooth as opposed to slightly textured. Overall, the Ti spork gets a 'B+' from me.
The accessory tool is a bit different.

It is designed to be a package opener, can opener, cap lifter, pry bar, and screw driver. When snapped onto the spork, it acts as a 'kickstand' to keep the eating end up off the ground. It also allows the spork to hand off the side of a pot.
Awl good ideas....but it is heavy and pointy. I made a tiny cardboard sheath for the pry bar end to keep it from poking holes in my gear when stowed in a bag ( and being jostled around on a hike ). The ability to hang the spork of the side of a cup is nice....but it feels a bit like a solution in search of a problem.

I've had variable success with the small serrated 'package opener' serrations. If I hit a sweet spot it can work. But tough plastic packaging can bind up. Never tried the can opener or screw driver features. Cap lifter works just fine. But I've never needed a cap lifter in the field....and I'll probably have a SAK with me anyway......
Given the extra weight, awkward dimensions, and redundancy with the SAK I'll surely be carrying....the steel multitool bit will get a grade of 'C' and be discarded. The Ti spork stays.
-
@ReamerPunch said:
Apparently I did not take this challenge seriously enough. :ahhh
-
Ah.... another thing I need? A spork?

-
Chow day - lunch finally !
Heated up my "Tangy Chickpea & Coconut Curry" using the KellyKettle Hobo set. Worked nicely and was very tasty. It fed me well


Of course I tested kettle while I was at it. Brilliant I must say


After a mouth full of curry and smoke I felt for a fizzy drink...

-
<u>Chow Day 2252</u>

I still have a few items left in my food bag, and between the hummus chip and peanuts, I did choose the Hummus chip, just for curiosity sake. It was ok, but the taste is kinda blend. I wish I would have known about this chip earlier and I could have tossed in the tomato hotpot earlier. It could have gone quite well along with the crisps included in the hotpot, which the tomato soup had a tangy taste. But like the real MRE, you won't really know how good it would be based on just the menu, until you try it for real.

The wrapI would really like to thank Nix and Mags for this fabulous challenge, pretty outlandish and fun to be part of.

3700kcal is really a lot of calories to eat, and after surveying what's left, here are the items remained:
2x UCC coffee with cups 45kcal ea
1x Pocari sweat 287kcal ea
3x Japanese miso soup packets 21 kcal x3
1x Mala peanuts 69kcal
1x Mocha chocolate cigarettes. 1box 56 calTotal Kcal 565kcal remains
Considering how I constantly felt like I am filled up to my brim and it wasn't a physical day at all, it wasn't too bad. But nutrient wise, I think there are way too much artificial flavoring and msg in these foods, and it is probably not very sustainable and bad for health in a longer run.
Mrs used to swear by these self-heating pad 'hotpot' as her favorite late eats, and now I can see why. It's easy to prep and everything is self contained. All you need is just some drinkable water and you don't even have to do dishes when you finished. Kinda like Mountain House, but on steroid.
It was a great joy to see all kinds of food and choices in this challenge, and I think I do need to go back and re-read some of the posts to learn all the new ideas. Thank you for all the enthusiasm and the effort, and I will see you all in the next challenge!

-
Chow Day 07:45 ( breakfast ):
Breakfast used to be my favorite meal of the day......
Let's see what we've got:

Clockwise from coffee at top-left:
• Instant coffee (2) ( An MRE is incomplete without joe )
• Sweetened condensed milk (2!) ( I've been using these for camping for a while now. AN excellent product. I've seen sweetened condensed mik in some other nations' rations, but never in a US MRE, too bad! )
• True Lemon beverage base
• Almond butter ( With nothing to put it on?! Typical! )
• Hot Cocoa mix
• Freeze dried eggs with beans, cheese, peppers, and spices
• Beef jerky barOn a cold morning, I might be able to put a good portion of this grub away, but with rising temps my appetite has diminished. So....I just targeted a coffee and that delectable sounding "Summit Scramble".
Coffee first: used my June Pocket Rocket Challenge knife to carefully open the packets and the little homemade alcohol stove to get my water boiling away in the canteen cup.

Tasty!
And now I'm awake and ready for breakfast..... But the scramble requires a 15 minute rehydration period before it is ready. At higher elevations, even more time is required. The directions called for 1.25 cups of water. I added just a shade over 1 cup. And waited......and waited.....
Soup is up! :(

Way too much water ( though I added less than called for ). The flavor was good, especially after adding a packet of Sriracha hot sauce, but the texture was disappointing. The beans were 100% hydrated, the eggs were only 90% hydrated and needed more time. There was no evidence of the reported cheese and the peppers were noticed only upon visual inspection as little orange bits. Or was that the cheese?

While this had decent flavor ( if a bit salty ), I would call this meal a FAIL. Eating this on a lark during a challenge is fine. But if I were on my 5th night in the woods or my plastic-bag-filled foxhole, I would not be looking forward to breakfast. I'd probably skip breakfast altogether ( excepting the coffee; goes without saying ). The excess water left me feeling very full. I didn't think I'd want more than the eggs beforehand, now I'm doubting I'll want lunch! That is why the Summit Scramble is a fail for an MRE in my eyes.
To to pack up and ruck out......
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


