*** The Dean51 30-day ***
-
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- MichaelGT83
- NutSAK
- SteveC
- ReamerPunch
- Poncho65
- David
-
@old Lefty said:
Sounds fun! I think I might join, one question however: how do we define traditional?:D
Part of the tradition of this challenge is arguing about what a Traditional is.....
Dean awl-ways had some wise words there.
For my part, if it looks like something your Grandfather or Grandmother would have EDC'd as a pocketknife, it probably is a Traditional. Typically, we are thinking about slip-joint knives with scales made of wood, antler, or bone or delrin ( whatever that is ). Some locking knives like Lags or Opinels are definitely 'traditional'. The Buck 110 and 112 have their own challenges, so while they are traditional, they are excluded. I think a Douk-Douk or a vintage BAK might also qualify.
If in doubt, post a photo of the knife you want to use and we'll argue about whether it is a 'Trad' or not. ;)
-
RP, Poncho, and David -- great to have you guys join in!

-
@old Lefty said:
how do we define traditional?Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
Here is some great discussion on that subject from before the original Traditional challenge took place in 2016: /post/1325143
The final judgement call should be up to Nix since he is leading the 2021 challenge, but I think jerseydevil was pretty spot-on for his judgement of "traditional" in 2016. I would definitely not limit the the term to a certain area of the world, so I think Douk-Douk, Mercator, Laguiole, Opinel, et al. should be included.
-
@Nix said:
RP, Poncho, and David -- great to have you guys join in!

I wanted to join ever since this challenge was proposed.
It's good that Opinels are eligible. I do not have any trappers, scouts, canoes, etc. I have my lock-back folding hunter, but I already did the dedicated challenge for that, and it is too heavy. An Opinel on the other hand, now we're talking. :D -

- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- MichaelGT83
- NutSAK
- SteveC
- ReamerPunch
- Poncho65
- David
- McStitchy
-
I'm itching to carry one of my Opinels on a challenge! :ahhh

-
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- MichaelGT83
- NutSAK
- SteveC
- ReamerPunch
- Poncho65
- David
- McStitchy
- Echotech
-
I believe I will carry Opinels a bit more that month as well
I will mix them in with some others I have 
Also I believe except for Victorinox Pioneers or Soldiers and Wenger SI models, SAK really aren't allowed as we have so many other challenges that those do have
Of course Nix has final call but I think that is something that we have established over the years 
-
Poncho is correct. No SAK's allowed in this challenge.
-
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- MichaelGT83
- NutSAK
- SteveC
- ReamerPunch
- Poncho65
- David
- McStitchy
- Echotech
- old Lefty
-
@Poncho65 said:
I believe I will carry Opinels a bit more that month as well
I will mix them in with some others I have 
Also I believe except for Victorinox Pioneers or Soldiers and Wenger SI models, SAK really aren't allowed as we have so many other challenges that those do have
Of course Nix has final call but I think that is something that we have established over the years 
In prior challenges, namely the 2016 one, no SAKs were allowed at all, not even Soldier/Soldat/Pioneer models. It could certainly be argued that, prior to the 1961 models, they were built in a traditional fashion, but they were ruled out of the challenge due to the fact that they're in other challenges, as you mention.
EDIT: I see Steve beat me to it. ;)
-
I am in
-
... and the one you sad smurfers have been waiting for...
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- MichaelGT83
- NutSAK
- SteveC
- ReamerPunch
- Poncho65
- David
- McStitchy
- Echotech
- old Lefty
- Deathtakeslast
- FUZZY!!!

-
Well this should be interesting.......

-
I'm in this one for Dean.
- Nix
- Barry Rowland
- MichaelGT83
- NutSAK
- SteveC
- ReamerPunch
- Poncho65
- David
- McStitchy
- Echotech
- old Lefty
- Deathtakeslast
- FUZZY
- Alan K.
-
Helluva list so far! Dean would be proud.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

